Cancel

Open app

Search

Coleman's Crystal Lake

3.9 (15 reviews)
InexpensiveAmerican
Closed • 11:00 am - 12:00 AM (Next day)
Updated a few days ago

Order Coleman's Crystal Lake Takeout or Delivery

COLEMAN'S CRYSTAL LAKE · YELP ASSISTANT

Ask Yelp Assistant

Coleman's Crystal Lake Photos

Business Info

COLEMAN'S CRYSTAL LAKE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Loud
Outdoor seating
Good for groups

You might also consider

More like Coleman's Crystal Lake

Recommended Reviews - Coleman's Crystal Lake

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

4 years ago

Helpful 4
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Eric F.
3205
1204
2192

7 months ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 3
Oh no 1

11 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Andy M.
289
2583
34

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Lyn W.
74
71
5

8 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1
Photo of Lisa S.
106
26
52

8 years ago

The food is amazing. I love the new waitress that started. I cannot wait to go back and have her serve me.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

19 years ago

Helpful 5
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0

15 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Love this neighborhood Cheers! Staff is Friendly and courteous!! Fun place to hangout.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

15 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of D S.
6
11
8

9 years ago

First time at Coleman's Crystal Lake. Great food, fabulous service! We'll be back! Bloody Mary's we're perfect.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

best food ever!! I love the chef. Fast and friendly service. Can't wait to go back for the fish fry

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Coleman's Crystal Lake

Review Highlights - Coleman's Crystal Lake

“Been by here a thousand times and always mean to come for their fish fry, because they have a lot of choices, including my favorite, bluegills.”

Mentioned in 5 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Jameson's Original Charhouse - straw wrapper inside bread dough.

Jameson's Original Charhouse

3.1(340 reviews)
1.3 mi
•$$

We always have a positive experience at Jameson's. The service is great and so is the food. In the…read morerare chance something isn't to your liking, the staff quickly rectify it for you. We especially love coming here for New Year's Eve for the specials. The ambiance is nice anytime you come here. They've recently added lots more entrees, appetizers and drinks specials.

We used to be Jameson regulars, but our most recent visit was likely our last visit. Quality,…read moreservice, and ambiance have all decreased as of late. Both of the last two times we've been in, I've ordered the beef Wellington special, and both times it's arrived inedibley raw. The first time this happened (celebrating our anniversary), the puff pastry appeared cooked on top but was raw underneath and the meat was still cold inside. I sent it back and asked for it to be finished. They clearly slapped the cut side of the meat on a hot pan to sear it and returned it with the puff pastry dough still raw. I opted to send it back again and just nibble on my husband's prime rib instead of having them attempt to cook the Wellington for a third time. A manager checked in on us after my husband had finished his meal and we'd already paid our bill (the server did have the Wellington removed from it). Mistakes happen, so we gave it another go. This most recent time, the puff pastry was obviously underdone when it arrived at the table (so much so that I told my husband I was pretty sure I was cutting into an uncooked steak), and when I cut into the Wellington, it was still cold and raw. Not rare. Not blue. Raw. I opted not to have them try it again after two hours of waiting, and instead ordered a simple pasta dish which was mediocre at best. Given the variability in temperature within the dish, I have a strong suspicion it may have been microwaved. My husband's steak (ordered medium rare) was barely blue, with sections he didn't eat because it was undercooked. Our appetizer (potato skins) never made it to the table, and the pasta in the chicken noodle soup was still crunchy. It was not particularly busy, but our server rarely checked on us, and we spent portions of the meal with nothing to drink. He never noticed or inquired about the appetizer. No manager ever checked in on us, even after having to send a raw meal back. What was once a staple in our restaurant rotation has found its way onto our never-again list.

Photos
Jameson's Original Charhouse
Jameson's Original Charhouse - Mr and Mrs Martini

Mr and Mrs Martini

Jameson's Original Charhouse - Warm bread and whipped butter

See all

Warm bread and whipped butter

The Honey Baked Ham Company

The Honey Baked Ham Company

3.8(26 reviews)
1.2 mi
•$

Well done Ham Team! Stopped in today for a sandwich to go. Several customers in the store and I…read morewas still quickly acknowledged and expeditiously served. No frills - just a simple ham and cheese sandwich on white bread to go. Plenty of quality ham sharing the sandwich middle with Swiss cheese and mayonnaise all enveloped by two slices of very fresh white bread. A perfectly balanced and well crafted sandwich. And, this review gets better! The staff appeared sincere in their desire and willingness to meet the needs of the customer. The staff sincerely appreciated my business. Take a bow store manager; from today's challenging work pool, you have found, hired, and adequately trained a team to represent your product as stellar brand ambassadors. Combine that with a clean and organized store and you have earned a grateful repeat customer.

