Atmosphere is cozy and welcoming. Staff greets you like an old friend. But, the best part was the…read moreamazingly delicious food! If you are in the vicinity of Coshocton Ohio, stopping in Roscoe Village and having lunch here is a must. Also, just the street that the restaurant sits on is so amazing it's like stepping back in time.

Cute spot, tasty sandwiches and good coffee! I enjoyed the artichoke which was served on a…read moredelicious sourdough roll. My husband ordered the Italian which was packed full of good quality meat. The staff were warm and friendly. We will definitely come back again.

The food is good and the wait staff are amazing. The salad bar is fresh and well stocked. Breakfast…read moreis especially yummy

We enjoy the salad bar here. It's a nice hometown feel place. We enjoy the occasional kids eat free…read morespecials.

Barbecue is so-so and meal size is not consistent. Sides are below average too…read more Service is great . Restaurant is very clean and pretty.

Great food and friendly staff. The bbq was delicious. The portions were generous. The prices…read morewere very reasonable.

Absolute joke went in on Saturday afternoon. They couldn't break a $20 gave us a roll of coins. Was…read morea great place when they started now it's just a joke

From the owner: Our business began as Barrels N Nuts, a family-owned and operated establishment. After a few years,…read morewe temporarily closed due to a limited customer base. We later reopened and gave it another try, but the bar-focused concept continued to face challenges. Eventually, we decided to step away from the bar side of the business altogether. In 2026, we rebranded, refreshed our vision, and proudly reopened for the third time as Rusty Mug Café, marking a new chapter focused on growth and community.

I got me a vanilla iced coffee and I got my som a glacier cherry Gatorade in the bottle and it was…read moreexpired by at least 6-7 months

Coffee tastes like burnt ass. Why I buy a frozen Carmel latte. So I can't taste the burnt ass. No…read morenot this time, 25 minutes in the drive through just to get that burnt ass taste.

this place has struggled since it was waynes tasty freeze. it is & has been for sale-building only…read morenot the lot it stands on & is now - sadly closed permanently

The slushie (slushee) / freezy was 100% pure sugar. My 3 year old dropped hers immediately and I'm…read morea bit bummed they didn't offer to replace it (especially when I tipped almost $4 on a $6 bill) but also thankful because she definitely didn't need it! My husband poured sprite into his cherry slushee to improve the flavor. The flurry/blizzard (maybe that's what is called a freezy?) was delicious!! It definitely was worth the hassle of the visit but WARNING: CROSS CONTAMINATION. I ordered an Oreo one and had bits of Reese's and later on had bits of Snickers. Now, I personally found it amazing and an extra special treat to have the bonus flavors, buuuuuut that's just a big ol' lawsuit waiting to happen if I had an allergy. Employees were friendly but I found it odd how they would take an order at the window but have to ring it up elsewhere. I'm not saying move the cash register... but what happened to the ability to do basic math? The signage displayed in the window was possibly inaccurate, or I didn't know if where to look for correct prices, but adding two numbers together shouldn't be too difficult for the 3 employees standing around talking. I'm not sure why they must insist on "medium, large, giant" instead of "small, medium, large", but nonetheless the signage indicated a freezy starts at $2.50. I with they had a smaller option than "medium" for young kids. There's a sign indicating a $5 minimum when using a card. This is understandable and pretty standard for small shops, so I ordered two slushies. The employee left the window and came back and told me it was $4something. That's great it was cheaper than expected but no idea where she got that price? And as previously stated, it's concerning how they couldn't do basic math and tell me I'd need to order a third item. (Maybe I didn't order a freezy? I ordered slushies. I'm not sure what the difference is. But the signs indicated slushie flavors, and the price sheet didn't list slushies. It was confusing and all the signs were overwhelming.) They've been in business for 6 years and may be confident in their ways but I would like to suggest that they list the items, flavors available, AND prices, all on the same spot. The window displays look like an art project completed by employees (students) anyway, so this wouldn't be difficult to update. Also, it's 2019. Every high school employee probably has a decent camera on their cell phone, and swipe through enough instagram photos to know how to take a decent picture. Include pictures next to the items and make a price chart like below: SM. MD. LRG. FREEZY $ $$ $$$ - list flavors SUNDAES - list topping options SHAKES 3 stars because at least the employees were nice and the ice cream was delicious.

Best buger place in town. But then mermaid drinks are to die…read morefor.. I called it in it was fast friendly service. I say its my favorite place.

I'm extremely disappointed with the way they've been serving us (my company) lately…read more We are an out of state company that comes to Coshocton often, and we've always come to this location for our foot longs. It used to be good service, but not these last three times. Having to deal with bad customer service over the phone and in person is unacceptable! Also, showing up to pick up an order and finding out order hasn't even been prepared is even more annoying. Customer service goes a Foot long way! we love subway though.

Never disappoints, I've tried different subs over the years, Italian BMT and tuna my fav. Employees…read moreare always pleasant and helpful if questions.

From the owner: Your local Coshocton Subway® Restaurant, located at 390 South Whitewoman Street brings new bold…read moreflavors along with old favorites to satisfied guests every day. We deliver these mouth-watering flavors with our famous Footlongs, 6" sandwiches, wraps and salads. And we offer a variety of ways to order--quick and easy in the app or online, convenient delivery, come into your neighborhood shop for an in-restaurant meal, or pick up curbside. We're proud to offer a change from same old fast food with fresh cut veggies and toppings with protein choices, fresh-baked bread and let's not forget cookies! And we're happy to help you with any catering needs as well. All Subway® Restaurants are independently owned and operated by business owners who employ talented Sandwich Artists™.

This Subway is the best subway east of the Mississippi. It's essentially great because of 2…read morespecific Sandwich Samurais, who go above and beyond to make subs. This subway is truly the best of the best

Just outstanding product and worth the drive! I would…read moredefinitely try the crumb cake and pick up a cup of their coffee

Pastries are pretty small compared to the prices. Not sure what was going on with the taste of the…read morecupcake. Looks of cakes and pastries are amazing if that's what you're looking for.