Biagetti's is the best Italian restaurant in the area. From impeccable service to amazing food, no one does it better. On Saturday nights, the place is filled with regular customers and it feels like dining with family. For private events, it's the best bang for your buck. The owner decorates beautifully and the array of options is amazing. Biagetti's is definitely a ten out of ten. read more

The birthday traditions begin for 2025. If today's meal is any indication, this birthday year is going to be super delicious. The food at Biagetti's tastes like you are back in your Italian grandmother's kitchen. Everything is made from scratch, super fresh, and truly a dining delight. Linda, the owner and our server made us feel welcome, and made every effort to anticipate our wishes. They completely met and exceeded our highest expectations. The ambience is lovely, even with large crowds in the dining room. It is a relaxing and elegant way to celebrate a birthday. There is off the street parking and a great happy hour as well. Definitely worth the trip from anywhere! read more

Biagettis puts Steak Houses and other Italian restaurants to shame...We love the meals. Always big portions. Miss Biagetti checking on every customer is so welcoming. The decor is high end. Great ambiance read more

This is of my favorite Italian restaurants, service is amazing food is really good, the staff are very attentive very easy to talk to, very friendly, the ambience is very good when you come in table and bars and more table at the back. I do recommend this to my family and friends read more

We had a group of 18, and OMG! ,the service, the food, was top notch and beyond. The owner made us feel welcomed, server Mike was outstanding, the room was beautifully prepared. BRAVO, BRAVO, BRAVO read more

We where told we would have wedding party in a room , the morning of the wedding the area was given to a retirement party. That meant he wedding party had to sit in front at the bar area. Talk about disappointing. We can't even hear ourselves at the same table. As for food well I ll let you know soon. But I can tell you this they want 50.0 per person for this and thats totally ridiculous, and poor management Never again for me read more

Wonderful atmosphere. Great service and superd food. Had dinner there on a busy Sunday night. read more

Been going here for years. The best Italian home style food in the area. Food is consistent. Portions are huge Service is the best,! read more

We had our motorcycle group Christmas dinner again! Management made sure our night went smoothly. Our Server Matt was 100% professional. He had to deal with 18 of us! The food was amazing, no one had to wait for their entrees to come out. The tables were set beautifully. read more

See all

First visit last week. Dinner prices seemed high, but meals include soup of the day & salad. Portions were generous. I loved their chicken Parmesan which came with side of ziti. Waitress was excellent. read more

The portions were massive. Almost any meal you order is guaranteed to be enough for two meals. We ordered the stuffed filet of sole and chicken Ricardo. Both were cooked perfectly and paired with salad, soup and pasta. Great restaurant! read more

We had our son & and his brides " Night Before Dinner Celebration " at Biagetti's . I can't even begin to say how absolutely wonderful, amazing, & fantastic the evening was. From the breathtaking room and decor to the scrumptious appetizers! The Italian wedding soup was delicious and the bruschetta was the best we have ever had! Their special appetizer ClamsDiMaeo was to die for! The house salads were the perfect size and the homemade dressings were outstanding. The choices for the main course were plentiful from seafood, fish, to chicken and steak. Every one of our guests praised the food and our server Mike was very attentive and extremely professional. One of the many compliments was " I've been to many Rehearsal/Night Before Dinners and this was hands down the best ever". Many thanks to the entire staff at Biagetti's for creating such lasting memories for our son and his bride. read more

See all

Wonderful dinner and service as always. Treated to live music tonight by Gunn Street Revival who just made the night perfect! read more

Biagetti's Restaurant - Chicken Milanese was huge and the homemade soup (chicken pasta fagiole) and salad dressing (tomato Gorgonzola) was delish - Italian Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

Their wine list is nonexistent Terrible, terrible wine choices Their food mediocre at best lacking flavor. I did have a nice salad there, I liked their salad, but the main dish - I got eggplant Parmesan - could have used seasoning maybe garlic ? something else other than what they used. read more

Four of us dined incredibly well here on a Friday night and definitely needed our reservation. Started with clams D'amico as our amazing appetizer. Dinners come with soup and salad so we enjoyed a great NE clam chowder (not overly creamy, just right) lovely house salads and crisp Caesar salads. Our fabulous entrees were a couple of treasure chests, chicken Ricardo, and stuffed cod, all massive and absolutely delicious. No room for dessert as we left with enough for at least another meal. Great owner, great staff, great food. Cheers! read more

Delicious food and great service. My go to place when visiting West Haven shore. Chef prepares high quality ingredients consistently. Started with tis app. read more

Biagetti's Restaurant - Steamers, little necks and mussels - Italian Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

