Carter's Bakery is such a gem. Their cakes are incredibly yummy--moist, flavorful, and not overly sweet. The cookies are just as good, the kind you think you'll have one of and suddenly you're three deep. (Brown Butter Toffee is my fav.) And the latte? Excellent! Smooth, rich, and honestly better than what I've gotten at some big-name coffee spots. The staff makes the whole experience even better. Everyone I've interacted with has been warm, friendly, and genuinely happy to help. It's the kind of place where you feel welcomed the moment you walk in. I definitely recommend this bakery to anyone in the area. Whether you're grabbing a treat, a coffee, or something special for an event, Carter's is absolutely worth the stop. read more

Stopped in again while visiting in May. Had the pear and lemon tart both were delish. The cakes are the best in the area and ice cream YUM! Service is fast friendly and efficient. The garden sitting in the back had beautiful garden flowers. read more

Carter & Co - Carter and Company during the night market - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

I heard about this place and decided to visit on a hot July day. The caramel ice cream with Jack Daniel's was very good. The lemon sorbet was also good. My Westie Abby enjoyed some vanilla in a pupcup in the seating area outside in the back with tables, chairs, and umbrellas. It was a pleasant environment to enjoy some ice cream on a hot evening in the shade. The seating area is located on the Marina side of the building in the back. The staff was helpful with ice cream choices and Abby couldn't have been happier eating ice cream with us. I'll definitely visit again. read more

See all

I came into Carter & Co hoping for some cake and they were unfortunately out so we decided to get a bunch of other tasty looking desserts instead. Everything was really good. I'd say the cheesecake and stuffed brownie were my favorite. They were well made, flavors balanced and delicious. I especially loved the flavors of the brownie. The ice cream was unique and creamy and the flavors were really there. The shop was fun and gave us all some giggles. We liked the plants and the llamas. It was a quiet evening so our family had the shop nearly to ourselves. They were friendly and I will be going back to try the cake! The only thing I didn't like was the cookie but that's my bad because I didn't read the ingredients and wasn't a fan of all the things being mixed together but it was still a well made cookie regardless read more

Carter & Co - Blueberry cheesecake, Swirly Jack + Coffee Chocolate Chip Ice Cream, Chocolate covered brownie, Cookie - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

We have always had great service and wonderful food and drink at Carter's. This morning was no exception as I enjoyed a warm pecan roll with plenty of pecans and just the right amount of caramel goodness to accent the light tasty roll. For me it is like sitting done with my dad after he made our family's recipe. The caramel latte was excellent as well. My mom had a decaf Americano and a lemon scone. It was also very good and brought a smile to her face. Seating inside, out front, or in the back garden offers a nice variety to start your day. Check out their broad menu from pastries, quiche, rolls, ice cream, chocolates, tarts and more. The folks at Carter's know how to start your day. read more

Carter & Co - Pecan roll and caramel latte - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Amazing ice cream! The staff are super friendly too!! We didn't try anything ele, but the cinnamon rolls looked yum!! read more

Carter & Co - Ice cream menu - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

See all

DO BETTER CARTER & CO!!! This is what happens when you try to support local businesses these days. Take your money elsewhere!!!!! With my MINI poodle in my bag on my shoulder, I go inside and before I even get to look at their sad looking pastries in the dirty fingerprints smeared and dimly lit showcase, the young girl behind the counter says "Is that a service animal?" To that I responded "no she's not" and to my surprise the response she gave me then was "Well, we can't serve you but you can go outside and order".....so I laughed and said "oh wow even if she's in my bag??? and I'm ordering for takeout??" I walked out. It was in the middle of a heat wave in Port Orchard. Wtf do I look like ordering through the glass window from the street in the heat. read more

Carter & Co - This mural was the only good thing about this damn block. - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Had 3 different cakes, they were moist and delicious. I like that they charge slice of cake by the weight so you can customize. Cookies were tasty also. Friendly staff and accommodating. read more

