I was part of a large group on Sunday morning. The restaurant was crazy busy, but service was excellent. Food was awesome. Everyone's meals were enjoyed and there were 8 of us. The negative reviews I read are nonsense. This place was packed but service was friendly and responsive. Food was tasty, hot, and delicious. I recommend Butters. Make a reservation if you plan to go on the weekends. read more

I've been here a few times now and each time I've left saying I won't be back. After this time I told my boyfriend to remind me not to go back. The service is good, but the food is not. This time I ordered the Butters Bennys, poached eggs on a croissant with hollandaise sauce and home fries. I remembered when they brought my plate that I didn't like the home fries last time because they just don't taste good at all. They look and taste like they were made the night before and reheated during the day. That wasn't the worst thing out of this meal, though. The hollandaise sauce was spicy! Hollandaise sauce is only supposed to have a pinch of cayenne pretty much for color. You should not taste the cayenne in hollandaise sauce! Now they did offer to change my meal, but I declined. However, I was not able to eat it. I tried to, but it was just too spicy. You would think that they would remove it from the bill since I only had a few bites, but they did not. My boyfriend did enjoy his French toast and scrambled eggs. So between the good service and my boyfriend enjoying his meal, I give them 2 stars. read more

We've given this place a try twice since we had a gift card. First time it took so long to seat us and once we got seated it no one ever came to take our order or greet us. So we walked out. This second time the wait was about 30 min to get a table when they weren't busy and were empty tables. Once we got seated it was another 30 min until they took our order. The food was horrible! It was cold and flavorless. The chilaquiles were so soggy and cold. The pancakes and eggs were so cold. The cups were dirty. Definitely don't recommend them at all!!! Save the money and go elsewhere!! read more

Overall, Butters food and atmosphere is pretty good. However, I had a terrible experience today. Our waiter, Jose, was inattentive. He stood at the bar and chatted with his coworkers while we waited 20 minutes for our check. He never checked in with our table for refills and when a cup of water spilled, several staff members ignored the issue. The service must severally improve before I consider returning. read more

Third and last visit. I tried giving them a chance since 1st two visits were on busy weekend mornings, but today's visit was a Tuesday at 9am and maybe only 5 tables full, still took well over an hour to get breakfast, AND the food still came out cold like it had been sitting in back. Waiter stood behind the bar mist of the time looking at his phone. Won't be back for a forth chance. read more

I've been here a few times and today was likely the last sadly. I got the Benny's Benedict and discovered I was chewing egg shells within my first few bites. I decided to work around it and continue eating to avoid wasting it. I proceeded to find a hair which was cooked into my other egg. We let our server know and she just said "Ok...?" and said the hair could be anyone's. I found this interesting as a server. Anytime someone finds a hair, our restaurant tends to comp the entire meal or offer to get a new one made. She ended up taking off $7.00 specifically for the egg shells since they "don't do anything for hair." I understand mistakes happen and nothing is expected to be perfect but I do wish the situation was handled better. read more

10/10 recommend! The mimosa tower is The service and food were delicious! And the ambiance was here is poppin! read more

Everything about this breakfast place was delicious. Server was super nice. It's like everyone in Colorado is just so nice! I have yet to meet anyone rude asf! I got just a basic breakfast sampler type meal. Eggs are over medium with home fries bacon and sausage and I threw on a French toast. The French toast was perfect. Fluffy and had just the perfect taste. Almost didn't need syrup. read more

See all

Service was awesome. Food was incredible. My daughter had The Ricky breakfast sandwich. Best breakfast sandwich ever. Croissant, ham, bacon, egg, avocado, cheese, special hollandaise sauce and tomato. I had a regular breakfast: eggs were perfect and sausage was best I've had. I'm very picky about sausage. read more

The food and service were great. I do miss the patio though. Sitting outside and having breakfast was an enjoyable experience

