PREFACE: If you're wondering why all the most recent posts are from privileged, entitled students or rich people who clearly hate poor people more than they understand the role of policing, this review is for you. My review will not focus on the homeless, since that's a much larger issue than any cops can or should single-handedly address. I'm also not going to complain about protests, an inherently sticky issue anywhere in the world. Rather, I will focus on the lack of training and professionalism evident in Berkeley police officers, which effects all of those things.
Side note: I'm focusing on Berkeley police, not UC police, though they're related. I'm also not hating on the officers; they're often nice people who just weren't trained on more than the bare minimum of procedure.
(FYI, hate speech is not free speech, so comments about BPD being the enforcers of Antifa are just plain wrong. Antifa has many complaints of its own about BPD, and "conservatives" need to be more careful about associating personal beliefs with professional critiques, though I don't expect them to understand that. This review is for people with a healthy distrust of American cops, not a blind and un-examined hatred of poor people. Berkeley is not a filthy hole, just another city with a complicated past and present. If you're more upset about its grime and homeless population, it's probably because you have a limited perspective on the world. Your sheltered life is not your fault, but it is something to know about before commenting on the world at large...)
REVIEW: No one at this department knows what they're doing. In my interactions with them (and, for the record, every Alameda Sheriff's officer I ran into), most of their conversations were debates about how to do their jobs. Seriously, from beginning to end, everyone had questions about the basics of their daily job. How to fill out this form, how to process this kind of case, when things are happening, who should know what, where superior officers are in the building. The entire system is a scary farce. They're writing tickets and making arrests to prove they do something, but a lot of it is legwork for show. In the end, they're mostly just newbs who are confused about the role of policing. Admittedly, in a police state like the U.S., that's a tricky issue, but training should cover at least half of that confusion. From what I saw, I can only assume training is a two week coarse on how to wear the uniform, not what to do once it's on...
Again, nice people. But niceness doesn't get stuff done. Often, this kind of obliviousness leads to more injustice in our already imbalanced and hodge-podge "justice" system. Train police better, and they might be less likely to eff up left and right... Just an idea. read more