Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Benjamin Elder, MD, PhD

    5.0 (2 reviews)

    Benjamin Elder, MD, PhD Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Benjamin Elder, MD, PhD

    Recommended Reviews - Benjamin Elder, MD, PhD

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    12 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Mayo Clinic

    Mayo Clinic

    2.9(367 reviews)
    0.0 mi

    I have never been to a medical network like the Mayo Clinic. This place is absolutely massive, and…read moreI was not disappointed in the care I received here. I first visited to discuss a surgical procedure for my facial nerve. Even with me traveling here from across the country, everything was a well orchestrated symphony. The electronic check in systems gave me exactly what I needed to know, and told me precisely where to go. When I arrived, they even told me where I needed to sit for when I'd be called back. The care team took their time with me and I had all my questions answered and we agreed on next steps. They even got me in, same day, to talk to a physical therapist, since I was from out of town.

    The good, I have had excellent care at both the La Crosse, previously in Caledonia, Mn…read more Although, this hospital should really move into the new realities of life in 2026. What I will describe to you is the phone system, the RN or MD calls you, and leaves a VM with the phone number to call back. Alas, you cannot call the number that is provided. I have a heart procedure scheduled, and you would think proper care would involve the hospital providing the patient with an important phone number to call in the VM. Of course, perhaps I am not an international patient who pays cash?? This practice should stop, full stop. I was told by a kind receptionist that the nurse ( who called 4 times within 10 minutes while I was teaching) leaving an accurate phone number to call back, was possibly a HIPA violation. What is going on here? This is ridiculous! Is leaving the correct number a HIPA violation, I think not. If so, how about a modern variation TEXT me the proper information, that is used with many Mayo correspondence. The app doesn't help, when responding to the updated time that was described in the VM. I believe I am not the only person experiencing this problem. Too big to fail ? Maybe

    Photos
    Mayo Clinic - In the Palmer building at Mayo Clinic one of the Mayo doctors one of the brothers original office preserved

    In the Palmer building at Mayo Clinic one of the Mayo doctors one of the brothers original office preserved

    Mayo Clinic
    Mayo Clinic - Gonda Building

    See all

    Gonda Building

    Mayo Clinic Hospital - A sippy cup with the Mayo clinic logo on it.

    Mayo Clinic Hospital

    2.6(39 reviews)
    0.8 mi

    I had surgery at the Mayo Clinic Hospital, for a condition that has caused me issues for over a…read moredecade. After months of consulting and scheduling, it was time for my surgery. From a patient perspective, everything was very smooth. Check in was quick and organized, and they pointed me right where to go. I got taken back for prep within about fifteen minutes. Prep itself took about two hours before it was show time. During that time I did intake with the nursing staff, met with the anesthesiologist and a pharmacist, and eventually talked to the surgical team directly. When it was time to go, my bed was wheeled to the operating room, where the staff had a very upbeat attitude that quickly put me at ease. Anesthesia is sort of like time travel, you just wake up finished as if you'd just closed your eyes. When I was coming around, they got me situated in recover after my seven hour surgery. When I was ready they wheeled me to my room where I spent one night. Every single person I interacted with was so wonderful and kind; Truly I have no regrets with choosing this team to handle my care. I've seen other hospitals where the attitude of the staff can project onto the patients, and I saw none of that here. Never once did I feel like a bother, and never once did I not get the care I needed. And I'm healing up nicely!

    I was very disappointed with the Mayo Clinic! After being referred by two different doctors in the…read moreTwin Cities for a very rare disease, I was accepted as a patient with Dr. Joseph Butterfield. Dr. Butterfield's reviews rank him at a 2.6. All of my Twin Cities doctors are at least 4.8. These ratings I have found pretty accurately reflect competency and patient interactions. Dr. Butterfield was rude, dismissive, unresponsive to questions, and actually stopped communicating when I asked questions. I went to Patient Experience at the Mayo Clinic and requested a different doctor but was denied and there was no follow up. I did find much more competent doctors in the Twin Cities who have been able to treat my rare disease.

    Photos
    Mayo Clinic Hospital - A breakfast of potatoes, scrambled eggs, and turkey sausage.

    A breakfast of potatoes, scrambled eggs, and turkey sausage.

    Mayo Clinic Hospital - A chilled single serving of sherbet.

    A chilled single serving of sherbet.

    Mayo Clinic Hospital - French toast and diced sausage.

    See all

    French toast and diced sausage.

