I am deeply and highly disappointed after my recent visit. I had been a regular Big O Tires customer since I bought my first car many years ago. Then, Big O Tires technicians generously taught me about tires and tire care. Big O Tires was a brand I respected and trusted, until recently.
I had a disappointing experience six weeks ago after visiting this shop. Beware, this shop has a cancellation charge without prior notice for tire orders.
After I brought a flat tire that could not be repaired, service advisor Marvin ordered two (AWD tires are replaced in sets of twos or fours) 99H Pirelli Scorpion Verde All Season Black Wall tires and kept my flat tire and wheel. Back home, I researched Marvin's tires and discovered his tires, rated Speed H, UTQG Treadwear 600, Traction A, and Temperature A, are rated LOWER than my then tires, 99V Pirelli Scorpion Verde All Season Plus II, Speed V, UTQG Treadwear 740, Traction A, and Temperature A. A V speed rating is superior to an H speed rating, and a 740 treadwear rating is superior to a 600 treadwear rating. I phoned Marvin and asked about the discrepancy. Marvin explained that Pirelli "no longer makes your Plus II tires" and ordered the regular Scorpion Verde tires. I told Marvin that he had downgraded two of my superior tires. Marvin, in his shop, did not tell me about the Scorpion Verde All Season Plus 3 tires, the direct replacement for my Plus II tires. I asked why? Marvin said the Plus 3 is different and that I would need four new tires. Marvin stated that he had found the best tires for my needs, the tires he had ordered. However, the best tires Marvin had found are not the same quality as my then tires. I asked for better tires. Marvin replied that "there will be a $100 cancellation charge". Marvin did not inform me that there is a $100 cancellation charge at the shop. A cancellation charge is not printed on my copy of the shop's quote. I kept the order over the weekend as I researched his 99H Pirelli Scorpion Verde All Season Black Wall tires, which clearly are not as good or better than my then Plus II tires. On Monday, January 26, I cancelled the order and told Marvin, "I will order four Plus 3 tires at TireRack.com and [since you are a TireRack.com contracted installer] you will install the Plus 3 tires".
Where were the Tire Rack Plus 3 tires? On January 27, 2026, at 9:01 am, UPS delivered the four Tire Rack Plus 3 tires in two bundles of two, tracking numbers 1Z5EA4490311549055 and 1Z5EA4490311549073. However, when I called and inquired at 9:32 am, an employee replied, "tires haven't come in, there is nothing in front of me". I inquired with UPS. At 10:31 am, the local UPS station left a voicemail that stated "it (sic) was left by the roll up doors". When I inquired at 10:44 am, Marvin replied that the "tires are not here". Finally, at 1:24 pm, Marvin called and stated that my tires arrived, contrary to UPS's 9:01 am delivery time.
I brought this cancellation charge issue to the Better Business Bureau (BBB) as documentation of the company's business practices and for resolution. The company stood by its cancellation charge in poorly written and poorly reasoned responses to the BBB (see attachments). The company has never documented or proved that it has a written or printed cancellation policy to the BBB or to me. I have disputed the cancellation charge with my credit card company. I will definitely avoid this company; it is not the same company that I grew up with or respected. read more