Buffalo Bar & Restaurant Murdo, S.D. 08/01/2026 Dear Buffalo Bar & Restaurant Team, I wanted to take a moment to express my gratitude for the wonderful experience I had during my recent visit to your establishment. If Northlake, Illinois, wasn't over 800 miles away, I would gladly be there every chance I had for the exceptional food and warm atmosphere. Upon arriving at 8 PM, I was warmly greeted by Christy, who quickly seated wife and i with a big smile. The service was just as impressive as the food - from the delightful bar drinks that were promptly served at our table to the impressive build-your-own salad bar and delicious soups. Your team truly made an effort to ensure that our dining experience was flawless, and it did not go unnoticed. Overall, Buffalo Restaurant is a treasure in Murdo, and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for great food and a welcoming environment. Keep up the fantastic work, and I look forward to my next visit, even if it's a bit of a trek! Enjoy your meal, Sincerely, Gary Williams Northlake, Illinois read more

Very local feel. Partner had liver and onions. He said it was great. My beef dinner was very tasty. Very generous portions, especially for the price. Enjoyable meal. read more

Best place In town. Great staff makes you feel like you belong even though you're passing through. Excellent food. Def recommend to check it out. Don't expect a fancy place. Just an honest hard working family business. read more

This is a solid choice for local dining. I will begin by saying the exterior of this building gave me pause. I have walked into a few 'less than friendly' establishments in my life and the exterior gave me that vibe. Thankfully, inside is a warm and delightful business with plenty of food options and stiff drinks at a fair price. No beer on tap, but a fair variety in cans. Definitely a space to bring the family, there are two dining areas. One to the right is a long narrow space with booths on the front side and tables in a variety of four and six seating configurations. Decor is wildlife pictures and dark paneling. No windows. To the left of the entrance is the bar and another grouping of dining tables. Parking is on three sides of the building and there are no designated parking spaces. Just be sure you and others can get in and out. The building entrance is street side. There is no awning or anything to let you know 'this is the one'. The menu has a kids section for the young ones. The regular Saturday special was prime rib w/a salad, roll, potato and dessert. So much food! They also offer a couple of ground buffalo meat meals along with sandwiches and entrees. We went with lighter fare and found a side salad order gives you one walk up to the salad bar. They also have a soup & salad bar meal option. As in most other restaurants we've encountered on our travels through the area, the salad base is a bagged iceberg lettuce mix. There were plenty of toppings and salad dressings to choose. My mushroom swiss burger was tasty as were the onion rings. The burger was well cooked and not greasy. Real onions in a tempura style batter had a nice flavor and crunch. Our waitress was pleasant with all the guests and she kept a close eye on us. We had our drinks in good time and the food came in an expected amount of time. Pay at the register by the door on your way out. There's a basket of candy just behind you there (I had a butterscotch. Yum!) and toothpicks are available in a dispenser on the counter. The internet tells me they are open until 11pm. read more

See all

I am 71 years old and I have never had a prime rib as good as this one. Along with choice of potato, another side and soft drink (I think). Plus real ice cream + fudge desert. All for $28 bucks. Go Saturday night and encourage them to come up with other specials on other nights. Like Walleye on Friday? read more

Feel weird giving it 5 stars. It deserves 10. Sidney (Sydney?) best hostess. Waitress. Busser. She was doing it all while in the weeds (Restaurant speak for slammed busy). Smiling. Cracking jokes. Juggling all of us and keeping a full dining room happy. Steaks? Perfect. Onion rings? Delish. Chili? Fresh made. Drinks? Cheap as heck. Great cooks If you're passing through town~do yourself a favor and eat here. Tip Sidney extra. She deserves it read more

See all

The Friday night we were in Mardi, this restaurant was the only game in town. They were very busy, but we enjoyed our 30-minute wait with drinks in the bar. The special was Prime Rib. It was amazing flavor and large serving. The French fries were some of the best I've ever had. There used to be a great salad and soup bar. The liver and onions that you be in our party had was great (I hear), but suggests ordering extra onions. Another had fried shrimp, which was really good and there was plenty. This is an old restaurant and bar, but don't let that keep you from stopping in for a great tasting dinner! read more

The food was average, but this is a very small town on the Interstate highway so my expectations were modest. But the staff and servers were very friendly. read more

This place was great! After a long day of traveling we wanted something other than fast food and the Buffalo Restaurant provided. We highly recommend the grilled walleye! We got so much food for what we paid, and it tasted homemade. What a great find in Murdo, South Dakota! read more

If you're not from the area, don't bother stopping in. We're moving across the country and I'd expect really quaint hospitality from this place and area but the whole experience was downhill from parking outside to leaving. The service was rude, short, and ignorant. More worried about some random tomato crop discussion among regular patrons than serving people, it was so hard to get someone's attention. They were out of several items we asked about like the salad bar, any salad or green veggie, and they don't serve baked potato as a potato option but they have onion rings as a potato option (?). Several rude patrons as well. We went on down the road to Wall for dinner instead. read more