I checked this place out for a sweet treat while visiting friends in Port Orchard, WA. I loved the options they had! The ambiance felt like a Christmas themed all year round vibe. I did not check out the patio, but was told it is spacious and a great place for meeting up with friends. No service here, just order at the counter, but options ranged from baked goods to homemade ice cream, which is what I had, specifically the Brickleberry, which was made fresh with local blueberries and amazing! Also ordered the Swirly Jack, which was probably one of my favorite whiskey infused ice creams. They were so smooth and creamy, just what you'd want from good homemade ice cream! Definitely recommend checking out, as there's so many more options from the bakery and want to check out that patio! read more

Carter & Co - Indoor vibe - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

See all

We haven't been to Carter & Co in a few years, but we decided to pop-in on a recent trip downtown. As with our last visit, we were a bit underwhelmed. The ham and Swiss stuffed brioche we chose was decent, though the bread to filling ratio was not quite right. And the key lime tart we purchased (based on a staff's recommendation) had a bit of a strange texture and flavor profile. The cookie we ordered was quite tasty, so that was a highlight. This was the first time we opted to sit inside the establishment to eat our treats, and we found the interior a bit dark and drab, definitely in desperate need of some refreshing (as with most businesses in the downtown corridor). We really want to like this spot, as it is obvious the owner is very passionate about his business, but we've yet to be wowed. Maybe next time? read more

Wife and I went to try this past weekend as she saw the shop and wanted to try plus I saw the reviews. The service was ok, no one jumping to help, seems very "next customer" type of service (guy in mask seemed like he did not really want to be there that helped us). There was seating inside and there were ppl there. It gave off a place to stop during your walk or stroll while in downtown. It seemed outdated and needed its own vibe as it seemed to be using the prior tenants decor/ look. Wife ordered a pastry which was a 4 star. Ordered 2 specialty drinks 1 star. My wife's was bland and mine was way too sweet. Wife ended up dumping hers and drank mine as I could not get past the first sip. We personally will not return as we were very disappointed in the drinks & pastry on the higher price, but if you are into pastries & sweets, give it a try while supporting a small business. read more

The cheese cakes and tarts are AMAZING and so affordable. Ice cream was great too but the tarts really blew me away especially for $1.50 a pop. Cheese cakes came in so many flavors there something for everyone. A must have. read more

The food was bland and dry. I've gotten food from here in the past, and it's been the same. I'm not surprised that every time I've been here its almost empty. read more

Carter's is one of the best places around!! They have the most delicious cakes, pastries, and savory options as well! And they make chocolate!! They have truffles, handmade trees at Christmas and eggs at Easter, they have chocolate heart boxes you can have filled with truffles for Valentine's Day and everything we have had has been phenomenal! And there is more!! They make their own Ice cream and it is incredible! Swirly Jack is a favorite ( vanilla with a Carmel and Jack Daniel's Swirl) and their plain old chocolate and vanilla are top notch!! The proprietors are always on site making new creations. They are wonderful and welcoming. You should go!! read more

Cool vibe inside and lots to offer for those who want lots of options when it comes to sweet treat selections! Quick service for a milkshake! read more

I went here on my b-day because Holy Water refused us service, saying their grill was shutdown 40 minutes before their closing time. After seeing Holy Water's disgusting, vacant employees vaping and hawking luggies outside, we said, "no thanks" and went over to this little gem. And what a gem it is! Their decor and ambiance is perfectly uplifting for these winter doldrums, with plants and art bursting from every crack and crevice. Their desserts and pastries are amazing, to say nothing of their goat cheese quiche. The quiche as well as the savory croissant roll I 'et were the best I'd ever had. Do yourself a favor and avoid Holy Water and come here instead! read more

Dirty inside, I thought their cinnamon rolls were supposed to be the best thing there and it was dry and bland. The guy working took forever to help us. We just stood there waiting. Overpriced, never going back. read more

