Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    4.0 (1 review)
    Open 5:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Casey's

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    The pulled pork pizza is awesome!! We stayed at camp Rudolph and Casey's was like 2 minutes away.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 378 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    S&S BBQ and Pizzeria - Veg pizza without cheese

    S&S BBQ and Pizzeria

    4.0(22 reviews)
    4.9 mi

    The pizzas here are excellent. After a long day at Holiday World, we came for dinner. The pepperoni…read morepizza and chicken bacon ranch pizza were both great, especially the latter. Even our kids ate the chicken bacon ranch, which was unusually adventurous for them. They ate the leftovers too. Only drawback were some weird incidents with the service. For one, we got reprimanded for our children "walking around the store" -- which, in reality, meant playing the claw machine. For another, the servers were dropping items alert and right. Everyone just seemed really overwhelmed. Overall, I'd recommend. I just hope they learn not to take out their stress on paying customers.

    My group of travelers and I decided to eat here after a long day at Holiday World. As we walked in…read moreat 8:20 we were immediately informed that the kitchen had shut down their grills, BBQ, and buffet. When a cheeseburger was mistakenly ordered, the cook in the back yelled,"Grills not on. Complain about it." They changed their order accordingly, but were uneasy by the cooks response. At around 8:40 our food was delivered with no complications or send backs. Shortly after, however, the place started closing down for the night with closing tasks (20 minutes before posted close). This made me and my crew feel rushed and awkward, as the staff was asking us if it was ok they cleaning the bathroom for the night, or, asking we could pay in the middle of our meals. We understand that it may be useful of time to close early, I get it, I've worked in the food industry, but this was odd to us seeing us they were being pushy about it and making us feel unwelcome and awkward. Beyond that we had no issues. Kudos to our server, Migel, who handled us with care and wit. Overall, we were pretty disappointed, we can't imagine we would return.

    Photos
    S&S BBQ and Pizzeria - Double cheeseburger and portobello mushrooms

    Double cheeseburger and portobello mushrooms

    S&S BBQ and Pizzeria - Breadsticks

    Breadsticks

    S&S BBQ and Pizzeria - Half cheese and half meats

    See all

    Half cheese and half meats

    Homestead Pizza

    Homestead Pizza

    4.2(17 reviews)
    8.1 mi
    $$

    I wanted to give Les than one star ONLY - for the coleslaw that my wife and I received 11-2/25. I…read morewant to tell others that the pizza is pretty good! The fried chicken is really good! The potato fries are pretty good, but don't box them together to go for 20 minutes. Too soggy. If you get the delicious chicken and French fries, leave the top open. AND - WE ARE probably the unfortunate ones to receive the most horrific tasting coleslaw we have ever not wanted to enter our mouth EVER. It tasted like the absolute bitter core of the cabbage with disgusting fish sauce or sea weed. I love fish sauce and sea weed as an ingredient in Asian food. However, WHO in the HECK approved this mixture? I never had coleslaw minced that fine, and that would have been an amazing difference, but my wife and I spit it out immediately. THE PIZZA IS really good. If we received - 2 - coleslaws at the same time that you are proud of, then I'm sorry you didn't get that nasty feedback before my order. But I might ask for a sample taste the next time. Just in case there was a mistake.

    Homestead pizza Is à great place to eat love there food clean and you totally feel welcome here…read moreand if you have big family l know you will love there bread Sticks with cheese dip are red dip And I know they fix Friday chicken now lots to pick from Love you All

    Photos
    Homestead Pizza - Classic sausage and pepperoni!

    Classic sausage and pepperoni!

    Homestead Pizza - A delicious order of garlic breadsticks with cheese dipping sauce.

    A delicious order of garlic breadsticks with cheese dipping sauce.

    Homestead Pizza - This is pepperoni and Italian sausage/jalapeño

    See all

    This is pepperoni and Italian sausage/jalapeño

    Casey's - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...