Overpriced!! $4.50 for a small,greasy slice is highway robbery. Way to take advantage of the tourists

The circle is infinite. Circle pizzas wait time is also infinite. Ordered pizza at 7 today, with the promise of a hour wait. The pizza arrived at 8:45. The pizza was cold. Need I say more? I think not. read more

I have been coming to Avalon since I was a kid and lots has changed down here, but Circle Pizza is still one of my favorite places to go when I am back here in Avalon read more

Terrible delivery drivers and even worse costumer service. Grew up in a restaurant and was shocked by how poorly they handle a situation. Won't be referring people to circle again. read more

Maybe I came in on a bad day? But, the pizza was just pretty much awful. Oddly enough, we went in because we had noticed they were a very busy pizzeria. So we made it a point to stop in for lunch, and left very dissappointed. Like I said, maybe it happen to be bad timing. $3 a slice read more

I've been going here for years, but I think I've had my last slice. It's always been just ok, but the slowness of service and problems almost every time we take out have left me no choice but to look elsewhere. read more

If I had to choose between a frozen pizza and a pizza from Circle, go with frozen. My pizza was bland and tasteless. Pure disappointment.

Overpriced. $4.80 for one slice of buffalo chicken pizza. It was cold and had no ranch or blue cheese on it, so I asked for a side and she said that would be an extra dollar. The pizza was also cold and we had to ask for it to be heated up. Cheaper places on the island with better deals and better pizza. read more

It sucks to have the worst service and the people suck the stupid idiotic it is extreamly expensive

Cold ok pizza. And the "wiz wit" was terrible. Would not recommend and used to be a favorite choice on the island.

Terrible. Overpriced by double what a normal pizza shop charges. Dirty place. Lousy. Terrible. Don't bother eating here. read more

I spent 15 minutes reviewing pizza in Avalon on Yelp and hoped Circle would be decent. If you appreciate Little Caesars this is your pie. It's one of those pizza's that you can just tell is made with really inexpensive ingredients. Kinda salty, no sauce to be tasted (if your expectation involves some hint of tomato), cheese you feel more than taste and crust that is chewy, but not in a good way. Fries were ok, very salty and not hot (we got it delivered...late and only warm) read more

Been coming to Circle Pizza more than 30 years. Never again! Went in for 2 slices to go at 8:30 PM. No one at counter for 5+ minutes. Watched employee push condiments and straws aside, climb up on counter with shoes on to fill ice machine. A cook took my order and gave me a cup. No slices. Finally counterperson comes over and asks what I want. Gives me two cold slices then questions why I want them put oven. Says they only do that in the winter. Begrudgingly puts them in oven (I think) and charged me $11.73 for 2 slices and a Pepsi. Walked out with slices and found them cold when I went to eat them in the car. First review I have ever written and only because food, service and atitude were so bad! read more

HOW AWFUL! Coupon in the Menu & Dining Guide says NOTHING about being limited to Mon-Thurs. Person on the phone argued with me that it has it on the coupon or in the book. Which is wrong. You should honor the coupon. POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE! read more

Not sure if it was how wasted I was or not but this pie was amazing!!!!!!!

Decent pizza for late night eats---but the help acts entitled and rude. I asked them to warm up my slice b/c it was cold and they told me they wouldn't and asked if I wanted a refund. I just wanted a warm slice. So if u want a good slice of cold pizza, with an obnoxious staff, come here! read more

Best pizza in Avalon. Since moving to Nevada, we really miss NY pizza. There is Nu Yalk Pizza in Reno, which is great, but Circle is the best. We look forward to it each summer! read more

Great greasy slice of pizza. Can take a while to get your food though, they are always super busy. But they have this really nice outdoor space to sit and last time I went they had a band playing which was awesome! read more

I ordered a "BRICK OVEN" pizza from Circle (I THOUGHT) but it turned out to be Vozzella's Pizza operating a separate business INSIDE circle. They make a good pizza that is big enough to feed 2 but their "Personal" sized pizza cost $19.99! Way to much in my opinion! read more

Must've been wearing my invisibility cloak...couldn't get served at the walk up window (only 2 other patrons, who already had their pizza). Food smelled good, tho...I was bummed. "And it's that kind of attention to detail that garners you a one-star Yelp review". read more

Love this place, not easy to park at, found delivery much more efficient and less stressful way to go. Pasta dishes plenty big & delicious with friendly/knowledgeable staff-Tina & Maddie were great on the two occasions we went! read more

Awesome pizza, but a few bad experiences are enough for me to stay away from now on. Tonight we waited for our one cheese pie 45 min longer than the pick up time they gave me. Plus, the food was cold & they gave us the wrong toppings. Hm... You must have serious patience to eat at Circle Pizza these days.. read more

If you'd like an extremely over priced meal $10 for two slices of horrible blackened pizza and a soda then this is the place to go. The miserable staff really sets the mood for a memorable experience! read more

Circle Pizza - Great charcoal pizza - Pizza Near Me - Avalon, New Jersey

Better than expected based on other reviews. We had the Buffalo Chicken and Meathead pizza. Delivery was quick.

