Tourist prices are the norm here at Orcas Island, but this pizza joint is the place if you want a…read morevery good flavor for those $'s you're spending. Wife and I ordered slice each of the Supreme pizza, and they did not disappoint! Even the edge crust had a nice char with soft, slight salty chewy texture. We ate with gusto! Servers were nice and efficient, and eating area (outdoor and indoor) was very tidy.

I love that there were vegan options here. There are pizzas made with cashew cream…read more We ordered pizza for takeout. I really liked the thin crust. I wondered if the pizza would have tasted better in the shop though. We were only a 5 minute drive away, but the middle of the pizza was a bit soggy. The ranch here is made in-house, I believe, and this was the highlight! I'm not usually one to have ranch with my pizza, but this ranch was a good addition.

We've been to Houlme a couple of times and have learned what's best to order, given our tastes. By…read moreall means, opt for the Summer Things: today's best grilled shoots & leaves, carmelized onion, hen egg. So good you want to lick the plate. We're also fans of Houlme's various pizzas. The one with onions, smoked mozarella, and hot honey is excellent if you want something more sweet. Our go-to is the more basic choice: tomato, mozzarella, and basil. The restaurant's ambiance is pleasant and inviting. Cordial service. Pizzas are cooked to order so we've learned to be patient. Island time. Relax. Be sure to make a reservation.

We did a last minute trip to Orcas Island and have heard of this place, but reservations for…read moreSaturday dinner were obviously completely gone when we tried looking 2 days before. We decided to walk-in as the website mentions bar and outdoor seating are first come first served so we were optimistic. However, when we showed up right at 4pm, the bar seats are all taken (only 4-5 seats, 2 parties at a time) and so we got put into a 2 hr 10 min waitlist for next seating, as they don't do outdoors in October (but the weather is so nice... and nowhere on the website mentioned no outdoor seating after summer). But this kind of worked out on our part as we didn't actually want to eat at 4pm. We got the Houlme Dog, MRF pizza with Norcino salami, an orange wine, and dessert (only option is rotating daily - we got brown butter ice cream with grilled chocolate). The Houlme Dog is a fun, casual meets fine dining hot dog with crispy potato and kale and caramelized onion jam. It's good but definitely nowhere near $16. It's just a fun way to enjoy a hot dog with play on textures MRF pizza was a green pizza - it's a kale sauce so it's quite interesting while the others were either red sauce or a white pizza as in olive oil base. The salami add-on was $7 but worthwhile as it definitely made the pizza much more filling and perfect to share for 2 people The dessert is pretty good, a bit simple on presentation but the flavors win. The grilled chocolate had a little bit of smoky flavor to it, and the ice cream itself has a nice small bit of savory, kind of like a salted caramel Their wines are good but expensive, but they were willing to split 1 glass into 2 For a restaurant at this price point, I expected a little more on service. When we arrived back 2 hrs later, we made eye contact a few times with the host/server but they kind of ignored us and took their sweet time doing other stuff than checking us in. I feel like they could've been more efficient seating tables as during our dining, which is around 6pm which should be prime time, they somehow failed to fill the other bar seats the whole duration of our ~2 hr meal, despite overhearing that 5 parties were in the waitlist and someone coming at 6pm would probably not have luck getting seated for the night. Also, when we finished the water jug, they took it away to fill a bunch of them but they never sent a full jug back to us. Even bigger miss was when I finished my water cup and a little loudly placed my cup on the counter and the server saw me, but they still missed the memo to give us water until I had to finally ask. All these little details should be expected as a bare minimum for such a nice restaurant. I had to take off a star for this, despite a strong 5 stars on food

Had high expectations that didn't deliver…read more My girlfriend and I came to stay the night on Orcas Island, and this was the first restaurant we tried. Having made reservations beforehand, we were really excited to try this place out. The servers who greeted us were really nice. The restaurant had a beautiful dark interior that gave off a cozy steakhouse vibe. They even offered to take my coat, how nice of them! Despite the hospitality, the food did not really live up to expectations. I got the birria, and while it was okay, it definitely wasn't worth the price I paid. My girlfriend's scallop crudel was almost as pricey and it did not even fill her up. I believe the bill for our whole meal (including a mocktail) was over $80. This was definitely not worth the price point paid for, considering that we were not fully satisfied with that meal. Regardless, many thanks to the Monti staff for having us.

First visit and I'm smitten. Great decor and service, but the meal really distinguished itself…read more First course was a fennel shaved salad with exceptional flavor - don't be dissuaded by the reference to anchovy dressing - it works magnificently and nothing overpowers. The chicken liver with summer tomatoes was magnificent, even if they needed an extra slice of sourdough to finish the plate. The star was the roasted pork belly. I've had many in my day but this was the crown jewel of belly's - succulent, tender inside and crispy edges, and the flavor was off the chart delicious. Rigatoni with lamb did not disappoint and pasta was cooked to perfection. Saved room for chocolate mousse and it was excellent and not too sweet. Wine pairings supported the wonderful meal. I look forward to returning and trying all the dishes we didn't select. This place has it over Rosario and Madrona. Your wallet will be lighter but not unreasonably so.

