Carter's Cantina

4.3 (126 reviews)

InexpensiveMexican

Closed • 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Order Carter's Cantina Takeout or Delivery

Order Takeout or Delivery

Carter's Cantina Photos

Carter's Cantina - This is a Cantina Combo. It has an Enchilada, a soft taco and a tostada with a side of refried beans and green salsa. - Mexican Near Me - New Haven, Michigan

Carter's Cantina - Inside - Mexican Near Me - New Haven, Michigan

Carter's Cantina - Fish tacos - Mexican Near Me - New Haven, Michigan

+102

Carter's Cantina - View from my seat by the window. - Mexican Near Me - New Haven, Michigan

Business Info

Health Information

View Health Score

Carter's Cantina Popular Dishes

$15.50

Street Tacos

3 Photos15 Reviews

$16.50

Enchiladas

9 Photos13 Reviews

$17.00

Steak Tacos

3 Photos3 Reviews

Carter's Cantina menu photos

Menu photo 1 Carter's Cantina New Haven, MI

Menu photo 2 Carter's Cantina New Haven, MI

Menu photo 3 Carter's Cantina New Haven, MI

Menu photo 4 Carter's Cantina New Haven, MI

Menu photo 5 Carter's Cantina New Haven, MI

Menu photo 6 Carter's Cantina New Haven, MI

Menu photo 7 Carter's Cantina New Haven, MI

Menu photo 8 Carter's Cantina New Haven, MI

See all

CARTER'S CANTINA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

Inside

14 Photos

Outside

4 Photos

Casual

Moderate noise

Outdoor seating

Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Carter's Cantina

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

This is our go to place. Staff is always nice and food is always great. The dinning room is very cute and has a great ambiance.

Amy C.

First time eating anything from Carters. Everything looked and smelled great. I was underwhelmed by the cheesecake nachos. All the flavors were there, I just wanted way more cinnamon sugar and I thought the chips were a little over done. The enchiladas were good. The ground beef had a nice even flavor. I wouldn't order them the same way next time, simply because I prefer cheese enchiladas. The CYO burrito was HUGE and delicious! Steak fajitas had good flavor also. I LOVED the chips and salsa. Chips were thin and crispy, the salsa was bright and tomatoey. The side of rice also had nice flavor. I'd definitely return.

Nicole E.

Serena is waiting on us. Ordered guacamole, chicken street tacos with fajita chicken (usually comes with pulled chicken), chicken flauta with corn tortillas, no sour cream sauce and all beans, no cheese and a pineapple Jarrito, that's the only flavor they have. $37.63. The spicy salsa and mild salsa are decent. The chips are greasy, but nice and crunchy. The guacamole isn't bad here. All of the salsas and guacamole is made in house. The flautas were okay, the pulled chicken is seasoned. The corn tortilla is definitely the best for the flautas. I am glad they were able to make the flautas with corn for me, since I am not greatly fond of them with flour much. The chicken tacos were better than expected. Pay at the counter. Service was all good. Food was better than average. They wouldn't give me a paper copy of my credit card receipt, that was a bit odd. I was only given the original tab was all, not what I was wanting. Oh well.

Pla C.

Heard a lot about this place on ELM and from locals. Had to come try it out. Watermelon Margarita was great. Salsa was VERY bland and very watery. Also, pass on the street corn appetizer dip. My shrimp tacos were flavorful & hearty. My friend got the combo plate and enjoyed it. Not too shabby. Wish they had different sauces you could try & put on your tacos. That would be great!

This is a Cantina Combo. It has an Enchilada, a soft taco and a tostada with a side of refried beans and green salsa.

Kelley C.

The restaurant was spotless, the service was wonderful. The food was absolutely delicious and worth everything hyped up I had previously heard, would absolutely go back again in a heartbeat.

BYOB - Big Burrito. They call it big burrito because it ain't a small burrito.

Kent M.

"Stick a fork in it!" That's what my inner self said when I saw this meal. I ordered a BYOB - Big Burrito. Rather than checking for doneness, I wanted to see if the fork would reach through to the plate. I buried the fork tines and still hadn't bottomed out. Yes, it was that big! Let's back up a bit, shall we? I entered from the ample parking lot and chose to sit at a booth. My waitress came over and asked what I wanted to drink. Since the name of the restaurant included the word 'cantina', of course I requested a well-known beer. Sadly I must report, she told me that they didn't serve the beverage delivered by Clydesdale horses. I wanted to give her a dirty look, but she was very pleasant both in her demeanor and her good looks, so I 'turned my frown upside down' and simply smiled back at her. I changed my request to an Arnold Palmer and all was well. At this writing, I suggest that you refrain from ordering any beverages of the adult nature, as the tequila wagon hasn't arrived. So, with many items on the Mexican menu that met with my approval, I decided on the big burrito. I was hungry and it was calling my name (to be honest, I had to hold the menu close to my ear to hear my name called out). My waitress accommodated a last minute change-up and made it a wet burrito. My meal arrived in good measure and it didn't have time to get cold on my plate. As I mentioned previously, I was hungry and after giving thanks in a prayer, I dug right in. With just a few bites left, I remembered something about portion control. So I paused and pondered that thought. Then I reasoned that portion control probably starts in the kitchen. After coming to that conclusion, I simply transferred any guilty feelings to them and finished my meal. Since I am a proud member of the Clean Plate Club®, I did my best to finish my meal to the requirements of club rules. Plus, I learned a long time ago that if you come up a little short on cash at the end of a meal, the cleaner the plate, the easier it is to wash (grin!). From time to time, I forget to ask about military discounts that may be available to veterans. I didn't forget this time, and was awarded a discount when I went to pay with cash. Thank you. This is not a fancy restaurant with valet parking. It is located on the mile road side of a small strip mall in the northwest corner of 27 and Gratiot Avenue. In my humble opinion, it is the best Mexican restaurant in New Haven. I recommend!

