Came in to town late Friday night this place and the other pizza shop 2 doors down were the only…read morethings open past 9. My fiance got the heart attack burger which he said 4 slices of bread was to much but otherwise good he added a fried egg to it, I just got the cheese curds which were yummy I always love cheese curds when I'm visiting up north! And then the maple garlic knots were our pleasant surprise we actually really enjoyed them. I would come back! They have a cute outside area that you can bring your dogs to.

Fast service and the place was PACKED on a Saturday afternoon!…read more I had the wings with buffalo and they were the best I've had since being back in VT. Wife had the Vermonter and it was great but a little sweet for me! The boom boom fries were RIDICULOUSLY good, they had a beautiful spicy cheese that was hard to beat! I'd go back just for the boom boom fries alone! Atmosphere was great, clean and polite staff! I couldn't ask for a better spot to go! I can't wait to come back to try the other items on the menu! Waitress was attentive and refilled glasses promptly without asking!

So I think they're great... I grew up in the area and it was always a choice between this place and…read morethe Pizza Deli. I will choose Paul's 4 out of 5 times over the Pizza Deli because of 1) the price and 2) the quality of cooking is far superior. There's always the right amount of cheese; never too much, always just perfect. You can't beat the price here.. seriously!! around $24 for 2 large 3 topping pizzas!!! THAT'S INSANELY AWESOME!! Their pie is a little thicker, and to some like myself who like thin pizza, it's a little off putting, but I assure you the quality and the taste makes up for the type. I go here at least once a week because it's that good.... "2 large hawaiians plus black olives".... To top it off the service is always super nice, the people there are always friendly, and when I show up early they bring my pizza out to the truck. What a nice staff! I think John F. in an earlier review wrote something about right-wing literature being in the deli. Quite honestly does what people read in a pizza joint matter to the quality of pie? I notice old pics of people's hunting excursions and news clippings from local youth league sports. Is that so wrong or off putting? I don't think so.. it reflects the community which I think is what a person looks for in a local pizza joint, and like I said, I'll take Paul's Family Pizza over The Castleton Pizza Deli ANY DAY!

Most important part of the pizza - taste of the sauce. Sauce had the right flavor, nice toppings,…read moreright amount of cheese. Coming from NJ it's hard to get pizza in VT that's similar, but this seems to be the closest (crust still a little thicker than used to but tastes good). If you like NY/NJ pies, you'll enjoy this. It's the only pizza place around we've been back to more than once. The new owners have really stepped up the pizza.

Scoring System: 0-3 Food Quality = 3…read more0-3 Service = 3 0-3 Ambience = Pizza Place 0-3 Cleanliness = 3 0-3 Likelihood I'll Return = 3 Total divided by 3 = Star rating 12/3 =4 Nice fresh pizza made with care. Our new favorite VT pizza place

If ya gotta have a pie and can't make it to Rutland, it's decent in a pinch. They run skinny on…read morethe toppings, and the pies are generally pretty lightweight, but they are fast to make em.

Scrumptious and beautifully crafted food. Very nice staff and owners are a huge part of it. They…read moreaccommodate to your allergies with a smile.

It was a bit out of the way for us but well worth the drive. The food was top notch. Donna was…read moresupper nice and helpful as our server. There were a lot of specials that it made it difficult to choose what to get. I got a burger that was perfect! My DH got a salad I can't remember which one. The desserts were SO good! We shared the ooey gooey maple pie and strawberry cheesecake.

Well deserved an updated review! The precipitous decline of this joint is nearly complete! $35…read morepie! Yep! Toppings continue to shrink faster than melting snow in May! And on top of having customers pay merchant fee on credit cards! News flash Christo's it's a called a merchant fee, because the merchant pays it! It the price for accepting credit cards and get cash deposited into you acct the next day and not have a cash headache. This place used to be something back in the day! But it's clear the family is exhausted and no longer committed to being the dining establishment it once was! At this rate a PapaJohns franchise might be the best out!

