Surprised for the current 3.6 rating for this place. I see some older 1-star rankings so not sure…read moreif old stuff is dragging them down. Anyway, this was recommended by my niece. Thankful for the advice. Restaurant is clean, has a nice hometown vibe, and the service was amazing. The food was plentiful; my wife and I left stuffed. And it was delicious. We got chicken wings, cheese bread, and a pepperoni lovers pizza. All cooked to perfection and just delicious!

Our pizza and cheese sticks were amazing. I don't know how they could get it more perfect. Our…read moreserver forgot us but the owner I believe quickly made it up to us and waited on us. Everything came out pretty quickly and was so delicious. The restaurant is welcoming and cute and clean with lots of seating. Will be back

This is actually a Casey's General Store gas station & convenience store combo even though Yelp has…read morethem listed as a carry out pizza restaurant. The gas is reasonably priced, the bathroom tiny but clean, and the convenience store crowded but well stocked. The were several options for coffee (Columbian, hazelnut, and classic). We got the Columbian and it was good. I got a raised donut that looked like donut holes arranged in the shape of a flower that could give any donut shop a run for its money. I didn't try the pizza, but it was individual slices and personal sized pizzas under a little heat lamp. I don't know if you can actually order a whole pizza to be made fresh or not. Not bad for a refueling and restroom stop.

So good! The sauce was so savory and good. They delivered to our campsite, and the delivery person…read morewas very nice. Having the option for delivery to our RV was so convenient after a day of travel. Definitely will order again next time we are in the area.

We've settled on and made peace with their original thinnest crust pizza. With the right toppings…read moreand eaten HOT, we've come to enjoy it. We're from Chicago. Nothing in Central Illinois compares to Chicago pizza........we've accepted that. Alfano's other pizzas, crusts, are just mediocre. We've also started to order the breadsticks, tho they could use more flavor like an "Aurelio's Pizza" breadsticks. I prefer a creamy garlic salad dressing for dipping the breadsticks. Alfano's does not serve one and all I could find in Central Illinois grocery stores that came close was a Wishbone creamy Italian. We've given up on the garlic bread, just too dried out, brittle and they won't add extra butter or garlic. Found out that their garlic bread is pre-made, then frozen, then thawed.........which explains the dissatisfaction. Yet, most of their other ingredients on their other food/pizzas, seem very fresh. All that said, it's nice that they deliver to the lake at Oak Run, $8 delivery charge and then we tip $5 on top of that. They've delivered in all weather, very much appreciated. And finally, everyone working there has always been very kind and efficient. We've never eaten at the restaurant itself. They've never messed up our credit card bill or gotten our order wrong. We're lucky they're there and that they will deliver.

Good thin crust pizza pub style thin. Son had spaghetti…read morewhich was a big serving. 2 kids could probably split. Bread sticks were descent too. You Order then sit or sit then order at counter. Table Service was Great after sitting. The place is a little dingy though out of date

I love their thin and crispy pizza. Service in Princeton is always good and they are quick with…read moredelivers and pick up orders.

I called first to see if they had something handheld as I'm traveling through town. The employee…read morethat answered the phone was very polite and helpful and also willing to explain specials and ingredients. I decided to go in and make my choice. Both employees working were so kind and helpful. The sandwich was delicious! And liked the kindness showed when the employee that checked me out got me more napkins upon my request and offered to grab the door for me on the way out. While the food speaks for itself (so good and a fantastic price for a healthy lunch!), politeness goes a long way! Highly recommend!

This was flagged as one of the best pizza places in all of Illinois so it's been on my to try list…read morefor a while. Located on Seminary Street, cute shops surround and on street parking available. Unassuming from the outside and purely historic, refurbished, recycled everything inside. Jazz and classic rock was playing on a record player. Staff was lovely and helpful with questions. Order at the counter and take a seat. Glasses are chilled, no ice. Canned sodas, water, alcoholic beverages available. Pizza has 4 sizes, specials and make your own. Sandwiches, salads. I chose the goat cheese and herb pizza and it was sooooo good. Chewy yet crunchy, the crust is perfection. Takes 20-30 minutes when not just. Worth the wait. Will definitely come back when we are in the area.

What can I say? Sams has been an icon here in the Illinois…read moreValley for as long as I can remember. Sam serves pizza. That's it. Pizza. But what a pizza it is. Never have we been disappointed with it. The thing that gets me is, you call to place your order and he never writes anything down. Ever!! He puts it all in his "computer" lol. That's his noggin if you haven't figured that out. Anyway, give him a call, place your order, wait 49 minutes, and dig in!!! You'll be back..... We all go back. Enjoy!!!

Amazing pizza. Sam is hilarious. A big reason for me to visit this area was to eat from his…read moreplace. Unfortunately it appears he is now retired and it seems that he is permanently closed. Hope he can sell the business and train someone on how to work his magic. He sure is something special and will be missed

Wow! Really surprised. Stuck here on work for the night. I got the Deluxe Combo, Salad and a…read moreCannoli. It's was all excellent! Thin crispy crust with a great sauce. I'm in shock that I found a decent pie in this shit show.

I don't understand the good ratings on this place, maybe it's good for Mendota? Pretty average…read morepizza, I tried a second time just be sure. Ordinary pizza, the wife agrees.

Our first visit to Smash Pizza. In a word, OUTSTANDING. My wife and I shared a large half-sausage…read morehalf-pepperoni pizza. Actually, it might be more accurate to say we fought over it! Fortunately it was large enough to satisfy both of us plus enough left over for almost another meal. At the end, we just looked at each other, smiled, and agreed it was right up there with the very best pizzas we have EVER had. And we're both in our 70s. We've had A LOT OF PIZZAS. We will be back again and again.

We live in Las Vegas so pizza is not difficult to find and there is a lot of great pies. Smash is…read moreoutstanding. Our daughter and son-in-law brought us there and we ordered the Bee Sting. This is one of the best Sicilian pizza's I've every had. The dough was thick and airy and the toppings were fresh and the sauce was perfectly perfect. Our other daughter and son-in-law joined us and they tried a thin crust pizza, so I couldn't help myself...and it was also excellent. And of course we started with a wonderfully fresh salad. Top off the great food with OUTSTANDING service and a great atmosphere. It was our first meal in town and a wonderful start to our Christmas week. Do yourself a favor and getchoself some Smash Pizza.

Easily the best pizza in the area. No question…read more Easily the best pizza in the area. No question.

this place is deadass dogshit. pizza was so mid, service was the worst for ever had, manager was…read morevery inconsiderate, first 0/10 ive ever had at a restaurant. fuck ass restaurant

Tried a jumbo slice of their regular crust sausage and cheese pizza at lunchtime. It was just ok…read more It didn't inspire me to try a whole version of their deep dish/stuffed, as I had hoped. At $5 the jumbo slices are ample and affordable and the man at the counter was very nice. I just wouldn't go out of my way to eat there again though, but I hope they do well. They have plenty of other choices on their menu and they seem accommodating to having customers who return. There seems to be a need in Kewanee for a place like this, especially at lunchtime. I just wish I had enjoyed the pizza more.

Excellent Chicago style deep dish and the Italian beef is great. Can't wait to go again.read more