Myself, my wife and our friend went here on a Saturday evening. We had reservations but the place was empty. I've been here several times in the summer and the place gets packed. Definitely doesn't hurt to make reservations. The young lady that greeted us was very nice. Our waitress came out very quick after we were sat down. She was very pleasant. Our drinks came out very quick and all 3 were very nice. I had the Carlsberg beer, my wife got the moscato and our friend got the espresso martini. All very good. We ordered the buffalo chicken flatbread and fish tacos. Both were very good. The restaurant was very nice and the bathrooms were very clean. We will be back. read more

Food was good and service was nice! There are different hostesses for indoor vs outdoor seating, which was a little odd but we survived :) read more

Buttonwood Grill - The Plain Jane - New American Near Me - Lahaska, Pennsylvania

See all

The Buttonwood Grill at Peddler's Village was not worth the Hype The burgers were ok the fries were dry and cold ,the cole slaw was dry cabbage served with no dressing the price understandable with the market. I would not go back. read more

I visited Buttonwood Grill while spending the day at Peddlers Village with friends during the Peach Festival. They had some limited-time, peach-themed dishes and drinks for the Peach Festival. We had a reservation, so we shopped a bit while waiting about 20-30 minutes for our table. We split the wings and pretzel sticks. I had a Hugo Spritz (St. Germain, mint simple syrup, prosecco, soda) and the Roasted Butternut Squash Salad with mixed greens, Bibb lettuce, dried cranberries, toasted almonds, goat cheese, and cider vinaigrette. I wished the butternut squash was a little softer. Our waitress was super friendly and enthusiastic. We sat outside on the deck but it was very sunny and hot. While I wouldn't necessarily plan a full meal here, I'd go back for a quick bite or a drink while shopping. read more

Buttonwood Grill - Roasted Butternut Squash Salad - New American Near Me - Lahaska, Pennsylvania

See all

We have been here multiple times, with a large group and just 2-4 people and it's always consistently good. Service and food is wonderful. Prices are fair, especially for being in a major tourist spot at Peddlers Village. read more

Buttonwood Grill - Mahi mahi fish tacos and burger - New American Near Me - Lahaska, Pennsylvania

Food was outstanding. Wait staff were very friendly, food came out fast. Had the peach salad but changed the dressing to citrus honey. My son had the kids pizza and he loved it. My daughter had the Cesar salad would've like more dressing. Husband had Mediterranean burger enjoyed it very much. read more

See all

Food was so delicious! The harvest pasta was so filled with flavor and filling, burgers were juicy and overflowing with toppings. The service was exceptional and I would highly recommend paying a visit when in the area. It was very family friendly and the fireplace is a nice touch! read more

Buttonwood Grill - Harvest pasta - New American Near Me - Lahaska, Pennsylvania

See all

Always very busy. Staff is beyond friendly, or at least our waitress was. The food was prepared in a very timely manner despite the crowd. It cost under $100 for four of us to eat including an appetizers to start. The restaurant is always dimly lit which is odd for a lunch, but the area and the restaurant are pleasant nonetheless. Most places in Peddler's village are very expensive, but for the price this was very fair. We will likely be back to try more soon. read more

Buttonwood Grill - Guinness Onion and Bacon Burger - New American Near Me - Lahaska, Pennsylvania

See all

We requested the pub room for a party of 9! It was a celebration of our marriage with our grown children. It took about 15 minutes to have someone come greet us at the table. Which was after my daughter went to the host stand to ask if anyone knew we were there. Our silverware was then dropped off at the table. Food was good as it always is. I just feel more time can be spent on making the consumer feel like someone wants them there. Silverware should have been clean, rolled and set. And silverware should match! read more

Buttonwood Grill - Unrolled Silverware - New American Near Me - Lahaska, Pennsylvania

See all

Delicious food. Quick service and kind waitresses. I really liked sitting out on the patio, but the bees were unbearable. Next time I will opt to sit inside. They have two different hosts for inside and outside. The wait for outside is longer, which is to be expected. I waited an hour, but we were able to check out some of the shops at peddlers village. read more

