Little lasagna was extremely good with an excellent mix of cheese meat pasta and sauce. This Italian salad dressing is amazing it tastes like it was homemade with flavor that compliments everything. We even put the dressing on the lasagna to kick it up a notch. The service was phenomenal. Even though there was a not a seat available in the entire restaurant both inside and out, the wait staff took care of our table and we didn't miss a thing. This is a very casual Italian restaurant so the ambiance is casual Texas country rural with a little bit of Italian decoration. read more

Catalano Pizzeria - Entrance from main Street sidewalk - Pizza Near Me - Cibolo, Texas

See all

The place is a bit outdated; there is a lot of seating, including a private area in the back. The service was good, even though the server was not the friendliest. The Pizza was good, but it was not great. (6 out of 10) We came to celebrate a friend's birthday; if not, I would probably never return. Even though I recommended it in my first review, we did not come back until today. read more

See all

Nothing like finding a little gem with an at home feeling to it. This was our first time at Catalano's Pizzeria. The food was amazing, and the best part is that the food is made to order, you can't get any fresher than that! I got the spinach and mushrooms tortellini with Alfredo sauce. My husband got the ravi/mani Friday special, with focaccia bread and a salad. Both were amazing and the portions were big. Our server was awesome and made us feel at home. read more

See all

I went to the Tri-Co midday mindset at Catalano's in Cibolo last week.It was my first time there and it exceeded my expectations! The food was fresh, delicious, and large portions. It was fast, and the service was top notch. I'm bringing my family back so that they can enjoy my new find! read more

Focaccia worth fighting for, this place being on my regular route to HEB is such a temptation lol. It's a cozy little spot on Main Street, a couple places for street parking and a large lot right across the way, easy to stroll in and grab a table. They have a daily special that runs for I think $12.99ish, salad, whatever their pasta of the day is, and a huge slice of focaccia, you just can't go wrong. Feels homey, staff is super friendly, and service is great. Their baked ziti and lasagna have been a couple of my faves from those specials. read more

Catalano Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Cibolo, Texas

On this day a sudden craving for Italian cuisine and it just so happens that I was near Cibolo, and my craving was quenched with Catalano Pizzeria. Upon arriving you notice that the restaurant is in a quaint little building, but entering you see a cozy room, with a view of the fish tank, but that view is deceiving because they offer a second area that can entertain a large party and also when the weather is comfortable there is seating in the patio area. But before continuing I must mention that you are treated kindly by the personnel inside upon entering. But as always the most important aspect of a restaurant is the food, this place will not disappoint. Viewing the menu you can see a good selection of dishes from appetizers, desserts and main courses. To start my experience, I chose "Catalanos Italian Bread Bites" they are absolutely amazing little bread bites and they are accompanied by a great tasting sauce. My main dish was an absolutely delicious "Stromboli" l, the preparation and delivery were top notch. The variety of meats and the sauce gave this dish a unique flavor. Catalanos is an excellent choice, I highly recommend this place. read more

See all

There pizza is so good I highly recommend the peanutbutter and jelly pizza especially there stuffed pizza it's like a hotpocked it's so good

We visited Catalano in Cibolo for a date night and--rookie mistake--we ordered pasta dishes without realizing this place is known for its pizza. While the pasta wasn't bad, it was just okay. But as we were leaving, we saw the pizzas coming out and instantly had order regret. They looked absolutely incredible! What really stood out, though, was the amazing service and clean, welcoming environment. You can truly feel the love the owner has for this place--he was walking around talking to guests, making everyone feel at home. It made the whole experience feel personal and warm. The Italian bread bites were our favorite part of the meal--soft, flavorful, and so good. We will definitely be back--and next time, we're going all in on the pizza. Such a great spot for a relaxed, local date night! read more

The pasta was a huge disappointment--tasted like boxed noodles with jarred sauce. If you're looking for an authentic Italian experience, this isn't it. The pizza, calzone, and appetizers were about what you'd expect, but skip the pasta. There's clearly no real chef in the kitchen. "Italian food"? More like just pizza. read more

