This place was busy when I got in to place a takeout order. Maybe because it was a BOGO Boneless wings Thursday and the time I got there which was just before 6pm. But, the service was great regardless of the wait time. Got my orders right and as soon as I placed my order, it was out within 10 minutes. read more

Buffalo Wild Wings - 15 Boneless Wings BOGO Thursday 8/31/2023 - American Near Me - Sidney, Ohio

See all

The food was good. Really good and I will admit that. But the service is terrible that it makes the food terrible. For starters I will give them the benefit of the doubt. It was BOGO night and there was a large group of people who came in. But they left a table dirty for well over 30 minutes and do not even get me started about how they did not give us refills. There was a whole table of empty cups so we just refilled our drinks ourself because the people do anything but their jobs here. Also I was charged a whopping 18% for gratuity because we had over 10 people in our group. I understand that but 18% of my bill when all I ordered was 6 boneless wings and a lemonade on BOGO night?? They used to be good but their workers don't work. This place is beyond saving! read more

Buffalo Wild Wings - 12 honey BBQ boneless wings - American Near Me - Sidney, Ohio

Fire the manager! Understaffed for the volume of customers on a Saturday night. Two bartenders ( one very pregnant) trying to make drinks for the entire restaurant and a full bar, plus do all the dishes, while two girls sit at the front desk and talk and watch YouTube. BWW take the franchise from this dump read more

Food wasn't great or good, but not terrible. Atmosphere was horrible. Service was awful. New to this town and yet to find a solid restaurant

Scheduled pick up for 11:20. Arrived at 11:20. No one came to register until 11:27. They gave a lot of pickups not ready - what's the point of scheduling a pick up. 11:47 and they just came out to tell me that they don't have an order for me. I showed them the email confirmation of my order. Horrible management EVERY TIME I come. It's a shame that my family and co-workers like the food. Order just came cold and wrong. This would be a great location to open a restaurant. read more

Over priced bar food and slow service. It was 10 minutes before being greeted and over 50 minutes waiting on food. We did have a good server that recognized the delay and brought a couple extra wings. read more

Best nachos ever and great fries good service and good food it's a bit pricey though

I ordered BWW's tonight since it was BOGO for their traditional wings. Besides 4 different style of wings, I also ordered cheese curds. I've only eaten at this location one other time, typically I eat in Marysville. This one is closer to my home though. I placed my order on the app. I arrived to the store 10 minutes early and figured I'd have to wait but my order was ready. Glad I didn't wait until closer to pick up time. While waiting for the hostess to bring my food up, someone came from the kitchen and walked around/messed around the register maskless I always love to get carrots & celery from BWW but don't do it at this location. Other locations buy carrots and cut them. This location just dumps some baby carrots out of a bag. Baby carrots don't taste as good as regular ones. The celery was discolored and looked like they had been frozen. They were so wet that by the time I got home, the bottom of the celery container had fallen apart. I didn't take a picture of the cheese curds because I ate some on my way home. They were good. Not even warm but they tasted okay. The wings though are the biggest disappointment. They are so dry and some of the drums only had meat on one side of the bone. And they're small. I ordered four sauces, only one was a dry rub but they were all dry like they were dry rub. The next time I'm wanting wings, and I'm driving to Sidney, I'll try one of the many other options. read more

See all

So I went to Buffalo Wild Wings to give them another try. I ordered six traditional wings and a large order of fries to go. The pictures are what I came home with 6 tiny dried out flats and a handful of fries (supposed to be large basket). Note the size of the wing compared to the quarter. At $2 a wing, I hardly think this is any kind of value. I called and spoke to a manager and she told me they have no control over the size of the wings. But I find it funny that the place down the street has wings three times that size for $1.25 each. I knew there was a reason I stopped going there. So much for giving it another try! I would never recommend somebody waste their money on wings at that place cuz they are the pits!!! If you remember when they first opened up they had $0.10 wings and that's about the size of what these things are. Sorry, I can't post my pics. But one of the pictures I took a quarter and put it on top of one of the wings and the wing was only twice the size of the quarter in length. read more

Won't visit this place again staff is constantly doing everything but there job ...on phone in kitchen goof n off outside smoking...food quality is poor at best and it takes forever to get food or a second beer...restaurant was very clean either bathrooms a wreck read more

I love B Dubs but this is the worst managed and worst location I have been in the country. It's like a dive bar with bartenders off to the side on their personal phones having derogatory conversations in front of guests. read more

We ordered lunch to go, as we were traveling north. The girl who was working in the to go area was awesome and our food was so good!!!!

we usually like to sit at the tables by the bar, we adore the bar tender name Michelle, she's great food is amazing but we try to work our schedule around Michelle's so that we know she will be working when we go in, absolutely do NOT like the BIGger bar tender that works there which was recently told she's now a manager ‍ geez they will make anyone managers now days. she's rude and had refused to wait on us a few times so when we know michelle isn't working we won't go to that one, we will go to the one in Troy . from what I've been hearing we're not the only ones that's complaining about her rudeness! they shoulda hired Michele for the manger position ! we her ! read more