    Saint Marys Hospital - Candied Butternut Squash Salad at the Mayo Clinic/St. Mary's Visitor Cafe

    Saint Marys Hospital

    3.3(32 reviews)
    0.8 mi

    A broken bone left me feeling forced to go to the ER. The attending physician was good in that he…read morefound the fracture, even though the radiologist said there was none. They left a resident to set my bone, but he was very sleepy and very poorly trained. He was not supervised while doing it, and he made three major mistakes. Though I didn't realize it at the time, I told him three things that should have prompted him not to make those mistakes, but he made them anyway. I pointed out an area of pain after he finished setting the area, but he just glanced at it and threw his hands up as though he was upset that I mentioned it. Then, he stared at my face, unresponsive. I'd been calm and patient throughout, but bizarre behavior concerned me. I didn't feel safe with his trance-like gaze and lack of response to the pain. I had told him it would have to be fixed before I left, but he refused. He could have called in his attending physician, but he didn't. He was ready to discharge me with an improperly set bone that ignored three significant precautions he should have taken. Since I was exhausted and sleepy, I told him it was fine so I could get out of there and seek care somewhere else. If I had been more rested, I would have insisted that he bring in the attending physician. Instead, I simply let them discharge me with an improperly set bone, in pain, and went home. When I got home, I found the problem. I made e a temporary fix myself, waiting for my family to come home 14 hours later to help me make a better one. Then I returned to the hospital to have the bad splint cut off, with the standard procedures followed, the precautions taken, and the problem fixed. Until I did that, the first one was unsanitary and caused intense itching from bacterial overgrowth as he'd not sanitized the area; there were bloody abrasions in an area not close to the broken bone, and there was swelling from him jamming two body parts tightly together without precautions. The resident clearly had no idea what he was doing, as the situation was not complex. All he had to do was properly sanitize the area, protect a specific area from abrasion after swelling began to subside, and prepare the area so that no collateral damage was caused by the way he set the bone. He did none of that, though I had pointed out those three issues. Instead of getting help to find the cause of the pain, something I was able to do myself at home, he simply wrote that I had experienced a psychological problem. I looked that up, and I had displayed ZERO symptoms of that or any other psychological problem. He just used that as an excuse not to address the pain his very poor performance caused. When I talked to the surgeon about addressing that baseless diagnosis, the surgeon blew it off, though he easily could have told the resident to address it, especially since my having to replace the splint quickly left plenty of evidence that his bad performance was the issue. The surgeon then tried to dismiss me from physical therapy after only one session, though I was unable to use that part of my body, it was mangled-looking, and there was intense pain and immobility in a large area. I did everything as directed. Rather than investigating, the surgeon laughed it off, saying, "No pain, no gain!" He dismissed me without addressing that area and without my having full functioning of my body part. The records said I did, but that was absolutely not true. I had to read medical literature on my own and use kitchen utensils to try to fix the affected areas, and it was painful. Because of the delay in diagnosing the large areas of many thick and painful adhesions (with me having to self-diagnose) and because I'm not a medical professional, there was no way for me to get them addressed well by myself. I did the best I could, but years later, I'm still unable to straighten that area or use it normally. In fact, it caused limited blood flow, and I had to figure out on my own how to improve it. Two areas shriveled over the years due to inadequate blood flow caused by undiagnosed adhesions. To top it off, that surgeon was supposed to send approval for transportation since I couldn't drive with the fracture, but he repeatedly failed to do so, leaving me stranded and suspected of fraud by my insurance company. In one appt, he made grotesque faces and wildly waved his arms while speaking in a nicer tone than usual. That was after a badgeless man who claimed to be a doctor came in his place and asked me inappropriate questions for the situation, claiming the surgeon was not there. To top it off, a surprise phone appointment with the surgeon featured him slurring his words the entire time. Very unprofessional all around. Not exactly what you'd expect from someone paid 7 figures every year.