I would not recommend this place. Even though they are advertising "new location and remodeled", this place was disgusting! I should have walked out as the dining room was so dirty, I began to wonder what the kitchen/prep area might look like. The wait staff never bothered to pick up and discard a napkin that was used to clean our table even though they visited the table 4 times (once to take the order, deliver the food, once to refill coffee after having to ask, and lastly to bring the check). The floor around and under the table, as well as what I observed while leaving, including the host station was just as bad, if not worse, than what can be seen in the pictures attached. Had I noticed how dirty the dining room was before being seated, I would have left. The service from the time I entered to the time I left was poor. I was in a party of two and was told it would be a 10-15 minute wait. After waiting 20+ minutes and having observed that two parties of 3 individuals each were seated before us, I inquired about our placement on the list. I was told that they had to wait until a table for 2 was available as they could not seat a party of 2 at a larger table. I am in my 60's and this is the first time I have ever heard of such a policy. Once I was seated, had requested that our party of 2 be seated in the next available location regardless of table size, the waitstaff only stayed long enough to take the order and return with the bill. The busser brought out the food and upon request refilled the coffee. Until management changes and/or the owners demand that their employees are trained appropriately, I will not recommend or return to this restaurant. read more

See all

Friendly staff and good service. Husband had fresh French toast. My breakfast was inedible. Absolutely awful. I got hockey-puck biscuits barely warm, watery gravy, rubber scrambled eggs and dried burned bacon. I think it was a left over from the day before. So bizarre. read more

Tried to make a reservation but I wasn't able to so my party of 7 walked in and put our name on the wait list. We were seated in the time the hostess told us and had a server at our table immediately. Let me tell you, the food was AAAAMMMAAZZEEE-ING! Eggs cooked perfectly medium like I ordered, omelets were large and tasty. The French toast was mouth watering and I would definitely drive 2 hours to eat at Butters again. This is a hidden gem in Greeley and one that everyone must try, keep it up team!! read more

Service was great, smiling and polite. Ambiance was good, once the music was turned down to a reasonable level. The food..... order came out warm, not hot. Sourdough bread was great! The "bacon" in the Cali omelette is still a bit of a mystery to us?? It was not a traditional strip, rather a ground up rendition of it. The 2 for 1 coupon helped, but we most likely will not be back. read more

I have had breakfast here in person s few times now, and it is always delicious. The coffee is hot and delicious, and if you're brave enough for the mimosa tower, it's a statement piece (and they let us take the leftovers home, though we were prepared to camp out for a while to finish...). They can get busy on weekends so either show up early, make a reservation, or expect a wait. The service isn't speedy, but genuine people with kind personalities are working with probably never enough staff. I would not take a hungry toddler here without a snack or something on hand. That said, everything we've had has been delicious. Pancakes, waffles, Benedicts, omelettes, scrambles, biscuits & gravy, green chili... all winners for us overall. We are keeping Butters in our restaurant repertoire. read more

Service, food and drinks were all great! Well worth the wait for sure. Looking forward to my next trip to Greeley so I can go back.

Placed an order for pickup. Called the store to confirm the time and they assured us they would confirm as soon as order was done. Nearly hour later order not confirmed. Go in store and it has clearly been ready for some time. Food was cold and they never confirmed the order. We confirmed and refunded. It's a shame, their food is good but increasingly their service has gotten worse. This is the third time in a row we have gotten food from them and it has been cold or barely warm. Unfortunately think we're done with butters. read more

I recently ate here while on vacation in Colorado. They didn't have a negative star or I would have posted that. The salmon patty was undefinable, eggs hard cooked, hash browns extremely greasy. Who orders salmon patties on Eggs Benedict? What you see is what I could not finish, it was so bad. Oh, the spinach was edible! I should have known better! I highly recommend driving right by this restaurant and searching out something better. Anything, including a drive thru eatery would have been more appealing! Just saying! read more

Butters Breakfast & Lunch - Worse Salmon Eggs Benedict ever! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

The food is decent and the menu is ok. The noise. It's so loud. The acoustics are horrible. Service was great.

