Cancel
Open app
Search
Sign Up
Log In
Nearby
Bookmarks
Start a Project
Add a Business on Yelp
It's easier on the Yelp app
Continue
Stay on browser
Add Review
Call
Directions
Website
Add Photo
Health Information
View Health Score
More like Casey's
Breakfast & Brunch
Donuts
Breakfast
Delivery
Start your review...
Get app
3 years ago
It is a typical Casey's upgraded/replaced a outlet years ago. The pizzas are good. The service good.
106 N Front St
Montezuma, IA 50171
(641) 255-0087
Call Now
Visit Website
https://www.caseys.com
Full menu
Hours
What time does Casey's open?
Casey's is open 24 hours on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.
What time does Casey's close?
Mon-Sun Open 24 hours
Does Casey's take credit cards?
Yes, Casey's takes credit cards.
Does Casey's have catering options?
No, Casey's does not have catering options.
Does Casey's serve alcohol?
Yes, Casey's serves alcohol.
Does Casey's have outdoor seating?
No, Casey's does not have outdoor seating options.
Does Casey's have parking?
Yes, Casey's has parking options.
Does Casey's have free WiFi?
Yes, Casey's has free WiFi.
More Info
Health Score
Get access to customer & competitor insights.
First time coming here, wanted a place to grab some gas, food and drinks for my trip back to…read moreIllinois. You either have this gas station or the one across the street. I'm not picky but this place is your typical gas station. They got fair deals on items, great food options. Staff here is friendly and way less crowded too.
Many cases of bad rude encounters with manager there prices have got high on food yet quality has…read morewent down hill just cross the street to caseys your better off
See all
I love Pagliai's pizza. The beef, mushroom, and red onion pizza is my favorite and their homemade…read moreliquid gold ranch is exceptional. I would recommend this pizza place to anyone passing through Grinnell, Iowa.
We'd heard of this pizza spot since we arrived to Grinnell, so naturally we had to try it…read more Immediately greeted as we walked in the door and loved that we could see all the chefs in the kitchen right then and there. It was busy but not so much that we didn't get sat right away. Our server was also busy so someone else took our drink order - and then gave us menus. We ended up ordering the meatballs, a salad, and a classic pie, and walked out also with a cool vintage looking Pagliai's tee! The meatballs were large, came with two, and really flavorful. The sauce was classic tomato but not basic, you could taste the aromatics and that was so good. Basic salad but really delicious runny ranch to go with it, which I loved. I dipped the crust from my pizza in it and it was just so good! For the pie we split it in half - half with meats and the other half with special. The crust was thin and also seasoned nicely and couldn't say enough about how delicious the cheese was. It was so gooey and thick - it made the pizza so incredibly good. Besides our server taking us on due to the prior one being too busy, the vibes inside were chill and casual, music was good and the atmosphere was pleasant. Everyone behind the pizza counter had smiles and acknowledged you. Was a real delight. Everywhere in Grinnell folks rave about Pagliai's and we understand why. We'll definitely have to come back!
Pizza in the back is the Pesto Pepperoni
I definitely recommend this pizza. We thought it was very tasty - we got the Hawaiian, hand tossed,…read moreand it was delicious. They even have dairy free cheese for the dairy allergies. The only reason I had to take a star is that we cannot recommend dining in and want to give that heads up to fellow travelers. We were stopping through town on our way to see family and thought it would be easier to dine in with our toddler than taking it back to our air b n b. It was small but there were a handful of tables set up for dining in so we thought it would work ok. But when we came in and asked about dining in we were given a bugged-eyed look and they echoed, "dine in?!" But they said sure and pick a seat. It takes a bit to make me uncomfortable and doubt a person but this was not welcoming. We sat down and when our 2 year old wanted our menu, we asked for a second one and got an attitude from the same person again. At that point I threw in the towel. I can't enjoy my meal with someone questioning every single thing we did or said, especially with an unpredictable toddler. So we put in our order and left. My husband had to go back to get it. So just a fair warning to other families to be prepared for a possibly awkward dine-in experience. They also do not have high chairs - they do have booster seats but they do not buckle down. We for sure would order here again but would plan to carry-out only.