Justin H.

Too bad wasn't with my wife for this meal, because she would've loved this place even more than I did. Nice friendly service. Clean and I even heard some country music playing over the speakers. Heck ya baby. Let's be honest, most of us would rather listen to country music instead of mariachi anyway. The Chimichanga was the best I've ever had.

Cinthia R.

I really wish I could give this place at least 3 stars but if I am rating fairly I would have to say that 2 stars is the best I can do. First let me start by saying that when I first visited this place a little over 2 years ago, I was not impressed. It was run down, dirty and the food was terrible, the service was even worse. Now, two years later, the place is updated, better decor, nicer staff, and slightly better food. I know that this place is highly rated but we are in a small town and I can only speculate that the only thing they have to compare this place too is Trini's down the road. Which in comparison it is WAY better. However, this place by no means makes me reminisce about taco trucks in Florida or makes me all nostalgic-craving cantina tacos. Now, although this place missed the mark for me, I do wish them great success and because of that, I hope that the owner Carter (which I happened to run into with his children when I recently went) takes my pointers into consideration. 1. Make sure that your staff is regularly washing their hands. I watched your cooks (there were 2 when I visited) lay corn tortillas down with bare hands and turn them with bare hands, then run to the back touch containers with meat came back and flip the tortillas barehanded without once washing their hands. 2. The wait staff was also touching money, debit cards, pens, taking orders, phones, and making drinks. I waited for quite some time, not once did wait staff wash their hands. 3. Cantina tacos come with onions yes small diced onions. The onions are diced far too large for a cantina taco. 4. The type of tortilla being used is too thick to double up like a traditional cantina taco, this makes for a very DRY taco and not enjoyable at all. There are places you can source them from, even have them homemade. 5. Consider offering carne asada just saying....this Latina prefers Asada and al pastor over ground beef and chicken and I believe that those visiting go for that authentic cantina taste you get when eating a taco al pastor!! 6. Sabor!! Where is the flavor? The beans, the rice, the chicken. Nothing I ordered had any flavor, not even the salsa. 7. Cover your chips and salsa. I am not sure why there was no netting or cover over your chips or salsa. Even if they are kept in the fridge they should be properly covered at all times. Anyone, staff, customer, or flies could contaminate by sneezing, coughing, etc. Extreme? Possibly, however, it is still a possibility. Overall, I am not running to this place on a regular basis. Especially, during taco truck season. However, since I have seen some improvements within the last two years, although it was a slow progress. I am hopeful that this place will make some strides and some much-needed hygiene changes. I am certain some would say this was a harsh review but when you grow up with a taco truck in every corner and you're Hispanic, the standard is a bit different. On my food order was 5 a la carte cantina tacos and a street tacos dinner which comes with 3 tacos and rice and beans. I ordered one of each of all of the meats to try and ended up with 2 doubles. There were 3 of us eating and for all of us, the most edible out of the 5, was the chicken and slow-roasted beef. As you can see even with 3 people we barely cleared a taco a piece. No shade to the cook but hit me up if you need some help in the kitchen I got you!!! I want to see this place succeed!!

Danielle T.

So I've been a few times and have always had good experiences with fast and friendly service! You get free chips and salsa (super mild) and refills as needed. Menu has lots of options for whatever you are craving! I usually build my own burrito and you can build it however you want! Side salad was tasty with an amazing Mexican sour creamy ranch dressing! Family feel forsure a d I love supporting smaller businesses!

Very very fresh and Yummy!!! Great big portions too!!

See all

Tiffany M.

8 years ago

Best Mexican food out this way! Love getting carters, the prices are fair and the food is delicious. If you get take out they even give you chips and salsa which most restaurants will not do! I just with they had tamales!! Give them a try!! read more

Business owner information

Dan C.

Thanks so much Tiffany ! I’ll have tamales on special soon :)

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cassandra M.

8 years ago

Yum, food is so good and always hard to pick what to order . The owner is great & now ce. Family place!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Susan M.

8 years ago

Very cute small restaurant. Staff was friendly. It is busy for the area on a friday night. Chips and salsa were fresh and tasty. Enchiladas were tasty. Botana was ok, could not eat much, the beef is spicey. They did offer to discount for the uneaten portion. read more

Business owner information

Dan C.

Hi Susan ! I’m glad you tried us out. The enchiladas and botana are…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Samantha A.

6 years ago

This place is amazing!! The shrimp tacos are to die for! And their guacamole is superb! Literally 5 minutes from my house and I have never had a bad experience! Always fresh and delicious! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Chad J.

8 years ago

Went there for the first time a couple of days ago. Food and service we're great. Will be back. Glad to have a good Mexican place close to home. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mike M.

8 years ago

Surprisingly enjoyable. Stopped in for lunch on a recommendation and was very happy I did. I've been back a half dozen more times. This little Mexican restaurant in the middle of a strip mall is very inconspicuous. The decor is nothing special. There are about 15 - 20 tables and there is a counter as well. Wait staff is friendly and accommodating. Usually not crowded but have been there during a busy time and had to wait a little longer than usual but not bad. I've had the Quesadilla's, the Enchiladas, the "Build your Own Burrito" and the Chimichungas. Never disappointed and always filled up. Prices are very reasonable. I've had their guacamole and their queso-cheese dip as well as their complimentary chips and salsa. Ask for the hot salsa which is not TOO hot. Very nice place to grab a lunch if you're in the mood for Mexican. read more

Business owner information

Dan C.

Thanks mike! We love the great feedback. And positive review. I’ll…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Steve M.

9 years ago

Really good food small place good food try the cheesecake nachos the are great and the avocado sauce is really good

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jodie N.

8 years ago

My husband and I love this restaurant. We can finally get really good Mexican food close to home! We also love being able to support small local businesses. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kevin O.

