This visit, I had custard on a cone and some funnel cake fries. For the custard, I got the small size. 2 flavors: Honey Milk & Nutella (swirl) and decided to get a topping: rainbow sprinkles. You have a choice of which cone, so I got the cake cone (it looks like they only have the long one). An employee asked if they could put the cone in a cup as I could see the custard was really soft - it was fine by me. A spoon was provided. As I devoured this custard combination, they were still fixing my funnel cake fries. I got regular and had requested it to go. When I received it (covered in a cup), I decided to try some soon afterwards (while still in the lot). I did notice a big difference from the last time I got the funnel cake fries here. This time, they came out lukewarm and a bit limp - not sure what happened (maybe they had an off day with it). No biggie as I'll just stick to other things on their menu. read more

See all

Their marketing plan worked on me. A friend sent me a social media post saying that my name was one selected for a free small gelati or Italian ice. The two locations that participated were all 30 mins away. Well, I decided to drive as what are the chances my name would be selected. I didn't know this place existed honestly. It was located in the back of Cava Mezze and it was pretty much hidden. It is peaceful even during rush hour. That's the plus side where you can get ice cream or ice during hot weather and just chill outside. They do have some benches around. I had the Arnold Palmer and it was pretty good. Now we know this place exists, I would keep it in mind when our sweet tooth hits. read more

See all

Still my favorite shop for Italian ice and custard! I love getting a gelati with different flavor twists. Lemon cookie custard is one of my favorites and I was so happy to see it on the board last week. Come with an open mind and good eyesight to read the menu from the end of a long line! Only a few seats out front so be prepared to eat standing up or even in your car! read more

See all

Always a Rockville delight to stop at! Always has a line because it's so tasty! I love getting the mango or strawberry ice with the ice cream! Don't forget to pick up a pup cup too! For your furry friend! There's no indoor seating but there are some outdoor seats. Or you could always cross the street to go to the park! read more

Carmen's is what I would ask for as my final meal. The mango ice with vanilla soft serve. The people who work there are so sweet and it's consistently delicious. Devastating I can't bring it back with me to New York read more

Carmen's Italian Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Olney, Maryland

When asked "what is your favorite dessert?" My response will always be Carmen's. Italian ice, custard, ice cream, frozen yogurt, shakes, popsicles, and ice cream sandwiches...They have it all and every single item tastes amazing (even better if you add your own little shot of #winkwink). Tip: They cater to patrons with allergies and special diets (vegan). read more

My family have been loyal Carmen's customers for decades now. We used to drive 20 minutes to their Rockville location, which isn't too far, but when they opened their Onley location, we were so happy! They've expanded their menu a lot over the past few years, but I'be mainly stuck to their ices and custards. My family has also catered from them a few times, and every experience has been positive. Definitely recommend supporting this local business! read more

Carmen's never disappoints!! I'm so happy there is one in Olney, much closer than Rockville :) I got Ube custard and I was impressed at how spot on the flavor was! It wasn't too sweet and it was really creamy. My boyfriend got Nutella custard and ice tea ice, not sure why he got this combo but they tasted great separately. The Nutella custard wasnt too sweet like actual nutella, there was more of a chocolate flavor than hazelnut which I enjoyed. The iced tea was spot on too :) Overall will come again! The cashier was super sweet and welcoming as well. It was a pleasant experience. read more

Carmen's Italian Ice - Ube Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Olney, Maryland

See all

Omg I never had ice this great! This is really incredible! And they have vegan options. WOW! read more

Carmen's Italian Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Olney, Maryland

So excited to stumble on and spot the Carmen's sign that I literally slammed on brakes to stop here after a meal elsewhere around the corner. I had no idea they had another shop. I really liked the Rockville location but remember prices were steeper but worth it. For all those comparing this to Rita's, Rita's prices were not that much cheaper and flavor was just okay, on par with an average popsicle taste. I had mango here and it did not disappoint. It tastes like the actual fruit and wasn't overly sweet. Even though I am not on the vegan or sugar free wagon, think it's cool they offer options for everyone. read more

See all

Best custard around! We visit Carmen's way more than we should. Their custard is the perfect consistency and sweetness. The flavored custards are well balanced and not overpowering. We may have gotten ice a couple times and that had great flavor and consistency too. Service is quick and easy. Parking is plentiful. Great spot of a sweet treat. read more

Carmen's Italian Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Olney, Maryland

WOW! This was an amazing experience! Audrey helped us out this evening and was very enthusiastic to helping us find our favorite flavors!

Once again still my favorite places for a cool treat even day or every other day the favor change so that really is a great way to taste different favor. Today my friend purchased horchata, i purchased half & half sweet tea & watermelon sooooooooo refreshing & my mom purchased Olney orange w/ vanilla custard.....ONCE AGAIN I HIGH RECOMMEND read more

See all

I'm used to frequenting the Rockville location, but I was excited to see the difference at this new location in Olney. I can imagine this place being busy based on the frequency of housing surrounding this shop. I got the cookie dough cookies and creme gelati with salted caramel custard while my sister got the chocolate chip cookie dough gelati with nutella custard. There was not a recognizable difference between the cookies and creme dough and the chocolate chip -- I had no oreo pieces in mine :( I probably wouldn't get the cookie dough again because it is so sweet, but the custard is amazing, creamy, and delicious. Great customer service as well! read more

Carmen's Italian Ice - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Olney, Maryland

Delicious ice cream and gelato, an easy stroll from Cava Mezze. Many flavors to choose from. There are Italian ice and Vegan options. Shaded area and a few benches available. read more

