Went to get some steaks for the holiday bbq on 5/24/24....and again, the food looks fantastic, but…read morethe customer service is awful. The place is clean, and everything is neat. The varieties of food look fresh. You can't go wrong with any choice. Chicken is delicious and so is the teres major steak ($15.98 new to me). However, I seem to get the most miserable employee, Joe. Not even a hello and slaps the food on the scale. Doesn't make you want to return.

The guys that work there are very friendly and knowledgeable. I ordered a prime rib roast, the meat…read morewas perfect! Have been going here for years for many other items such asstuffed wings, skirt steak, and pork chops.

Ordered the Valentines Day special. The filet was a good size and delicious. The lobster tail meat…read morewas tender and delicious. A nice touch with the chocolate covered strawberries as well. Thanks for a great dinner making our Vslentines Day wonderful

First time going here after hearing so much about the place...Some servers use gloves, some don't,…read morea lot of the items aren't priced till you get rung up, & then it's to late.. my items are being made and priced but aren't put in front of me but they are putting them on the back counter till the order is done, they don't let you examine the order till your moved to the registers...Ham & cheese on a roll was 12.95, my Bologna and American on a hero was also 12.95, explain that to me.. I don't like the way they do business & after 40 years in the food service industry I think I know my stuff!! I won't be back,

Upsetting experience. I came out in the freezing cold to shop here only to find the store closed…read moreearly. Online hours say they close at 10:00 PM, but I was told they shut down at 9:30 PM because the worker "lives far." If that's the case, the hours need to be updated online. Customers plan their time around what's posted, especially in this weather. Very frustrating and inconvenient.

I like this place, and highly recommended. Always fresh…read moremeat. They also have seasons meat that's ready to grill.

Favorite place to get meat to bbq! The flavors are always so good with a variety to choose from!read more

This place is a joke. I saw pics of the place with ready made food. They were empty when I was…read morethere. No one was at the counter either. Just dont bother with this place.

The store is your typical Italian store with sandwiches, ready made food, There are Italian goods…read morelike cookies and bread. I bought a ham sandwich it was very tasty. They packed the sandwich with loads of ham. Staff is very friendly and fast.

I ordered lunch for the first time via Grubhub. The wife enjoyed an order of eggplant rollatini. I…read moreordered a Cuban empanada and a pastrami/provolone/slaw hero. The rollatini was very good. The eggplant was tender and the filling very nice without being too heavy. The empanada was easily the best I have ever eaten. The shell was thin, light and flaky. The inside was very flavorful and plentiful. (They offer a vast selection of filling choices. Next time I might just order several knowing that it will be excellent). The hero was good but far from great. The pastrami needed to be sliced thinner and the coleslaw probably had cilantro in it of which I am not a fan. My suggestion is stick with the empanadas and the Italian offerings. Very nice!!

high-quality meats, and very good knowledge of the workers been going there for 30+ years, never…read moreonce had any issues with the people or the products. if your coming to Rockaway Beach, you must visit and for sure try the Kansas City steak, burgers,

A Good local butcher, a lil pricey but decent meat as compared to stop n shops butchers who are…read morebarely "butchers"

Beautiful 10lb bone in rib roast seasoned and vacuum packed recommended by Andrew with simple…read moreinstructions. Turned out perfect with 10 happy guests . I will definitely return for my next engagement. Great way to start 2026

What a great place! We were going out to the Hamptons from NYC and stopped at Basil and Prime for a…read morebunch of Prime Ribeyes. We met the owner Andrew and he is such a nice guy. The steak was a 10/10 quality.

We had a great overall experience at quality meats. We ordered the large fillet, the salmon, and…read morethe hanger steak to split for two. Salmon was cooked perfectly, the hanger steak was a huge portion and we liked the cherries, we were disappointed with the fillet- i think we were accidentally given the smaller portion, although the check did say it was the larger. If i could order again, I would have got the Porterhouse; I wish the menu indicated the size of the porterhouse. We got the Parmesan truffle waffle fries, and the cheese gnocchi, and I recommend both. Desert was epic!!! We got the grasshopper Sunday to share, and ended up ordering another it was so good. Service was also outstanding, but at the end there was a lot of seatings in our section, so we waited about 15 minutes for our check. All in all, I still gave it five stars despite the fillet and wait at the end, as I thought the service was great otherwise.

The Ambiance is Everything !!! Very beautiful and cozy excellent date night or just chilling vibe…read morewith your friends.5 all the way from upon entering with the professional staff to our cozy table hidden away by the bar. We started with the shrimp cocktail very very good fabulous taste.. Actually food was so good we dug in before pics. Sorry filet mignon .gnocchi Delicious and stuffed cheese and broccoli balls very good . Fabulous Wine we were stuffed and had a very enjoyable experience we will be back soon. thank you