The pizza is amazing. My husband prefers xtra thin crust but once he tried the square pizza he…read moresold. The staff is friendly and the tables clean. Be sure you get the butter crust
Super Hawaiian Pizza (14" Large) hand tossed - so good!!
Menu pg 7
We stopped for lunch on a Friday. The lunch special was $10 - - a drink, 3 ounces of onion rings…read moreand a 5 inch pizza. We decided we would just order a bigger pizza to share. We got onion rings to start and they were good, as usual. I just think 30 seconds more in the fryer would make them a little crisper and tastier. Our Canadian bacon mushroom pizza was awesome! The crust was just right. The amount of sauce was just right. The waitress was friendly and took our order at our seats. Drinks were self serve. If you're wanting a good pizza, keep Giovanni's in mind
Amazing food and the manager, Regina, is the best! The owner…read moreis an Amazing Christian that does a lot for the Newton community. Thanks, Giovanni's!
Very cool vibes with a mixture of racing, baseball, neon signs, and old nostalgia signage…read morethroughout. The Hawaiian Pizza on the Regular Crust was deeeeelicious. The Pizza Fry was thin crust and comes with a marinara sauce for dipping. The Onion Rings were very good, I'd say more of the Onion string cut...came out with a ranch sauce....everything was hot, delicious, and homemade. Staff was friendly and accommodating and it seemed like we weren't the only newbies that were showing up tonight. We saw a post on Facebook about the Haverhill Social Club and figure a few others must have as well. Very good place...we'll be back to try the burgers and other pizzas as well!
Quick update! ! Pretty busy on a Friday night! We got lucky and a group had just left so we got a…read moretable. We visited for a while before ordering our food. We had the spaghetti special - - spaghetti meatballs, bread, and a salad and a small Reuben pizza. The Reuben pizza was very good. The spaghetti meal was as well. The salad is served on the same plate as the spaghetti so it doesn't come early.
Decor
More pictures of the pizza
Mules
The pizza here is amazing! Looking forward to sitting outside in the summer and having some more!…read moreHighly recommend!
Excellent woodfire pizza. Swift service. I had my high school graduation party today (May 15, 2016)…read morefrom 3:00 PM to 7:00 PM, and Stone Wall Pizza catered for the party. Recommend the Italian, Autumn Apple, Rancher, and Hawaiian pizzas. All of the guests (as well as the hosts, my family and I) were satisfied with the good food and swift, high-quality service. For this reason, I give this food truck business a rare 5-star rating. Final grade: 5/5 (100%)
Holy wow. This place was incredible. As first timers in Iowa, we weren't sure where to eat and what…read moreeven was available for a handful of vegetarians - but this place was IT and then some. We went on May 21st, and we were greeted by 2 men at 8:40 pm. They let us know the buffet was closing shortly but essentially implied "take as much as you can since we throw out everything at the end of the night anyways" so WE DID (as you can see from our plates. And we were FULL after a 10.5 hour drive, but then they brought out a custom made veggie pizza which we DEVOURED. An incredible experience for something we thought was a "mom & pop" shop for how nice the host was but happy to find out it's a chain that exists in our home state!
Great place in North Liberty, clean, good is always hot, tasty! No waiting, super service!read more
Chicken and pizza
For dessert, make sure you try Cactus Bread - warm cinnamon streusel with a swirl of icing.
Pizza Ranch's buffet offers a variety of pizzas. If you don't see your favorite, you can request it and they'll make it for you!
Between Iowa City and Des Moines leave I80 and drive into Grinell and dine at the Prarie Canary…read more Worth the 5 minutes. Vietnamese spring rolls made by Matayas (the owner? and our waiter) mother were delicious. Our simple fare was perfect after a long drive but there were more complete meals on the menu. Sunday with a homemade blondie and a flourish wrapped things up!