Buttonwood Grill - Pulled pork - New American Near Me - Lahaska, Pennsylvania

See all

This place is incredible! We weren't gonna after we walked in, seemed like an "early bird special" kinda crowd. SO glad we did. We met our server, and she convinced the whole table to get burgers and not gonna lie, it was the best burger of my LIFE. Their seasonal drink menu was great too. I tried the cranberry mule and it was a good balance of cranberry and vodka with a little spicy kick. I'm sad this place is on the other side of the state, but I'll be back next time I'm in town! Happy Eating! read more

See all

Sat_11/1/25,Lunch, 1:15pm, 2 adults_Waitlisted when we arrived at 12:30. Seated in main dining rm lower level at 1:10pm. Place was buzzing and packed! Our server (Jillian) was very friendly and took excellent care of us! We drank Caramel Apple Sangria 10/10, Vanilla Cider Mimosa 4/10 (lacked flavor). It was painful to lose $12 on the Mimosa! Started with Carrot Ginger Soup 10/10, Entree for both of us was Harvest Apple Burger (with fries) 10/10. HIGHEST MARKS to the chef and kitchen staff for this food!! It was tough having to skip dessert, but we both were COMPLETELY STUFFED after our feast! Love the pub restaurant atmosphere and we look forward to dining here again!! read more

Buttonwood Grill - Harvest Apple Burger with Fries - New American Near Me - Lahaska, Pennsylvania

We had reservations for lunch for two couples. We were seated in a nice area of the restaurant with windows which seemed nicer than the dark interior tables closer to the restrooms. The menus were dirty and wrinkled like they had been in heavy use. If you can't have clean menus it makes you wonder what else is not clean. It just doesn't set the right tone. Our server Alex was fine. She did what she had to do but never checked on us during the meal. She seemed to be handling several tables so I'm not sure if this is just a staffing issue. Our food was fine- turkey sandwich, tuna melt, burger, and ribs platter. The desserts were really good- salted caramel mousse, chocolate chip cookie, and sticky bun bread pudding. Parking is across the street. Buttonwood was fine but I would try another restaurant before returning. read more

See all

Came here for lunch with my family when we were visiting the area. All the food was OK. My husband got the soup of the day which he did not like and the tacos which he said were eh. I got one of the salads which was satisfying. The kids food was what you expect. we did have to wait a little bit for a table. If you're looking for something to eat real quick with no high standards, this is the place to go. read more

*We spent the day at Peddler's Village and were famished when it was time for lunch. Buttonwood Cafe had a great ambience and was kid-friendly. They didn't give us a hard time about stroller. Great kids meal offerings. * My MIL ordered the Cheddar burger - wrong fries and forgot bacon. Corrected that by bringing potato fries. SP fries were VERY good but not hot when they arrived * Guinness burger - absolutely delicious * Kids grilled cheese with fruit: good even by adult standards * Old fashioned- generous pour * Grilled turkey okeefe style- definitely needed more apples but otherwise great. Got side of honey mustard. Dill potato salad on the side- very good. read more

See all

Very welcoming place as you walk in the the front door. Very spacious place that you are not sitting up on others. And they have a nice size deck area outside. Today was 95 degrees and humid. Air conditioning was very necessary. The staff was friendly and very patient with people. My waitress was really friendly and attentive. The menu has a lot to choose from. I nice children's section of foods I went with my usual cobb salad with chicken and shrimp. Any salad made with Cole slaw is good with me. The dressing added a nice flavor to it. My granddaughter raved about her pasta. So I had to try it. And yes, it was really good for just pasta. The burger was huge and cooked to a perfect need rare. This is a very family style restaurant. Room for big family gatherings if need a place with great food. read more

See all

Buttonwood Grill has great burgers and I love their pickles! Food is a bit pricey to say the least, but that's pretty much most restaurants in peddlers Village... I would recommend if you're in the mood to sit down and enjoy some good American cuisine . read more