If I could give the flavor of the pizzas more then 5 star I would. A day later I'm still thinking…read moreabout my first bite . Simple menu of deliciousness. Highly recommend the Alfredo sauce with pesto . Never had anything like it and could eat it every day . With a glass of their melot Great service as well .

Island Pie is a cut above the simple pizza place. Though its ambiance is casual, the dishes are…read moreelevated. The beet salad has fresh herbs. The squash pizza is drizzled with balsamic vinegar reduction. The location, right on Deer Bay Marina, is also gorgeous, particularly from the deck. Service is friendly and efficient. A cute and peaceful place away from the bustle of Eastsound.

We had lunch here while waiting for the ferry and really enjoyed the nice little patio and good…read morefood. Service was prompt and friendly and they had gf designations on their menu which made my life easy. I had the house salad and the apricots on top were delish. The husband of mine had a pizza which he said was the indulgence he was craving. Our friend had the curry soup of the day, fried cheese curds and a cider tasting. Everything was good. They had some cute stuff in their shop inside and I secured myself a perfect fox hat. Next time we come back to San Juan we'll definitely stop in again.

Solid experience. The most happening place in town! Busy on a Tuesday evening. Plenty of seating…read moreinside and out. Garage doors open so a very open air feel to it. No reservations necessary. Well staffed. Soup of the day was potato, bacon and jalapeño and wow! It' was amazing! Pizza with prosciutto and arugula was good. Crust is super, super thin. The prosciutto was in really large pieces and the arugula was light but overall good.

My husband and I came to the Cascade Bay Grill on our honeymoon for lunch. This restaurant is…read morelocated on the property of the Rosario Resort right next to the water. We had nice outdoor seating and our server was very quick. We both ordered the crab cake sandwiches with a side of fries and a glass of Chardonnay and they were all amazing. Food came out quickly and everything was fantastic. They are taking all the normal covid precautions here. Masks worn by all the staff and the checkout process was contactless as I was able to pay through their website. We loved eating here so much that we ended up getting reservations for the other restaurant on property, The Mansion, for dinner on the same day.

Nice views, good food. Nice summertime choice, i believe it is closed in the mid fall to early…read moreSummer.

Orcas Village Store was a great find while waiting for the delayed sailing back to Shaw Island and…read moreAnacortes (9/16/26). Well stocked for variety, necessity, or just because. Welcoming and helpful staff onsite. This was helpful for some cold beverages (Dr. Pepper, Pepsi, bottled water) and a substantial chocolate chip peanut butter cookie. All the items hit the spot. Very convenient located downhill from the ferry terminal. Pro tip - bring along a sturdy shopping bag or tote. Helps if there are low or no stocked paper bags available and for the walk back upstairs.

The best part of this little store is that you could find everything you need for your stay on…read moreOrcas Island and they have an amazingly friendly and helpful staff. Granted prices are a little more but you are on an island. They have a great selection of cheeses and you can get a latte for your ferry ride.

While rolling around San Juan Island for my daughter's bday we came across Cousin Vinnie's NY Pizza…read moreCafe on Yelp. What really drew my attention was some of the piss poor reviews from some fake Yelpstars...you know the ones folks; those fake folks that got three total reviews all one star. I thought it was comical about how scared and bent customers were regarding Vinnie's attitude. Honestly, if you can't hack a strong attitude maybe you should just stay inside and be scared! More great pizza for the rest of us. Cousin Vinnie's is not a hole in the wall pizzeria it's a walk up to a door you can't enter and order directly with Vinnie working in the kitchen! Bad A**! We ordered up one large thin crust with olives, mushrooms, pepperoni, and sausage. One personal size all meat pizza and cannolis. Vinnie told me to come back in about 35-40 minutes. He's a one man show people. Rolled back to the front of the pizzeria and Vinnie was showing off other pies he created for orders infront of us. Once ours was done he freshly filled the cannolis and showed off our pizzas. Wow not only did they look great they tasted great. Loved the flavor of the crust and ingredients! 5 stars Vinnie! Great pizza from a great guy! I'll be back!

Rude owner Pizza was not great, don't waste your money…read more Pretty sure the crust was frozen

Ordered two pizzas to go (Margherita and Spinach & Goat) a Caesar salad and grabbed a bottle of…read morewine when we picked it up. Pizza was great, staff was very friendly and they had a nice selection of wine. Highly recommend if you want a pizza fix while in Friday Harbor.

The lady was so nice it was amazing pizza the restaurant was so "homey" just an awesome place if…read moreyour on Friday Harbor!

Service was standard. You should probably reserve in advance on Friday harbor is what we learned…read more Added to the wait list and walked around downtown. The arancini leek was okay but tasted mostly of cheese and for the price a bit expensive even for seattle standards. The lummi albacore had a very heavy mayo sauce that took away from the fish. The pizza (clam pie) was good but needed a hint of acid - it was nice to see them making it outside in the wood oven.

Everything was fantastic! Olivia was our server and she was a delight. We shared the beets &…read moreburrata and the meatballs- delicious! We also shared the bucatini with shrimp and the lemon pesto pasta. Seriously- so good! Service, food and ambience all 10 out of 10.