6 years ago

By far my favorite mexican restaurant. Nice to see a small "Ma and Pa" restaurant that serves consistently excellent food

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mike J.

6 years ago

I understand with everything going on, restaurants are struggling. I also understand that on Cinco De Mayo, restaurants are busy, however, they charged me $50 and never delivered my food, won't answer the phone. A simple, we're sorry, you won't be getting any food tonight would have been appreciated! We could have ordered from somewhere else. No need to disregard us! We would have understood, totally unacceptable! Will never eat here! Would never recommend!! read more

Business owner information

Dan C.

Hey mike I’m truly sorry about tonight we got destroyed and will for…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Matt C.

116

9 years ago

First time coming, ordered carry out for 5. After looking at the reviews I had somewhat high expectations. Staff was very friendly are did an excellent job taking our order and making sure we had everything we needed/ordered. We ordered combo platter, 2 burritos, spicy enchilada, and cheesecake nachos. Guacamole had a terrible aftertaste and could not eat it. Cheesecake nachos were very good, everything else was average and lacked flavor. Everything was just very bland. Dinner for 5 for $70 is not bad, but the food was just food and was average there was nothing "tasty" about it. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gus A.

7 years ago

Little hold in the wall place in a small strip mall. Cement worn floors...nothing fancy by any means...BUT THE FOOD AND SERVICE WAS GREAT! Great prices too! Our new little place when we have that Mexican craving! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kayla K.

9 years ago

This place has the best Mexican food!! Best everything! Service is great! Plenty of Parking! Food is Fresh and you can tell they Keep a Clean Kitchen! No worries here!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lisa T.

Elite 21

232

11 years ago

Well, I said I'd be back. Came for their pork tamales special. Very authentic. I did the request sauce, they do come without sauce. I had the green chile enchilada sauce, which was a bit spicy, but very, very good. I also tried a sample of the guacamole sauce. Wow, really like that. As I said before, w the food is very fresh, the staff is very helpful, and friendly. I'll be back again. Hours have been extended and now they are open Wednesday through Friday. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Natss P.

10 years ago

I LOVE the Street Tacos Here.. My family is from Mexico. And I find myself very picky about my Mexican food. And I have been dying to find a place like this around here. Well. I finally found a good one. And I am glad to say I will continue to come back here. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Amy H.

11 years ago

Food is so good and fresh. The Taco salad is the best. The street tacos are always tasty, especially the carnitas. Carter is doing a great job! Since it is only on Monday, the whole family looks forward to coming back for our weekly fix of lil' Mexico in New Haven. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Piper B.

7 years ago

Me and my family have been to this place multiple times and love it every time we go. My family knows the owner pretty well so every time we go they already know our order. The only downside is when the main cook Alex, is there the Mexican sandwich is decently sized, but when the other main cook, Carlos is there the Mexican sandwich is half the size of Alex's. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lance B.

9 years ago

Had the spicy chicken enchiladas and they were great, small place, friendly staff, clean, a great value, give this one a try

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Andrea V.

10 years ago

If you want real Mexican food and not taco bell this is your place. Super friendly staff and good service. We had the combo plate amf tacos. The salsa is fantastic. You get house made salsa ans chips for the table. The avocado sauce is my favorite. We will bw back soon. Also this is NOT an expensive restaurant. Not sure why it's listed $$$. The most expensive thing on the menu was $12. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Denise K.

11 years ago

Great local Mexican place. Very fresh food, great beans and rice. Attentive wait staff and pleasant atmosphere:-)

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gerianne A.

163

10 years ago

Surprisingly good. Someone said new place opened up. So, thought I'd try it. Had street tacos with chicken. Clean atmosphere. The waitress was friendly also. Definitely coming back soon read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Christi P.

9 years ago

So glad to see Carter's is open now more hours. Excited to take my out of state family in there when they visit!!! Cheesecake nachos are out this world read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Deliaghassan N.

8 years ago

This is a very nice place with really good food. I love the decor of the restaurant! The owner is very responsive and attentive. Very sociable and values his customers as much as his food. We loved the fajitas and steak burritos. All the food is fresh and high quality. You can tell the owner pours his heart and soul in this place. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Emmaline B.

7 years ago

The food here is always great and comes out very quick. The waitress' are always polite and check in very often.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michelle M.

11 years ago

Awesome Authentic Mexican food. My husband mom and I had the Combos two beef and one chicken. It was so good. The chips and salsa were so fresh. I loved the guacamole. Will definitely be back. Can I give six stars out of five? read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

J M.

8 years ago

I tried this place after if first opened, then again this week (3/2019). Both times the food was very bland and had an odd taste. Even the color was wrong on some things ant my friend who was with me both times said she doubted the freshness of the rice and beans because they were cold, odd looking and tasted funny. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Linda M.

9 years ago

Crazy expensive!!! $55.00 four fajitas. NEVER AGAIN!!!! And needless to say it was sooo not worth it!!!

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nicholas D.

10 years ago

Great find! Chicken quesadillas, slow roasted beef street tacos, and queso were all delicious. Very friendly staff. I highly recommend this place and I can't wait to come back! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Diane M.

8 years ago

Food was very flavorfull, spicy not bland. Service was friendly and prompt. Decor was uninspired. We will be back, affordable and delicious. read more

Business owner information

Dan C.

Thanks for the great review! We appreciate it!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Caleb H.

9 years ago

Tacos were good but the salsa is where it is all at, the salsa was chunky tomato. It tastes like you are biting into a tomato filled with cilantro and oregano. Reminded me of tasteless, cold, runny spaghetti sauce with no meat read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Amber K.

