I purchased my engagement ring here and I have nothing but great things about this place. I worked…read morewith Brett S., who was fantastic. I made three separate visits to Kessler's before my final purchase. The first time I just sat down with Brett and we talked about diamonds for an hour. The 4 C's, what is important, what is not, the type of setting I was interested in, looked at several different stones under microscopes, etc. There was no guarantee of a sale at that point and Brett spent as much time with me as I wanted, just explaining all of my options. It was great, and after that, I felt 100% comfortable. I came back a second time to narrow down my options and again felt absolutely no pressure. When I finally made the purchase, I was confident I was getting a great diamond and a great ring. I got the ring appraised afterwards, and it was appraised for more than I purchased it. So to top it off, I got a great deal. The diamond sparkles and my fiance loves it. I highly, highly, recommend Kessler's. I drove from Chicago three times (upon a recommendation) to buy a ring there, and it was worth every minute.

Stopped in to drop off a ring rhodium plated. My husband ended up purchasing a silver chain while…read morewe were there. Kayla provided exceptional customer service even though the item we were purchasing wasn't not very expensive. I mention that because she really spent time helping us and made the experience easy and fun.

I was in Madison on a business trip and I stopped by Chalmers to get some advice on an engagement…read morering I was designing. Garrett was incredibly helpful and gave me all sorts of great advice and ideas for my design. He is honest and incredibly knowledgeable in the world of jewelry design and gemology. I even got a quote from him out of curiosity and it was very competitive, even including shipping to CA! Sadly, I ended up going with a jeweler that was local to me in CA just for the sake of convenience, but if I lived anywhere near Madison, I would 1000% go with Chalmers.

Fantastic customer service. Victor was kind and helpful. On a business trip and my watch battery…read moredied. Located this shop in Yelp and so glad I did! The jeweler needed a special tool to open my watch but he had it and he fixed it! So thankful- I always need to know what time it is. Thank you Victor and Chalmers Jewelers!

Honest/fair pricing. Good people who run the business. Family owned. They will weigh your jewelry…read moreand tell you what it's worth and potentially purchase from you.

My son had an amazing experience here purchasing an engagement ring. Highly recommend!read more

Under the heading of "you can't make this up" my husband and I both found ourselves in Madison…read morewith dead batteries in our watches. A quick online search lead us to Goodman's so we walked over from our hotel after check in. We were greeted quickly and both of our watches were professionally serviced and back in working order at a very reasonable price. As I was waiting, I checked out the selection. They have a wonderful selection of diamonds and gemstone jewelry with prices ranging from very affordable to fine quality. Highly recommended

Complete waste of time. I explained in a very detailed way what I wanted done to my rings, what the…read morematerial was, and why I was unhappy with the previous work. I was told they have the best jeweler around and come on down. Drove two hours to get told they can't help me because the exact details I gave over the phone prevent it. I was also told I should just accept substandard work because it's actually not substandard, it's really good work (it's not). Yet another local jewelry shop who over promises and under delivers.

This place is amazing!absolutely fabulous customer service! I have sold numerous pieces of jewelry…read moreto them! Very fair trade-in costs and I've also purchased from them and very very happy with my purchases! Highly recommend!

Great place to sell your coins/jewelry. Their pricing is spot on and they are very fair. Depending…read moreon when you go wait times can be longer. Worth the wait though.

The most informative and knowledgeable jeweler! All my questions were so sussinctly answered…read more Estimates offered as well. I highly recommend. Classes available.

This is the place to go to trade in your gold and silver for cash. A reputable business with a…read moreknowledgeable staff. I felt very confident that I got the best prices for my unwanted jewelry with no gimmicks. What a great shop as well! Full of talented jewelers. I will return in the future. Who would have known such a place still exists where integrity takes front stage? It was a pleasure to do business with the Howard family.

I recently bought a watch that was a bit too large. This place adjusted it free of charge. I…read moreperused a little while I waited. They also have a good selection of time pieces.

I went in to get a watch battery changed and left just a few minutes later with this adorable retro…read morecat clock as well! What a great local shopping experience.

Before coming to Diamonds Select I visited over 9 different ring shops in several different states…read moretrying to find the perfect ring. Most of the places I went were overpriced, pushy, and mass produced rings so there was no individuality. I decided to visit diamonds select on a whim while home visiting family. My mom had heard wonderful things about the business and the people who worked there. Upon entering we were greeted by warm hellos. Teri was so gracious and asked important questions to better understand my ring preferences and most importantly my, now fiancées, preferences. She was patient, knowledgeable, and most of all honest. She genuinely listened to the stories my family shared about my relationship and was eager to help find the perfect ring. When I finally found the perfect ring, I discovered it was vastly out of my price range. Teri was so accommodating offering to call other shops and even help reduce the price. But the best part was how she managed to bring the price point down on the very ring I fell in love with, so that I could purchase it. There were lots of happy tears! After purchasing the ring, Teri made sure to have it ready as soon as possible, since I lived out of state. The ring was flawlessly resized and cleaned. It was done earlier than expected and I was able to propose while my fiancée was still home and surrounded by family. The whole experience from start to finish was better than I could have ever hoped. I will be returning there with future business.

Never trust a business that tells you lab grown diamonds far exceed the value of a real diamond…read more I was told to put it under my insurance and make a claim to get what the value is of a real diamond. So commit a fraud to get money for my diamond. Never ever have I ever heard such Bull crap. Unbelievable.