I would love to thank Renata. She is absolutely amazing and helped my wife and I get a dream…read moreapartment. Against all odds we were denied many times previous to working with her due to an issue of credit. But Renata was so determined to help that she helped us get an apartment beyond what we were hoping for. It's absolutely beautiful and may I say this was all within just one week. She was SUPER responsive EVERYDAY. Answered all my questioned and yes I had a lot. She is so nice and showed me that she truly cared. Also extremely professional and very reassuring. I couldn't have asked for a better experience. I worked with people who I knew in real estate and even they couldn't get me approved. But Renata got it done and she got it done fast and in a place that I'm so happy. We are truly grateful to you Renata continue to help lives the way you helped my wife's and I. We feel truly blessed and couldn't do this without you. Everyone reading this know you are in good hands!!

Reneta gives off a very condescending and unfriendly vibe. She said my partner and I were "wasting…read moreeveryone's time" by asking to tour places more than a month ahead of our move in.

I have lived in this building many years on the UES and they do the minimal to maintain the…read morebuildings on my block that they manage. They do nothing to stop the rats and roaches that live in the walls of my building. At night time it's like the rats are having a party. Take a look at the picture of one that was caught. I've called 311, and then HPD came by, but nothing was done. I have been in court with them for the past 2 years and have gotten nowhere. They keep the buildings unclean. Don't rent from them, because rats will be your roommates.

Not even deserving of 1 star. Pure fucking trash…read more Landlord is Gerald Musano. Google him to see his past stint in jail. He owns 28 buildings within Manhattan, mostly concentrated on the Upper East Side. Lived in one of his buildings for 3 years. Rent was below market rate and my actual apartment layout wasn't bad. It was spacious. The kitchen was small with crappy appliances but that is expected. The building is HORRIBLY managed and maintained. Maintained isn't even appropriate here. Tenants are left like animals without basic utilities like heat and hot water for days/weeks at a time. I lived here and experienced no heat for two weeks and no hot water for a week. When we had no heat, they gave us shitty $20 Home Depot space heaters that didn't even help. Calls to 311 don't do anything and the landlord knows this, so they are in absolutely no rush to fix anything. They are too cheap to hire a porter on weekends and holidays so trash piles up during those times and stinks up the entire building. I recall one long weekend when the trash was literally coming up the basement stairs because there was so much of it. The front door of the building had a broken lock for a week and could be opened by anyone. Totally safe. Management took their sweet ass time getting around to fixing it. Anything that requires attention in the building, even important things are not treated with any kind of urgency. They simply don't care and they will get to it when they feel like it. The basement is filled with rats and mice because all of the trash sits down there. I was coming home one day and literally, a giant rat passed by me on the staircase and ran down to the basement. The basement stairs have mice and rat shit all over it. Management doesn't give a shit, pun intended. As far as I know, I only had a mouse in my apartment once towards the end of my time here. I killed it with a trap myself and hired my own exterminator because I know management wouldn't pay for an exterminator to do the right job (patch holes with the correct materials). I had several cockroaches skittering about over the course of my 3 years. They have an "exterminator" visit the building once a month but he is pretty useless. Given how filthy the building is overall, I am surprised more critters did not enter my apartment. No matter how well you clean, you will get mice and roaches because they do not take the proper actions against pests in the basement, etc. The people working in the management office ignore most emails and when you call the office, someone picks up maybe 1 out of every 10 times you call. Do not ask for anything and don't expect anything from them. You will get nowhere. Management is based in Westchester and does not visit the buildings. New York State Law says landlords must return security deposits within 14 days. Musano and Liberty Mgmt don't care and won't return your security deposit unless you threaten and take legal action. The law doesn't mean anything to them, clearly. They're hoping you won't fight and they can hold onto your money. Rent Manhattan (also owned by Musano) sucks too and charges you bullshit fees, ballooning the payment you need in order to rent in the first place. Stay far far away from this management, this landlord and his shithole buildings. Given how open the market is right now, you do not need to rent a cheap apartment from them out of desperation. You can and will find something better. Trust me.

We rent a condo every year on 30a. It was a cold February 2025 and we simply requested 3 blankets…read morefor our 3 bedroom condo. You'd think we asked for the world. After 4 cold nights and numerous phone calls we finally had our blankets delivered. The WiFi in the condo never worked. We ended up buying our own router and having it installed on our own. This management company is horribly unresponsive and rude.

These people are an awful company. They are greedy and lazy. Grifters and grab money for lobby keys…read moreand maintenance. Don't get a coop apartment in their buildings.

They provide our coop with prompt, professional and outstanding support on a continuous basis.read more

Stay Away! A property is better off managing themselves. There should be an option to leave no…read morestars. The property managers there do not answer calls or emails. They refuse to go their assigned properties if they are in "questionable" neighborhoods. There is zero communication and zero accountability. Upper management does nothing to discipline them. Properties are leaving in droves. New billing system is a nightmare. Implementation was poorly planned. Residents are upset with restrictions on paying their bills. Billing calls go unanswered as do emails. Properties have no money to pay bills and it's because residents can't pay their bills and Garthchester doesn't collect on bad debtors. Agenda driven group in control of things, if they don't like you you're out or at least ostracized. Terrible culture, no professionalism. They talk a good game but it is all lip service. Stay away.

I rent a parking location in Yonkers, NY and someone stole all 4 wheel and rim. There is a camera…read morein the drive up area and the super can't give me access to the camera until the property manager approves. It has been a week and I left multiple voicemails and no one has gotten back to me. So they are pretty much letting the thieves get away with over $3200+ worth of stolen items.