    MUST READ.... I wanted to start the review with…read moreacknowledging just a few of the many exceptional staff we were fortunate to have interacted with. Dr Rachel Neff, Dr Franz, Kimberly Thompson, Dr Matthew Koster, and Eva Carmona are few that come to mind as being extraordinary in their fields of expertise. But unfortunately I feel an overwhelming obligation to share my Moms overall experience with Saint Marys hospital and Doctor Kalra, and Dr Silva. With the intension of hopefully helping others with unique cases like my Moms by sharing what we have learned. We realized early on that my Mom's Autoimmune Pulmonary Fibrosis was extremely sensitive to any types of stress, resulting in flare-ups and repeated hospitalizations. After years of continual monitoring we realized low oxygen even for short periods of time put Her body under a tremendous amount of stress creating inflammation, resulting in increased oxygen needs, elevated resting heartrate, and hospitalization (flare-up). So to extend time between flare-ups we implemented strict oxygen monitoring and titratration to maintain Her oxygen 93-95. Which has proven over the years to be Her healthy range. High enough to avoid an inflammatory response but low enough to not elevate Co2 levels. For us, strict oxygen management was the most impactful treatment validated by the few years of continuous oxygen monitoring data we have stored in the cloud. For Her low oxygen is like treading water, putting Her already weakened system under continual stress resulting in inflammation and increased heartrates. While in the hospital I know I ruffled feathers by continually mentioning this and was told I was worried too much about the numbers and should just go by how you feel. My Mom doesn't get really winded until Her oxygen drops really low, into the low 70s, which we try to avoid because we have repeatedly seen the negative results. Even one crash to the low 70s has doubled Her oxygen flow needs, and increased Her resting heartrates over 100 without the ability to come down without high doses of Prednisone. While dropping to 88 for short periods of time, for a few minutes, usually while recovering from activity doesn't result in any negative effects. Extended periods of time clearly does. It was extremely difficult to have our learned experience be repeatedly dismissed by Dr Karla, and Dr Silva. When bringing my concerns to Dr Kalra He said oxygen levels at 85 for hours isn't dangerous, and that people in the Himalayas have low oxygen their entire lives. As a life long runner, I explained that is actually incorrect. People living at elevation adapt by producing more red blood cells which is the bodies way to maintain healthy oxygen saturation levels similar to us. Which infuriated Him. It was so frustrating seeing my Moms oxygen levels regularly in the mid 80s, and referring to it as weening. The best way to ween my Mom's oxygen is by maintaining 93-95, which is what we returned to after discharge and without that stress on Her system Her flow rate came down on it's own. She returned to Her 4 liter baseline and it has remained that way for the last 2 months. This was the first hospitalization when low oxygen practices were used on Her and was also by far Her longest stay 41 days. She was admitted on 8 liters in the middle of a flare-up and eventually discharged on 7 liters with resting heartrates 90-110, still in flare-up. She also experienced erratic heartrate arrhythmia, chest pain and tightness during Her hospitalization for the first time but hasn't experienced it since discharge. We have the data to prove She was maintained a majority of the time in the 80s from our personal continous oxygen data logger. And daily pictures of our monitor numbers matching their monitor. Theirs was a visio logger that often had a dead battery for hours a day. So She was often unmonitored except for our personal logger. I was continually going to the nurses station begging them to turn up Her oxygen and noticed on their monitor once Her room number showed She was currently 81 oxygen but it wasn't red or in alarm. Apparently they were annoyed by my Mom's oxygen alarm continually going off so turned off Her alarm rather than turn up Her oxygen. Dr Kalara just repeatedly got angry when I attempted to communicate these concerns. Even more concerning is the repeated false reporting in my Moms clinical notes that our data, pictures, and time can prove was false. I was there and maintain meticulous documentation. I even reached out to patient experience with my concerns and realized rather quickly they weren't really interested in ways to improve the safety of patients or the integrity of reporting. More a coordinated effort of further suppressing and covering up legitimate concerns. When they found out I had proof I was told I wouldn't be able to visit in the future. Please stay with your family, advocate, monitor, document.

    Photos
    Saint Marys Hospital
    Saint Marys Hospital
    Saint Marys Hospital

    See all

    Carol Reid, MD

    Carol Reid, MD

    3.3(3 reviews)
    0.8 mi

    Dr. Reid is listed here as a cosmetic surgeon, but she's also an ear/nose/throat doctor. Both my…read morehusband and I have consulted with her for ear/nose/throat problems and have a lot of trust in her abilities to diagnose and treat us.

    I am so appalled by the way this doctor handled my care, if I could give less than one star I would…read more! I made an appointment for some sinus problems I thought I was having- I have not had problems in the past so this was my first visit. The first round of treatment was sort of a trial and error approach which I was fine with, because I didn't want to jump right into a cat scan to see what was going on. After that treatment was unsuccessful, I opted on her recommendation to get the scan. A week or so after I got the scan, I called her office to find out why I hadn't heard back with my results, and I was told that I would have to make another appointment to go over the results. I have had tests done in the past and usually the doctor or nurse or NP will call you and give you results and tell you course of treatment, but I can't get anyone at this office to tell me what they saw on my scan, if anything or if its necessary to have another appointment. I have an HSA , and unlike many visits that are co pay driven, I have to pay for each visit. This gets expensive and I explained that to her. I would be happy to come back in if they saw something on my scan that was concerning , but I would be annoyed and it would be unnecessary to have me come back in to prescribe antibiotics. When I told them that I would not come back in until I talked to the doctor or had the results of my scan read to me, they told me it was a 75.00 fee to speak to her . Cmon!! That's not why you became a doctor is it??? I left feeling like the only thing important to this practice was my money, which I have decided not to give anymore of-on principle . I wonder if she sleeps well at night knowing that? This is not a best patient care approach to healthcare! Very disappointed :(

    Photos
    Carol Reid, MD
    Carol Reid, MD
    Carol Reid, MD

    See all

    Benjamin Elder, MD, PhD - surgeons - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...