Today is Pi Day so I decided to try some local pizza while out running around. I was in Cibolo at an appointment and I looked for pizza near me. This place was right up the street. I have passed it a hundred times and never knew it was there. It is easy to overlook the restaurant. I walked in and was greeted before I could even close the door. This is a very homely restaurant, with no frill or expensive decor. However, it was welcoming and comfortable. I sat down and the cheerful waiter brought me a menu and took my drink order. Since this was my first time, I asked for a few minutes. The customer at the table in front of me turned around and let me know that also have daily specials on the chalkboard. That was so nice of her, you can tell she was a regular. They have a lot of regulars who frequent the spot. The napkin holder has a kid's picture on it, so homey. That's a good sign. I opted for a small order of hot wings and a personal Catalano specialty pizza. The wings looked like regular hot wings but for some reason they were sooo good. I don't know what they did but I tore them up. Then the pizza arrived. This couldn't have been a personal-size pizza. It was definitely bigger than that but I am not complaining. Just letting you know so you can be prepared. It was full of toppings. The only issue I had with the pizza was that the bell peppers needed to be cut smaller. They were in big pieces so I had to cut them so they would stay on the pizza. All the ingredients were fresh. The pizza sauce needed a little salt but I just sprinkled a little on my pizza slices. The crust was thin, crispy, and delicious. I love a crunchy crust. Overall I enjoyed my food and the wonderful service. This place has been around for over 20 years and I can see why the locals support it. read more

See all

The stuffed pizza was stupendous, the service was horrendous. The service was that poor and I just had carry out. FYI the menu price on Yelp is off by 50% or more. The person laughed at me then said the price listed must be 10 years old or more and they had no idea. I can't buy that in this day and age. No manager ever came out to say anything about, as I was handed my food in the front someone from the kitchen yelled that they made it a large instead of a medium. Not helpful since I was eating alone, and of no consolation because the pizza was made well before it was ever known to have any pricing discrepancy. Also 22 minutes after I placed my order someone called me back to "doubled check" that it was a medium. Great if you give everyone oversized pizza, but don't jack up your own order and try to turn it into a win once there is an issue. I paid, I tipped 20%. But was fleeced read more

Not great. Wouldn't go back. Pizza was hard. Order wasn't even started when we arrived for pickup time.

Small restaurant with big flavor. The hospitality and generosity the staff provided was phenomenal. There stuffed pizza fulfilled my craving and the crust was so fresh and crispy, you could eat that by itself and be happy. My wife raved about the flavor of their chicken alfredo fettuccini. Our party enjoyed other sides like there bread bites, mozzarella sticks and more. We left trying to determine which item we loved the most. We all agreed that Taylor, our server, was one of the best servers we have had. She was very friendly and personable. She wanted to make sure our first time there was a success and it was. Highly recommend Catalano's and ask for Taylor if she is available read more

See all

I absolutely love Catalano's and I have since I was kid. Their calzone is amazing and huge. The service is standard and the building is old but clean. It's a great family place. read more

Catalano Pizzeria - Garlic Catalanos Italian Bread Bites - Pizza Near Me - Cibolo, Texas

Their food is amazing, not to mention all the servers are so friendly and checked on us all the time.

UM WOW??? First off, what an unassuming building. Like so unassuming that me and my fiancé could not find the front door at first. HA. We chose Catalano's for this week's date night because we were both craving some cheesy carby deliciousness. The mozzarella sticks? *chef's kiss* They had just the right amount of breading to cheese while also having tons of flavor. In addition, the marinara sauce served with the mozz was equally flavorful. Quite possibly the best mozzarella sticks I've had in a looooooooooong time. My fiancé got a heaping portion of the grilled chicken marinara. He never has leftovers and took home half of his food - that's how I know he got a BIG serving. At first, I thought getting chicken on top of spaghetti was a boring choice, however, I had a bite of his chicken with that scrumptious red sauce and changed my mind. I had a spinach calzone and oh my goodness I never thought I would see the day that I was served a dish I would describe as having 'too much cheese.' That being said, it was magnificent. 10/10 would devour again. Shoutout to Joey for taking great care of us and even giving me a fresh batch of marinara to take home with my leftovers (which were excellent the second time around after just a few minutes in the air fryer). We absolutely will be back soon... especially since we have a couple of free bread tokens to use ;) read more

