Good egg Sammy today but the level of bacon on the thing was quite lacking to say the least; it seems to me as a one employee spot and no customers either. Who knows how long things have been on the shelf, for instance: Halloween gummy-candy faced on the center rack.... I think paying for extra bacon is quite necessary with this place but after that you might have something quite nice as that sandwich was super runny and flavorful. read more

See all

The food is amazing! Grabbed myself a bacon, egg, and cheese and received a generous amount (which is lacking in sandwiches nowadays). The woman working there was very sweet, so overall a great breakfast spot. read more

Super friendly folks here. Very reasonable prices in a cute location away from the main street. Food made fresh to order. BEC (bacon, egg and cheese) sandwiches were yummy and my mom enjoyed her turkey sub. $20.89 for 3 egg sandwiches and a large sub. We'll be back! Parking lot available. read more

After my yoga class I was hungry. I needed to eat. I checked my bookmarks and again I found one I've had for awhile. "Carman Street Deli" is a hidden gem and definitely worth the visit. I almost thought my GPS was wrong, it was taking me down a residential street. But right after a parking lot, I saw the deli. It almost looks like a house converted into a deli, but I found out from Kelly, it use to be a pharmacy. Like I said inside was Kelly, a wonderful fun spirited person. She asked what I needed and after a little back and forward joking, she made my wheat wrap. We talked a little more while she made it and was never without a smile. She made my meal herself to order so it was nice and hot. Kelly pointed out she put a note on it so I knew where the top was (how many places do that for there customers?). When I sat down on the tall boy seating to eat my breakfast I was pleasantly surprised. The sandwich was perfect! It tasted like something you make at home, no commercial flaws. Kelly fried my egg, the bacon was abundant and crispy, she used plenty of cheese and put it all on a wheat wrap! Bravo! Kelly understands that a person impacts customer experience, not the glitz and glamor of a new building. Help support a local business and head there. Try the wrap and see if I'm wrong. read more

See all

Amazing deli!! Hidden gem. My husband and I love this place. Owner is so nice and everything is homemade, and fresh!!!

Great little spot. Came home to NY for the weekend and was looking for a local deli spot to try for breakfast. Got the BEC salt pepper ketchup and it was delicious! Workers were so kind, the roll was fresh, i have no bad things to say about this place. Give this place a try, you won't be disappointed! read more

Stopped in today with the kids to try a new deli in our area, it was exceptional. All the food was fresh and made to order, the service was professional and the prices were on point. I tried the house special JBIII and all I can say is WOW; whoever dreamed up this bad boy has made a believer in me and I can't wait to get another one. To top it all off I treated the kids to fried Oreos™, best I've EVER had...food coma! Thanks again, can't wait to return. read more

See all

the new owner lives up to the flawless carman deli name. He dumped out a whole pot of coffee and made a fresh one for me without asking, and the sandwich was great. read more

Surprised by the variety of things they have neatly stocked in here. It almost seems more like a supermarket. But what keeps me coming back is the breakfast sandwiches. So friggin good! read more

One of my favorite places to eat when I'm on the go, whether it be a breakfast sandwich, a hero for lunch, or even a small snack. The prices are very affordable, and the service is quick. The catering menu has a large variety and calling ahead to have a sandwich prepared is simple and saves me plenty of time. If you're looking for a small mom and pop owned deli, this is the place. read more

Upon moving to this area, I was overwhelmed by all the restaurants in town. It was nice finding this hidden gem deli down the road. The service was extremely friendly & efficient, and the food was top notch. The prices are amazing to boot. I can't say anything negative about this deli. I will continue to be a loyal customer here. read more

I go to this deli all the time and I love it. The prices are more than reasonable and the food is awesome. I also love that they cook anything at anytime and don't give the "we don't do breakfast after 11 am" excuse to not make an egg sandwich is my main reason for coming here at first. I like knowing I can get a burger at 9 am and pancakes at 7pm. The owners/workers are very nice as well l highly recommend if you want a good price deli with great food that isn't limited due to what time it is. read more

Stopped in for breakfast before a softball game in Patchogue. Breakfast sandwiches were yummy. Love to find local businesses that are hidden gems. read more