First off I absolutely hate and despise rice crispy treats and I never touch them when they come around on special occasions but today would change that. When I saw that this place was upping the rice crispy game with like 50 different flavors I had to reevaluate my distain for the treat. The place is small and very busy on my visit and hard to move around to look at all of the different flavors. Buy four and save a $1 I heard but I was going to baby step it with 3, 2 for me and 1 for my neighborhood bar tender which he was surprised and looked like he really appreciated my little gift. I got the peanut butter cup and and a maple pecan for me. OMG the peanut butter cup was f#cking delicious with a peanut butter center. Had my whole life the rice crispy treats been this creative I would have never had a deep dislike for them. With my new found fondness for the rice crispy treat I would definitely be back in the future. For the people who came up with this fantastic idea of elevating the rice crispy treats to a gourmet premium treat, hats off to you. They definitely hit this one out of the park. read more

See all

What a great idea! I've been hearing more about this business from my family and friends who either live here or travel past this business. I've seen their product on vacations, but recently stopped in with my bestie on a roadtrip. She wanted to stock up on her puppy chow and I purchased 8 of random flavors. Preference really is subjective, but the one that stood out to me the most was coffee toffee. I want more! Cannot wait to go back to grab 8 of those specifically! They also had some small slices for $1 at the checkout area which I would recommend if you're on the fence of some flavors. read more

See all

What's not to love about a store that is filled to the brim with gourmet rice crispy treats?! The site is small and that could impact your enjoyment of visiting but on the trip I made there was only 1 other customer in the store at the time so that wasn't an issue (there were 2 of us that visited). There is a wide variety of items with amazing flavor combinations leaving me literally like a kid in a candy shop as I walked around. I'm not a lover of rice crispy treats but these were delicious and I will definitely be back for more. My niece definitely appreciated them, too. :) read more

Tony Cu made us do it! We saw his TikTok review of Carrie's Crispies and immediately added it to our must-visit list while in town visiting family this past weekend (worth the 45 minute drive). It looked way too good to pass up and it did not disappoint. This bright turquoise gem is tucked into a quiet neighborhood, and it's absolutely adorable inside. Small, cozy, and full of charm. The staff were super friendly and welcoming. Now for the main event: the treats. I walked in thinking I'd grab one or two... and walked out with EIGHT. I went with 3 S'mores (yes, three--no regrets), Puppy Chow, Almond Pistachio, Brown Butter & Sea Salt, White Chocolate Macadamia Nut, and Caramel Bourbon. Every single one I've tried so far has been delicious! Perfectly chewy, marshmallowy, rich in flavor, and so creative. I could've kept going, but my wallet told me otherwise. If you're anywhere near West Allis or up for a roadtrip, this place is a must. We'll definitely be back soon. I think I might even add this to my roadtrip routine. read more

See all

Lets just say that these are so wonderfully good that I overspend each time I go in...because there are so many great flavors available to try all the time. When I told my friends how many I buy at once...not one of them minded ...and they eat them all. Kids have trouble opening their mouths to eat them they are so big! read more

Carrie's Crispies were included in our wedding guest recovery bag. They were so delicious and a perfect sweet addition to the bag!! read more

Carrie's Crispies - Puppy Chow, Peanut Butter Cup - Caterers Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

Carrie's Crispies is a small store with big taste. Of course as the name implies the shop is based on crispy teats and they deliver some unique flavors. The selection is good and the treats are a large double decker size so the price is fair. There are deals such as four for $15.00 and other discount items know as "scraps" which sell for a dollar. The service is always good and store employees are friendly and helpful. They have a club that is free to join and allows the member to get points to use towards future purchases and emails of upcoming promotions and events. The flavors rotate often so there is always a nice variety to choose from. Seasonal flavors are also available. If you are looking for a special treat stop by Carrie's Crispies you won't be disappointed read more

Really good peanutbutter cup is my personal favorite.alot good flavors granddaughter loves fruity pebbles crispy

I have purchased Carrie's Crispies on three separate occasions, including this afternoon. They make awesome gifts for coworkers, friends, and families. They have a variety of flavors and the vast majority of them are gluten-free. They often have seasonal flavors, including root beer float, pineapple mai tai, and strawberry margarita this summer. Both Carrie and her husband, Brian, are really sweet people. Support small businesses! read more

Carrie's Crispies - Carrie's Crispies are perfect for my nursing assistants! - Caterers Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Huge variety of flavors! Super cute establishment and friendly staff meeting! I didn't expect such amazing flavors! Try this place. You won't be sorry. I'm in love with West Allis! read more

I love them so much. The flavors are so delicious. This is my favorite Summertime treat. Yes you can get them all year around but for some reason they remind me of Summer. If you were thinking about buying some of there Crispy Treat...DO IT NOW!!! You are gonna love them too just like I do. read more

New to the gf life so always on the look out for my favorites and especially sweets. I recently was researching rice crispy and treats but no real help. Saw Carries table at the Harvest fest and bought a peanut butter rice Crispie it is pretty darn good. I will be visiting the brick and mortar store soon - read more

Carrie's Crispies - Peanut butter rice crispie - Caterers Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

I tired 3 crispies in one day. The first fruity pebble was everything! Really chewy and just enough sweetness and was my favorite. Then I tried the Reese pieces . That was pretty good with a flavor from the candy. It could use a little more of the candy flavor to make it more sweeter. Then last was cookies and cream. This was also good also. But just like the other one could use more glacier of the cookies n cream to make it a little more sweeter. Overall they were really good and worth trying and worth the price! read more

Carrie's Crispies has the best customer service and worked to create a delicious package of 3 minis for his 3rd birthday. They created the cutest labels and provided bags for the treats. We chose birthday cake, puppy chow and maple bacon for our selection. We received rave reviews on everything. Also had to try their sampler and other flavors. Happy to support woman small local businesses and keep them going especially during COVID. Highly recommend for great treats and gifts as a sweet treat option. read more

See all

Crispie crazieness!!! I love crispie treats but do not always have time to make them. These are not only great they come in fun and fantastic flavors. I cannot choose just one!! They also sell other sugary fun from local confectioners like flavored mashmallows and caramels. read more

Carrie's Crispies - Some of the flavors and sugary snacks. - Caterers Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Not only are the crispie treats beyond amazing in taste, but the customer service is top notch!! I have ordered twice in 8 weeks. and I plan to order many more times!!! HIGHLY recommended!! read more

Great Crispies in amazing flavors. Very cost effective catering. I catered for my daughter's quinceañera and there were so many compliments on the crispies, everyone loved them! I highly recommend supporting this small business! read more

Bought three of these at a craft fair this past weekend and they were delicious. Fresh and flavorful. I decided to look them up online and discovered their business is very close to me. I will definitely buy again. I love the root beer and pretzel. My daughter loved the muddy buddy. read more

Excellent! We had Pumpkin Spice and Carmel Apple flavors for a fall themed engagement party and they were a big hit! They are delicious and Carries Crispies has great customer service, very easy to communicate with. The party trays even came with tongs for serving and covers. Very happy we found this unique catering for our dessert table. read more