We finally stopped here for some ice cream and I was pleasantly surprised. Their menu offers a…read morevariety of ice creams, shakes, desserts and ice cream cakes. The staff is super friendly and answered any questions we had. The biggest plus was the dairy free ice cream! I didn't see it on their menu so I asked a server and was so happy to see they had vanilla, coffee and chocolate cookies and cream all dairy free. I am so happy to find a place that serves delicious dairy free ice cream. They accept cash and credit cards for payment and have a nice size parking lot. Seating is also available inside. I will definitely return!

My wife got nothing after trying 5 different flavors as she said none had any flavor. I got a…read moreflurry and got a cup of soup which I threw right in the garbage which is where this ice cream shop belongs. We will not be coming back when we come to the island. In there defense it was the other location on the island but still the same menu and company

An ice cream chain I can certainly get behind and support!…read more They have vegan options and their selection is pretty decent, including some staples like chocolate and vanilla, but very tasty. It's worth a try if you've never had. There's wooden picnic tables outside with umbrellas if you bring the family or your friends with you to get something cool and refreshing on a hot summer day.

Great selection of ice cream, Italian ice, vegan ice cream and sugar free ice cream. We had the…read morevegan Oreo smash, regular Ghirardelli and sugar free salted caramel. All were really good!

Very upsetting how little ice cream they give to you for the price. Ripping off customers is never…read morea good business model. Don't waste your time.

Great options especially for vegans or people with certain allergies. It seems like they take care…read moreto use separate spoons for scooping which is nice. Service is sort of rushed, which is understandable as it's mostly teens working there, but oh boy - I saw something pretty disgusting. There was a taster spoon trash can put on the counter and one of the workers pulled a spoon out from it to give someone a sample. I tried to tell another employee but he shrugged me off and said it's not trash - then I spun it around to show him the trash label. He was about to tell the worker, but ultimately gave up. That was pretty disgusting but maybe management didn't give the team proper training. Also weird that prices are not visible anywhere until you check out. Seems easy enough to write it on the board especially since there's a board for flavors and a board with step by step instructions of size, flavor, and toppings

We stopped by for an Gelati and an waffle with soft vanilla. The gelati had cotton candy chip ice…read morecream and blue water ice! My son devoured it!! We shared the freshly made waffle with soft vanilla, strawberries, whipped cream and hot fudge on top!! Delicious! The windmill waffles have been a family tradition for many years!! I have to have one when we are here!!

We enjoyed the Red Bull drink and oh boy was it delicious! The wide selection of frozen treats…read morebrings something new to the table

I stopped in to try a milky bun and chose cinnamon toast crunch ice cream to go in it. It is a…read moregreat concept and I love mixing cold ice cream with a warm dessert. It was good, but it was probably not something I would come out of my way for. While definitely warm, the donut was a little bit on the drier side. I also felt that the ice cream could've had more cinnamon flavor, but I do give them credit for keeping their ice cream nice and soft. Service was quick and the location was clean. If I came back, I would probably try another flavor in a standard cup.

If you need your ice cream fix on the Island, this is your spot! Though the line may be long, don't…read morelet it fool you, the wait is worth it. We got there about an hour before closing, so maybe that was an oops on our part but none the less, we were satisfied! Note: if you're looking for dairy free ice cream, the flavors change often, so check their IG for updates!

1st morning in LBI and definitely needed some donuts. Got 4 of them and they were yummy. Love this…read moreplace.

FANTASTIC! It takes a while after you order because they will freshly fry the dough. Cannot…read morerecommend enough.

I had the chocolate brownie / blueberry ice and spooned it so quickly that I didn't mind the…read moreguaranteed 'brain freeze'. SRSLY, IYKYK Hot tip: if you're there around sunset, drive to the end of the street, enjoy Rita's goodness and watch the sunset from one of the best viewpoints on LBI. Trust me on this one...

If you're looking for a frozen treat that hits the sweet spot between creamy and refreshing, Rita's…read moreis the place to be. Known for its ice custard happiness, this local favorite consistently delivers top notch flavors and a vibrant atmosphere that keeps people coming back for more. The menu is packed with options from their silky-smooth frozen custard to the bold, fruity Italian ices that come in an ever-rotating variety of flavors. Whether you're in the mood for a classic gelati (a perfect layering of ice and custard) or want to try something new like mango, Swedish Fish, or cotton candy ice, there's something here to please every palate. What really sets Rita's apart is the quality and consistency. The flavors are rich, not overly sweet, and always taste freshly made. It's clear that flavor innovation is a priority, and seasonal specials keep the experience exciting year-round. It's almost always busy, and for good reason. The lines can stretch, especially on warm evenings, but the staff moves quickly and keeps the vibe upbeat. If anything, the crowd just proves how beloved Rita's is in the community. Rita's is more than a dessert stop it's a summer tradition. Don't let the line scare you off. Great flavors, friendly service, and a treat that never disappoints make it well worth the wait.

First, the good part: the baked goods at Ferrara's are some of the best on the island. I've never…read morebought anything there that wasn't fresh and delicious. Their prices are reasonable, too. Five Stars for quality. Now, the not so good part: the service is terrible. On multiple occasions, I've asked for something only to find when I get home and open the box that I was given the wrong thing. It happened today. I asked for two sticky rolls with pecans and I was given two with walnuts. The person who seems to make the most mistakes is the older lady who works there (whom I suspect is the owner, as all the other employees defer to her). She always looks stressed and out-of-sorts. My other complaint is that they aren't customer friendly. Last year toward the end of the summer, a friend gave me a gift certificate from Ferrara's that was supposedly good to the end of October 1st when they close for the year. When we went to use it in September, our last visit of the season to the island, we found the store closed for a week for some family event. When I explained what had happened after they reopened this year and asked if they would still honor the certificate, the grumpy lady said "no" because they had already "closed the books" for the previous year. For crying out loud, it was $20 coupon and I was a regular customer (emphasis on "was"). Despite the excellent baked goods, I prefer to give my business to bakeries that treat me well. Hence, I now buy most of my baked goods elsewhere, including at Big Apple Bakery on E. Bay Avenue in Manahawkin (next to the Acme Supermarket). Their stuff is just as good as Ferrara's and they have a larger selection. One Star for service. Five Stars plus One Star divided by two is Three Stars overall.

My first visit to Ferraras went well. Arrived on Saturday morning at 6:45 and there was a short…read moreline out front probably about 10 people. The line moved fairly quickly. I was excited to try the sugar coated jelly doughnut, but in my opinion and others in my household, the jelly to donut ratio was off, there was too much jelly filling. The Boston cream doughnut was just OK and the orange Creamsicle I didn't like it at all. Overall, the donuts are good, but we like the jelly donuts at Big Apple bakery in Manahawkin better. The prices were reasonable, 5 donuts and an iced coffee was $15. The counter workers were very nice.