313

171

9 years ago

Yum! Glad we followed the yelp reviewers and checked this place out. No wait for a weekend and quick service of chips & salsa. Chips were homemade - obviously a good sign. We tried chicken burrito, enchilada, tostada, and soft tacos. All were very good and flavorful. Plenty to eat with leftovers. We for sure recommend and will be back! read more

Business owner information

Dan C.

Thanks for the great review Amber! Next time your in say hello:)

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gretchen P.

10 years ago

I love their Street Tacos!! This is good traditional Mexican food. This is now our family's favorite restaurant, we will be coming back! Also the staff is super friendly. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Adrienne K.

11 years ago

Hands Down the Food Is Amazing, full of flavor and very FRESH tasting. I hope they open up full time here in New Haven!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jan H.

10 years ago

Love this little gem! We felt like old friends the first time we ate there. The food was awesome..the chips and salsa were great..the server was very friendly and helpful with selections and the owner/chef greeted us at our table. Happy to have a Mexican restaurant in the area again!! And a great one! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

T P.

8 years ago

Food and service were both quick and really good. But food is nothing extraordinary, no standouts that warrant the prices. I've had just as good or better for a lot less money. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tara J.

9 years ago

Always delicious and very friendly! New updated to the restaurant are awesome!! Highly recommended!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Shelby S.

9 years ago

The food is outstanding! Nothing on the plate is bland, the prices are beyond reasonable, and the service leaves nothing to be desired. I'd come back here time and again with my entire family. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Joshua B.

10 years ago

Everything is great going in, but wow is it rough coming out. So much grease practically dripping off of every dish. Nice small location and friendly family like staff. Not a bad price for the portions you're getting. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kyle C.

9 years ago

My girlfriend and I have been here several times to eat. The food has always been good and the service outstanding. That's what keeps us coming back for more. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Martin H.

9 years ago

We are frequent patrons of Carter's and love the food but, we went there Sat. evening (3/24/18) and new young guy cooking. We ordered the combo meal. Taco meat had odd taste and no flavor like it usually does. The hot salsa had no heat or flavor. Two young waitresses running around had no clue what they were doing. When Dan isn't there the quality and consistency drops off. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 3 of 4

59063 Gratiot Ave
New Haven, MI 48048
Directions
(586) 646-1160
Call Now
Order Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://carterscantina.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Carter's Cantina open?

Carter's Cantina opens at 11:00 AM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Sunday, Friday and Saturday.

What time does Carter's Cantina close?

Carter's Cantina is closed on Monday.Carter's Cantina closes at 8:00 PM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Sunday.Carter's Cantina closes at 9:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.

Mon ClosedTue-Thu, Sun 11:00 AM - 8:00 PMFri-Sat 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Carter's Cantina take credit cards?

Yes, Carter's Cantina takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Carter's Cantina have catering options?

Yes, Carter's Cantina does have catering options.

Does Carter's Cantina have a happy hour?

No, Carter's Cantina does not have a happy hour.

Does Carter's Cantina serve alcohol?

Yes, Carter's Cantina serves alcohol. Full Bar

Indoor Amenities

Does Carter's Cantina have TVs?

No, Carter's Cantina does not have TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Carter's Cantina have bike parking?

Yes, Carter's Cantina has bike parking.

Does Carter's Cantina have outdoor seating?

Yes, Carter's Cantina has outdoor seating options.

Does Carter's Cantina have parking?

Yes, Carter's Cantina has parking options.

Other Amenities

Is Carter's Cantina wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Carter's Cantina is wheelchair accessible.

Does Carter's Cantina have free WiFi?

Yes, Carter's Cantina has free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Homemade Fresh Mexican Food

History

Established in 2015.

Carter Family Owned and Operated

Meet the Business Owner: Daniel C.

The cantina is owned by Dan and Leah Carter. We live local in New Haven

More Info

Health Score

Ask the Community - Carter's Cantina

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

Los Pinguinos

4.6(50 reviews)

15.2 mi

•$$

Hands down the best Chicken Tacos I have ever had. I work down the road and taco Tuesday is…read morestandard practice in my office!

The food is still fantastic week in and week out this is the spot ... best birra tacos aroundread more

Photos

Napkin holder

Ordered the chimichangas...

See all

#TacoTuesdays

Dos Locos Burritos

4.3(32 reviews)

5.3 mi

Tacos are always my go to here. I typically get 3-4 tacos…read moreeither Chicken or Beef, with a side of chips and salsa! The service is always friendly and quick to take your order. The Ambiance is nice and nothing over the top!

I paid $17 for a California shrimp burrito that tasted like shit. It was a sloppy, drippy,…read moredisorganized mess full of liquid sour cream and thin guacamole that exploded all over the place when biting into it. I counted 3 shrimp inside. They forgot to grill the tortilla wrapping the thing too. I'll never pay $17 for a burrito at this place again. The guy running the counter was a neurotic train wreck and clearly overwhelmed handling the long line of customers. Dos Locos is usually very good, but they dropped the ball on this one. No rush to go back.

Photos

Burrito and 3 Taco Americano

See all

Juan Miguel's

4.3(517 reviews)

9.6 mi

•$$

My first time (out of state resident)…read more Heidi was a wonderful server, very professional and friendly. A wonderful meal & the best salsa I've ever had.

I try to post the positive reviews. We eat authentic Mexican on a VERY regular basis. So I feel…read morecompelled and qualified to post this one. Overall meal - average. Important point - their salsa served with chips before and with the meals is overloaded with chili powder (dark color) and would make an amazing base for chili. We didn't finish either dish due to the salsa and were really hungry by the time we arrived after traveling. The restaurant was semi full so must be some like that. For us - no bueno! Won't be back. We were kind about our critique and waitress received it well. Restaurant was clean and well kept. I mean this with kindness - Recuerdos! (Best wishes) PS: shockingly waitress agreed with us and stated she doesn't recommend the restaurant even though she works there. Try it for yourself and see if it works for you though.