Buttonwood Grill - New American Near Me - Lahaska, Pennsylvania

See all

Stopped in for dinner after some walking/shopping around Peddler's Village. We were seated quickly and our request for a different table choice was accommodated which we greatly appreciated. Our table had a nice view through a series of windows out onto the main road of the shops. We ordered three appetizers to get started: Grilled street corn, Mediterranean Hummus, and Baked Soft Pretzel Sticks. The appetizers were excellent, especially the grilled street corn which was amazing. For entrees we had the White Pie, Full rack of BBQ ribs, and the Endive Pear Salad. We also ordered a blueberry cheesecake which was a special item ending today. Dinner entrees were all very good, but not exceptional. The White Pie was a highlight. The ribs were good but lacked depth of flavor in my opinion. Would definitely eat here again and recommend if you're shopping over at Peddlers. I saw a mention of flies in another review and we also had flies buzzing all around our booth while we ate. This is tough to control I'm sure, but it definitely detracts from the dining experience and was part of my 4-star rating. read more

See all

Holy YUMMMMMM! This place must be tried. I'm not even a big burger person, but I had to try one since they're known for them. I was NOT disappointed! First, had to get the onion rings as an app. Perfectttttt!! Gobbled those right up. The Mediterranean burger with the dill potato salad on a hot summer day? PERFECTTTTT! Omg it was seriously the best burger I've ever had. So flavorful. Could only eat half, it was so big. The outside seating is nice and the drink menu is fun too! Will be back again for sure! read more

Buttonwood Grill - Mediterranean burger and potato salad - New American Near Me - Lahaska, Pennsylvania

Food wasn't that great. I had a burger and it was dry. My husband had corn beef and he didn't like it. The waitress did not check on us so I was unable to get a drink refill. The food did the some time to get. It was a busy night with Fire, Frost and Fun going on. I have been to this restaurant before when it was slow during the day for lunch and the food was good but that was a few years ago. read more

Ordered turkey o'keefe, fell apart when i picked it up, soggy bread, looked like a blind person tried to put it together, not edible. Potato salad seemed to consist of day old french fries, mashed potatoes, and sliced fried potatoes held together with some kind of gelotinous goop. Waitress was miserable until time to pay. Disgusting!!!!! read more

Burgers off the chart Service always good Drinks and specials are creative Booth with window seat is the best ambiance Meatloaf is my go to hands down read more

The Buttonwood Grill was a perfect place for our family to have lunch after rafting on the river. There was something for everyone including two kids 7 and 11. Everyone was pleased with their meals. Pasta with marinara, soft pretzel appetizer, fries, pizza, bison burger, turkey burger and a beef burger. Service was excellent. We would definitely go back again. read more

See all

2 people ordered the meatloaf tonight. It arrived at the table looking "very dry"...AND it was..,so we asked the server for more gravy. Bill arrived with a $2. Surcharge for each person for the extra gravy to improve the poor result from the kitchen. My advice...at this establishment send your food back right away and go somewhere else. $29. For dry meatloaf then charge me $2. For gravy to improve it. Bad business imo! read more

We got take out from here for the room. We tried the squash salad, salmon and chicken fingers. It was quick and just fine. Breakfast service the next day was terribly slow. We had pancakes, a skillet and spinach and mushroom omelet. The food was good but service left me feeling upset read more

Beautiful place. Service was fantastic. Our food was fantastic. We shared spinach artichoke dip then each had a burger. Beat burger I've had in a long time. Very flavorful. Special drink was strong and delicious. Can't wait to go back! read more

See all

Great bison burger and potato salad! Service was also on point on a very busy day!! Will be back

What a great place to eat. Arrived just after 2pm and there was no wait. Quickly got a table and the server greeted us and gave us a run down on the specials. Decided on the Kenneth square pizza, order of truffle fries, and some hummus. SO GOOD. The hummus had fresh veggies and was great. The truffle Fries and the garlic aioli was so good I took the aioli home! The pizza was the best. Gorgonzola on top made it even better. read more

