My husband purchased/sized all of our wedding rings and bands here and it was a great experience…read more Recently, I stopped by on a week night to get my band sized up a little to match my engagement ring. It was a little before close, so I was expecting to have to leave my band there for them to work on it, but they were able to work their magic in the time we were there and get the ring to finally fit my finger comfortably. Would highly recommend this place for purchasing rings! They have great customer service and a nice selection.

Went in to have a watch band repaired and Wow - they were so great. No waiting and they offered to…read moreclean my wedding band as a bonus. It has 16 diamonds on it. I didn't realize how dull it was looking until it came back cleaned - practically needed sunglasses it was so sparkly! Very nice staff and so helpful - I'll definitely go back for my jewelry gifts! First class all the way. Thank you Middleton Jewelers!

Rick's Olde Gold - they made my day today! I had been hearing their ads for years, packed-up some…read moreold never used jewelry & for some oddball reason, just kept putting it off. Well TODAY I finally visited this wonderful place. Tom, Trevor, & Veronica are the best. I'm so glad I finally got my but-tocks in gear & made the visit. It's a museum of sorts & I happily took it all in while my stuff was being appraised. Thank you!! ps - life is short, don't put it off.

Straight forward and knows the market. Left with greater knowledge of gold. Willy Neighborhood…read more Good bars and restaurants all walkable.

Expert, Friendly & Honest -- Highly Recommend! I love it…read morewhen my expectations are exceeded, and that was definitely the case at Midwest Fine Jewelry & Coin. The shop is welcoming, and Gordy and his son were both friendly and professional. I brought in a mixed assortment of gold odds and ends -- even some gold dust -- and Gordy examined everything with the eye of an expert and the enthusiasm of someone who truly loves what he does. His excitement when he found pieces worth more than I expected was delightful! As a former silversmith, I asked plenty of questions and he was a wealth of knowledge. I felt genuinely well taken care of throughout the entire process. I left completely satisfied and highly recommend their shop.

Fathers-Son establishment ... best and most fair gold and silver buyers in the area!!! I would…read moreconsider myself loyal to them at this point! Thank you for all you do!!! Your paisan friend, Lombardo!

I came in to sell my unwanted gold. I found way more. The staff of friendly, talented Goldsmiths…read moreran by Bill Howard is a well kept secret in the Dane County area. The shop is an amazing place for not only jewelers but metal artists, potters and painters. The things you find in retail stores pales in comparison to the treasures these people create. I was one to think I could not afford custom work...I WAS WRONG! What a find...Great place and THANK YOU AGAIN!

Bill refused to return calls. I dropped off some WWI bayonets to be restored months ago and…read morestopped by his building on two occasions during his office hours, but no one was there and no response to the calls. I finally heard back from Howard, and picked up my restored bayonets. He did a very good job on the knives and scabbards.

I had a deeply disappointing experience with McCoy Jewelers that I feel compelled to share,…read moreespecially for anyone considering them for something as costly and meaningful as an engagement or wedding ring. After reading yelp reviews, I was drawn to them based on the reviews and them being a small business and operating since 1973 I took in my late father's vintage wedding band to have it resized so I could wear it. The original size was 10.75, and they measured my finger at a small of 9.25--a reduction of 1.5 sizes. They quoted me $250 for the job, with half due upfront. The technicians were articulate and displayed skill. I trusted their expertise and left the ring in their care. When I picked up the ring, it felt uncomfortably tight. Their response was simply, "Give it a few weeks." As time went on, the ring became so tight I couldn't wear it at all. When I returned, they insisted the work was done correctly at the time and blamed my finger for supposedly changing size. They offered no solution, only excuses. I asked them to resize it to a 9.5 or 9.75 so I could wear it. The refused. When I tried to discuss my concerns, the owner dismissed me with condescending double talk, suggesting I was just a difficult customer because I hadn't worn jewelry before. I felt insulted and taken advantage of. To add insult to injury, they kept the gold removed from my ring during resizing. For a typical men's gold band, reducing by 1.5 sizes removes about 1.2 to 1.5 grams of gold--worth roughly $120 to $150 at current prices. Ethical jewelers follow the practice of returning this gold to the customer, but McCoy's did not. Instead, they kept it, likely to resell or reuse, which felt dishonest and exploitative. It's important to mention that getting engaged and dealing with expensive and meaningful jewelry for a lifetime is already a stressful time. You need to be able to trust the people you're working with. Unfortunately, McCoy Jewelers only made the process more stressful and left me with a bad taste. Eventually, I had the ring properly resized at a reputable jeweler in Chicago for $85, and now it fits perfectly every day irrespective of the time of day, the weather, or my body temperature. In summary: McCoy Jewelers overcharged, kept my gold, failed to stand by their work, and treated me poorly. I support local businesses whenever I can, but I cannot recommend this one. My experience shows that, at McCoy's, the customer is definitely not always right.

My Fiance and I have had a great experience with McCoy Jewelers. He went to McCoys and got my ring…read morecustom made to how he wanted it to look like. They were great with communication and getting it done in a timely manner. We recently went back in to get our wedding bands made. We are on a time crunch and they were amazing at getting us different designs that we were looking at within two days. They all have been amazing to work with!

Honest prices and nice people. Recommended! They have quite an eclectic selection of items besides…read morenumismatics.

I was extremely disappointed in the attitude of the owner and given poor reviews of the 2 different…read moreitems brought in. I asked about the coins assessments, and I was told they are worthless even though evaluated with offer from a different company. My second visit was a pair of Diamond Earrings that had been appraised from original highly rated Diamond store. With the appraisal in hand, the owner of the The Coin Shop told me that they are worthless and that the diamonds are no longer a great investment because the value of the diamond jewelry is is not as profitable and it is ALL GOING UNDER! All diamond stores are closing. My assessment was for $1300 even after viewing the original paperwork given to me when purchased and as I upgraded the earings. I did not cause this owner any grief, yet I was told to leave! I am EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTED in the treatment with ZERO reason to be treated with such disrespect! I WILL NEVER EVER RECOMMEND THIS PLACE OF BUSSINES TO ANYONE!!!!!