We decided to try this place because it looked pretty good. Came here and was not disappointed. I think it was decently priced and very delicious. We got the following and liked everything (except the small hot wings weren't good). Mani/Ravi combo Italian bread bites Spinach lasagna Eggplant Parmesan Small hot wings with veal parm I would recommend. Give you the small town feels read more

All dishes are made to order and pasta is made in house daily. Great atmosphere and wonderful service. Family owned! Absolute gem in Cíbolo, Tx. read more

Was craving pizza but didn't want to get any from the main chain pizzas and searched for pizza places near me and decided to give Catalano Pizzeria a try. Order the Meat Galore (pic). I'm glad I did. Pizza was nice and hot when I got home. I could really taste all the different meats and flavors. The crust was soft and eatable, not as hard or crunchy as others. Different but I liked it! I will definitely eat here again and try some of the other dishes and the all you can eat pizza on Wednesdays and new stuff on other days. There is to go orders and dine in option. Must wear a mask to enter the facility. Facility was clean and noticed proper distancing at the tables. Staff were friendly, professional, and answered a few of my questions about their pizza and place. I have reviewed a few pizza places around here and this one has a different soft and delicious crust. Definitely want to try their stuff crush in the near future. No major complaint except their were two slices that did not have ham on them but other than that, price is reasonable compare to pizza size and toppings with other pizza places in town. read more

Catalano Pizzeria - Specials - Pizza Near Me - Cibolo, Texas

See all

Baked Zita special was fabulous! Overall, the service, food quality & ambience was perfect!

If you're in Cibolo, and notice a wonderful aroma of Italian cooking, it's not your imagination, it's Catalano's. This is a Family owned restaurant with a wide menu selection of all your favorite Italian meals. Come hungry, because portions are large. There is dining areas in the front and rear. It's very Family friendly however, not pet friendly. The only reason I give Catalano's 4-Stars is because no alcohol is served, only soft drinks, Lemonade, Iced Tea and water. Catalano's is a great value. Bon Apitete. read more

The atmosphere gives you the feel that you are in an old traditional nj diner. The food was super hot and came out very quickly after ordering. You could taste the fresh herbs in the sauce. The service was extremely fast and friendly. Great little hidden gem read more

I'm a longtime customer of this Pizzeria. My family and I have tried almost everything on the menu, it has changed since their opening 22 years ago, although the menu has changed, the taste of food is still as delicious as ever. The portions are large enough for 2 people! Catalano's is a family owned and run Restaurant, and they pride themselves on the service rendered. The food is made fresh for you, nothing frozen, nothing microwaved. You can't beat it! The Restaurant isn't large by any means, and you have short wait for a table to be cleared and cleaned. The prices for the meals is inexpensive in relation to the food, service and ambiance. read more

Great food ... great service Great small business that delivers better than the larger chains. Worth the trip. read more

A true gem. I can't rave enough about the lasagna, toasted ravioli pasta, eggplant parmesan and the pizza, I mean even the pasta salad is delicious. I've honestly forgotten all about The Olive Garden since moving to Cibolo. Catalono's is for sure a staple in our community and it adds charm to our downtown. The atmosphere is comfortable and family friendly. My girls just love seeing the fish and the turtles throughout and the owner and staff are welcoming and kind. I'd for sure recommend. read more

We ordered two large pizzas for my brothers birthday and the slices are huge. There was 7 people eating and that was more than enough. So keep that in mind. We thought the pizzas would be small so we ordered more. Lol! The crust was nice and crispy and the meat lovers and supreme was the best! If you are in the area and are deciding between a regular chain restaurant or them. I'd definitely say order here. We did order on a Saturday so the wait time was 45 minutes. Hope this helps! read more

Awesome menu and family friendly. Service is great and homemade by family that owns the business.