Saw this in replace of Rita's driving by and decided to give it a try. My girlfriend and I got the churros which were super good and crispy. We also got a passion fruit popsicles which are freshly homemade and had lots of flavor. Lastly we got the vanilla custard with the lava cake. The deluxe lava cake custard was pretty good too but I would recommend getting the cake on the side because they put within the custard and it got hard since we didn't eat it right away. The service was stupendous and loved the man helping and giving us suggestions. They have a lot of selections if you aren't feeling Italian ice or custard. Would definitely recommend trying them out and always love to support local businesses! Rita's is kind of overrated anyways. read more

This place replaced Rita's. Overall they have great custard. It is very flavorful and creamy. Both the chocolate and the peanut butter were great. You really can't get better anywhere around here. The mango and cherry Italian ice was also very good. There are cherries in the cherry though did taste a bit more fake fruit flavor than other places . Skip the edible cookie dough- it tastes like flour. My biggest complaint is they offer online ordering but only have about 1/4 of the actual menu listed. I would've just waited in line and ordered there if I had known how many options I was missing out on. read more

Got a small vanilla custard and churros. My churros were soggy inside and undercooked. My custard had a long black hair in it that was given to me by a taller teenage girl with black hair and some highlights. The flavor was also off. Super disappointed as I've loved to come here for the last year, reconsidering my choice. Doubt I will be returning. EDIT: Was also given attitude by staff. So unprofessional. read more

Carmen's Italian Ice - hair. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Olney, Maryland

Really tasty! Flavor is nice and strong. Plenty of flavors to choose from. As good or better than Rita's water ice, in my opinion. I like the cherry, blue raspberry and sour apple so far. Parking is limited but there is a Safeway nearby if you need to walk. read more

I love custard not just regular soft serve ice cream. They have gellati and Italian ice. A wide variety of flavors and creations.

I love this place! The staff are wonderful! I ordered from them on Uber Eats. There was a problem with my order. They were very helpful about correcting the order. The manager and owner were very pleasant to deal with. They went out of their way to make sure that we were happy with our order. I recommend this Carmen's! read more

There are so many great options at this place. It's a go to for us in Olney. I had a shake and the kids had gilatti.

This place reminds me of Rita's and other Philly area water ice stands, but Carmen's isn't quite as good. For Maryland, I would say it's quite good, and what is lacks in texture they make up for quantity of flavors. The last time I was here I ordered a cup of chocolate vanilla swirl custard, and it had a strange after taste, like aspartame or something. The Nutella custard is much better taste-wise. This is a very popular neighborhood spot, with fun promos and lots of options to customize. read more

Two words. Over priced. Italian ice (small) was served in chunks is the best way to describe. Pina Colada had very little taste. I miss Rita's already. Expect to bring lots of money. read more

We were here this afternoon as we have been many times before. My daughter spilled her custard and the wonderful owner (I think) came out and offered her another one. At this point a long line had formed and she, instead of us getting back on line and waiting, just brought one out for her. Not only is their custard delicious, their care and concern is top notch. I love this place! read more

I would have given it a 0 if it was possible! Do not waste your money getting anything at this place. The ices are tasteless & the custard is so galatinous you might as well be eating jello. Our grandson who loves custard said he could not eat it because it was awful. In addition to not being very good the cost is higher than other "icecream" places. read more

I have been going to Carmen's in Rockville since many years ago. I am just happy they finally added a location in Olney and a walking distance from my house. My family and I have been here 3 times already. It's my kids' favorite spot lately. The first time we came, I had the vanilla custard, kids had grapes ice, and hubby got the gelati (vanilla custard and lemonade ice). The second time, I decided to get my favorite gelati (Nutella custard and chocolate chip ice) then kids and hubby got the same from last time. The third time, I saw on their menu the "UBE" which a popular Filipino dessert flavor. I got so excited. So I got the gelati (Ube custard and chocolate ice) which I made a mistake of mixing the Ube with chocolate. I love chocolate but it didn't go well with the Ube. I was skeptical I haven't had an Ube custard just an Ube ice cream. The Ube custard was good! It's creamy, nutty, and not too sweet at all. The color is lighter though it should be a vibrant purple. I wish they have the Ube on their menu everyday. My kids had cotton candy ice, smells good and taste refreshing. The grapes and cotton candy ice are their favorites. They are generous with the proportion. The store has 6 FT social distancing stickers. Employees are friendly and helpful. I recommend Carmen's for custard/gelati and ice. I definitely will come back again. read more

See all

I've been here quite a few times, and loved the Nutella and Salt and Caramel flavored custard. The vanilla with cookie dough or a brownie is also really great. Super sweet so, but creamy and delicious. Service was excellent as well. read more

Waste of time, money and resources. I would expect this terrible eatery to close within the next six months because of its poor quality desserts. It is not fresh, and not satisfying to eat. Spend your hard earned money at better ice cream shops with better products for cheaper prices. Dissatisfying and not tasty, would not recommend. read more

They filled the custard in a cup only on the edges. The center was hollow. It was a cover up job over paid and wasted money. read more

Carmen's Italian Ice - Custard along the edges only. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Olney, Maryland

Amazing custard, Italian ice, dairy free options, and many flavors. Friendly staff who support the community. Our favorite place to go for a treat. Love the Jersey Mocha. read more

The goat. Their peanut butter custard tastes so good in my mouth. There's always a line, but that's expected when you run the local custard game. read more

Had a gift card to use here and got an Italian ice for my son. Overpriced for such small size cups ($5 for a large) and it tasted like the stuff you get from 7-11 or target. It is also a silly location and setup. First and last time here. read more

We had the best experience today!!! Everyone was friendly and wonderful!! We love Carmen's and if you haven't tried it you have no idea what you're missing. read more