The sheet pepperoni pizza was was just about as good as I've ever had...and that was following a…read moredelivery into a campground, which took a little extra time. The crust was chewy, tasty, and thick. It wasn't overly done or under done. It didnt lack for toppings or cheese. The sauce wasn't too sweet, salty, or sparse. We had tried a few wing flavors, extra crispy. I particularly enjoyed the mustard bbq (golden?) sauce. It was mild, but sweet and tangy and very delicious. Loved it! The one big issue is that someone else at the gathering grabbed a few "flats" wings and they had several chicken feathers which I witnessed on several wings. It didn't appear to be just a stray one missed. Maybe this isn't a big issue for some, but definitely unappetizing for me. Luckily, the drumstick wings didnt have that issue. They were great! Try asking for drumsticks only?? The celery and blue cheese accompaniments were fine.

I called and ordered a sub. The girl was kinda rude. I went through my whole order and address and…read moreeverything just for her to say "we're not gonna deliver that far just for a sub" and they are only 10 minutes away. I called another place, 10 minutes away in the other direction. They had no problem bringing me my sub ‍

The garlic knot stinger sliders were the best sandwiches I have ever had, and they were even great…read morecold the next day.

Pizza was greasy, wings tasted funny and were cold. They tell you 45 minutes and when you get…read morethere the foods been sitting. Kids running the place.

First time sitting on the pizzeria side. They seem to be sitting a lot over here tonight…read more Service was good. Ravioli were delicious. It's a lot quieter on this side lol

This is my favorite pizza in Batavia. After living here for a few years, this was my go-to spot. We…read morewere back in town for the day hanging out and decided we needed to get some pizza before we went home. We ended up getting a few things which were all delicious. We got a large cheese and pep pizza, some wings, fried mozzarella, and some fried dough bites for dessert. The pizza here has been great and the service is always pretty quick. They have two sides of the restaurant with takeout on one, and dining on the other. The dining room is gorgeous and has such a great vibe to it. It feels upscale, yet cozy. If you're in Batavia and need a pizza, Main Street is the place to go.

Came here on a Saturday evening, and it was fairly busy. There is both indoor and outdoor seating,…read morebut it was about 85 with 400% humidity so we opted for inside. The place is fairly dated, but practical with lots of space. The 2 bartenders who also serve as waitresses were swamped. They are expected to do take out orders, in-house orders, drinks at the bar, and bringing food from the kitchen to tables simultaneously. I'm assuming they were understaffed. Service was slow, and we were fairly certain they lost our order for a while, because folks that came in after us were served first. Lots of take outs passed through, so again, I assume they were simply inundated with orders. Once we received our food, we were pleasantly surprised. The pizza was good (aside from my little pet peeve of cutting a round pizza into squares and triangles. Why?!?). I was raised Sicilian and I'm a crust snob. Their crust is flavorful, with a good texture and not too thick. Very nice. The hubs said the Turkey wrap was excellent, my and a friend's calzones were cooked beautifully (microwaving the sauce for 30 seconds instead of sending it out cold would have been nice), and my friend's BBQ boneless wings were SPECTACULAR. All-in-all it was a good experience. Everyone was friendly (even those poor waitresses), and when it slowed down a bit the cook came out to see if everything was okay. Good times all around!

First time we ate in and waited 50 min for 2 calzones. This time we ordered out for 2 pizzas. Said…read more35-40 min. 1 hour & 10 min later it came out. They did give us a $25 gift card but probably because I complained and was ready to ask for money back to go somewhere else. Probably give gift card to someone else because we won't go back

The family stopped in for dinner and games! We loved the place!…read more Amazing food, great service and always friendly staff! Dubby's is a great place!

Great food, great fun. The Woodford pizza is worth the trip. Add in fun lawn games, that are house…read morein an Indoor arena,and you've got fun for the whole family.

After my son's basketball game in Medina, we decided to try Doug's pizza. I called and ordered a…read morelarge cheese and pepperoni pizza. We really liked the pizza. His sauce had an Italian seasoning flavor to it, which we liked. The pizza was sauced with just the right amount, and the crust was a thicker crust, which I liked because I love the thick crust pizzas. We will definitely order again the next time we are in the neighborhood. I'm looking forward to trying other food options from the menu. The man who answered the phone was nice considering I had the basketball game noise in the background.

I just tried Doug's again after many years. Oh My..... I just had the best sub I have had in my…read moreentire life. I ordered the spicey "smiley sub" it came with the spicy italian meat. I asked for extra lettuce, tomatoes, onions and mayo and their italian dressing. All their subs are toasted.....It was so good. Great bread, great flavor, dripped all over the place, but it was a glorious dripping of great flavors. I was moaning with each bite, so my wife asked for a bite and she just said, "Oh my goodness." you gotta try doug's again. I am not kidding the best sub I have ever had. My only regret was I did not take a picture. After the first bite I could not put it down long enough. It was that good. Great Job Doug. And the price... 12 for a great whole sub with great bread. Less then any other subshop in town.

