Pizzas on the buffet table were unlabeled, no idea what they were. The ones I tried were thin & the…read morecrust was tough. They don't take credit cards. The cinnamon rolls were good.

This pizza is hard to beat! I really can't think of a better-tasting pizza anywhere that I've…read morevisited. It's unique. Made with the best ingredients-the sauce & so much cheese. They have a wide variety of pizzas, great salad bar, & the homemade cinnamon & caramel rolls are to die for. The owners are very nice & welcoming-staff is friendly. You MUST try it. They have never disappointed! My friends always want to eat here-everyone is obsessed with it. It's famous, or should be!

Service was great, but the place was basically empty except for a handful of college kids playing…read morepool and drinking. The wife and I are in town to attend an event at the University of Iowa and we just needed a place to grab a quick dinner on the way back to the hotel after a long day of traveling. We sat at the bar, and as mentioned, the bartender was friendly and attentive. We ordered cheddar bacon fries as an appetizer and a small thin crust Lola Pizza - which had spinach, garlic, red onions and pepperoncini peppers. The cheddar bacon fries probably sat in the window because they were delivered with the pizza. Not a huge deal, but they weren't very flavorful. The pizza was better.. crispy crust, good sauce to toppings ratio, but sadly it really didn't stand out enough for me to recommend Sam's. There are just too many better options downtown for better food.

Sam's Pizza rarely disappoints. From its thin crust to its (best in the area) deep dish-- there's…read moresomething for everyone. Don't miss out on Happy Hour. Which is Tuesday - Friday (they're closed Monday) from 3-6pm. Snag a $3 Domestic Pints or get $1.50 off Craft Pints and a whopping 30% off most apps. This is our go-to for a large group, as there is plenty of seating. Generally service is prompt and professional-- though it can be pretty hit or miss. The food always comes out piping hot! Parking can be a pain-- there's limited meter parking behind it.

We were new in town; The smell was in the air, couldn't stop myself from going in. Best pizza in…read morethe area.

A must for anyone visiting Iowa City. But - also a great place to get a good, hot pizza if you…read morelive in town. Hot pizza and an ICE-cold Coors lite. Easy parking across the street. Great service. An Iowa City tradition.

The best pizza in town. I love their family-run business, their crust reminds me of Casey's without…read moreall the greasy cheese, their garlic bread sticks might look like severed Mongoloid fingers but they are a-m-a-z-i-n-g. Highly recommend - and they will actually make one of my favorites of all time: Canadian bacon, sauerkraut and pineapple pizza. I also feel the gal(s?) who delivers are so sweet. Our dogs always greet them a little too rambunctiously, but they love it.

Long wait time, made the order incorrectly, rude customer service, treated condescendingly when we…read morecalled about it, and were forced to go back to return it. Heard them yelling at each other (about us) in the kitchen while waiting for the remake, despite asking a refund instead. My brother ordered for his dinner, but is allergic to the excessive onions they added, despite telling them ahead. I tagged along for support, as he has some health issues and is not always able to speak up for himself. Not worth the trouble, the visit back, and definitely not worth the price ($25 +fees for just a medium pizza). The remake looked okay, and they added in dessert breadsticks on the house, but still left us with an overall bitter aftertaste.

Oh my goodness haven't had Pizza this good in years. I talked to the owner and everything is made…read morefrom scratch. And it was very very yummy. I couldn't quit eating . We ordered the Hawaiian and it was cooked perfectly and the crust oh my it was crunchy but not over cooked and it was great . We also ordered the house special and it was the same so yummy. If you want to try a great pizza in a small community but also the best ever go here. . I know we will definitely be going here for pizza when we are hungry. Please try this you wont be disappointed

Alright so I usually love local small town restaurants and I'm a sucker for locally owned and…read moreoperated. This one is a true gem in the middle of small town iowa. Today we came to Sigourney to spend time with some family and they asked us to join them for some pizza from this local place called Nicks Pizza. Im always down for some pizza. We decided to give the menu a spin and we got breadsticks. (sorry no pictures they were gone as soon as they hit the table.) The breadsticks were amazing home made deliciousness! They were almost a mix between pizza hut and northern lights pizza bread sticks and they were AMAZING! We ordered the Greek pizza and the house pizza. The crusts were homemade perfectly crispy and perfectly sauced. The Greek pizza had perfect gyro meat and a mix of onions it was amazing. The house pizza was like a supreme pizza but the most delicious topings and the perfect crust. Im not sure if im sad or glad I dont live closer. If I lived closer I might weigh a few hundred more pounds because I would be here every day! This is a great stop here in Sigourney and I will for sure be back. If you are in town stop by and see what i mean. 5 star all the way!

The owners have something good going on here. Long narrow store with a few tables. Line is 20+…read moredeep at 1AM. Line moves quickly. They have several choices from your traditional cheese or pepperoni to very popular pesto chicken, mac n cheese, and even pizza with pasta on it. Price is just right. They premake alot of pizza and heat it up for you much like a Sbarro. I had the bbq chicken with ranch and it was incredible.

Mesa Pizza - Iowa City…read more The macaroni and cheese pizza here is next-level -- creamy, cheesy, and perfectly baked. If you're in Iowa City (Universityof Iowa) this slice is an absolute must-try!

The chicken wings are absolutely trash. They are dry, small, and they know it. The Wig And Pen in…read moreIowa City has decent ones (last I checked) and North Liberty gets all the rejects (as best I can tell). I would not buy them again. The pizza is good.

When we have a hankering for taco pizza on our trips to Iowa, we usually go with the original at…read moreHappy Joe's, but on a recent occasion we decided to pick up from Wig & Pen, as we were curious about how it would work as a deep-dish Chicago style pizza. Also, there were some in our group who are decidedly not fans of this particular concoction, so we had to choose a place that offered something a little more traditional. In addition to the taco pizza, we got one of their Union Jacks, which most closely resembles Giordano's special. With regard to the taco pizza, it differs from the Happy Joe's version in that it isn't made with refried beans, which I think is a critical component of a proper taco pizza. Still good, but not quite what I was looking for. The Union Jack was good, a very classic Chicago-style pizza. The crust was good, maybe just a little dry. In any case, this satisfied our cravings but we'll be getting one of those Happy Joe's originals soon.

I've never actually been to the restaurant but a friend brought some chicken lips that were…read moredelicious! Then, last weekend Graze donated a meal for our HS football team trivia night fundraiser and I was reminded how much I enjoyed it. We'll be heading over soon! Thanks Graze for your generosity!

Delicious's chicken, Lips, outstanding pizza, and wonderful personal service at the counter!read more