This review is for take-out as I was TAPPED out after freshman orientation and the heat. Let's…read morestart with why it is 5 stars when I'm going to make some critical comments....the reason? The burger was that good. Because I want to end on a positive, let me start with negatives: the fries were okay. Normally these are a side dish not worth mentioning but this restaurant makes them a star with a fry menu. ( I humbling suggest they try frying in beef tallow to make it a whole other fry experience). The other critical comment is my French onion soup (on take out) was really cold and we weren't late nor (but for the fries) anything else cold. To give you reference, I microwaved for 1 minute and was still cold and did another 1:30. But it was delicious. Now, why 5 stars? The burgers. My son and I both got the Lancaster burger with horseradish mayo on the side and substituting wagyu. It was heaven. It was perfection. We still think and talk about that burger and any food that makes you miss is worth 5 stars!

5 Star. 10/10…read more Highly Recommend. Best burgers in State College. Add in the experience with the Table Fries (everything fries taste like a Middleswarth Chip) the food here is top notch. One of our favorite stops in State College to meet up with family. Service is quick, the staff and waitress were helpful on suggestions and keep it real with you regarding what they like/don't like. The setting with the fireplace and views of the golf course and lake are beautiful. Love this spot. If you are heading to State College, give it a go!

My son treated me to lunch here, after I helped him pick up some furniture he purchased in…read moreGettysburg. It's a small pub that offers excellent burgers, sandwiches and wraps. I had the smokehouse burger. I ordered it medium rare and it was served exactly how I ordered it. It was pink, moist, juicy and not over cooked. The burger was not a frozen or preformed patty. I could see the patty was hand formed. We were sat immediately at a table not far from the kitchen. Each of the dozen or so tables comfortably sits four people each. Our server was friendly, cheerful and attentive. There is a bar in the main dining area serving liquor and beer. In the back of the bar is a pool table and an outdoor patio also with a bar and several tables, offering a great way to eat and relax outside. There are two bathrooms, one inside the restaurant and the other is outside by the patio. The one by the patio is a little cleaner and better maintained. Burger prices are a little on the high side, averaging between $17.00. However, you are getting a superior burger. Street parking can be a bit of a challenge due to the restaurant being located in downtown Gettysburg. Parking is free on Saturdays and Sundays until 1 PM. This is a nice local pub to meet up with friends and family for a casual eating experience I recommend giving this joint a try. The qualitu of the burgers alone make it worth while.

First I'll say that the service here was top notch. We…read morewanted to dine indoors since the weather has been hot and muggy, but, once we entered the dining room , the dampness and a musty smell made us opt for the albeit uncomfortable but still the better option. I should've left and found another option altogether. We both ordered burgers (of course), his a bacon cheeseburger with fries and coleslaw, mine a patty melt on rye bread with Swiss cheese, fries and coleslaw. Both medium rare. Both came out medium well, no coleslaw, one invisible slice of cheese on each burger and white bread instead of rye on my patty melt. The grilled onions actually looked more like onion jam and the trays with black/white checkered paper this is served on looks like it's never seen a sponge or water. No, I can't recommend this place.

Well i must say- I don't usually do reviews- HOWEVER- IM a Believer now..the burger taste like it…read morecame from my kitchen...and the fries were Yummy as well. Special note to the young lady at the register- very pleasant and helpful. Will be back if I'm ever in this area again...!

Had an All meat OMELET this morning! It was awesome!! I also had Some fries with Onions and…read morePeppers!

Been here only twice now as I rarely eat out because of my celiac. Great food. The Gluten Free…read morebun is the best I have ever tasted. Asked a couple of times today, but could not get the brand name of that bun. They have a separate fryer so the fries are GF as well. The waitress is great and the kitchen staff that brought out our food was lovely as well. Highly recommend this restaurant

Solid burger spot. Pick what kind of burger and what you want on it off a sheet of paper…read more Allergen info: they offer gluten free buns and their fries are GF. Basic GF bun. Held together decently well Food- the burger was cooked well. Wasn't all that seasoned. Bacon was a little under for my liking. Fries again were decent but nothing special. Overall a solid but not great burger at a pretty good price point

Small place but the food was to DIE for! Wasabi mayo was a great addition to a double burger and…read morethe kids loved the hot dogs and fries. The dumpster fries were so good, too. Staff was friendly and checked in even though they don't actually "wait" on the tables. Will definitely be returning!