Jonathan was the best…read more Prior to meeting with Harborview i had the WORST experience at a neighboring realtor who tried to scam me out of my money. Jonathan helped in so many ways. Jonathan was super patient and bent over backwards to make everything happen. I am super happy to have trusted in another company and found Jonathan. I love me place and cant thank them enough!!!!

Harborview Rental Properties will email you when the rent is due. Most properties are in ghetto…read moreneighborhoods and environments and are embarrasingly maintained by a semi professional maintenance crew. The landlords seem to allow subleasing and trespassing on their properties they pick and choose when to answer their phones, they pick and choose what to maintain on the property to keep extra money in their pockets instead of making the lease holder happy. They will only care about the ridiculous rent money and won't take necessary precautions to upgrade their rent locations and homes. The landlord is a young immature guy who only deals with things if he feels they need to be dealt with, having no concern for urgent situations and moving on his own accord to fit description of slum Lord trying to make money off of other people's pockets. Whoopty Doo Go Figure Here We Go Again With Things Like This.

I have lived in a building managed by Blue Woods for 27 years and have found them to be incredibly…read morediligent. I don't understand these other reviews, except to say that they must be by people who have a grudge. How can someone who lives in Florida live in building NYC? I looked up 710 and it is a co-op, so the management company is not who you would call. You would talk to the super first. They have always been very responsive to calls. The daily management of a building is left the supers of all co-ops, with the co-op boards making guided decisions about the funds and making other decisions about facilities. Maintenance of most buildings is usually managed buy the superintendents, and ours have always been great. We have had mostly incremental assessments over the time I have lived in the building, with the big ones to be expected of a pre-war building. A friend who is a real estate broker said that he is relieved when a building is managed by Blue Woods because he knows that the sale will go smoothly. While I have mostly dealt with the founder, our building is managed by Steve Wilson, and remains one of the best managed buildings in the neighborhood.

Disappointing really... While they are nice generally nice guys, they do a poor job demonstrating…read moreany type of competence towards managing a building. During the 3 years that BW managed my building - they took very little responsibility for the upkeep of the bldg (daily and preventative maintenance), mismanaged our funds, and had no concept of how to leverage basic technology (i.e. email management)... I would not recommend them!!

I am updating my original review after gaining additional perspective. While I was not fully…read moresatisfied with Stillman at the time, my co-op has since transitioned to Blue Woods--and the comparison has been eye-opening. Although Stillman occasionally required follow-up and proactive communication on my end, their agents appeared to be managing a substantial workload, and obtaining multiple quotes for contractors felt like standard practice in the world of property management. In hindsight, these issues seem typical rather than negligent. Stillman was my first experience with a managing company, and I now believe my initial judgment may have been overly harsh. Our new management company has demonstrated behavior that was not only unprofessional, but retaliatory after I shared an honest review of their services. That experience has given me a newfound appreciation for Stillman. Count your blessings if they are your managing agent

The one star is beyond generous…read more My husband and I applied for an apartment through Stillman, submitting all required financials. Multiple professionals--including our mortgage broker, financial advisor, and real estate agent--confirmed we were fully qualified to purchase. From the start, the process was a nightmare. After submitting our application on July 2nd (which took hours of careful preparation), we heard nothing from Dawn Martin for nearly a month. When we followed up, she falsely claimed she had responded earlier--a claim that no one on our email chain ever received. This delay caused unnecessary stress for us and the sellers. Throughout, we remained respectful and cooperative, despite her mistakes. When the co-op board began questioning our finances, we provided everything asked of us, all of which checked out. Later, we disclosed that both my husband and I have legitimate psychiatric service animals, supported by official documentation from our doctors. Shortly afterward, we were abruptly rejected without even being granted an interview--under the vague excuse of "financial reasons." It was clear to us and to every professional involved that this was not about finances at all. It was about discriminating against us because of our service animals, which is a violation of the ADA. To cover themselves, they hid behind a false financial pretext. In the end, Stillman took $3,000 from us, strung us along for over three months, wasted our time while we're preparing to welcome a baby, and deprived the seller of a fair and willing buyer. This process was corrupt, dishonest, and discriminatory. I strongly urge anyone considering working with Stillman to think twice.

I live in one of the condos they're managing and I must say that they are doing a great job. Our…read moremaintenance and other requests are looked into promptly and everything is convenient for us. Definitely highly recommended for both landlords and tenants. I hope landlords and building owners hire a property management company as effective as them.

From the owner: McGrath Management LLC specializes in property management, commercial management, residential…read moremanagement, property maintenance, real estate brokerage, municipal planning, new project development, financial reporting & consulting, and receivership services.

I have never posted a negative review before on any business but this situation warrants it…read more If I could give Gramatan Management zero stars, I would. They are unresponsive, unprofessional, and lack accountability. We haven't had a proper board meeting since 2023, and before that, 2019. Requests for meetings, communication, and financial statements are ignored or delayed. Most concerning is their interference in board elections. After we were forced to petition for a board meeting, management began knocking on doors, making calls, bad-mouthing candidates, and pressuring shareholders to sign proxies for a silent board that does not challenge or hold them accountable. Under Chris Chiappa (President) and Glenn Capobianco (Vice President), this management has shown they are not fit for this level of management. Prospective co-op buildings and shareholders should be aware.

very unprofessional. NO HEAT. NO RESPONSE WHEN THERE IS A PROBLEM. collecting extra in the…read moremaintenance for oil bill still no heat. shut off hot water to repair the boiler for two days straight still NO HEAT. THE WORST EVER MANAGEMENT. They are suppose to be of help to the people but they are not. What are they doing Over there? OH absolutely NOTHING.HORRIBLE.