Food was subpar at best. Shrimp had a weird aftertaste. The location was a typical bar setting. The waitress was nice and helpful

We were told we could have a seat at the bar. When bartender arrived, he said he would be moving us into dining area because it would be "easier" for him. The restaurant was bit that busy. We just left. read more

There aren't a lot of options in Murdo but if we lived here we would likely eat here regularly. It's your standard small town bar with steaks and drinks and that locals vibe. There is a dining room and a bar. Small salad bar with an assortment of salads that didn't look super fresh but the lettuce and boiled eggs and dressings were good. We ordered the Rib Eye steak which was a large serving that cane with soup and salad bar, baked potato and an ice cream sundae which was a nice touch. The steak was cooked well however it lacked seasoning. Easily fixed with a salt shaker. The service was great however and we felt like we got our moneys worth. Would definitely eat here again. read more

Everything was excellent - friendly, efficient service; excellent salad bar and delicious soup of the day; outstanding brisket, fish, and shrimp meals. We were so hungry after a day of traveling - and we enjoyed every taste! read more

I had the grilled walleye and it was excellent. I got the last baked potato, the salad bar was fine and the tomato soup was homemade. They were out of rolls which was okay, I didn't need it. Beer was cold. Excellent meal for this size town. They are understaffed so it took longer but very nice. read more

The food is great. The servers are working hard, they could have used one more person to help clear tables or serve, but they made it work! We were seated immediately, waited a bit to get our order in, but the food came out quickly. Everything was hot, home made and good! Reasonably priced and easy to find right too. Oh, and did I mention the free ice cream?! Your choice of chocolate or crème de menthe topping. read more

Buffalo Restaurant & Bar - In front of the restaurant - Salad Near Me - Murdo, South Dakota

My son and I had stopped by to get food before continuing on our journey. Unfortunately we felt so uncomfortable and unwanted. Everyone was staring at us and nosy wanted to help us. I do not know if this was because of our Hispanic heritage or they were truly "behind" as another had told us before giving us a scowl. All we wanted was to eat and be on our way. We kept going without dinner and headed to Sioux Falls just In time to sleep. I always try to find places to try on long trips, just unfortunate we did not get to try this place. read more

When driving across S.D. you must stop at The Buffalo Bar. You can't drive to or from Wyoming or Mount Rushmore without having lunch or dinner at The Buffalo Bar. The waitress was fantastic. They should charge more it is worth it! read more

Great dinner, good cocktails and a nice little salad bar. I ordered the walleye grilled fish dinner and it was tender and delicious. We were just staying over in town for one night on our way back home to IL. We don't get fish like this back home so I was very pleased. Hubby got a nice steak and was also very happy.. price was right as well. read more

One of the best Prime Rib dinners I have ever had. Service was fantastic. I will stop here every time I'm traveling through for their Prime Rib. read more

The only place open. Tombstone & Beer served by a witty yet assertive seasoned grandma. She runs the whole place by herself. Of coarse she has issues with large groups. Y'all should be happy she's even open... shitty service and all.. welcome to SD read more

We stopped at Murdo to have a quick bite and we found this little ol restaurant. Proud to say if we ever return we will certainly go back to Buffalos. The food was exquisite, and the salad bar was a nice little snack while we waited for the food. 10/10 would recommend! read more

Chicken fried steak was excellent. A steakhouse first and foremost. Service was quick. Nice lounge available. Will return.

Overall pretty good food! We had a group of 13 and the server was great about it. Some of us got chicken tenders, some got burgers, and one brave person got the buffalo burger. Overall everything was pretty solid. It was really our only option that was open but if I had to pass through Murdo, SD again for whatever reason I would eat here. read more

Dinner for four, the server was friendly, the salad bar was crisp, and the stake was tasty. My daughter loved the home made soup.

Food was good. Our Server was AWFUL! Stopped in with another family on our way thru South Dakota heading home after a two week road trip. We had just crossed the time zone line so instead of 7:30, it was 8:30 pm. I called ahead to see if they could accommodate a party of 12 and was told yes. When we arrived our waitress was openly irritated, stating when she was told she was getting a party of 12 she didn't think it would all be children. We had 6 adults in our party. She blatantly ignored us the entire time. I had to go to the waitress stand to get napkins and more water because she would not even look our way. She had just three other tables. I had to get up and get her to ask for our desserts that were supposed to come with our meals. She finally brought our checks, we sat there for 10 minutes waiting for her to take our credit cards, but she never returned, so we ended up leaving cash on the table and leaving. read more

It's been many many years since I've been here, so it's probably changed since then. I believe it was in 2002 or 2003, when we tried to stop at a hotel in Rapid City, but couldn't due to Stergis, so we had to drive all the way out to Murdo, SD to find the closest available hotel. This was pretty much the only restaurant in town, so we decided to give it a try. What really made this place memorable was the buffalo burgers. They were definitely unique, from a city slicker like myself, and was tender. If you're driving down I-90, bored to death and looking for a good meal, definitely stop by this place, if it's still the jewel it was 6 years ago. read more