Photos

Complimentary Chips and Salsa

See all

Raspberry lavender margarita

Las Tortugas Taqueria

4.4(460 reviews)

15.7 mi

•$$

I ordered three tacos so I could try different fillings: carne asada, al pastor, and chicken. The…read moreal pastor was my favorite, with nicely charred edges and a good mix of savory and slightly sweet flavors. The carne asada was tender, and the chicken taco had plenty of fresh toppings. I also added a side of elote, which was creamy with a little kick. Everything came out quickly, making it an easy choice for a casual meal.

I'm updating my review a third time. I ate inside the new location for the first time instead of…read moreordering to go. The Mexican Street Tacos and Wet Burrito were still the same great menu items as before except much more expensive. The prices were still within range of other Mexican restaurants. But, unlike other Mexican restaurants, the chips and salsa were not complimentary but cost extra. I was not impressed with the restaurant, though. We were first seated at a table/booth combination and the booth upholstery was totally torn and had been taped and not very well. Very unpleasant, so we moved to a better location. The service was not exceptional even though there were barely any customers. There are a plethora of Mexican restaurants in the area now, so we will be searching for a new one that offers complimentary chips and salsa and nicer ambiance. Las Tortugas Taqueria, you really should have stayed at your last location (even with limited parking), which was so crowded at lunch and dinner time you could barely get a seat.

Photos

Super nachos with shredded chicken.

See all

Antojitos by Chatitas

4.8(13 reviews)

12.1 mi

Small Mexican restaurant located in Frontier Town in Romeo. The food is definitely authentic and…read morethey take their time. I had driven by and spotted a sign outside that said "fish tacos" and since I love fish tacos, I thought I would try them so that was my first time there. My friend got a burrito off of the lunch menu even though it was dinner time (there was no burrito listed on the dinner menu ). His burrito was enormous! I ordered 2 fish tacos and they were like $5.50 each. I also ordered a side of beans and rice, which was about $5.00 also. I was so far from my two fish tacos that I brought the rice and beans home and my friend somehow managed to attack his entire burrito although like I said it was enormous. I will definitely go here again no doubt about that.

Lovely food! Had a bit of a wait for my beverage and quesadilla, but it was delicious. Wish it was…read morea bit more affordable, but I understand a small business requiring higher prices.

Photos

Interior

Burrito

See all

Clean.

Cancunsito

5.0(1 review)

47.9 mi

If you haven't checked this place out, you're really missing out on some fantastic Mexican fare…read more I've been here a few times and have yet to leave disappointed. The restaurant isn't obvious from the outside...I passed by it when looking for it....but it is worth the search. The restaurant is very clean and is bright and cheerful. The service is top notch...Uber friendly staff...attentive and efficient. When you order, you're given freshly made tortillas and salsa (with a combination of sauces). On my last visit, I ordered the Enchilada Rojah...5 chicken enchiladas, smothered in cheese and a red sauce, topped with lettuce. It came with Mexican rice and beans. It was off the charts good...far and away the best I've had dining out. My dining companion ordered the Baritta Taco....3 beef Tacos, covered in onions, paired with a beef broth soup (that is used for dipping the tacos). The broth was incredible...a rich combination of flavours. Once the Tacos were woofed down, he dived into the soup. He was in awe of the complexity of the dish and said he would come back again and again just to have this dish. Once you're done...you go to the cash register to pay. This place is outstanding...I highly recommend it.

From the owner: we are authentic mexican cuisine in leamington , we are a famous for the best birria in town read more

Photos

See all

Birria tacos

Senoritas Mexican Food

4.3(258 reviews)

13.8 mi

•$$

I won't go anywhere else in Macomb county. This food is fresh and authentic. I love their Al pastor…read more- no one else has come close to this flavor. The tricolor burrito wasn't our favorite because we didn't care for the red sauce but that's just not our preference. The server was able to change out a few things on the tacos. I wish I got The male servers name he was the best I've had there yet. You know the food ls good when you see Mexican people dining in at a Mexican restaurant. You will not regret coming here. Also there is a store in the back!!

The food was okay, but unfortunately the prices--especially for the drinks--really hurt the overall…read moreexperience. $7 for an iced tea with no refills is ridiculous, especially when you're already spending a decent amount on your meal. We ended up paying over $100 for the meal, including the credit card surcharge and tax. The food itself wasn't bad, but at these prices I expected better value. Charging $7 for a ice tea and not offering refills feels excessive. I'd probably consider coming back if the drink prices were more reasonable, but as it stands, there are other Mexican restaurants where I feel you get much more for your money.

Photos

See all

Salsa Caliente Mexican Grill

4.4(46 reviews)

49.1 mi

•$

A very causal family style dining restaurant. We were greeted right away. Apparently it is always…read morepacked and weekend, you have to wait. Staff were very friendly and always greet with a smile. Food is pretty legit. The only thing you may be missing is the heat from the kitchen which I don't mind. Thumbs up !

Visited this restaurant while staying in Kingsville for Ontario staycation and it was the real…read moredeal. People waiting in line early for Sunday dinner was a good sign, we were lucky that we were seated quickly and at a table. There is an option to sit at the counter as well, which gives a diner kind of vibe. Everyone looked like they were enjoying their food. It was very busy but the servers were efficient and friendly. The food - awesome and reasonably priced. I had the mix plate and my husband had the quesabirria which he couldn't stop raving about. It was closed on Monday so we couldn't go back. We are definitely going back next time we are in Leamington.

Photos

Horchata

Mix plate with chicken, rice and beans

See all

Quesabirria with rice and beans

La Montana Mexican Grill

4.8(27 reviews)

27.1 mi

La Montana is our favorite local Mexican restaurant with consistently excellent food and great…read moreservice!