Well if you want cold pizza, hot salad and hour+ delivery this place is for you. After calling to speak to the manager about the delay( we were told 30 minutes), we were told they would make it fresh and deliver it right away. Two seconds later they showed up with two cold soggy pizzas and two hot salads. I don't recommend this place unless you are desperate. Service is terrible and the food matches. read more

This is by far my favorite restaurant on the island. The pizza is delicious and the atmosphere is even better. Employees are always extremely helpful and generous. As I said the pizza is scrumptious, but if you want something fried, their wings and cheesesteak egg rolls are phenomenal as well. read more

My visit was on 6/15/2018 We used to go here with my family years ago. Came back in town for a few days and decided to get some pizza. Worst decision ever. We went in and ordered there, knowing it would be a wait, didn't mind. The kid at the counter acted like I was bothering him by ordering. He's rushing me to order and was very rude. Later I saw him eating while standing at the register staring at customers. So unprofessional. About 25 mins later they called my name for my pizza, but oh wait the fries aren't done yet... how a pizza got done before fries is beyond me but ok. 15 mins later I'm asking where my fries are and the pizza is getting cold, while she said she's "keeping it warm" under the fan. The man in front of me who's pizza was already done was waiting for over 10mins for a damn salad. This place has gone so downhill and it's time they close. The staff is running around like chickens and have no idea how to pace food properly. Avalon is becoming our new vacation spot, but Circle Pizza will never be involved in our vacation again. The only reason I gave two stars was because my luke warm fries and almost cold pizza were still good, just wish they had been hot. read more

20.00 Large pizza? Need I say more? Pizza is larger than average but not $20.00 large. Pizza is greasy. Bad service twice in a row for me. I would advise against eating at the store as it is FILTHY. read more

If your're a fan of recycling then eat here. They take your cardboard and turn it in to crappy late night pizza. Didn't know it was possible to screw up late night pizza. read more

Circle is my favorite place to get pizza. Although to don't think the takeout is the best when you are getting the pizza there it taste amazing. read more

Tiny overpriced pizza that lack cheese and flavor hopefully they go out of business so a real restaurant can come take their place

Love the pizza here. I like it better than Nemo's. Thin crust with a crispy bite and yummy sauce. I had a slice Fresh from the oven and it was sooo good. Bummed to see the bad reviews bc I had a great meal here. We also ordered the cheesesteak and fries. Both were excellent, great amount of meat, cheese and the bread was also fresh and flavorful. Try it you will probably love it!! read more

I can't believe the 1 star reviews, must be stupid drunks headed there after a hard night at the Princeton. Pizza is great, actually best in Avalon. The grilled chicken Caesar salad is was also delicious ! read more

I LOVE CIRCLE PIZZA! the staff is friendly and they are doing the best they can to serve you good pizza. There are mess ups, but there are always mess ups in ANY restaurant. This pizza place is doing its traditional job to make families, friends, and drunk people happy. It is not easy to please everybody in Avalon. Just remain patient and you will receive a great pizza, and if there are any issues they will be taken care of immediately by the wonderful managers. Their names are Ana, Dillon, and Danni. Drew is the owner aka BRUCE BUCKMAN, he is a good guy and runs a tough and stressful business. Drunk residents and shoobies must recognize this! Circle Pizza wants to serve you the best food on the island. People are able to hang out, have a good time, but all they ask for in return is respect. It is not the cheapest pizza on the island, but Avalon in general is expensive. They always deserve more than one chance. They have been serving for over 20 years and helped people make memories and even so many love stories. Gotta respect Circle Pizza. read more

Worst Stromboli I have ever had. The sandwhixh my son got was completely burnt. The chicken was as dry as the sand at the beach. I will never ever put my family through the torture of this place again. The employees also were all young adults who were very childish when I picked up the food. Very disappointed. No way a place here in Avalon should taste like that. read more

You don't have to try very hard when 90% of your clientele is three sheets to the wind (e.g. drunk). Service is horrible, food is worse.

I oredered a buffalo chicken salad. It came with TWO buffalo chicken fingers which was not near enough for the entire salad, lettuce, onions, mushrooms (not sure why they were in there) tomatoes and ranch dressing. It took 15 minutes for my meal to be ready. My salad was $8.45 and I oredered a fountain soda. The entire meal came to $11.45 for a horrible salad and drink. I felt ripped off and the food was awful. I would never go back. read more

They would not honor a gift card off this year at a benefit for st Jude's children's hospital. Unacceptable.

Drew is a great business owner, clearly reflected in the success of his various restaurants. In my 22 years living in the area I've had nothing but great experiences with Circle's pleasant staff and delightful food. The buffalo chicken and pizza are to be unmatched. I recommend this to all! read more

So don't go here in the late hours of the night. They take advantage of drunk people and charge $25 for one pizza....plain pizza!!! And it was cold and gross! Never going back. Wawa it is! read more