Absolutely awesome food and great service! My new favorite breakfast place. Relaxing atmosphere and they accomodate canine companions (outside). read more

Butters Breakfast & Lunch - Veggie omelet, hashbrowns, and a side of biscuits and gravy. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

The new location seems smaller than the other location. Very noisy, it was hard to have a conversation at our table. Food is good. Had to ask for refills in coffee, and they did not have a carafe for hot water for tea. $4.00 for a cup of coffee read more

Ordered door dash and my Benny came with no hollandaise or the fruit, very dry . Don't understand how restaurants can short people ‍

Or waiter was great, his name is Travis. Our food was was so so. The hash brown are in the form of a cup kinda like the scoop when you went to elementary school and they were cold. The menu price says one thing your charged another. For instance coffee show $3 but your charged $4. Not sure I will be going back. They don't sweep up the messes the previous patrons made. Felt not clean. read more

See all

Food and service in really bad the staff is slow and unfriendly do not recommend this place to anyone

Giving these folks another star. Since my first review a year ago, they've revamped their menu so it's not so overpriced, and items are no longer a la carte. i was able to order two butter pancakes for $6.99, and they came with two eggs and hash browns - so I had sides plus better pricing than a year ago. That's a very nice improvement and I will likely come back here more often - the sticker shock from the first visit had kept me away for so long.... About the food - good! Eggs and hash browns were nice and had a very light tangy, smoky flavor from their grill. I really liked it. The pancakes are good -- very, very rich. I could only eat one. Service was very friendly and very good. Short note about my ratings for other Yelpers: * 3-starts means "A-OK". That means - in accordance with Yelp - I like this place and will come back and dine again, expecting a good experience. ** Just because I like a place and favor it does NOT mean I throw five stars down. There is a REASON there are 5 levels of rating. This is not a bipolar world. There exists nuance. To those who are bad at math or who think anyone 'good' is entitled to a trophy, I say, pound sand, loser. *** If you think only places with 5-star ratings are worthy of your patronage, that's your loss. read more

I will start by saying I enjoy eating at Butters. Today the food was delicious as well, the reason for the review is the experience. Our waitress was polite and took our orders. The issue was the service after the food was received, waited over 20 minutes after we were done eating and at that point was running late back to work from lunch, had to go to the counter to get the check. I want to also state the place was super empty, maybe 4 tables. Should not take that long! read more

Very long wait time for a table. We got burgers but the meat didn't taste fresh and it was pricy for what we got. When we tried to use a coupon the server was very curt. Won't be a go-to place for us. read more

Thank you Heather for your rock star service and incredibly delicious recommendations! Our food came out fast and perfectly hot. Everything was delicious and cooked just as we requested. The mimosas... GET THEM This was our first time here, and we always can't wait to come back! Amazing service and tasty food! Thank you!!! read more

Butters Breakfast & Lunch - Butters XL with bacon, stuffed French toast, and a side of biscuits and gravy - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

I've been a customer of Butters for a few years, now. I have to say that it's going downhill, lately. Their food is great, when it's hot. I don't know if it's the owners trying to save money and not staff enough people to adequately run the restaurant on a weekend, or if it's the younger generation not showing up to work, but they were WAYYY understaffed. And to charge $4 for a cup of coffee (this is Greeley, not Aspen), I'm going to assume it's the owners trying to get more money. I had to, practically, beg my waiter for refills of coffee. To sum up, It's a good place when they aren't busy. Try on a weekday morning. And get plenty of coffee to justify the price. I won't be back till they adjust their prices. read more

I was a little hesitant to come here after seeing the bad reviews but I'm SO glad I gave them the benefit of the doubt. Everything was awesome! The service was awesome, got the food very quickly and our server had 6 full tables. Food was really good and I loved my berry pancakes. Our coffee was good too. Highly recommend and would definitely come back! read more

Showed up on a Saturday morning around 8:15am. Place was about 1/3 full. We were greeted with less than friendly hostess who directed us to a seat. We then sat there for more than 20 minutes without an acknowledgement from any sort of wait staff for as much as a drink order or a "I"m swamped and the only waitress working" so we left and went somewhere else. On our way out we were greeted with a monotone "have a good day" with little concern as to why we left. We've been here before and they have some very unique breakfasts but I don't think we'll be returning any time soon. read more