You can smell the fajitas wafting from the kitchen once you sit down…read more Ordered guacamole, flautas dinner with beans only, chicken quesadilla dinner and one chicken taco and one chicken tostada. Corn chips are thick, crispy and a bit too hard. $53.19 The hot salsa is bad, better mixed with the house salsa. The guacamole doesn't have a ton of flavor, just creamy, still ok. The flautas are small, 4 small ones with the dinner. I asked for beans only and on the side, got beans covered with cheese. I had asked the waitress about the order being wrong. She looked agitated. She went to take my plate away. I said not to bother, I don't trust her to not spit in my food, she looked like she wanted to hurt me. The tostadas is covered with too much iceberg. The chicken quesadillas are thin and subpar. Meal was average. The service left a lot to be desired for me.

Photos

Shrimp Tacos

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

37 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

T A.

5 years ago

The Carter's are an amazing family. They are friends to the community, heartfelt, giving, and kind. The employees they hire are much like them, smiling and energetic. I've ordered food from them perhaps 30 times or more, and the quality of food is always excellent. My favorite is the Chicken Chimichanga! My son always orders off the menu, as he is very picky, but the Carter's staff always faithfully complies and gets a kick out of it when he orders his "rice tacos". Unfortunately, in the typical fashion of today's outrage culture, a recent customer who goes by the name Michael Anthony, has decided that the Carters should be destroyed because of a perceived slight. This customer arrived at the Cantina within an hour of closing time and were told they couldn't be seated. I myself have been told that on a number of occasions when arriving at a restaurant near closing time. My usual reaction is, "Oh, I see. Very sorry. I didn't know it was close to closing time. No problem, I will return another day." Pretty reasonable, right? Michael Anthony does not think so. He believes the ONLY answer could possibly be that he was a victim of RACISTS. His righteous indignation has run over to the point that he is now filing claims against the poor family. Today, bullies like Michael are encouraged to forge their impudent rage in to a weapon. Good people are being harmed and there is no room for reason or for facts. Unfortunately for Michael, the Carter's have been around quite awhile. Their customers are neighbors, friends, and family. We know these baseless accusations are patently false. Michael is clearly an outsider and does not understand that his lies will not gain traction here, because everyone knows the Carters. So to my fellow friends and Carter's patrons, I ask you all now to leave a review for the Carter's. Tell the world how awesome they are, and send a message to all the Michael Anthony's of the world: when you cry wolf, you hurt yourself, but you also hurt a community, and a family. It is far better to be reasonable and have some empathy, then to let your own illogical rage lead you down the path of lies and deceit. read more

Maurice H.

5 years ago

Moved to the area about 5 years ago. People kept telling me to go here. I had another Mexican restaurant that I liked in the next town over. One day I went here just try it out. I regret waiting a year to try this place. The staff is very polite and helpful. The crew seems like they get along and you always feel welcome when you go in. The food is absolutely incredible! No idea what they do to make the meat so flavorful. I always take a large nacho platter to events and it's always gone within an hour or so. Trust me, if you are anywhere near this restaurant please go here, you will not be disappointed. They are my go to spot now! read more

Paul R.

5 years ago

The service was absolutely top notch. The food was solid and prices were very reasonable. Portion sizes were large with plenty to aid that midnight craving we lovingly refer to as "fourth meal" in our home. Chips were crisp and salsa was spicy! The avocado dip was a solid partner to the chips as well. Wife asked for sour cream, and guac. Most places have a ridiculous surcharge for this stuff. We weren't charged anything. Also frequented during takeout only periods of covid and man was the staff super accommodating when we needed silverware for a picnic, etc... just absolutely top notch! read more

Randz H.

5 years ago

My family and I love Carter's. We have been ordering in or take out since they opened. I recommend all family, friends, and Facebook groups to dine in or carry out their authentic Mexican dishes. Every single visit the quality of perfection is delivered and leaves us full and satisfied. The atmosphere is great and their employees amazing. Dan has truly blessed us with his creative talents. You will not be disappointed!! Dan also gives to the communities a lot. He is always so generous with helping out schools and organizations. He will forever have our family as their guests. read more

Matt L.

211

11 years ago

Wow, heard about this place threw a local Facebook group and glad we went. They are only open Monday's from 5-9 as it is a Coney Island the rest of the week. We ordered the enchiladas with slow roasted beef and it was crazy good. My friend had a taco salad and it looked amazing. Place was rocking but service was quick and friendly. We will be back Starting 2016 they will be only open Thursday evening instead of Monday's. Same times 5pm-9pm. Just a updated Now open Wednesday, Thursday and Friday 11-8pm !!! Yes! read more

Stephanie F.

5 years ago

This is the BEST Mexican restaurant around! I literally live across the street of a well known Mexican place where I live and they are nowhere near as good as Carter's Cantina! I will always drive to New Haven over walking across the street when I want good Mexican food. Everything I have tried here so far has been delicious. The shrimp fajitas and street corn are my absolute favorites. Great staff and great food. Highly recommend! read more

Jannie W.

5 years ago

I am so impressed with not just the food and atmosphere, but also knowing how serious they take the health of their employees and customers! To regretfully have to tell people that the place needs to be cleaned and sanitized after a party of 35 left, even offering a carry out, shows that they take this business serious. Kudo's to Dan and Leah and their staff! Can't wait to have dinner again there soon! read more

Nicole B.

152

5 years ago

This restaurant is amazing great food and such friendly staff every time we go in the family who owns it are amazing as well .. they're some of the nicest people out there not one ounce of hate at all .they have the best tortilla soup ..so of u are in the area definitely hit them up and don't pay attention to the one guys review read more

Megan M.

5 years ago

Carter's Cantina is fantastic! We love it so much that we often do carry-out and dine-in! From the fantastic customer service (writing Happy Birthday on my to-go bag) to the homemade desserts, they made this birthday the best one yet. They go out of their way to make your experience an excellent one!!!! read more

Jeff C.