See all

this place was a nightmare. We went to peddlers village to enjoy the lights and shops. I thought we could swing by here and get something to eat before we started our journey. We got there and it was a full house (understandable for a Friday night) there's no room to wait in the lobby so you have to squeeze against a wall. We waited about 30 mins and we were then seated next to a screaming baby. Our waitress Liz came to take our drink orders. She was very polite and kind. Well she took our drink orders and was gone for about 10 mins until she came back to deliver them. She left right away and didn't ask if we were ready to order. So another 10-15 mins went by. Finally upon her return, we were able to order. My husband and I both ordered burgers. He got the holiday apple butter burger and I got a regular cheeseburger. I specifically ordered extra cheese because I got mine well done. Well as you can imagine the food came out 45 mins later. My husband was in the bathroom, she sits the food down and ask me if the food was ok...how would I know if you just sat it down?....anyways...my husband gets back and he said his burger was amazing. I took a bite of mine and realized there was no extra cheese. Not a big deal I took a bite and it definitely needed extra. Again no big deal. I'll wait for the waitress to come back and check and I'll ask her to bring out a slice of cheese. Well moral of the story, the waitress never came back until about 45 mins later, my drink was gone and I couldn't eat my burger anyways because I was so thirsty. So my food got cold and I refused to eat it or take it home. When the waitress finally made her return, I asked for the bill and I explained about my burger being incorrect and I had no drink, thinking that maybe she would redeem herself and I could just give her a nice tip. Well, she brings the bill and left my meal that I sent back on there. And that's right you guessed it, left again for 15 mins. Upon her return to pick up the payment I asked her to please take mine off as I sent it back and it was not how I requested. She got super pissy and told me that's not something she can do, her manager has to do it. (So shouldn't you just asked your manager to do it in the first place) common sense to me but whatever. What really set it off for me was when she brought the corrected bill back and threw it on the table instead of handing it to me. I'm not going to say I would never come here again, but I promise you, I won't let a waitress disrespect me when it was something that was easily able to be fixed. Managers. Please tell Liz to be more attentive to her customers, if that was the old unmarried me, there would have been a different outcome. Super unprofessional and inattentive! read more

This was pretty standard grill food-some interesting combinations. Was surprised to still see many butternut squash options on the menu in June, but I like butternut squash and it was a rainy day. Was happy to be able to get a naked turkey burger. It was a just a bit dry but the Mediterranean toppings did help. Also got a house salad, and enjoyed the vinaigrette but it was so thick and creamy, it was hard to use it as a dressing. read more

Had a nice dinner here. Loved the deck, but the flies & bees were really bad, so the staff graciously moved us inside with a view of the deck. Service was excellent overall. Appetizer of pretzel sticks with jalapeño beer cheese was on par. We had the grilled mahi mahi fish tacos which were amazing and the burger was awesome! Wasn't overly crowded so they let us sit for quite a while since our show at the Winery didn't start for hours. As it got more crowded, we paid our check to give someone else the table, but the waitress still said, no rush! We sat back out on the deck for a while and had another drink until that got crowded too. Great experience, good food and warm, friendly atmosphere! read more

We came here for lunch on our trip to Peddler's village. The atmosphere was very warm and inviting. The staff were very attentive and the wait time was reasonable. We both tried the Bison burgers and they were delicious. We are looking forward to coming back sometime with some friends. read more

4 adults for lunch and the waitress took us to a very noisy section of the restaurant so we asked to move to the back of the section where it was quieter with open tables but she refused to sit us there! We left the section for a different room with open tables and still told no we couldn't sit there! The hostess was terrible and they didn't want our business apparently so we left and they didn't care! Horrible customer service! We ended up having a delicious and wonderful lunch at Earls and were treated so graciously we will be a repeat customer! read more

Never been to Peddlers Village and decided to stop at Buttonwood for lunch. There was a long wait but I managed to snag a sit at the bar. The bartenders were very friendly and made you feel welcome. After reading the menu the three meat burger blend caught my eye. It has brisket, short rib and beef and it was amazing! I asked for medium and it was cooked to temperature and so juicy. It came with a choice of side and i picked the potato salad. It wasn't the best I've ever had but good. I should have got the fries after seeing them on another diners plate. lol. Great place to dine while in Peddlers Village. I would visit here again. read more

