Stopped for dinner. Staff was friendly, we ordered one chicken sub and one buffalo chicken wrap and…read morefries. $36. The buffalo Wrap came out as a sub at first - they corrected but I felt bad asking them to switch. It didn't have much ranch on it, but overall it tasted good. Fries were really good! The atmosphere could use a revamp- the lighting feels like an office building with fluorescents and very white light. Some darker table lighting would be nicer in my opinion. The buffalo chicken wrap upset my stomach, so that's why I'm rating it 3 stars.

We really love this place! Tony's Chicken wing pizza is outstanding!! Love the wings too! During…read morethe holidays, we always order sausage bread bc my family loves it!

Excellent pizza, stopped in for 2 slices on road trip, good location just off the highway, super…read morefriendly genuine owners. Delicious pepperoni with red sauce slice and the other was pulled pork and cheese, very good. Crush was just right. Absolutely outstanding homemade cherry cheesecake, so glad I got that. Celebrated the Kansas City Chiefs getting beat with these fine proprietors.

The pizza is awesome and the people are super nice. The atmosphere is very comfortable and prices…read moreare great!

Yetty's Pizzeria in Herkimer is a solid and respectable lunch spot. The dining area is roomy and…read morecomfortable, and the pizza especially their Red, White, and Green upside down pizza is reliably tasty and satisfying. They also have gluten free pizza options. Prices are fair, and portions are generous, making it a decent value for what you get. One of the best things about Yetty's is its huge menu: besides pizza, you'll find calzones, wings, salads, paninis, subs, wraps, burgers, pasta dinners, Italian dishes, appetizers, desserts, and more. There's really something for everyone, especially if you're in the mood for Italian comfort food or just want variety. However, one consistent drawback is the slow service, if you're on a tight schedule I'd place your order ahead of time. The quality of the food usually makes up for the wait, but it's something to keep in mind.

Food takes forever and is overpriced if you want to eat a whole plate full of pasta you would be…read morebetter off, boiling some noodles.

Awesome pizza but closed at 9 pm on a Saturday? Super super lame. We are never going to get back…read moreto normal at this rate.

One of the best newer restaurants in the valley. Purple cow wings are AMAZING but you cannot go…read morewrong with anything on the menu.

Awesome server & ambiance! Food was excellent! Came in from Wisconsin (fish fry capital of the…read moreworld) and the Baked fish fry was awesome! Just a mile off Interstate 90 Herkemer exit! P.S, the house Italian Dressing on a salad is a must!

The greens and chicken riggies were very good. The service was excellent. Very efficient and kind…read morewaitress. Tired looking place but enjoyed the experience of this little town Upstate NY.

I absolutely love their pizza. They have a good selection of canned sodas, like root beer and cream…read moresoda, tasty desserts, and incredible cheesesteaks. Their staff is always friendly and provides great service.

Take out was super, On Time, Hot and Correct. Very satisfying meal... We were camping in…read moreMiddleville, tried NY Pizza in Newport, they didn't list a correct phone number... Glad they didn't !! This was great!!!

Five Star Real Italian Food! Lovely atmosphere and great service !! Highly recommend if you are in…read morethe area! The "bar" has officially been raised!

Should be zero stars for mediocre and under cooked foods that gave me horrifying stomach illness…read morefor over 24 hours! The garlic knots are bland, dough raw and chewy, no garlic and lifeless ...like the employee Karen that was rude beyond measure. I do not believe the reviews online, they must be falsely generated, check yourself. For a " family owned," business i expect at the least humble, wholesome, grandma recipes..im out.

Had a couple of cheese slices. Let me start by saying that our uncle owns a pizzeria in the Bronx…read morethat I have loved since before I married my husband. I compare all pizza to his. This compares! The pizza was thin/medium with the crust perfectly crunchy with soft fluffy dough in the center. Met the owner Joe and he was so hospitable and welcoming. We had a couple good laughs. It was my first time here and I had no idea how big this place is! He showed us around. I wished I lived closer because I would definitely consider this place for parties like graduation etc. my sons going to school in Utica so I'm sure he'll be back with a bunch of his friends and big appetites! I found out about this place through some camp friends who frequent this place. I better thank them. I forgot to take a picture before. I only got the after and the since we got to go!

My family and I arrived here after a trip on Erie Canal Cruises and at the recommendation of my…read moresis's bf, who had heard fantastic reviews and that the majority of his co workers went to. I ordered a chicken club with bacon, my sister got her and my Dad an upside down pizza, my sis bf got chicken wings with hot sauce and we all shared from a sampler platter and garlic knots. The food was absolutely fantastic. My order was accidently given to another patron on accident and a whole new order was made. Hey, accidents happen and I purposely was calm and had no intention to adding to the service industry woes of bad customers being entitled and treating wait staff like shit during these pandemic times. The woman repeatedly apologized and my patience was rewarded as the server brought over my sandwich she said she overstuffed it, especially with bacon...so much so I only had one half of the sandwich and saved the rest for another dinner! The food was absolutely fantastic...the garlic knots, the platter and the wings got rave reviews. My Dad thought there was too much tomato sauce...can you imagine an ITALIAN saying that...my sis and her bf liked the leftover slices so to each their own In any event, the service and food were absolutely impeccable. The server was attentive and nice. I highly recommend!

Wouldn't recommend ordering from this place. They left my food outside and never tried to contact…read moreme. Needs better management.

Without getting too detailed. I ordered the pasts bowl and a brownie. By the next day I had…read moreexplosive diarrhea. I've been sick for 48 hours now with food poisoning and had to call 911 to go to the hospital. I got home today, still sick. My son had a brownie last night and hasn't left the bathroom yet today. Clearly the brownies are poisonous. I wanted to get this message to everyone in the area and am calling health services now.

This spot came highly recommended by a few locals who swore by the quality of the pizza, so…read moreexpectations were set going in. I've always believed the best way to judge a pizza place is by its basic which means starting with a classic cheese pie. The cheese pizza did not disappoint. The dough was well cooked with minimal sag, striking a nice balance. The sauce-to-cheese ratio was right where it should be. The cheese had a slight stretch to it, and the sauce delivered a solid, flavorful bite that tied everything together. I also tried the chicken bacon ranch pizza. It was flavorful and satisfying, with a generous amount of bacon throughout. While I would have liked to see a bit more chicken, each slice was still a tasty combination of savory toppings and creamy ranch that made for an enjoyable bite. Overall, this place lives up to its local reputation, especially when it comes to the basics. A solid option if you're looking for well-made pizza with reliable flavors. Side note/ I do a lot of chicken wing/ bleu cheese reviews and the employee at the counter said she makes it herself each day. So I had to try it. Well I can say this bleu is a solid 6/10, it's just missing some larger chunks, the flavor profile is spot on but the pieces in it are just crumbles. While it doesn't place in my top tier , it's not far off. Next time I'm going to have to try it with some wings.

I've ordered from this restaurant 3 time. first time is was so delicious. The last two time they…read moremessed up on my order. The third time I ordered a chicken Parmesan vodka rotini, they actually forgot the chicken Parmesan. How do you forget the most important part. i called the restaurant. They could care less, definitely won't be ordering from there again.