My family and I went to Biagetti's on a Saturday night. We had early reservations so when we arrived there were not too many people in the restaurant. As we began eating, more people arrived and it did get pretty busy, so I would recommend making a reservation. For appetizers, we ordered fried calamari and an order of cheesy clam bread, which was a special. The clam bread was excellent, it was cheesy and packed with flavor. The calamari was also very good, but was a little on the greasy side. All of our entrees came with soup and salad, which were delicious. I asked to substitute the soup of the day for pasta fagioli and I sure was glad I did because the pasta fagioli was amazing. The italian wedding soup was also very good and so were the salads. For an entree, I ordered the penne with broccoli rabe and sausage, which was a HUGE portion and was very delicious. My fiancé ordered the chicken Parmesan which was also huge portion and he said tasted good. Overall, we really enjoyed Biagetti's. The price was right, especially for the portions, the staff was very friendly and attentive and the food was great. We will likely be back! read more

See all

Went there for my Granddaughters wedding reception. We were supposed to be in a private room. Instead, we were in an open dining area right next to the bar! The bar was open to the public, and there were around 20 people at the bar being excessively loud and getting very drunk! We could not enjoy our reception because it was so loud! And we were charged $50 a plate... why, I have no idea...because meals on their menu average about $25!! The food was terrible! Chicken parm was very thin sliced chicken that was dry and overcooked. The pasta was stone cold with hardly any sauce. And I question the cleanliness of this place: the floor in the bathroom was "sticky", my cloth napkin had something stuck on it and had to ask for another one. We spoke to the manager, but to no avail. All she kept saying was that she had been in business for 49 years! She had absolutely NO customer service skills, and offered no possible resolution, no apology....nothing! She was very rude! In fact, she blamed my grand daughter for not coming to look at the place before hand! I warn all potential customers: please be careful in considering this place for a private event.... do yourself a huge favor, don't even consider it.... there are other reputable places in the area that deliver great food, fantastic customer service! read more

The moment we walked in we felt like family. Linda & Scott made us feel welcome and went way out of their way to accommodate without us asking for a thing. We went with our 14-month grandson who just moved to the neighborhood. They reserved a quiet corner in the restaurant and were attentive to every little thing. The service was exceptional, and the food was outstanding. I loved my chicken marsala. Dinners still come with soup AND salad and plenty of sides. These days many restaurants now charge for salad & veggies. This decades old restaurant lasts because of the care of the owners, the tasty dishes, the atmosphere close to the water and the staff who take pride in their work. Thanks to all who made our evening special! read more

Picture does it no justice the best chicken parm I've had in a long time. Attended a work event, staff were courteous and attentive. Location is easily accessible and thoughtful holiday decor. read more

Biagetti's Restaurant - Chicken Parm - Italian Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

Nothing better than traditional old school Italian favorites, just be sure to go on an empty stomach and wear your comfy pants. We initially went to Biagetti's to pick up a gift certificate for a local family member but decided to stay for dinner as we couldn't resist how delicious everything looked. We were seated in the lounge area off the bar which was perfect for us as we had a little one and this area was a bit less formal than their main dining room. The bar was packed with not an empty seat for the two hours we were there. Our server and bus boy were on point throughout all of dinner service from filling our water glasses to replenishing our basket with hot bread bread to providing excellent recommendations! The only thing they forgot to share was how humongous the portions are! We started out with an order of calamari that was crispy and tender served with a delicious marinara sauce. Our little one had a plain chicken cutlet that was perfectly pounded thin and fried crispy with a side of spaghetti. The best of two worlds collided and the chicken Riccardo was born; homemade chicken cutlets, layered with ricotta and their house eggplant parmigiana. The portion could of easily feed two people as it's very filling. We ultimately packaged up the chicken Riccardo to take home as the two other entrees filled up three adults. The stuffed sole was better than I would have made at home. It is two large pieces of sole stuffed served with a potato & vegetable, soup and salad (we really enjoyed the Cesar). To top off the meal, we were treated to some of the best cannoli cake and treated like regulars the entire meal. We can't wait to go back as every dish looked delicious! read more

Biagetti's Restaurant - Chicken Riccardo - Italian Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

This is absolutely my favorite restaurant for many reasons. For starters the owner and her staff are first rate- friendly, professional and always willing to go above & beyond to make your dining experience special. Now to the food- expect a delicious 3 course meal with soup, salad and an entre that will challenge the heartiest appetite. The best part for me though is their clams DeMayo which we order as an appetizer every time we go there- it is superb !!! If you haven't been there it's a must. read more

If I could give this place no stars I would. The food is atrocious- granted there are regulars here but it is because of either the close proximity of where they live or because they like bland food or maybe it is like the neighborhood cheers. The service is sub par- movement of a glacial pace; rude; can I dare say racist? Maybe.? Ambiance is a tight square with the bar in the center basically a house with a restaurant sign. If you want a good Italian restaurant go to Apps. You will thank me later. read more