Very disappointed with the quality of this order. They explained it that a new girl made the order…read more If she was not ready, why trust her with orders just yet, without checking them? First, I ordered the individual macaroni and cheese on DoorDash, but didn't get it and they said they don't actually carry it and it's on the site because it's a corporate item and gave me a potato salad in its place which is $2 less than the mac-n-cheese. No one contacted me to let me know in advance and only explained it when I called asking for it. Second, they handed the dasher a Honey Baked Ham lunch box only, with no bag. She said the girl also messed this up and didn't bag it. It was left on my porch and when I went to get it, bugs were crawling on the box which they could easily get have gotten into. No one saw this and corrected her??!! Their response was that I needed to contact Doordash with the complaints. Third, about 30 minutes later when I went to eat the lunch, I noticed that the Broccoli Bliss salad was completely dry, so I called and spoke to the Mgr to ask what happened to the sauce and the Mgr again stated that the new girl forgot the sauce. The one good thing was the Classic Ham sandwich and the potato salad. They were still good as usual. Overall; the care taken to prepare and hand off this order was unacceptable. It was not the quality I've known them to have in the past. It's not acceptable to just blame a new person. If she is making significant mistakes, why not check for accuracy??!! Perhaps these are checks and balances to consider for future order quality. Thank you!

Photos
The Honey Baked Ham Company
The Honey Baked Ham Company
The Honey Baked Ham Company

See all

Duke's Alehouse and Kitchen - The Duke Abides

Duke's Alehouse and Kitchen

3.7(688 reviews)
1.8 mi
•$$

Dukes is a wonderful place to go. First thing first as a vegan, they have meatless Monday…read morepromotions all the time (bogo half off for vegan entrees). They have an attached bar, a wide alcohol selection and a good choice of kombucha as well, and an upstairs area as well. Overall service is about normal, but the food choices are pretty unique. The Vegan appetizers and vegan entrees are all of good choices, from a falafel pita to a Korean inspired tofu + kimchi sandwich. Sometimes (???) they are generous on the tater tots and sometimes not. It's weirdly inconsistent and I have no idea why. It's as if sometimes the fries and sweet potato fries are good and other times it feels like they gave a 12 year old the salt shaker to season literally everything in salt. But overall the food is decent with a decent selection enough to go on the regular. Price is a bit over the top too, but not outrageous. Therefore : pretty good but not number one.

Not sure why this place has low ratings because it was fabulous! We came on a weekend during off…read morehours and the place was pretty quiet. We sat inside and the indoor seating is clean and spacious. It was brightly lit with big windows to the main road. There was also a stage which I'd imagine has some live music at night to complete the ambiance. The food quality is unlike any other. It's one of the original farm to table restaurants in the area. They even list their food sources on their menu. We started with the tempura green beans. I'm not normally a fried food person but these were so light and fresh and came in a very generous portion. For my meal, I had the grain bowl and added tofu. It also came as a generous portion. I loved all the different flavors and textures. I tried a few of my boyfriend's sweet potato fries and you cannot get fries tasting any more fresh and flavorful. Service was on top of things and helpful at providing recommendations. Shoutout to Kyle for the great experience!

Photos
Duke's Alehouse and Kitchen
Duke's Alehouse and Kitchen - Mussels were delish

Mussels were delish

Duke's Alehouse and Kitchen - Veggie app. You can't see it easily but two small red and yellow peppers are in there too. Whole?

See all

Veggie app. You can't see it easily but two small red and yellow peppers are in there too. Whole?

Jude’s - Three medallions, Ravioli, & Shrimp with crab filling on top

Jude’s

4.2(130 reviews)
1.6 mi
•$$$

The food was absolutely delicious. The only things ive tried and not liked were the peking chicken…read more(wrap things?) (too saucy....) and the pierogis (not enough flavor and too oily, but not at fault of kitchen staff). The menu has tons of variety too, and their specials change out so regularly i cant keep up! The drinks ive gotten there have been phenomenal so far, and the mocktails dont make you feel like youre missing out on any fun. In addition to the Food, the service is positively delightful. Our server last time i went was also the bartender, and the other staff were kind enough to step in and help him with our orders, and he himself was more than helpful enough. The interior of the resturaunt was beautiful with wonderful lighting and a very cohesive layout, but i do have two complaints: the tables are very small and the booths are very low. When you order at a tapas resturaunt, you dont really get just one or two plates at a time, and when a solid quarter of the table is being occupied by the standup menus, the water glass, and the decorative flowers, it gets crowded very quickly. Overall a 9/10. Definitely a wonderful place to go with friends, family, or even on your own!

I have been meaning to post this for awhile…read more I sadly only have bad things to say.... First! The girls they hire to work here can be VERY rude, the food is not great, I think this is really just a place people get together and drink at so the environment isn't very relaxing. The couple times I've been here there is always loud drunk people.

Photos
Jude’s
Jude’s - Alligator bites

Alligator bites

Jude’s - Thai Peanut Chicken Kabobs

See all

Thai Peanut Chicken Kabobs

Coleman's Crystal Lake - tradamerican - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...