I've been a frequent regular here for quite some time. This is a long review because I have a heap…read moreof compliments and then a serious complaint/request. First of all, it's important to understand that this place is literally our Blue Note. I don't say that casually, I lived in NYC for 15 years and was a regular at Blue Note. I am a massive jazz nerd and I live around the corner so I come here very often, but it's objectively far superior to the other jazz clubs in the city in terms of both booking and food. The music is a range, sometimes it's local (incl NYC) guys, but they also get a ton of the upper-middle tier, who are not household names, but are outright celebrities to jazz fans. Blue Note opts for the household names and won't book those guys, which is why Chris's is better. But just in the last 6-8 months, off the top of my head, I've seen Nate Henderson (at least 3x), Cyrus Chestnut, Eric Alexander, Emmet Cohen, Kurt Rosenwinkel, Joe Farnsworth, Peter Bernstein, and John Pizzarelli. At the same venue!! If you're into jazz you will understand how completely nuts that is. NYC could never. You would have to go to half a dozen venues and spend several business days on the subway to see that list in NYC. The food is also ridiculously good, reliably some of the best upscale food in CC imo. Frequently rotating menu (a good thing!), very creative, unbelievably good, and artistically plated. It is expensive, but if you do the dinner + show package it's much cheaper, and while the portions are not huge, you don't want to eat much more than that or you'll want to be lying down on the floor during the show.
My complaint here is about the noise. Based on personal experience and some of the reviews I've read, there are people who don't understand that in the evening hours this is a ticketed music venue where people are here to see serious and often really well known musicians. A large portion of these musicians are not random local kids. There is a strong possibility that the person you're trying to talk over is very famous to people who like jazz. There is a cover charge because it's a music venue. There is a minimum purchase requirement because it's a music venue. If your intent is to have a full on conversation with your friends with random jazz vibes going on in the background, there are many other places in the city for that. Due to the acoustics of the space, when people are doing this even in the bar/high top area by the door, that sound carries and is overwhelmingly loud near the stage (as in literally it can overwhelm the music) and actively ruins the show for both the patrons and the musicians. It's super disrespectful. I've seen many shows that were totally ruined by this, and several to the point where patrons were cussing out the waitresses over it and the musicians were getting on the mic telling people to be quiet because they can't focus. I really wish they would include a request for people to keep talking to a minimum during performances in their set-opening announcement on the loudspeaker. It would be a simple way to set expectations ahead of time.
This is the only reason for 3 stars - if they were to address this issue I would not even be able to give this place sufficient stars. 5 would not be enough. But that's how frustrating this issue is.