Two stars would be a bonus. We should have know when Linda was as unpleasant as they come while taking our reservations. The service was the worst we have ever experienced - we had reservations so that was no excuse. It took 50 (yes, 5-0) minutes for our drinks. We wondered the entire time if the waiter was avoid us, he never even made eye contact when he walked by. The ambience was fine, a very mature crowd. The dinner was good; nothing exceptional. Definitely a one and done experience. read more

See all

My family just had our annual outing and there are not enough superlatives to describe our satisfaction with the total experience at Biagetti'S. Once again Linda exceeded all expectations for this year's event. I would give a 10 star review and recommend this venue for anyone who wants to have an outdoor experience.My thanks to Linda and the entire staff for a job well done Joe Lenzi and family read more

See all

Been coming here for quite a few years with work and loved the food every time. This time I figured I would bring the fam to show them what good food taste like .. but we had just come from a memorial service of a family member and it was last minute reservations but they were able to accommodate us and we were grateful! Matt was an excellent server and made the experience even better. 70%off the party was from out of state and they loved the food. read more

See all

If you like everything floating in some of the worst gravy (sauce for the rest of you) then you'll love this old dark and dinghy joint. Service sucked. Ambiance again if you like a dark old joint you'll love it. The hostess could not be anymore rude. Do yourself a favor don't go. I can't give 0 stars or better yet negative numbers of stars or I would. Junk !! read more

The food was superb, the waitress was entertaining and the price was reasonable. Drinks were very good

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Biagetti's restaurant and I must say, I was blown away by the incredible experience. From the moment I walked in, I could feel the warm and inviting ambiance. It's clear that Biagetti's pays meticulous attention to detail when it comes to their food. Their eggplant rolllatini, sausage bread, and every meal we ordered was the best Italian food we have ever had. Their tomato sauce was amazing! Not only was the food delicious but the service was top-notch!!! The staff at Biagetti's went above and beyond to ensure that every one of us was well taken care of. By the time we left we felt like family. We loved everything so much we went back again 4 days later. We live in FL but rest assured we will be back at Biagetti's on our next trip to CT. I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a great family Italian dinner. Mangia mangia read more

Great portion sizes. Good service. Food was well prepared. One of the best values in the area.

This is my first time ever going to Biagetti's restaurant. I think it was absolutely delicious I love the homemade pasta. It was so light. I did it was delicious I can't wait for my leftovers for my lunch tomorrow. read more

Biagetti's Restaurant - the outside of a restaurant - Italian Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

This review is a correction for the overly critical and frankly embarrassing review I gave just a few days ago. I was contacted by a very nice woman from the restaurant the next morning, and advised that I was one of 32 people she was getting back to after a total breakdown of her phone system the day before. She was very apologetic and tried her best to accommodate me to schedule another reservation. I thanked her and assured her that we would be back soon. So, I haven't yet eaten there, but I wanted to make sure and correct my previous post. Btw, if anyone can tell me how to delete that post I'd be grateful. I will review again after we eat. read more

This place is a gem in West Haven. Food is great and the staff is top tier. I have been her several times and will continue to go there. read more

Biagetti's Restaurant - Tiramisu is my favorite dessert! It exceeds my expectation. - Italian Near Me - West Haven, Connecticut

During my last day in Connecticut my friend was beyond excited for me to try this place. She bragged that every time she brings a new person here, it becomes their favorite meal and now she can add me to this list. This is one of the best Italian places I've had in a while. I was shocked at how busy it was on a weekday night but thankfully the wait wasn't too long. Food and service were also pretty fast and the portion sizes were ginormous! I ordered the famous meat treasure chest and a treasure it was! The different meats were so flavorful and plentiful. Even eating half of it a day later it was still, to my surprise, so delicious! My friend had a special seasonal chicken parm dish they had available for the month and she thought it was just ok and suggested sticking to the meat treasure chest. All in all a very good first time visit! read more

Always a great place to go with friends. The meal never disappoints! Friendly service and good food a must try. read more

We went to have a family style lunch served after a sales presentation. The food was very tasty but we didn't choose off the menu. Great restaurant! We'll be back. read more

Five of us went to dinner tonight and we all had delicious dinners. The favorite was their famous Treasure Chest which consists of four of their specialties over pasta. Awesome! The wait staff is efficient, accommodating, and friendly. read more

As my first time at Biagetti's, I was attending a baby shower and not sure what to expect for "event" food, however I was pleasantly surprised how good and plentiful the food was-- I had the stuffed filet and salad, my friend had the steak which was great. The service was exceptional for the entire shower, considering how many of us were ordering different wines and variety of drinks for the table! Now we have a new place on our list for dinner. read more

Great for family gatherings food is always consistent. I love the eggplant there! Service is good and they sometimes have music which is nice read more

Homemade cavatelli was out of this world! Never had passatelli before and it was so good--I'm going to try to make it. Their sauce is delicious, dinner was like eating at your Italian grandmother's table. Can't wait to come back! read more