After reading the reviews below, we decided to try "the Buffalo"... to see for ourselves. The special of the night was 3 pieces of beer-battered cod with soup & salad bar, choice of potato, and an ice cream sundae. (I only wanted a small vanilla ice cream, but was persuaded to let them add a bit of creme de menthe on top!) I do not normally eat fried foods so am not a judge of quality...but it was quite adequate if not gourmet...and...at $13.50 per dinner, I'd say we definitely got a good deal!! Hard to beat! In regards to the reviews of the people who thought this restaurant might be closed, this was in the middle of May and there were plenty of cars in the parking lot...one of the factors that convinced us. Wine was Franzia or Livingstone Cellars...but only $3.50 for a good-sized glass! I hope my pics post ok. read more

See all

The sirloin was okay. As I hoped for the price. Choices in this small town seemed limited. I would have been happier if the ambience were better. I am on vacation so I'm happy either way. From the east coast to the West Coast it's all fun. But this place probably would not do so well back home . Nothing special here. Sorry. read more

Buffalo Restaurant & Bar - Salad Near Me - Murdo, South Dakota

The Prime Rib is the best I've had! Tender and lean, even the end cut that I ordered was tender and medium temp... save room for the creme de menthe over ice cream! read more

I thought the food was really good. Had a steak which was delicious. They had homemade chicken noodle soup. I would recommend this restaurant. read more

Overpriced, bad food. Terrible salad bar. Save yourself some heartache and go hungry instead of eating here. I spent $50 for a kid's meal, a salad and the "special," none of which were any good. read more

My partner and I had a very satisfying experience at this restaurant, yesterday, on a Friday evening. Both the restaurant and bar were fairly busy at 8 PM. The two women working the restaurant could not have been friendlier or more helpful and attentive. Our entrees came with access to the soup and salad bar. The salad bar was delightfully old fashioned and well tended. The tomato soup was one of the best ever. Being from out of state, we both ordered Walleye and a baked potato. Both were perfectly cooked and arrived in short order. The restaurant provides its patrons with a small cup of vanilla ice cream at the end of the meal. You can choose a chocolate sauce, but we went retro and had it covered with creme de menthe. Do yourself a favor and have a meal here. This is the way restaurants used to be before the commercial chains took over. read more

Great place. Could use some updating and a fresh coat of paint but place was clean and staff friendly and accommodating. Food was fresh and very good. Highly recommend if you want a genuine hometown restaurant with good food. read more

This is a must go to place! The soup is the best I've ever had (the night i was there i homemade tomato soup). Service is excellent with reasonable prices the steaks are great. Come with an appetite or you will need a to go box. Ask to meet Linda the soup master...Great friendly people and clean place..A real find. read more

Buffalo Restaurant & Bar - Dining room off of the bar - Salad Near Me - Murdo, South Dakota

It looked kind of scary from the outside but I'm glad we braved it! It probably has not been updated in 20 years but the dining room was clean and comfortable. The waitress was friendly and gave great service. I am picky about the quality of service and food! The salad bar was small, but everything was fresh and tasted good. I had a rib eye that was huge and tender. The hash browns were great! The rolls were okay, and the real butter was actually brought to room temp before serving! A little local gem! read more

We went The Buffalo with some trepidation after reading a couple of yelp reviews. We were delighted with every aspect of the place.

Yelp map directs you to a billboard not the restaurant. Exit on Rt 83, go west on 5th street. Almost to the next access to I-90. Linda in the bar was very hospitable and friendly. Madison was our server in the restaurant. Great service. Reasonable priced meals. Great beef n noodle soup, nice salad bar. We enjoyed our dinners. Filet wrapped in bacon, chopped steak and hash browns. Definitely recommend. read more

Buffalo Restaurant & Bar - Chopped steak and hash browns - Salad Near Me - Murdo, South Dakota

See all

The decor, beer selection, crinkle cut French fries and salad bar are all sad and tasteless. However, the French dip sandwich was made from a tender, slow roasted hunk of juicy beef layered with some of the best caramelized onions I've ever tasted. My travel companion had the same meal, so I have no idea about the rest of the menu. read more

NEVER AGAIN. The "I'm a grumpy old lady" shtick used to be funny but now she's just a rude old woman. Went there with 20 people on our way to Sturgis and she was unprepared, and understaffed. He daughter, who may be mentally challenged, was trying to help but hadn't a clue of what she was doing. They messed up multiple orders and the old lady owner actually told one of us to shut up when we asked where an order was that we waited 1 hour for. She needs to close the doors to this POS restaurant and retire. We'll take the $600 we spent and go to some place that knows what they're doing and actually appreciates customers. read more