The owner was unexpectedly rude from the start, which felt completely uncalled for. It was disappointing and took away from what should have been a fun, lighthearted ice cream outing. Not sure why someone who seems so unfriendly toward customers would choose to run a place like this.. read more

The owner is rude, mean, has no manners and is a bully. Carvel is very good ice cream, i will drive out of my way to a different carvel before i would go back to the one in New Milford. read more

This is a family owned business, and they are so kind! Always delicious ice cream. I love carvel!

I only got a soft serve and it was great! Not very clean in there. And a small was 6 and change. Kent isn't even that expensive!

I read reviews and took notice that I'm not crazy and not the only one who noticed that the owner of something that involves person-to-person interactions isn't cut out for such a career path. read more

I was told about the carvel experience and it lived up to everything I heard. He is the most iconic ice cream man I have ever seen, why can't people appreciate the irony as a unique New Milford experience. If it was the Soup Nazi people would be lining up for a mile. read more

Wellllll the owner was condescending and not very kind, the other employee was nice so she gets a star. But the hours weren't correct and so when we showed up the precious time they were closed...even though everywhere else stated they were open. read more

The rudest man in New Milford. I have been in there multiple times and have tried to overlook the condescending attitude of the owner. I just couldn't bear it any longer and will never go back. read more

DO NOT GO TO THIS PLACE. PLEASE take your money elsewhere. The owner is the rudest person I have ever met. The worst customer service I've ever received. read more

This is by far the worst Carvel I've ever been to!!!! I tried to order a junior cup for my daughter with hot fudge... The guy working there said I can't get a junior cup with hot fudge it has to be a small, medium or large cup... Apparently that's the owner's rules. That's the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard of. So my kid had to be disappointed without hot fudge bc I was not buying a larger cup. Hey owner, BAD BUSINESS!!! Don't you realize you'd be making money on that squirt of hot fudge??? Guess you don't care about pleasing your customers. And if this isn't your golden rule, then have a training conversation with your staff. I was in there around 5pm today. read more

I don't understand why Carvel is so good, but it is. I love a dipped cone, or vanilla covered in sprinkles. Out in CA all we have is the grocery store frozen cakes which don't do this place justice. If you're in New Milford, Carvel is one of the finest attractions here. read more

I can't find a negative enough number to give this give this disgusting dump. It should be shut down! This is NOT CARVEL ICECREAM. It tasted like it was made from raw flour with grease....and that's a compliment. It is inedible! The owner should have his franchise removed as this certainly isn't even remotely ice cream. Don't waste your time and money...it made both my husband and I I'll! read more

They need to just get a new owner, honestly. I've been living in New Milford my whole life and the guy is STILL a dick. Ice cream is great, but I drive to a different Carvel near my work before going to this one that's walking distance from my house. read more

I'll add on with every one else that this guy is a class A jerk. I purposefully bulked up our order to get over the $15 card limit as I only had about $8 in cash. I understand, the card companies charge a lot, it's part of business now however. His machine was acting up and it took 3 different cards before a swipe would register. Not declines mind you, and not old worn out cards either, HIS machine was the problem. He then proceeds to ask very rudely to me and for the rest of the store to hear "why can't you just put $20 in your pocket"! WHAT?! Unbelievable! At least a few people followed me out the door after that exchange. Out of respect for the families that were in there I kept my mouth shut but I sure didn't want to. read more

We got the sinful chocolate cake and it was amazing and very fresh!: the service was very friendly. The bonet pre made cones are a family favorite read more

THE OWNER IS AWFUL!!! He was insanely rude to my husband and I and then smacked my husbands arm while he was trying to pay and told him "you don't mess with people bigger than you" even though he was the only one who had a problem from the second we walked in. Will not EVER return to this location. read more

Soft serve is always good but inside smells like spoiled milk, and the workers are rude. Also doesn't seem very clean, we saw a visible spider in a web dangling above the register. Won't be rushing back. read more

The owner is a bit odd. He has absolutely no personality and seems annoyed when you order ice cream. Not sure why that is. This location is not large inside but does have a large selection of cakes. It has a moldy odor when you first open the door which is a bit of a turnoff. The ice cream tastes like the usual soft serve Carvel. My only complaint is the lack of customer service. read more

So I was in here the other day and was charged a .50 surcharge for using my debit card.. which in CT it is illegal to even do so when using a credit card. There was a sign that said 5$ minimum, the thing came to 5.09 and this scum of an owner takes it upon his awesome self To apply his 50 cent handling fee. Enjoy. read more

The owner has to be the RUDEST person doing customer service on this planet..yikes. Nothing like being talked down to when trying to buy an ice cream cone LOL. No thanks. read more

You absolutely can not beat the pumpkin ice cream, sold only in the fall. It's just the right fall spice flavor. Second favorite are the red & chocolate "bonnet" ice creams. No one does them better than Carvel. The young staff sometimes make it obvious that they do not want to be there, but you find that in a lot of places. read more

Albert (I'm guessing the owner) is rude and seems miserably unhappy. There is a $15 MINIMUM on all credit AND debit cards which debit was not on the sign. The Wednesday bogo is for soft serve only and says so very small on the coupon too. Sub par ice cream. read more

The best ice cream Ever!! Nobody beats their soft serve!!!! Don't know about the staff at night but super sweet lady there during the day! Did a great job on my sons birthday cake as well!! Mmmmmm crunch! read more

Fat Albert makes me not want to come back. Why is the front door broken? Why can't a milkshake be mixed well enough so that the milk and ice cream are blended and drinkable? Why is the front driveway blocked off and why are the front steps sealed from pedestrian traffic? Something is not right with this shop. The extra star is for the nice original neon sign. read more

The owner, Albert, is the absolute worst! Purchased 2 ice cream cones with a buy one get one free coupon, and he proceeded to tell me it was for junior size because of the color of the cup in the picture. I have never heard of such a thing! No idea how he stays in business! read more

Web site says they're open until 10, but the place looked like it was well closed by 9:30. I love Carvel a great deal, but historically have found the employee (owner?) in this particular store seems miserable to be there every time I go. The good ice cream makes up for the lack of personality, but I wouldn't go out of my way for it. read more

This particular Carvel only has 3 flavors on a good day. Vanilla, Chocolate, and if the man working there isn't feeling lazy, a 3rd variable flavor. Honestly this is the worst Carvel I've ever been to. Not only does it not live up to the variety that Carvel offers normally, but the man working there has a TERRIBLE attitude. Honestly save your money and go somewhere else. read more

The ice cream is frozen in the freezer and there are toppings. The store is locating on a road with cars as well.

Just one criteria for my rating... I have had Vanilla Ice Cream Sodas, since the 1960's. So that's a whole lotta sodas! I have now had them at this Carvel, made by who I believe to be the owners... they are the best I have ever had! I know, it's a simple recipe, but they are just amazing. read more