Buttonwood Grill - a bar with a television in the background - New American Near Me - Lahaska, Pennsylvania

See all

We had a nice dinner with our friends at the Buttonwood Grill. Our meals consisted of hamburgers, onion rings (excellent), clam chowder and salads. Atmosphere was nice. Plenty of parking across the street. Take credit cards. Large bar area with plenty of beers on tap. Service was prompt and friendly. We would go back again for sure. Not overly noisy. We all had a nice time. read more

Family friendly. Food is also vegetarian friendly. Our server was attentive. The only downside is that this place isn't open late, ie after 9:30 pm on weekends. read more

See all

Fiancé and I had a date night at this wonderful restaurant! There was a wait, but we were able to go to the stores near the restaurant to pass time. We started with the Onion Ring appetizer that came with a parmesan sauce and it was absolutely delicious! The onion ring batter was well seasoned and it did not fall apart easily. When you bite into each ring, the onion did not come out of the breading which is a huge plus! I had the meatloaf and fiancé had the Grilled Turkey O'Keefe style sandwich. The meatloaf was phenomenal and out of this world. It was probably the best meatloaf I have ever had and the mash potatoes that came with it was smooth and well prepared. If you are in the area, definitely visit this restaurant and the stores that surround the restaurant. read more

Buttonwood Grill - Meatloaf entree - New American Near Me - Lahaska, Pennsylvania

See all

Cannot wait to go back. Food was done to perfection and the waitstaff is even better. Finally have a flawless meal at last. No wait on a busy Saturday ( they were packed and found us a table pronto) ticket times were short, food was hot and done perfectly. Our waitress was a superstar. Looking at other dishes for other table made me want to comeback for more. As crowded as it was, i was still able to have a nice conversation with mu wife. Great atmosphere I will be back and very soon read more

Found ourselves at Peddlers Village browsing through the store getting hungry. Luckily there were restaurants with good reviews making the decision tough as to where to go and we picked Buttonwood Grill. Was looking for a place for a cold beer to go with lunch and they had a decent selection on hand. What really won me over was the fact they had Coastal Evacuation? A double IPA, from Cape May Brewery in Tap. Definitely one of my favorite Brereries and beers so my meal started off on a really high note. The menu had a decent selection to chose from and we ended up ordering a burger a d the pulled pork sandwich. I will say I saw hot sliced cherry peppers on a different burger and requested them on my plain burger. All to often, these simple request are often dismissed. However my request was easily accommodated and a great compliment to my burger. Beer was cold, service was great, and the food was tasty. A great meal all around. We were able to be seated as soon as we entered, and our drinks were served and food came out in a reasonable time and we were back to shopping in no time. If you find yourself in Peddlers Village or passing through, you may want to check this place out. read more

See all

We decided to come back for a third time with family and while I appreciate them being open and all during covid, today must have been an off day for them. For drinks we ordered the orange Creamsicle & peeping it real. The peeping it real tasted like juice, tasty with a cute peep decoration. The orange Creamsicle was pretty standard. It was ok. Our guests had water and beer. The mystery kids had apple juice and chocolate milk. Ordered the salt & pepper calamari again and it wasn't crisp, it lacked flavor. No pepper or salt at all. Just bland and not fried enough to achieve the crispy effect. So a thumbs down on that one. Our guests ordered the shredded chicken quesadilla which they said lacked flavor. Very sad to hear this. They also ordered burgers and they liked them so that was a good thing because that was what we came for anyways! Mystery man got his usual Mediterranean burger and he enjoyed it. Mystery kids had the pasta with butter & parm with a fruit cup, as well as the chicken fingers with French fries. Much of the fruit was inedible. Everything else was pretty standard. Thumbs down for gross fruit. For myself I ordered the pulled pork sandwich and thought it was ok. For my side I ordered the sweet potato fries and they were good. But they're fries. I think I would come back if I wanted a burger, but really only stick to the burgers when ordering from here. read more

See all