Absolute garbage from the start! Myself my wife and mother in law stop by for a later brunch. First thing walking in one waitress I heard say "ugh another one" same waitress who I saw later kicking a cup drying rack along the floor back to the kitchen. Now our waitress herself was decent. I ordered biscuits and gravy with hash browns and two over easy eggs. The biscuits were hard and old, gravy was for sure old and thrown in the microwave along with the soggy hash browns. Gravy was also discolored from sitting out so long. Now for the eggs which were the only thing made fresh on my plate. They weren't bad until I cut into my second egg and it shot out water at me. Not sure how that happens, never experienced squirting eggs before. So in all would never go back or recommend this place to anyone. read more

The food was ok but not that ok!!!! U know what I mean!!! My wife waffles was day my country fried steak the gravy bomb but steak hard!!!!! But we were there from California!!!! Could have been better than the server took for ever to serve us read more

I just don't think I'll be returning. I don't know if it was the time I went but the food and service were just not up to my expectations. I got the huevos rancheros and it was sub par. The only good thing was the mimosa tower read more

Got some pancakes and side of hashbrowns to go from here. There was nothing wrong with the employees or service. The pancakes were okay. I wasn't happy with the hashbrowns at all. $4 or so for a side of hashbrowns??? They weren't even seasoned at all... not even as basic as salt or pepper... its also like they were just put in the microwave because they were not crispy either... wtf kind of hashbrowns were those? I didn't even get ketchup or anything for it either... wish I could get my money back. I dont think i will be returning. read more

I have visited this restaurant twice. Both times the food took a very long time to prepare, over 45 minutes after ordering. The service was also terrible. Not only does the food take a long time to prepare but the staff also won't stop by to check with you and see how things are going or if you are in need of anything. I think the staff avoids you because they try and avoid complaints. Unfortunately if you you can't handle bad experiences upfront, you usually end up with a bad review online. I rarely write poor reviews but I would not visit this establishment looking for good service or your food prepared in a timely manner. read more

It was good for breakfast. Might be the best spot in Greeley, however it doesn't compare to the real great breakfast spots in Denver or Fort Collins. Big portions here! Get ready to eat lots. The pancakes are the must have here. They are so big and really tasty. The selection they have makes this place a bit above average and better than other similar spots for breakfast. read more

Butters Breakfast & Lunch - Mama Mia Pancake - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

See all

Food is fine, but that's not the problem here. Our experience with the waitstaff was not great, to say the least. Simple things like getting silverware, clean cups, or even just getting the check took 10 times longer than it should have. We didn't come in when it was even busy, but we were there for 2 hours. My friend's request for silverware wasn't even ever fullfilled and we had to go ask for it. You're food will be fine, but dont expect decent service. Go to IHop instead. read more

Butters is a mediocre place to get breakfast or lunch but I would read the menu thoroughly and ask questions about the costs of items. I came here with some friends for lunch and I chose to get the butters xl dish. I read in the description that you could add hash browns for 4 dollars and read that you could add waffles or pancakes for 1 dollar. So I ordered two extra waffles. Upon receiving my check, I noticed that I was charged $8 for each waffle. I asked the waitress why this was and learned that I had misinterpreted the menu. The waitress kindly removed $10 from my bill for my confusion but I don't believe that you should have to ask the staff what the menu means exactly to understand the pricing of items. The waitress was kind and thoughtful but this restaurant is overpriced for the content that they serve and seem to only care about the bottom dollar, based on my experience with their menu. I would not come here again but if I did, I would make sure to ask the price of each item I was interested in. I am currently having a challenging time financially as a graduate student and having to pay for a breakfast that is more expensive that I expected it to be is particularly stressful. read more

Service is terrible. I watched a waitress treat a family horrible. The waitress also waited on us so we were nearby watching when things got heated. This waitress skipped over our table so many times. It was more of a quick checkup more then actually asking if we needed anything. But I heard this waitress forget some of their food. Then she said she would fix the bill. Because of all the mistakes and her not being a decent waitress, she made the whole dining area uncomfortable or a show. I felt so bad for this family. No one should have been treated like that for slow service, a waitress barely there and their food being messed up. Because of this, I'm not going back and I advising my church group about it. This isn't the way service should be even if they are having a bad day. read more