Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    5.0 (3 reviews)
    InexpensivePizza
    Open 4:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 years ago

    Friendly people and great service. Great pizza for a good price. I like their Veggie Pizza but I do add pepperoni.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Awesome service and phenomenal food! Staff is extremely friendly! Locally owned! Cheap gas abs you can't go wrong with Casey's pizza

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    We absolutely love the pizza here. Our favorite is Flatbread with crispy bacon, pineapple, and black olives.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Filippo's Pizza & Italian Food - Cannelloni with Meatballs

    Filippo's Pizza & Italian Food

    3.8(32 reviews)
    8.0 mi
    $$

    The food is delicious! Unlike a certain pizza chain restaurant nearby, the pizza crust tastes and…read moresmells like fresh baked bread. We also like the house salad and the lasagna is wonderful. I can't wait to go back.

    Make sure and read all of the negative reviews. They are probably the most objective and they hit…read moreall the highlights. Disclaimer: this visit was on Mother's Day so we understood that it would be crowded with longer wait time. First time in restaurant. The tables are packed claustrophobic tight. Or table was smack up against the side of the salad bar. I was afraid my hair would get in the lettuce. Every time someone walked past our table they bumped into the chairs. Payment is No cards, cash/check only and this info is NOT published anywhere but on a notecard taped to the cash register which was blocked from view as we were seated. Not on the door, not on the website. I see it's here in the comments on Yelp, but I had poor signal and didn't do a review search, just looked at the website. Poor treatment by owners - attitude was not "I'm sorry for your poor experience" but "I'm sorry you're complaining, get lost." Carry out orders and friends and locals seemed to receive priority service. Mediocre, overpriced food. "Baked" pasta dish was runny, mozzarella barely melted, meat sauce with barely any meat, way too sweet. Garlic bread with very little garlic. Pizza crust was hard, flavorless, over cooked on edges. Sauce (to me) has a weird chemical-like taste. Toppings were not fresh, mushrooms were canned, pizza was under cooked in the middle. Wait time - it was one hour until someone told us it was ready to come out in a couple of minutes..... then it actually was another 30 minutes or more later, during which the waiter avoided us like the plague until we flagged him down and asked when our food would be out, then another ten minutes after that. After reading reviews, it would seem that the time deception is a sanctioned tactic. Finally, after going to the car, retrieving an old checkbook, and writing a check with a generous tip in spite of the deficiencies, we politely expressed that they should publish their payment policy and how wait time was misrepresented. Received a very curt response. Left an honest comment on the community fb page and was threatened, cursed, and called every name in the book by most of the friendly "locals." But hey, social media, right? The rudeness on a busy day could have been easier to forgive if everything else had been five star, but the food really isn't worth the price and the wait. And jeez, Monticello....I'm afraid to drive through town, much less eat at this restaurant again.

    Photos
    Filippo's Pizza & Italian Food - Filippo's Pizza

    Filippo's Pizza

    Filippo's Pizza & Italian Food
    Filippo's Pizza & Italian Food - A (half eaten XD ) bacon and garlic large pizza.

    See all

    A (half eaten XD ) bacon and garlic large pizza.

    Overpass Pizza - 12" thin crust pepperoni pizza

    Overpass Pizza

    4.6(38 reviews)
    66.8 mi
    $

    This was our first time visiting Overpass Pizza and we were so surprised! It's in an unassuming…read morelittle building - off the beaten path. When we arrived we were seated right away but it was buzzing with locals and pick ups (good sign, right?!) We really enjoyed looking at all of the local memorabilia on the walls and our service was EXCELLENT! The woman that served our table was very friendly, upbeat, and knew exactly how to take care of her guests. Our food came out very quickly and we enjoyed all of it. We had the 12" thin crust pepperoni pizza and some garlic bread. Next time we'd like to try either the deep dish or some of the house special pizzas. I was pretty shocked to see that our total was over $45 for the 12" pizza, bread, and two drinks with tip. But really everything else made it worth it. And we got a slice of the most delicious almond cake on the way out for free - score!

    7/5 stars...yes, it's that good!!…read more Dad was visiting in Lafayette, and wanted to try something new. Found this gem, listed as one of the best pizza places in Indiana, and I was NOT let down. Pros - Service- Our two waitresses who were working and helping all the tables were amazing! Friendly, joking, amazing. - Food- I order a personal meat (thin crust), app of breadsticks, and my Dad got the pepperoni pizza sandwich. All were amazing! Hot, fresh, tons of toppings, and very affordable. - Atmosphere- The atmosphere was great. Fun and had a few funny signs (see below). While this place is small, it is friendly, good, and we'll worth checking out, no matter where you are! Cons None

    Photos
    Overpass Pizza - Funny sign in the restaurant

    Funny sign in the restaurant

    Overpass Pizza - Cheese bread

    Cheese bread

    Overpass Pizza - Order of breadsticks. Sauce was great (I wish they sold it).

    See all

    Order of breadsticks. Sauce was great (I wish they sold it).

    Casey's - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...