Ordered a 20/20 wings online for pick up, a fries basket, a 20oz soda, and three $0.60 dips. The order requires you to choose up to 2 flavors for your wings, and up to 8 sides of ranch/celery/carrots. We decided to go with 8 ranches. I go to pickup my order, and as I'm approaching the main door, a "Masks required" sign is visible on the door. I walk my happy butt in with a mask only to see that out of all the staff and costumers, im the only person wearing a mask. I pick up my food, take it home, only to find out that my fountain Soda isn't in the bag. I reach for a paper bag of dipping sauces where only 7 out of my 13 ordered sauces are. At this point im getting very frustrated and disappointed with my order. I'm very unhappy with the food quality, I could only eat 8 of my dry traditional wings. And my 20 BBQ boneless "sauggy" wings were fed to the trash. BWW owes me a 20oz soda and 6 dipping sauces. Poor experience. Will not come back! read more

If I could rate 0 stars I would. This place is a joke. You'll go in there and they WONT seat you. They'll look at you and not come seat you. The wings are always hard if you even get a seat & the staff are always just acting as if they'd rather be somewhere else. read more

The memories here are wonderful and this is an above average B-Dubs. The prices are a bit too much for chicken wings that aren't as good as Fricker's down the road, but it's still pretty good. Service here is usually on it and they give me their wings in about 10-15 minutes, which is much faster than any Day-Cin location :( Everybody from my school goes here post game for some fun and food. This is a wonderful place for people who are in high school and college (actually, college people, I recommend Fricker's or your local bar). read more

Ever since COVID hit their service it terrible. My wife abd I used to go to this BDubs at least twice a month pre COVID. We have tried to go several times post COVID abd most of the times end up leaving because service to even get a seat is so bad. It's funny Frickers is right down the road abs they are business as usual after COVID. Wow what a disappointment!!! read more

This is Tuesday Trivia Night. The atmosphere and and energy is amazing here. I had the popcorn shrimp and a burger with the Pulled Pork on top. The BBQ sauce was great! I enjoyed the food and loved being here! I'd come back on Tuesdays. This is fun! read more

Buffalo Wild Wings - This burger was epic! - American Near Me - Sidney, Ohio

Thanks for the reply back! Unfortunately I don't live close so i probably won't be coming back anytime soon. But i think it may of just been a slow day because it was like Tuesday at 5 o'clock and you guys were not very busy at the time. read more

tried two times and both times wings were overcooked and dry. tots on first order were only cooked halfway. second order of tots were perfect. ordered fountain drinks and they were wrong. work in sidney and it is too bad this place is not an option for lunch any more. read more

We are traveling from Toronto to Florida and decided to have dinner here. My this review is not for the food, it is just for the environment. It is pretty busy place and dimmed lights which I believe is good. However, there is a horrible dirty cloth smell everywhere. I believe they are not cleaning their cleaning cloths often. It is really disgusting. I also went to the men's room and that was also horribly dirty. I couldn't even stand in there. Flush wasn't working properly and the ground was full of urine. I think they should pay attention to their cleaning and sanitary stuff. As I said this is my environment review while I wait for my food. I'll do another review after I have the food. ____ As Yelp does not allow me to add another review to the same restaurant, I am adding my food review here. The wing options are good. The food it not outstanding. They are tasty but we found that there are lots of sauce on the wings. It is hard to get the taste of the wings. read more

Service was good and the food was ok. The location is convenient in relation to town and the highway. The thing about the place that threw me off was that it was pretty dark in there... more of a bar seen than a restaurant. Overall ok but not really what I expected. read more

The Sidney location will use small scotch glasses for your mixed drinks or margaritas, and then charge you double the price of a tall beer for it. This has happened the last 4 times I've been there. The amount of drink you get doesn't feel like it adds up to the cost. read more

Trash!!! did not receive full order. 40 wings only had 12, Mac and cheese only noodles no cheese, I had fried pickles no seasoning did not fry they slapped flower on it and soaked in water. i do not think people in food industry need higher wages can't even complete simple task. read more

Nice newer remodle of bar area nice out back patio....big place lots of room foods what's to be expected from a chain sports bar.....service was decent.... read more

Buffalo Wild Wings - Bw3 staff work n hard at the bar - American Near Me - Sidney, Ohio

See all

I hate to leave bad reviews but I also want to warn people before they go to this place. I love Buffalo wild wings but this location is beyond help. You're better off just hitting a McDonald's. If you do decide to order carry out make sure that your order is in the bag. I have ordered from this place four times and three of those times my order was completely wrong.... I ordered the 20 20 bundle and I get there pick the food up everything is good. Then I get home and look in the bag and there is only two orders of six wings and last time they completely forgot the second set of wings and fries it's so frustrating. When I call back they tell me that I only paid for the six wings. Which is bull crap because my order came to $40 and the only things that were added on was a pop and cheese curds. I have no clue why they cannot just write down a order right. Sydney's McDonald's has gotten my order right every time I've been and it's mostly kids working dealing with a lot more orders than this place. They just need to stop hiring people that cannot perform the job and stop doubling down and blaming the customer, admit when you're wrong. So they either got my order wrong or charged me for food they did not give me! Either way don't treat me like I'm an inconvenience when I call you so I can go back out and wait to pick up my original order!! OK my rant is over now.... read more