Service bad , takes over 20min to prefer staff more interested in their phones .. Not worth the wait read more

The pizza is always hot. The sauce is delicious and the dough does taste of sugar. This almost reminds me of my years living in Italy years ago..... read more

The price was very reasonable if you could handle the taste. We ordered spaghetti and meatballs with red sauce. The taste of the sauce was like something I've never tasted before, couldn't figure it out. Meatballs were so mushy that the spaghetti flatten the meat. It was just all kinda strange never experienced anything like it. read more

When I called in a take out order, they said my pizza would be ready in about 25-35 minutes. I waited 20 minutes before leaving my house, because it takes 15 minutes to get there. So my thinking was, it will be ready when I get there, right? WRONG! I had to wait an additional 20 minutes to get my pizza! Why?!?! read more

A really cheap, really good, and awesome staff? What more could you want for lunch? We drove well out of our usual haunts to Catalano for lunch. One of my co-workers lives near it and loved it. What the heck, ten of us went for a road trip and this place absorbed us like it was nothing. We sat in two tables though. For lunch they have an awesome pizza special. Tons of different large pizzas sliced narrow was perfect for me. The deal included iced-tea. I liked the narrow slices because then I could try a lot of different ones without thinking I was pigging out. But I did! I really liked the sauce and the crust of all of them. I had Hawaiian (ham & pineapple), pepperoni, sausage & pepperoni, supreme, cinnamon dessert pizza. Everyone raved about the peanut butter & jelly pizza but I missed out on that. I was too full. Our waitress rocked. Very fast, very efficient and on top of the fluid refills. The cook must be the owner because he too was super engaged. This was just a well run family enterprise that seems to have been around since Cibolo became an independent town (wiki it). read more

Catalano Pizzeria - Great lunch pizza: supreme (bottom), pepperoni, cinnamon dessert, sausage & pepperoni (upper right) - Pizza Near Me - Cibolo, Texas

Food is always very tasty and hot. Portions are large. Service is Exceptional!!! Sarah is the best. We eat there several times a month. We love their Pizza. Their daily specials are are also very good and very filling.I highly recommend trying this spot. read more

This place has gone down the drain. We ordered veal Parmesan and chicken Alfredo. We waited one hour for our food and when it arrived the Spagetti was Ice cold. They poured marinara sauce over it to make it look like it was hot. They didn't apologize or try to resolve the issue. I would not recommend this place to anyone. Don't care how busy you are. Take care of your customers. The owner said it was bullshit slammed the food in the trash can when when confronted was argumentative. I don't know what happened to this place but it isn't what it used to be and we will not return. read more

See all

There is a feeling of family from the knowledgeable staff. The food is excellent especially for the price. The pizza, spaghetti & meat sauce, and shrimp fettuccine are outstanding. Food isn't waiting under warmers but it's worth the short wait. Great beer selection but a better wine list would be a plus. read more

What a delicious Pizza! Ordered a Margarita Pizza and a salad for 2. It was a delicious cheesy Pizza. We drove home a 24 minute drive and pizza was hot when we got home. We look forward to our next visit. It was very tasty pizza. Inside the small restraunt, it had an old feel, with a beautiful fish tank. The staff were very friendly. Next time we may dine in. read more

I always enjoy the food. Service always excellent. Today not so much. My spaghetti was great but my sister's spaghetti was swimming in water. Very unappetizing. Her meal was discounted and I'm glad. Hope this was once and only. Like I said, I always enjoy the food, so I will try again. read more

Most definitely will come back! It will be hard to not order the Eggplant Parmesan again, but I really want to try other dishes. Order the eggplant Parmesan. read more

From the outside, this place is very unassuming. It's in a very old building. When we got out of the car, we smelled something good cooking. The staff was super friendly and very attentive. There seemed to be a lot of regular diners, as many people knew the waitresses by name. They have a great menu with daily lunch specials. Today was beef or spinach lasagna. I had one, my gf had the other. It included tea, a salad, fresh made foccacia bread, and a hearty portion of lasagna. Everything was delicious. We were stuffed, and had food to take home. I look forward to returning on other days to try some of the other lunch specials as well as the pizza, which looked amazing. read more

Got my large pizza wrong on a to go order. Wouldn't refund or remake the Pizza. Yes, you read that correctly...Only gave me an option for a future credit or to make me a small replacement pizza. What a joke of a business. read more