Ok. So we couldn't decide where to eat while in Manchester, VT…read more Beautiful little town! Beautiful little downtown area. Many restaurants and shops to check out. I know Manchester is no "best kept secret" but it kinda feels that way. Very nice place. Bougiiiiiiie! BOUGIE! We love Bougie haha! I saw a pink Bentley that absolutely made me day lol. As mentioned, tons of shops and restaurants. However, Manchester SHUTS. DOWWWN! At like 6! Winter probably even earlier. I mean, shuts dowwwn! There are like 3 places open past that time. Christos, the avocado restaurant, and the grocery store. Everything else...if you get into town late and need a place to eat...the avocado place and Christos is it...that I saw at least. Ok so we didn't actually eat here. Couldn't figure out what I wanted. Place is EXPENSIVE! Pizza that expensive is ... absolutely wild to me. I couldn't believe it. My brother had eaten here in the past and liked it. I am picky af when it comes to eating. I couldn't see myself spending this much on pizza lol. I told him...we can just eat here bc I'm tired of looking. We went to the avocado place instead tho. I'm not trying to deter anyone from going here. You're gonna do regardless of what reviews say...especially since they're open till like 9..while every other place...is not. Staff was ok. Not the friendliest. The other place we went to...staff was incredible. So I guess my review is just to give a heads up to everyone that this place is pricey. Like I said, my brother ate there before and liked it. I know the food is amazing, but again, spending what they charge for..:pizza! Hard pass. Restaurant itself is nice. Nicely laid out. Dimly lit. Very clean. Just looks like a super nice pizza place haha. I guess that's it. Was this review pointless? Maybe to some. For others, letting yall know it's an experience pizza joint...I think from that stand point it's not a pointless review. Staff is all young. We all know this generation, even tho so many work retail (for some reason) and hate talking to anyone other than their friends and coworkers. The staff here...you will experience this generation and the "no eye contact" generation and the "yeah?" When they ask if they can help. "Yeah" is "welcome in, wha can I get you" So the management here can take that into consideration especially for being a nice place that has the prices they do. Thanks for reading, JesúsYelperChristo's! Cheers

Great pizza! Pickup times are pretty quick and the interior is cozy. Staff is kind and…read moreaccommodating!

Got the 18" Uncle Bruno for take out. It was SO GOOD. Easy ordering, quick pick up. What more can…read moreyou ask for?

I love the meatball pizza here. It's unbelievable with the garlic knot crust…read more Also, the bathrooms here are always impeccable, so clean.

Best pizza in rutvegas. Great variety. Friendly staff. 85 character requirement................read more

I recently visited The Railyard Taproom & Restaurant for a date, and it was a wonderful experience…read more The atmosphere was welcoming and comfortable, making it a great place to relax and enjoy good company. The food tasted amazing and was clearly prepared with care and quality ingredients. Our waitress, Keara, was one of the best -- very friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed throughout our visit. She truly made the experience even better. I would definitely recommend The Railyard to anyone looking for great food, great service, and a nice place to spend time with someone special.

The service and food were overall great!…read more We got: -Classic Conductor w/ fries (sub veggie burger) -Great meal! Fries were awesome!! -Freight Train w/ added mushrooms + fries (sub veggie burger) -Just the kick I needed! LOVED the added mushrooms! The fries were awesome!! -Kids spaghetti w/ marinara + garlic bread -Really good pasta!!! Garlic bread was okay- it was a bit bland. Ambiance was great!! We'd love to come back and check out the taproom next visit!! We would recommend visiting The RailYard if you're in the area!

I understand prices have to go up but $14 for a personal cheese pizza is ridiculous....I cannot…read moreafford these prices anymore

Love this place! Cool vintage decor.. Stopped in for pizzas and it was so busy we got the last…read morepizza order. Out of dough. Pizza was great. Cold craft beers while you wait. The staff was super friendly and went out of the way to make the grandkids happy. I will be back next time I'm visiting Vermont.