This restaurant is overpriced for the quality of food. I didn't want fries so I ordered coleslaw. The waitress failed to tell me there was a dollar up charge. If that were the case considering how bad the coleslaw was I would have gotten the fries and not eaten them. I had a grilled chicken sandwich. I have had better at McDonalds. The way it tasted I question if the chicken was completely cooked. read more

Stopped for wings with my co worker last night. Ordered traditional plain just flats with a side of mild and blue cheese. She had the same. Tasted just like bdubs always does. He staff was attentive and friendly. read more

the Sidney Buffalo Wild Wings is honestly the worst place to order in Sidney. 9/10 wings are very dry with no sauce also the desk workers don't understand the offing system and cannot get orders correct. also there's never anyone up front to seat you at a table I would love to say I've had one decent experience but I have not read more

I went for lunch today, the food was as expected-delicious and convenient for the price. The service was especially great. I'm disappointed that other people were unhappy with their experience. I mean, when it gets busy, other people need to be taken care of too, not just ourselves. Unless your server is openly insulting you or there is hair in the food you likely should not be leaving 1 star reviews. read more

....the location is great, the layout is great, but the bartenders don't care. And that sucks. Sorry.

It's fine. Really could be a great restaurant, but just not enough compassion from the management. Too fake.

Way over priced for teeny tiny wings. I love the atmosphere but the wings look like they pulled em off of pigeons.

Where the heck on a chicken is the tough, gristle white meat? The boneless wings tasted like last months left overs. Adding insult to injury, our order was slow to arrive, and wrong. read more

Slow service. Subpar food quality (very subpar... Below McDonald's). Repeatedly out of featured drafts. They'll change the channel to your favorite team upon request, but it takes 10-20 mins. Seems poorly managed. Plenty of TV's. I've eaten here many times during business travel because I know what to expect from this chain but this location consistently falls short. Now i just go to Culver's and find another bar to hit when a game is on. read more

I used to have pretty decent experiences here but the last time I ordered carry out I was extremely irked. So I ordered online using the Buffalo Wild Wings website, me and my mom always use the website to order our carry out and the user interface is always pretty simple to use and easy. I ordered the black bean burger and my mom got a chicken wrap and some fried pickles. When finally it came time to pick up my order the girl handed me our bag and our bill the bill was strangely cheap I thought. Usually it's about thirty bucks for all of our food but this time it was about fifteen. That's odd I thought. So when I got to the car I looked at the receipt and the veggie burger had been deleted off of the bill because it was "unavailable". This made me extremely upset, not because it was unavailable but because they knew that it was and did not call me and ask if I wanted something instead. The woman at the counter didn't even mention that the sandwich was unavailable and I didn't find out until I was getting ready to drive away! If they would've told me that my item was unavailable I wouldn't have been upset I just would've ordered something else instead. I recommend calling in your order if you are going to order that way they have to tell you if your item is available or not before it's too late and you go home missing a meal. read more

Well where do I start. We out for a night of fun with the hubby and co-workers. We had a drink while waiting on a table in the bar. We got our table and then about 10 mins later the waitress finally cleaned half the table. (WHAT EVER). Took our order and we waited. Took for ever to get more drinks. My second drink was basically all juice. Had to have the manager make me another like he did the first time. The waitress asked if the drink was better. She told me that she told the manager if I wasn't such a lush. I had 1 drink. It took over 45 mins for our food to come out and it was cold. NEEDLESS TO SAY, WE WHERE DONE. We paid for our drinks and went to Frickers. A good wait staff equals HAPPY CUSTOMERS!! read more

Four stars might be a little generous, but I'm hungry at the moment so my standards are down a bit. I've got to say it's pretty consistently good. I do like the sauces. I'm a boneless fan, because I find regular wings just to be too much work and mess for the meal (I really don't like messy fingers). Last time, it did kind of seem like my boneless wings were more crust than meat. I like them nice and crusty, but this was really too far. Tried the limited time salted caramel barbecue, which was ok. I wanted the Korean barbecue, but they were out. I hope I can get that before it's gone for good, but I don't know if I'll be back that soon. read more

Ordered take out from here a few times. Had to walk all through the restaurant to find someone to help me. The other few times, I had to wait 25-30 minutes after the time I told them I would be there. The food was dry every time. I figured they had an off day, which can sometimes happen, so I gave it another chance. Every time I've called to place an order, the employees acted like I was wasting their time. Won't be back to this location. I will drive the 45 minutes or so to go to the one in the town I'm originally from. read more

Seems to be another usual BW-3's restaurant. It is just me or do their wings seem to be lacking on the actual meat they have on them? In my opinion they are becoming over priced for the amount that your getting. read more