We celebrated my nephew's graduation at the Prairie Canary which seems to be The Restaurant in…read moreGrinnell. It was quite happening the night we were there, as I imagine a lot of people were celebrating graduations. We ordered the spinach artichoke dip, shrimp and brussel sprouts to start, and I ordered the steak frites for my entree. Everything was delicious, and we were all very pleased with our meals.
Speakeasy
Chicken DeBurgo with glazed carrots
Five Spice Salmon over Sweet Pepper Risotto
Fast efficient staff; good smells throughout the dining area. Duchess Pizza was easily shared…read morebetween two along with a sizable side salad.
Pizza is fantastic. Onion rings are small for $8.50 and pretty generic. Will be back for pizza.read more
Mediterranean Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Duchess Special Pizza 12" Medium
BEST of Montezuma, Iowa Things to Do near Casey's
BEST of Montezuma, Iowa Breakfast near Casey's
BEST of Montezuma, Iowa Coffee near Casey's
BEST of Montezuma, Iowa Restaurants near Casey's
BEST of Montezuma, Iowa Shopping near Casey's
BEST of Montezuma, Iowa Burgers near Casey's
BEST of Montezuma, Iowa Thrift Stores near Casey's
BEST of Montezuma, Iowa Sushi near Casey's
BEST of Montezuma, Iowa Ice Cream near Casey's
Restaurants in Montezuma, IA
Donuts in Montezuma, IA
Breakfast & Brunch in Montezuma, IA
Breakfast in Montezuma, IA
24 Hour Restaurant in Montezuma, IA
Restaurants Open Late in Montezuma, IA
Late Night Food in Montezuma, IA
Burgers in Montezuma, IA
Restaurants Open Now in Montezuma, IA
Takeout in Montezuma, IA
Dinner in Montezuma, IA
Ice Cream in Montezuma, IA
Lunch in Montezuma, IA
Bar and Grill in Montezuma, IA
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt in Montezuma, IA
Barbeque in Montezuma, IA
Pork Tenderloin in Montezuma, IA
Tacos in Montezuma, IA
Pizza Delivery in Montezuma, IA
Delivery in Montezuma, IA
Pizza Specials in Montezuma, IA
Sandwiches in Montezuma, IA
24 Hour Pizza Delivery in Montezuma, IA
Saturday Specials in Montezuma, IA
Bars
Best Fish Tacos Served in Montezuma, Iowa
Best Places for Margaritas in Montezuma, Iowa
Best Rooftop Restaurant Experiences in Montezuma, Iowa
Best Wood Fired Pizza Available in Montezuma, Iowa
Discover Authentic Italian in Montezuma, Iowa
Discover Coffee & Tea Options in Montezuma, Iowa
Discover Healthy Salads in Montezuma, Iowa
Discover Hip New Restaurants to Try in Montezuma, Iowa
Discover New American in Montezuma, Iowa for Great Dining
Discover the Best Sushi Spots in Montezuma, Iowa
Enjoy Authentic Mexican Cuisine in Montezuma, Iowa
Enjoy Delicious Food Trucks All Over Montezuma, Iowa
Enjoy Fast Food Favorites Across Montezuma, Iowa
Enjoy Prime Rib Specialties in Montezuma, Iowa
Enjoy a Family Restaurant Experience in Montezuma, Iowa
Explore American Restaurants in Montezuma, Iowa
Explore Restaurants With Private Rooms in Montezuma, Iowa
Explore the Best Food Options in Montezuma, Iowa
Find Delicious Desserts in Montezuma, Iowa Today
Find the Best Caesar Salad in Montezuma, Iowa
Find the Best Cafes in Montezuma, Iowa for Every Taste
Find the Best Delis to Try in Montezuma, Iowa
Have Fun Bowling in Montezuma, Iowa
Highly Rated Steakhouses Around Montezuma, Iowa
Order Fresh and Tasty Salad Options in Montezuma, Iowa
Order the Best Deep Dish Pizza in Montezuma, Iowa
Popular Things to Do in Montezuma, Iowa
Savor the Best Burrito Flavors in Montezuma, Iowa
Taste Authentic Mexican Food in Montezuma, Iowa
Taste the Finest Gelato Available in Montezuma, Iowa
Top Breakfast Sandwich Places in Montezuma, Iowa
Top Gluten Free Pizza Spots in Montezuma, Iowa
Top Mexican Restaurants to Try in Montezuma, Iowa
Top Rated Seafood Dishes in Montezuma, Iowa
Top Restaurants With Private Party Rooms in Montezuma, Iowa
Top-Rated Spaghetti Dishes to Try in Montezuma, Iowa
Try Pizza by the Slice Near Montezuma, Iowa
Visit Popular Coffee Shops in Montezuma, Iowa
Where to Get Breakfast Burrito in Montezuma, Iowa
Bakeries near Casey's
Mothers Day Brunch near Casey's
Things to do in Montezuma
Casey's General Store
Articles by date
Great pizza! Crust had a little bit of crisp and slightly chewy on the inside. Sauce was great…read more The pepperoni curled up on top just like it's supposed to. Highly recommend.
