What a wonderful impressive jewelry store with outstanding personalized service. The selection is…read moreoutstanding and much more diverse than those big box one size fits all jewelry stores.. I have also used their repair service many times and have always been highly satisfied. I'm a life long customer and enjoy supporting an independent family owned business. Keep up the good work!

My husband and I have purchased many things from John and Heidi, including our wedding rings. They…read moreare awesome! Very knowledgable and personable. We make an effort to drive to Lake Mills from the Milwaukee area to have our jewelry repaired. Countryside Jewelry gets our highest endorsement!

Beautiful selection, excellent, professional and knowledgeable Found a gorgeous antique ring-…read moregoing back after Christmas

Today, I visited this jewelry store for the first time. I asked for a price on a gold vintage…read morenecklace. The lady that helped me was extremely professional , and she identified the karet stamp on a rope gold chain immediately. The owner offered me a fair price compared to their competitor across the street. The competitor across the street was not able to find the karet stamp, and the price was grossly unfair. $ 32.00 dollars for 18 karet gold a gram while scrap gold is trading over$ 62.00 I will definitely consult Kamin jewelry professionals. They were honest jewelers - and I would definitely give my business to them for future gold repairs or gold prices.

Taryn and Alisa NEED TO BE PAID MORE THAN WHAT THEY GET PAID CURRENTLY AFTER WORKING WITH THEN!…read more This place is a really nice spot to go if you need jewelry. Not to mention their whole team is awesome. I mainly worked with Taryn and she was amazing and was very helpful with sorting out the questions and finalizing my particular customizations I wanted. Alisa was very nice assisting with the initial visit and assisting when Taryn was out. I had the best experience ever and I'm thankful that I bought from this location. The whole team needs a raise, especially Taryn and Alisa deserve one though because they took the most time sorting everything out and helping work through all the hassles of the work flow. Taryn was exceptional helping me find something that I loved that also fit my style too, big props to her she definitely deserves a bonus and employee of the month. it's only fair because she helped me with my SpongeBob bracelet. I highly recommend, pleasantly surprised and highly satisfied with my purchase and the entire experience. They were down to earth, helpful, kind, supportive, fast and very efficient.. not to mention they took extra time to research and prepare a lot of extra stuff when I was looking/shopping for options. 11/10 you will not be disappointed. Give Taryn and Alisa a raise.. NOW! that's the only reason my rating is not 100/10 Ps if you don't give Taryn and Alisa more money on their paycheck i will find a way to tell everyone not to shop here anymore so you better do it. You should really really really do it (give Taryn and Alisa more money please) -Thank you in advance

Love the honest customer service. Everything you want in a local business. Great prices as wellread more

So far, so great! Got my engagement ring here and they were nothing but the best. I visited more…read morethan five other diamond shops prior to the diamond center they led me to look for better service. And I found exactly that at the diamond center on the west side of Madison. Tricia helped me find my ring and I bought it the first day I entered that building. I needed the custom ring within 10 days and Tricia got it completed and ready in six. I picked it up and it looked absolutely beautiful. Update: ended up needing it resized. I left Tricia a voicemail and she got me in the next day to drop it off and they had it ready in five days. Again, meeting my sharp deadline! I've been completely satisfied with a diamond center so far!

They created my engagement ring and it was beautiful. Was in every six months the first year to…read morehave it checked and cleaned - no issues. After about two year, the center stone fell out and I was told by another jeweler that TWO prongs would have had to fail for this to happen. TDC would not honor this because it. had been 7 months since I had my ring checked. The ring was just a few years old and I worked in an office. I was not hard on my jewelry. I had to purchase another stone (why did I buy it again from them???) to fix. I know things can happen but when you build a ring and I pay for the stones, the least you can do is not have it fall apart. And if it does - stand behind it and make it right. I had to make a claim on my homeowners who nearly dropped us for such a large claim. I sent a letter to the owner and naturally received zero response. Decided to never go back and we took all our spending elsewhere. We moved our business from TDC to Goodman's where we purchased many new pieces over the years. Now we live closer to Oconomowoc and go to a local shop where the jeweler is on site and they do stand behind their work.

My husband purchased/sized all of our wedding rings and bands here and it was a great experience…read more Recently, I stopped by on a week night to get my band sized up a little to match my engagement ring. It was a little before close, so I was expecting to have to leave my band there for them to work on it, but they were able to work their magic in the time we were there and get the ring to finally fit my finger comfortably. Would highly recommend this place for purchasing rings! They have great customer service and a nice selection.

Went in to have a watch band repaired and Wow - they were so great. No waiting and they offered to…read moreclean my wedding band as a bonus. It has 16 diamonds on it. I didn't realize how dull it was looking until it came back cleaned - practically needed sunglasses it was so sparkly! Very nice staff and so helpful - I'll definitely go back for my jewelry gifts! First class all the way. Thank you Middleton Jewelers!

Second review for Arthur and 1 month late-- he is amazing!!! I cried and hugged him when I picked…read moreup my "new" engagement ring. I had my grandmother's wedding band that (due to age) had fallen apart. I asked Arthur to design a ring using my engagement diamond and use the baguettes from her ring. Totally trusting that he'd create something amazing- he exceeded my expectation and I left with a ring that has received several compliments! Do not hesitate to give him the opportunity to give you an amazing experience!

Very nice place. Very knowledgeable and helpful. Fixed all my jewelry and very go rates.read more

They know their products. Had an estimate done and they were very prompt. Will be taking some…read morepieces back to get appraised.

Love Diamonds Select! From the moment I walked in and was greeted warmly by Teri, Hillary and…read moreBrian, I knew this store was very special. Sincerely kind, genuine and nice people! Very down-to-earth. And the store is beautiful!! Lots to choose from and awesome prices. Finally a jewelry store that makes you feel welcome and comfortable, and having a lot of different items to choose from. Teri is wonderful and a delight to work with! Go to Diamonds Select! You'll be so happy you did!

I had gone to Timothy Grant Jewelry to see if they could help me replace a battery for and…read moreinexpensive watch. Other jewelers had said it wasn't worth it and to just purchase a new one. The personnel at Timothy Grant were courteous, professional and considerate. They took the time to examine my watch and determined it not only needed a new battery but a bit of internal cleaning - which they did for free! It's difficult to find such good service nowadays, isn't it? I highly recommend Timothy Grant not only for their battery replacement but for their gorgeous jewelry selections.

Once again, I must stress that these are some of the kindest people in the jewelry industry I've…read moreever come across. I've loved jewelry since I was six years old and that was decades ago though I still love it! If you have an idea or a dream you'd like to see come to fruition, this is the place. Mike is the Master Jeweler and has so many brilliant ideas as well as designing and making the treasures, Damian is wonderful as far as helping to perfect the piece so it's just like you imagined, and Fennessa, Will and Jon, the owner, will make you feel so comfortable, you'll visit time and time again. Whether you need a simple watch battery or neck chain repair, give them a try~ you'll see after the first visit that you made the right choice. Christmas is just four months away so check them out and select the pieces for your loved ones or have something special made; they still have time.