We were staying at the Waddington House at Oglebay Resort for the week. We had hoped to have AYLI…read morecater everyday, but they were so busy they could only offer us Tuesday night dinner. We jumped on our chance as quickly as we could!! Our dinner started with a Baked Brie appetizer, Vichyssoise, Mandarin Orange Salad, Green Beans Amandine, and Potatoes Au Gratin. Followed by Chocolate Mousse with Whipped Cream and Raspberries. Bob and his assistant had been up since 5:30 AM, working weddings and special occasions but were able to set-up and serve our dinner with elegance and efficiency. I cannot do justice to how easily they handled my dinner party. Do not hesitate to book this wonderful caterer.

I had Waterfall Catering cater a birthday party for me on 6/14/25…read more Sophia delivered and setup by herself. She was very personable and did a fabulous job. She is a very hard worker. Everyone asked who catered the food it was so good. i will definitely use Waterfall Catering in the future

I had a party catered by Waterfall. The food was sensational, beyond any food I've ever ordered…read morebefore. Every guest was blown away with each and every dish. I'd recommend them highly to anyone wanting wonderful, quality delicious food choices. Renee is just amazing to work with and goes out of her way to help decide how much you'll need and the instructions were perfect! The best caterer in Pittsburgh!

We reached out to Melissa to cater brunch for the bridal party while we were all (~20 of us)…read moregetting ready for our wedding. She was incredibly quick responding and quickly sent over her menus and helped us choose a good variety: bagel bar, mini quiches, pimento biscuits with bacon jam, and mini strawberry shortcakes. She showed up right on time and to our cabin at Oglebay with all the food, and I cannot possibly express in words how good the food was!! The bridal party loved every bit of it and by the end, if I counted right, we had 1.5 bagels and two mini shortcakes left out of a couple dozen of each, Everything she recommended was absolutely perfect, and the food was the perfect thing to start off our wedding day! I STILL dream of those pimento biscuits with bagel jam! All the thanks to Melissa!!

She was very quick with sending an invoice and information about her services. Her food looks great…read moreand the pricing is extremely reasonable and fair. I think she's going to be grateful for my wedding reception!

She brought the food to our hotel meeting room exactly as agreed…read more The food was delicious and there was way too much! No one could eat that much food in one sitting! 11 of us had the shrimp and 3 had the chicken. She included garlic bread, a side salad with dressings, and the meals were individually contained and plasticware was included. Would recommend to all! Robin Richter Architecture Travel Companion, LLC Eustis, Florida USA We used her in Uniontown, PA.

What a great experience!!! Highly recommended and we will use Stewart's Smoking Backyard BBQ again…read morefor our party next Fall. Devan was great to work with on the planning side and he executed on his commitments to provide an amazing meal for everyone at my Fall Festival of Colors event. Prompt communications, timely arrival and departure, and exceeded my expectations on every front. He even came prepared with extra "stuff" in case I didn't have what I committed to provide. The pulled pork was so delicious it didn't need any sauce and the smoked half chickens were moist and tasty. The chicken was so good that even the day after when warmed in the oven they were still juicy moist and had amazing flavor. Support family run businesses like Stewart's!!! You won't regret the service, experience, and flavor of the best BBQ I've eaten in years! THANK YOU for providing a memorable meal for my guests. Everyone raved about how delicious everything tasted. APPLAUSE!

Pulled pork was good. Standard store bought bun. 10 percent fee for using credit card which is…read moreaccessive.

We did the Cooked Goose for our work event. Everything was hot and ready when we picked up. The…read moreemployees were friendly and efficient. Everything went off without a hitch. We did pulled pork, Cajun chicken, macaroni salad, and coleslaw. I really enjoyed the pulled pork. We got three different sauces to try with it as well. The Cajun chicken tasted good, but I was expecting a little bit more spiciness to it. We will definitely look to use the Cooked Goose again for our next needed event.

I was highly disappointed with my experience trying to arrange catering with this company. I am not…read morethe only one from the other reviews. Should have read them before I called. It would have saved me the headache. I was actually recommended to them by several people who have eaten their food, so I reached out hoping to have them cater a 30th birthday celebration. Unfortunately, the experience I had when I called completely changed my opinion. I had questions about pricing, how the catering process works, and what options were available. Instead of taking a few minutes to actually discuss it with me, the person I spoke with repeatedly told me to "look on our website." Yes, obviously I can look at the website. That's not why I called. I called because I wanted to speak with someone, ask questions, understand how the catering works, and make arrangements for an event. I shouldn't have to chase down basic information or feel like I'm inconveniencing someone simply because I'm trying to give the company my business. The interaction was extremely unhelpful and honestly left me wondering how difficult it would be to actually coordinate an entire catered event if getting basic questions answered was already this frustrating. You lost a customer today. And that's especially disappointing because I was referred to you by people who genuinely enjoy your food. Hospitality is about more than the food. It's about how you treat people, especially when they're calling because they want to spend their money with you. If answering customers' questions and helping them through the process is too much, then perhaps catering--and hospitality in general--isn't the right business to be in. I was excited to give this company my business. After this experience, I will be taking it elsewhere.