I bought 2 cookies and took a bite out of one had a long black peace of hair in the cookie I was so disappointed- do better! Cookies taste like ass too. read more

My husband and I were really disappointed this time. We are regulars and have been for years. The kid behind the counter must have been new because his customer service skills need a lot of improvement. He acted like he didn't want to be there. The ice cream was freezer burnt. This is what really got us! Maybe we will take a break for a bit and hopefully next time will be better. read more

Love this chocolate/ice cream /pastry/ sandwich shop Literally a one stop shop! Atmosphere makes you feel at home . The decorations are relaxed and tables are always clean Outside seating in the front or in the garden which is covered in the back . They have the cutest library nook inside I had no idea that was there ! With a table and comfy chairs We ordered : fruit tarte , blueberry cheesecake , ice cream and a pastry that was warmed with goat cheese . I wasn't a fan of the tarte since it felt like there was no bottom, it was soupy and seemed more like a mousse on the inside ? The chocolate was bitter and I wasn't. A fan Blueberry cheesecake was WONDERFUL ! Fresh , fluffy, and yummy Ice cream: they have rotating homemade flavors I had the chocolate chip coffee and wow .... Best flavor I've ever had . It was a coffee lovers dream . Goat cheese pastry : fluffy firm bread exterior , soft melty goodness on the inside . It was wonderful tastey , flavorful and warming I love coming here and will always stay true ! Also the kiddos adore this spot read more

See all

I've been here a few times before during my trips to port orchard. Stable coffee house with yummy desserts. I got the lemon tart recently and it had so much flavor despite being so simple. My kind of no-frills dessert. The last time I was there, someone took ten minutes to order and was being really picky about everything. I was patient but sort of hoped that the folks working would take other customers since the line behind was getting long. read more

Carter & Co - Lemon tart - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Delicious ice cream and chocolates. We loved the vanilla ice cream so much. Beautiful backyard garden.

Big fan of the gluten free cakes. The caramel cheesecake is also a personal favorite. Matt was also very sweet and kind. Stop by to satisfy your sweet tooth read more

It was very nice, the service, the food, the drinks also the ice cream we will come again. It's good for the family too they have books and board games if I'm not mistaken, good for hanging out they have outdoor seats in the back. read more

A quaint little bakery that packs great treats. Their chocolate cake is definitely the one that makes me come back here from Seattle. read more

Carter & Co - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Good spot for ice cream or something savory. I ordered the mushroom and cheese bun, it was filling. I think they used to make a blue cheese ice cream but its been a long time since they've offered it. read more

Carter & Co - Mushroom and provolone cheese bun - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Stumbled upon this place when I was in Port Orchard, WA. They have fantastic homemade ice cream and cakes. Everything is made from scratch and I mean everything. It's not cheap and you get what you pay for. A full cake will run you roughly $65 but again it's made from scratch. Your portions are weighed and you pay by the ounce. read more

Carter & Co - Carrot Cake made from scratch. - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Omg!! So so so delicious and what a lovely shop inside and out back in their beautiful patio! Must trys: jalapeño cheddar brioche-warmed of course! Pecan roll! Morning muffin! Lemon tart, key lime tart AND their orange chocolate chip ice cream is spot on delicious!! Try them out and enjoy your goodies on their beautiful and artfully designed back patio...but let's keep that our secret! read more

Carter & Co - Patio - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

Carters has baked goods, ice cream, chocolates and coffee. We usually go for the homemade ice cream. I especially enjoy the chocolate with chili spices. They usually have a good assortment of unusual or unique flavors for the four of us. Of course the have the standard traditional flavors. On occasion, with out the kids we have had cake and coffee drinks, all have been nice. It's a little gem hidden in Port Orchard. read more

We got tarts, cookies, a chocolate croissant, three cheese quiche, and a amaretto cherry cheese cake. All of it was absolutely delicious. The staff working were really kind, and the vibe is chill. Would recommend! read more

