Best. Pizza. Ever. I'm from the area & grew up on this…read morepizza so it's amazing to me from that standpoint alone. The crust is like something from a dream that you never want to wake up from; it's truly out of this world. Everyone has their own exceedingly personal & specific ways they prefer to enjoy their 'za so to argue about which one is better is kinda silly. You like what you like, I like what I like - fuhgettaboutit! I recently made a trip back home & after so many hours on the road the first place we went was this specific location to get the world's greatest pizza. It was hot as balls, the place has no ac, but I would seriously kick 4 toddlers in the face to get another tray of pepperoni & extra cheese right now. I would kick 40 toddlers in the face for a location in Minnesota. 400. 4000.

Service awesome and fast walked right in and picked up order. Crust was crispy to perfection …read more Sauce was not my preference but again I understand everyone has local favorites . One thing I noted was this was not as good reheated at all . Ok for hot and as soon as you pick it up.

Great pizza great calzones with great prices and they don't close early they'll be open around I…read morethink 11:00 p.m.

Only reason for a 2 is it has a unique crust or it would be a 1 dough was under cooked had no sauce…read moreand ingredients wasn't even cooked just thrown into

This was the first pizza place i visited when moving to the area . The pizza here is like eating…read morecardboard with ketchup on it . The shop was not that clean . The only reason im giving 2 stars instead of one is that the staff was friendly,li don't recommend this place and i wont eat here again

I'm sorry to say this was not as amazing as the reviews claim. I ordered a 12 piece and while it…read morewas a decent looking pizza it just tasted like bread, basic cheese and marinara sauce. The pepperonis tasted store bought as well. I placed my order and they said it would be 45 mins, so I set my timer and went to the store, after my timer went off and I got back it was still not done. Overall I'm just disappointed in the whole experience.

Since I grew up around this area it was interesting to see the large photos they have displayed of…read morewhat East Liverpool years ago. Being able to go in the vault of the old bank was also interesting. The service was really good and our food was very good. I had the steak salad and it was superb.

I can't believe this place doesn't have a higher rating! We went yesterday for dinner and we were…read moreso impressed with the ambiance, service, and food. We took a tour of the restaurant while we waited for our food.. it was so fun to walk through the vault and check out the back patio area. We ordered drinks, nachos, wood fired pizza, and a burger-- all delicious!

We ordered a few slices of square pizza for takeout from Bruno's last week. The food was ready…read morewithin the quoted time. It was hot and fresh, the crust was crispy, but I think they were a little light with the cheese. We always order an extra bag of cheese on the side to top with and we were glad we did. The staff here were very friendly. The inside of the shop is really just a counter and a beverage cooler, but they do have lots of local photos that are fun to check out! I'd like to try the calzones in the future.

I called to place a delivery order. A younger sounding woman answered (with zero greeting). After I…read moresaid I wanted delivery the was a moment of silence and she then asked where it was going in a way that sounded like she was super annoyed. After getting my address she asked what I wanted, and I asked for 6 slices, to which she said "Oh" which leads me to believe ordering a smaller number is an unspoken problem. She then said okay and hung up without telling me a price or time for arrival. So I'm currently waiting to see if it even arrives. I'm writing this before the food arrives as I'm not expecting it to blow my socks off with the quality anyway, but the lack of basic phone etiquette would prevent a higher review regardless of how the pizza tastes. UPDATE: I waited an hour after ordering to call them back and ask what the problem was. They didn't answer the first time then hung up immediately when I called again. Stick to DiCarlos; better pizza and better employees.

For this area Mary Janes is above average, they use quality cheese…read more 'Grande ' and good tomato sauce. The pizza is a round thin crust . The staff is super friendly and every time i have ordered around 6 times the service and food have been great . The only negative thing about Mary Janes is the prices , they are high . I understand grande cheese is not cheap but $2.75 per toppings is a little steep especially for this area . I don't mind paying for quality but $2.75 for .20 cents of mushrooms is not reasonable. The hoagies are small and nothing special but overpriced also . My order of a large 16" 2 topping pizza & a 10" Italian hoagie plus two 1pint cartons of Turners iced tea was $48 no delivery i picked up . I hope people try this place the pizza is good but not worth the price in my opinion

I wanted a quick bite to eat and I stop in. All they had was pizza pies and I just was 3 slices. so…read moreI look to the hoagie and order one. the lady ask if I want italian dressing or mayo on the side. I ask you dont put it on the sandwich. She said no cause people says it makes the bread soggy. I told her that makes the sandwich better. I asked if she cant put it on as they make the said.. she doubled check with me and she puts the order in... OH MY GAWD!!! that sandwich was great. I hate places thwe condiments of a sandwich on side. you have to deconstruct the sandwich to put it on yourself. even if you are dining in. I never go back to those palces.. I will come back her cause that was a great italitian hoagie.

If you're getting pizza, GET THE THIN CRUST!!!!! It's the best! The thick crust/Sicilian are a…read moredistant last. Thin crust the whole way!

Have been a customer for years but today I was there at the Beaver Falls Yolanda's restaurant. I…read moream disappointed with this visit having a salad mainly lettuce with only a small piece of tomato, few shredded carrots and 2 single rings of red onion. The Italian dressing was limited but good. My main dish was stuffed shells which bottoms of shells were so hard I could hardly cut. This is a new feature on menu so I figured it would be especially good. The shells were stuff with cheese, plus extra cheese on top with overflow of sauce which I thinkvewas hiding overbaked shells. It was so hot after 15 minutes I gave up eating. I was totally disappointed since had been a place I've gone to for years. I ordered a meatball that was more bread crumbs than meat. I hope this was just a bad night but will think twice before going again.

They have the worst customer service. They are rude, obnoxious argumentative, and wouldn't know the…read moretruth if they fell in it. The woman behind the counter waiting on customers should spend more time cleaning the restaurant instead of arguing with customers and chatting on the phone! I'm really not sure how this place stays open. The pizza is poor at best. If you like overcooked cardboard and uncooked cheese and toppings! My late wife for some reason liked their pizza for some reason and the only reason I went was to try and bring her a little joy in her last days. This has been over a year now and she passed in June of last year. I doubt if this place has changed. It makes me very sad every time I think about it.

Phenomenal customer service, food was the best i've ever had, very homey and calm eating area…read more Highly recommended!