I went back to Annette @ Wrapping It Up for a second time, after a wonderful first experience. This…read morego-around, she wrapped multiple gifts for a bridal party (beach bag and beach hat). She helped me organize them when I got to the store and was so patient, kind, and helpful (she also helped me carry them to my car!). I loved the nautical touch with the dune grass, rope, and adorable starfish (the creative Annette touch!). Annette is so crafty, while listening to the customer, understanding the theme, and executing it beautifully. She did everything in such a timely manner, as well. I continue to be impressed with this business and will ALWAYS highly recommend to all. We need more gift wrapping services like this on Long Island. If you are nervous about the virus like me, I felt very safe in this store. All CDC guidelines are being followed (masks, gloves, contactless payments, temperature checks, hand sanitizing, social distancing). This is always reassuring these days and it's wonderful to see businesses who care about the health and safety of their customers. Thank you, Annette! P.S. Y'all need to try her chocolate covered pretzels with Reese's M&M's... absolutely delicious. She has a wide array of fresh chocolate on display that you must try!

I love the selection of loose candy and nuts . Pack your own pay by the lb. I've had almost every…read moretruffle and they are all uniquely delicious !! Annete the owner is super sweet and does a fabulous job with custom baskets ! I highly recommend this store for all your sweet treats . The almond bark and chocolate covered pretzels never disappoints !!

What a great place for baking and candy-making supplies. I discovered yesterday that they even…read morecarry Asher chocolates which I have always found to be of high quality. So glad they are nearby.

They have a huge assortment of stuff for bakers and confectioners. I came in here looking for…read moreready-made treats, which they had a small selection of, including store baked chocolate treats and repackaged candies. Staff was really nice as well.

New owners, so they won't accept old gift cards (understandable, maybe) but they're fine selling…read moreproduct leftover from the old owners (really not understandable). Please note the hot chocolate bombs, purchased in December 2025 with the Best By date of May 2025. Had to be on the shelves for two years.

My boys love comi here! i also love that there are different options besides candy! we will…read moredefinitely come bac'

I have been coming here for decades. It has only gotten better over the years! Now that I live…read moreacross the country I often have items shipped to me. This is a GREAT business!

If someone ask u to hold something don't sale it out there name on it an hold it been a customer…read morefor years

We just had our daughters birthday party here. Everyone had a wonderful time. We were very happy…read morewith the party room and activities. All the kids said everything was delicious! Would recommend!

Received chocolate on Valentines Day from this place from my spouse and it was the worst I ever…read morereceived. I would have enjoyed Whitmans or Russell Stover better than the stale tasteless cheap chocolate they scammed my man into buying. Do yourself a favor and go to Emile's in Oceanside for fresh homemade old fashion handmade chocolate. That is where he usually goes but was strapped for time and ended up in this dump which is close to our house.

The Paper Store is just that, more than just a fabulous wide selection of Hallmark cards, gift wrap…read moreand ordiments. This clean, large location has merchandise like Kate Spade and Stanley tumblers, Good Life and local designer clothing gear, bags and more. I go in for cards and come out with something else as well like jewelry, wind chime, yearly calendar block, board games. The staff has always been super friendly and looking to help if you need it. Pricing is fair depending on items selected, and have always been in good condition. Would recommend this location, especially for those who are Hallmark Rewards members like me!

This is in regards to The Paper Store online... Has anyone…read moreelse had problems with items being canceled with no communication from the paper store online? Has anyone else had issues with not being refundef for items NOT received? I'm having such a hard time, and have had zero response to my emails. I've ordered several years in a row and this is the first year I am just disgusted with the online shopping. Did anyone experience the same this year?