Boy times have changed!! Stromboli is NOT what it used to be! Much smaller - still tasty but…read morereally disappointing! Double cheese was a joke.. no sauce inside - minimal pepperoni Still quaint place for Barker. It usually was a treat to get Stromboli or Calzone.. I guess it is what it is ! Staff still very nice! Very polite!

Went here for the first time since the change in management. The fish fry was absolutely perfect…read more The batter was crispy and light and it was a nice size portion. Tarter sauce is usually an afterthought but this one had some unique flavors and I really liked it. We had wings and the pretzel appetizer - both of which were great. I gave 5 stars but I feel I should say that the dessert was just ok. It was nice to have some unique choices however the cupcake flight completely fell apart when we tried to eat it. The pie was also ok. Maybe a little early in the season for peach pie? Even so, I highly recommend giving the place a try!

For New Year's Eve, my mom and I planned on getting pizza for dinner and decided on Cusimano's…read more We called around 3pm on New Year's Eve and at first, got a busy tone, but after waiting a minute, we got through and placed our order for pickup at 5:15pm. The woman who took my order order was very conscientious and ran through my order again to make sure she had everything correct. I was able to pickup my order at 5:15pm with no problems and the staff inside were just as pleasant. We ordered two medium (12", six slice) specialty pizzas: the Bianca and the Cusimano with Cathy's Sweet red sauce. Both pizzas were fantastic! The toppings were plentiful and the crust was very much a Buffalo-style with it being more on the doughy side but not overly thick and cooked to give a nice chew and a crispy edge. I totally recommend ordering the Cusimano specialty pizza with the sweet sauce though, as the savory toppings go in perfect harmony with the sweet-style sauce. The ricotta cheese on both pizzas puts a creaminess into each bite. The Bianca specialty was excellent and came across light, a pizza that doesn't sit too heavy in your stomach. The size of each pizza was perfect as we were able to eat as much as we could but still had leftovers. The price was very reasonable as well. At this point, Cusimano's has secured itself as the best pizza place in Medina, in my opinion. I would not and will not hesitate to come back here again! :)

Very clean restaurant however the pizza was just average doughy and very filling and heavy. I also…read morehad a salami sub and it was OK nothing special and the prices were good.

We took two steak hoagies to go. They were delectable. Friendly service and would go back again…read morewhen in the area!

Excellent fresh food choices! The portions are adequate. The service is very neighborly like.read more

It's not closed. It's very much open. I opened the door and they served us. Looks like it's open.read more

I had a reservation and our table was setup with a view when we arrived. The hostess greeted us…read morevery pleasantly. We had a great start! We ordered two cups of soup, pretzel, Beef on Weck and a steak dish. The kitchen was backed up so we waited a little for our food. The wait wasn't that bad since we were snacking on the pretzel . I don't usually give reviews under 4 stars. What happens next warrants the 3 stars. We ordered the steak rare or medium rare, depending on how rare they could make it. The steak came out with no pink at all. It was tough to cut. It took me awhile to flag someone down. When our server came, I mentioned that we requested the steak rare but it looks more well done. Her answer surprised me that I didn't know how to respond. I can give you A1 sauce, she said. I don't expect the steak to be a 5-star rating steak. However, when the steak wasn't cooked as requested and we were offered A1 sauce to make it more tolerable. That just doesn't seem right. She said she will check with the Kitchen to see what they could do. 2 minutes laters, she stopped by and said: I am just gonna make sure that I didn't make the mistake before I go to the kitchen. Hmmm, ok. She came back with two choices, 10% off or they will cook another steak for us. We don't want to chance it especially, when they kept on apologizing to the customers saying their kitchen is backed up. Besides, we had already lost our appetite because my father-in-law's beef on weck sandwich is also dry(see pictures). We didn't eat lunch so we arrived hungry but he could only manage to eat half of his sandwich, thanks to the Scotch Ale. I then asked to speak with the manager. I was told the manager is in the kitchen that probably won't come out. This was the first time that a manager wouldn't come out. Side note: I often asked to speak with the manager when the server did a great job and so want to recognize the server. I don't usually ask the manager for complaints. I told her 10% for this magnitude of error was nothing. She said she would check with manager. The manager still didn't come out. The kitchen must be really short staffed because now the manager offered to comp everything. We told the server that we are not trying not to pay the bill but want solutions for the two dry, overcooked meals. Especially, we had two glasses of beer, two soft drinks, two cups of soup and a pub pretzel. We countered that they waived the two overcooked dishes( not much was eaten). The server went back to check with the manager. She came back and said the manager accepted the offer and she would bring the bill right out. Twenty minutes later, we had to flag her down for our bill. My oh my, I felt so bad for my father-in-law because his Father's Day meal wasn't that great. He picked the restaurant because he was looking forward to the sandwich. I hope this is just a one off situation. Long review because I'm shocked with my encounter especially the A1 sauce solution offered for an overcooked steak. Still shocked!