5 years ago

We've been going to Carter's Cantina for 5 years now. The only place you are going to get MEXICAN food equal to Carter's is in Mexico. The staff and service have been top notch right along with the food... Thanks for the great dining experience everytime we show up!!! read more

Jose' N.

10 years ago

I work with a number of Latinas who turned me onto this restaurant. The food is very good and authentic. I usually get the carnita street tacos, but I have enjoyed all of the items I have gotten. Do yourself a favor and check it out. read more

Megan S.

5 years ago

Love the food, service and just all around atmosphere Carter's brings. Family owned by a loving and kind family that go above and beyond for their customers. Can't wait to dine again at Carter's!!! read more

Jessica Y.

5 years ago

The best Mexican food around!!! You will not be disappointed. I seriously want to lick my plate clean everytime! Absolutely amazing owners, some of the kindest most caring folks I have ever met! read more

Melissa S.

181

5 years ago

Such good food and great service always! Kind people and a great family place :) my kids frequently ask to go and take out or dine in is always so tasty!! The salsa and soup is the best ever!! read more

Susan C.

5 years ago

Love it here ! Have gotten take out several times & will be back !! Owners are super friendly & nice. Great food ! Don't believe otherwise! Stop in & check them out yourself read more

Pun N.

5 years ago

I did not like, one reason is prices are too high. The quality did not match price and chip and salsa was best thing but can't have for free if not buying dinner. read more

Julie V.

5 years ago

Don't let the American name fool you; this is excellent Mexican food. It is plentiful, delicious and reasonable. The service is fantastic, too. read more

Brandis L.

5 years ago

Great food and service! I always get the cantina combo meal and they are so awesome with substitutions! Make this place your next dinner out! read more

Meagan V.

5 years ago

Highly recommended! Carter's is wonderful every time we go and so accommodating for special diets. Their tostadas are to die for!

Jacob L.

5 years ago

Excellent service and food. Everything is always very clean and the people are very friendly not to mention the food is excellent

See more unrecommended reviews

Carter's Cantina - mexican - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of New Haven, Michigan Restaurants near Carter's Cantina

BEST of New Haven, Michigan Things to Do near Carter's Cantina

BEST of New Haven, Michigan Coffee near Carter's Cantina

BEST of New Haven, Michigan Tacos near Carter's Cantina

BEST of New Haven, Michigan Breakfast near Carter's Cantina

BEST of New Haven, Michigan Pizza near Carter's Cantina

BEST of New Haven, Michigan Sushi near Carter's Cantina

Best of New Haven

Things to do in New Haven

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Carter's Cantina also viewed

Don Patron

3.7

(98 reviews)

•$$

This was our first ever visit to Don Patron's and my wife was extremely impressed with the great…read moresteak quality and quantity on her fajitas. I enjoyed the pork quesadilla Barreira's as well. You get lots of food and the service was excellent. I also enjoyed their homemade chips and salas. My wife said the $10 mojito was very plentiful and just as tasty as the $13 ones we get elsewhere. We'll be back!

Terrible service and rude staff! I went here to pick up an order for a customer (delivery service)…read moreand the young man stated that the printer was broken....so it seemed like he didn't know the order. He wasn't being clear of what I needed to do as the delivery driver. I started to call the customer to get the order and clarify that their food was not ready when an older man came over with an attitude as if I was the one causing a problem. I do not control YOUR lack of a printer or getting a proper order from a customer for your food! As I further attempted to get the order from the customer, the older man started shooshing me...one thing I will not tolerate is rude staff at any establishment, I would NeVER spend my money here!

Trinis Mexican Carryout

3.9

(98 reviews)

•$

This place is SO GOOD!! I was pleasantly surprised by not only the delicious food but by the…read morefriendly people running the place. They are now our go to spot for when we need to fulfill our Mexican food cravings... even the desserts are scrumptious... particularly the Sopapillas! Also the chips are SUPER FRESH and perfectly salted. We've ordered several different things and everything was perfect with everyone's meals. The prices are reasonable and the portions are generous and did I mention how delicious everything is? Go treat yourself and tell your friends and family about this spot because I NEED them to be around for many years to come... LOL but very serious. I forgot to order the Horchata and I need to try the Tres Leches Cake but I already know it's going to be great. I'll be sure to post pictures next time.

Haven't been to this place in years and when I paid for my order they charged me a fee to use a…read moredebit card. Debit cards have always been considered exactly the same as cash. I looked it up when I got home and it is ILLEGAL to so this. I don't business with folks that commit fraud! Clean up your act Michelle!

La Fonda Mexican Kitchen- Bruce

3.3

(99 reviews)

•$$

We started with the chips and salsa with their freshly made guacamole. The chips were served warm…read moreand the salsa was mild, just the way we like it. I had the wet burrito with red sauce dinner and wife had chicken quesadilla. Both were served hot and fresh and we really enjoyed them. The service was good and the decor was nice. I will be going back soon.

This place runs on about 2 brain cells. Ordered carryout at 5:15- supposed to be ready at…read more5:25-5:35pm. When I get there at 5:45pm they had not even started preparing order. Told bus boy I was picking up order and evidently he did not comprehend what a carryout was as 10 minutes later the lady working there asked me if I ordered a carryout. I asked the lady if I should even bother ordering ahead given the experience I was up against and the woman working there blamed it on all 3 tables of people eating at restaurant- yet the place 90% empty and I can see why now :) . I finally got the carryout at 6:05pm. Can't foresee this place staying in business much longer with the current brain trust at the helm. Food was good- just totally incapable workers/management, so I will never be back.