Stopped for lunch again as the burgers are always good and this time the fry's were much better…read morethan the previous time.

Great spot…read more Understaffed, but they get it done. Cook is great. Beet salad was fresh. Dry rub wings great! Ranch is decent. Nice locals! I had a few local brew Trail IPA hazy #Tiptop

We were here @ 5 yrs ago while driving from Chicago back to NY. Was @ 2000 n near bellafonte PA n…read morehungry n found this restaurant on yelp n had no choice but to have dinner . Was the only restaurant open on a Sunday nite . Great choice n food was amazing. Fast forward 5 yrs n today we were Driving to Pittsburgh n going thru bellafonte n thought we'd go back.so stopped by. Friendly welcome staff not v fancy but clean restaurant. We ordered the tomato bisque, chili w corn bread, beet salad n Brussels sprouts. The chili w corn bread was v tasty n just enough for one person. . The best salad w red n golden beets had nuts goat cheese, greens n a nice dressing n generous portions for 2 to share. The Brussels sprouts was crispy , had bits of bacon n tasted good. On the way out saw these giant chocolate chip cookies by the cashiers desk n it looked good v soft . They had baked it the previous day. Oh my was so good, Thank u for a great lunch. Will come back again when we r in the area.

I think most burger joints taste the same, but I really enjoyed the burgers here. I got the…read moreSteakhouse burger and it was very well-seasoned. My friends also really enjoyed their burgers. I have to say, Odd Fellas is definitely one of the better burger joints I've been to. The "Little fella" size is a slider. Their "Regular fella" size is a regular burger size. The "Big fella" is larger than the regular size. I've been told that they switch out their menu every once in a while. Right now, they have a burger called "Hello, Newman". I know you just read it in *that* tone. Haha. Anyways, great burger spot to stop by.

This place has been around for a while now, I will say the food is actually really good. If I were…read morerating based on the food it would be 5 stars. However, this restaurant is so dirty. The floor looks like it has not been swept since it opened and the man working the counter was on his phone from the time we walked in, till we left. Prices are a bit higher but I think they are fair given the amount of food you get and how good it is. The table was sticky and the floor was also sticky. Probably also why it looked so dirty. Overall I think the man at the counter should get off his phone for at least 5 minutes to sweep the floor. I'm all for acting your wage, but there is a line and if the floor is that gross at least pick up a broom and mop. There was also a hair in the food but lowkey it happens sometimes and that's not really the worst thing ever I guess. Just a note.

Great food good prices very friendly staff with tables on site to enjoy your meal before it gets…read morecold

The food was delicious! My family loved the vibe they had. Our server was awesome and we tipped her…read more5 dollars! Will come again.

Awesome food, quick service even though the food is quality! The diner is clean and spacious. The…read moreowners were so helpful. They have a great program for kids after school. They offer them a discount and will even help them with their homework. It is great they provide a place for them to be social and thrive.

This is your average diner. Great name, friendly staff, average burgers. My spouse is bummed that…read morethere were no references to the TV show Dexter's Laboratory. Great name for a burger joint. We were the only one in the restaurant for a good stretch and found that to be surprising at 6 pm on a Wednesday. They were also almost out of ice cream, many sodas, and chili fries. That added to the 3 stars.

Friendly staff, quick service, and delicious meal! Will definitely be back in the futureread more

Best burgers around. 4th street is where it's at…read more.. You don't come to Irwin hungry and not stop at Burgher Burger. After lunch, you stop by Millers and Feathers for personalized shopping, then grab some Ice cream at McFeelys on the way out!