Stopped by after hitting the P.O. Farmers Market because of positive reviews. It was just meh unfortunately. On a positive note, the ice cream was tasty. Nice choice of flavors. But the cookies were very dry - bought a monster and a chocolate/peanut butte. Also got a chocolate croissant to takeaway - not worth the calories. Will keep looking for a great bakery in P.O. read more

We were craving some dessert and stumbled on Carter & Co via Yelp. Arrived about an hour before closing, delightfully busy so that was a good sign. Helpful counter persons quick to offer assistance and answer my questions. Overwhelming number of options, you'll need to make more than one trip :) My Swirly Jack ice cream in a waffle cone was just right, happy they stuffed some ice cream down in the bottom part. Right when I was wishing there was a bit more caramel I found a pocket of yumminess. Husband devoured his caramel chocolate brownie ice cream, his standards are pretty high so it must have been good. We took some mini cheesecakes to go as well. There's a case of chocolates I'll need to investigate further. Savory options and an espresso menu. Reminds me of a bakery in Morro Bay we miss a lot. Who knew Port Orchard could be so classy! read more

New to the area so took a little time to meander on Main Street. Popped in here when the heat was too much. As much as I love pastries, I went for ice cream which I rarely eat. The blackberry sorbet was fantastic! The young lady was very helpful and offered a few ice cream recommendations, then offered a couple of samples (all delicious). The backyard garden is excellent, cheers to the gardener. Given the owner does seem to read these reviews, I would suggest turning down the music or changing the genre. It was very loud, and grating at times (and it was music I liked) There was table of 3-4 elderly trying to enjoy their ice cream and chat but they couldn't hear each other. They left pretty quickly. I tried to do a little work but it was too distracting and left. I can't wait to be hungry and return for some of the many things they offer! read more

I've been here several times and plan to continue coming here for all my dessert needs! I absolutely LOVE their mini cheesecakes. If you love or even just like cheesecake, I recommend their minis! I've tried the caramel, Bailey's Irish cream, cherry, blueberry, and white chocolate & vanilla mini cheesecakes so far and have been 100% satisfied! I plan to try them all truly! They have plenty more there too, including their deep dish cookies. How insanely good does that sound? There's even savory food items that are equally incredible! All of their everything is just so delicious and I know no matter which menu item I choose it won't be the wrong one here! Definitely: Try. This. Place. read more

See all

Beautiful little spot in Port Orchard! Friendly, helpful staff, awesome, DELICIOUS tarts, cookies and pies! They have a boatload of ice cream flavors and sandwiches, coffee and cappuccino's! Wonderful find!! We will be back! Mmmmmmm read more

This place was fantastic. The young lady working the front counter was very friendly and helpful. My wife and I ordered the chicken panini and it was delicious. Apparently so delicious that my wife told me so 5 times. I counted. Their desserts were also very good. We had both their New York cheesecake and the berry tart and we they tasted great. My wife also ate their icecream and loved it. It was creamy and flavorful and not icy like other places. Overall, we really enjoyed the visit and will be coming back to try their other food. read more

You guys, Port Orchard is a special place. The campsites at Manchester State Park are magical and this little town is a place to spend many days. We loved it. A highlight was definitely Carter & Co's, where we had the best dang homeade ice cream in all of Washington. Brickleberry literally blew my mind with it's fresh local berries amidst caramel. You just have to try it for yourself. Daughter said the Orange chocolate chip was some of the best ice cream she's had in a while. Keep it cool, Port Orchard. read more

See all

Small gem in downtown Port Orchard. Great chocolates, pies, cakes and pastries. Freshly made and worth the stop. The ice cream in the summer really hits the spot. Highly recommended. read more

Really amazing pastries and chocolate truffles. Go there for my bday slice of cake. 10/10 would recommend.

Possibly best food I've ever eaten and it's so pretty, everything's perfect! I'd recommend anyone here read more

Carter & Co - Food and view - Chocolatiers & Shops Near Me - Port Orchard, Washington

See all