Taco Loco Chula Maria Mexican Grill & Bar

3.2

(260 reviews)

•$$

Taco Loco is my absolute favorite Mexican restaurant in Macomb County. The service is always greatread more

My husband and I have been enjoying the food at Chula Maria (Taco Loco) since it opened. Last night…read morethey had a new item to sample- Pollo a la Naranja-Orange Chicken. It's was amazing. I actually ordered it for my dinner. It was served with Mexican rice including an assortment of vegetables. I hope it becomes a regular menu item. The Mariachi duo was very entertaining and really adds to the authentic atmosphere. Our server was excellent and kept our glasses full. The margaritas are the best around.

Raíces Mexican Cantina

4.2

(56 reviews)

Went to Raices, ordered from the lunch menu. What a great place with delicious authentic food! I…read moreordered the cup of chicken tortilla soup, dang was that so very good. Ordered the 3 street tacos lunch, rice was one of the best I ever tasted, and their tacos were so good. No need to eat dinner tonight, it was very filling. AAA+++ Excellent!

Ate here on a Friday after work. Great service, plenty of options on the menu. We had drinks and…read morea queso dip plus tacos and the shrimp. Everything tasted wonderful and the portions were just right. There is plenty of seating, large booths and tables that can be pushed together. Raises is perfect for a date or meet up with friends. It's close by the movie theater and convenient to M59. Overall we had a great meal. The bar has some TVs and a full bar, we ate in there as it was a little more laid back. Will definitely come again.

Dos Locos Burritos

4.3

(32 reviews)

Don Armando’s Mexican Cuisine

4.3

(37 reviews)

This is a relatively new Mexican spot that very well may be my favorite one in the metro detroit…read morearea. Smaller diner with delicious food and great staff. Very authentic feel to the place, both the atmosphere and the food are exactly what you look for in a placed like this. We ordered Don Armando's burrito and the quesabirria tacos, both in meal sets that came with rice and beans. This is honestly the most memorable Mexican dinner I've had in a really long time, nothing more to say! Not many Mexican spots in this area that I can confidently say that - definitely give this place a try.

We stopped in for dinner after I saw a Tik-Tok'er show her dinner she had delivered, in a video…read moreposting. The dinner looked really good. This is a small restaurant located in a strip mall at the corner of Rochester Road and Tienken. The space is small and casual, decorated with a Mexican flair. We went straight to the counter to order. The lady that took our order was friendly and helpful with the menu questions we had. We ordered a street taco meal (2 tacos of your choice, rice of choice, and beans of choice). I like that they give you options for everything. We also purchased sodas and she gave us complimentary chips and salsa to eat while we waited on our meals. Our meals were really tasty - a bit on the salty side but I didn't mind. I had the carne asada taco and the chicken taco for my 2 choices. I really liked the beef one but the chicken was great too. If you are in the mood for some street tacos, this is the place for you. They also offer them à la carte in case you don't want the rice and beans meal.

Red Pepper III

3.7

(20 reviews)

•$

I have always loved Red pepper on Wadhams! But I visit today was not good the service was great!!…read moreThe food not so much , the taco meat didn't have any seasoning a was cold !! Also the flour a corn tortillas weren't even cooked !! This has never been like this before !!! Hope it was just a bad day & next time is much better !

Hometown nostalgia…read more There are several Red Pepper locations now, but I always go to this one since it's near my Mom's house. It is impossible to top Taco Tuesday - 50 cent corn and 70 cent flour tortilla tacos with free chips and salsa. The kicker is that it's absolutely delicious as well!

Maggies Mexican Food

5.0

(2 reviews)

Literally never disappointed with anything I get here. Made with love and authenticity. Perfectly…read morespicy and flavorful. Always served with a smile.

Maggie's Mexican food is the best Mexican food in town frfr! The food gives me a taste of home when…read morehome is across the country! The rice and beans are always so yummy and the main courses are divine! I recently tried the dos amigos plate and it's honestly probably my new fav dish from them! The birria tacos and tortas taste just like the ones from my home town and are stuffed with meat! And there's so many other delicious items on the menu! The staff however takes the cake! They are so sweet and accommodating and helpful! Definitely check them out!

Taqueria Lime And Salt

4.7

(49 reviews)

Food was amazing, I got the Fajita Burrito and it was just hands down amazing. The sauces were…read moregreat. As well as the XL steak quesadilla was fantastic. I would totally recommend this restaurant to anyone and everyone. Great service and great people.

This place is amazing! The food portions were HUGE!!! Very much worth the price! i highly recommend…read morethis place and the salsa was just amazing!

Carter's Cantina

Order Carter's Cantina Takeout or Delivery

Carter's Cantina Photos

Business Info

Carter's Cantina Popular Dishes

Carter's Cantina menu photos

CARTER'S CANTINA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Carter's Cantina

Reviews With Photos

More info about Carter's Cantina

Payment methods

Food & Alcohol

Indoor Amenities

Outdoor Amenities

Other Amenities

Ask the Community - Carter's Cantina

You might also consider

More businesses like Carter's Cantina

Los Pinguinos

Dos Locos Burritos

Juan Miguel's

Las Tortugas Taqueria

Antojitos by Chatitas

Cancunsito

Senoritas Mexican Food

Salsa Caliente Mexican Grill

La Montana Mexican Grill

37 Carter's Cantina reviews that are not currently recommended

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

37 reviews that are not currently recommended

Carter's Cantina - mexican - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

People found Carter's Cantina by searching for…

Related Searches in New Haven, MI

Trending Searches in New Haven, MI

Best of New Haven

Browse Brands

Browse Articles

People who viewed Carter's Cantina also viewed

Don Patron

Trinis Mexican Carryout

La Fonda Mexican Kitchen- Bruce

Taco Loco Chula Maria Mexican Grill & Bar

Raíces Mexican Cantina

Dos Locos Burritos

Don Armando’s Mexican Cuisine

Red Pepper III

Maggies Mexican Food

Taqueria Lime And Salt