Great crust on the hand tossed with super sauce. Reasonably priced and really nice people. Quick…read morejaunt from Howell COE. Would be a nice stop if you're walking downtown.
love their sunday promotions. service, subs, so fast i…read moreactually did freak!!!!! not even sure how they make money off this
Freh food, friendly staff. fast service, fresh interior, good location. Love that jimmy johns ate…read morethere 3x in the last week.
Did you think I wouldn't notice you only put 7 meatballs instead of 8 on my meatball sub? I'm sorry…read moresubway treats it's franchise owners so poorly but you shouldn't skimp on sandwiches.
Go to the one near I-80!! They're great every time. This one…read morehas a bunch of mostly unsupervised kids working who just don't realize what they're doing wrong. They don't honor corporate coupons and deals but will blame the app or corporate when they get orders wrong. When you order for a certain time, they make your food early and let it get cold or stale. They'll substitute ingredients and bread without checking or letting you know. Just skip the hassle with a good one nearby!
The pizza was pretty good but the service was very bad. They only gave us 3 of our pizzas and when…read morewe asked for our last pizza they said. It must be in the oven. So he walked around for 3 minutes then finally realized it was just right behind him the whole time. Very clean restaurant. Overall it was pretty good since food over service and ambiance.
We're incredibly pleased at the service. Food was hot, presented clean, delivered ahead of…read moreschedule, and was exactly what we ordered. Economically priced and easy to order online. Beats the local competition easily.
Quick service and great people working there! Food was as I remembered Pizza Hut to be...YUM!read more
Great place! Had some confusion with my online order but the staff was super helpful and got me my…read morepizza! Awesome place highly recommend. Great customer service!!
Why would anyone review a Culver's one might ask. You have been to one, been to all. Well not only…read moreis this brand the best of the best of the "Fast" food genre in our part of the wothis particular store is so well run it must be called out. Great job, and in a country that has found itself in an embarrassingly bad place, making safely served fast food important to a community this store just rocks it. Very Impressive!
foods amazing but the lady working the drive thru was so rude! my boyfriend has and english accent…read moreand she corrected his pronunciation and made him repeat his order a ridiculous amount of times. I mean i understand different accents can be difficult to understand but his really isn't and she could've had better customer service is all i'm saying.
They are doing pretty good in their first few weeks. Looks like the opening crew from corporate is…read morestill around and there was a lot of training going on while I was there. They had that line moving pretty well! I am always extremely disappointed when I ask for extra pickles and what I get doesn't even cover the bun. Chick-fil-A thinks extra pickles means 4 slices, because that doubles the two they normally put on. Long ago, I worked at Chick-fil-A for a few years. Not that crazy much has changed and thats a good thing. Nice, polite staff. Clean areas. Attention to detail. Remarkably fast service for the amount of people there. Really enjoyed it over all!
People wait in lines for this? Average chicken served with a…read moresmile. But the hype? That is crazy, and this is not good food.