Good food and service. Reasonable prices and big servings. Authentic Italian cuisine.read more

Ate here again today but this time I brought my husband who is the real connoisseur of Italian…read morecuisine. He ordered clams and chicken Marsala. I ordered Italian peppers and onions and meatballs for appetizer. It was all so delicious. I don't usually eat meatballs when I'm dining out because I don't like it when Veal is added to the mixture but I just couldn't resist this place because the meatballs were so big and delicious. I asked the waiter if they used Veal in their mixture and he said no so I knew this was my time to go for it. And they didn't disappoint. Each time gets better and better.

Honestly, love sitting at the bar, and the outdoor area is nice, but sometimes a place feels 'too…read morebig', which is a weird thing to say. Do love a neighborhood joint that's simple, just serves Beer & Pizza. If you are getting food here, eat it at the bar, don't order takeout. The best option is Hot Oil & Sausage, the price is relatively cheap, but not quite as cheap as it seems at first glance, as they charge per topping. Still, love this joint. Overall: 4.5/5

Seems like they added some menu items since I was last here like margherita pizza and a yummy…read morecreamsicle mocktail. Love the new mocktail options! I remember liking the last pizza I got and I don't know if the margherita was worse, the same or better but they are pretty equal as far as I remember. Would add a half a star if I could! Still doesn't have enough options and unequivocally amazing enough pizza for 5 stars in my opinion.

I was on my way to Glenville Pizza when I spotted this place and decided to detour -- best decision…read moreever. Parking was easy, even with all the snow. The pizza looked amazing. I asked for light cheese and it was perfect, finished with a delicious spiral drizzle. The slices were insanely crispy -- I haven't had pizza this good in a long time! Personal pie goes for 7 dollars till 3 pm, then price increases to 12.00. They just opened in 2024 and it's already my new favorite spot!

Food is delicious meatballs are fabulous! I gave my order at the counter and they brought my food…read moreto me at my table.

Napoli / margarita pizza. If you like cheese to taste like leather, pizza smothered in pesto…read moreinstead of fresh basil, and extremely floppy and salty, then this is for you. Never again. No idea why people are giving good reviews. And rude staff on top of it.

My wife and I tried this place today for the first time, and were both quite pleased with the food…read moreand the service. We shared a very nice salad and each had a personal size pizza. The toppings were excellent, and my gluten free crust was much better than average. I thought the cost was also reasonable. Five stars.

Food here is always great. I like my garlic knots garlic heavy but if you don't these are for you…read more I order takeout and have never had an issue (like missed order or poor packaging).

Your perfect hometown little pizza joint. My family and I usually order from Frankie and Louie's…read morefor pizza at least once a week. My sister is allergic to tree nuts and here we are able to order from because they do not have nuts anywhere near the pizza and are very allergy conscious. They have many options besides pizza ranging from pasta's, salads, sandwiches, wedges, etc. If you're looking to dine in they have lots of seating, plus a pond with turtles. Great for the kiddos to look at and always something I remember every time I stop in. I recommend getting Frankie and Louie's the next time you're craving a great slice!

During a recent visit to the area, I was on the hunt for a genuine New York-style slice, and "The…read moreJohns of Arthur" came highly recommended--a suggestion that turned out to be an absolute delight! This is not a fancy, upscale establishment, and that's precisely its charm. The Johns of Arthur is the quintessential quaint, little local pizza joint. It embraces its neighborhood roots, offering a wonderfully casual and welcoming atmosphere perfect for a quick stop. The star of the show, however, is the pizza. They currently sell by the slice in two classic varieties--Cheese and Pepperoni--and these slices are truly huge. They are perfectly cooked, flavorful, and deliver that satisfying, authentic taste I was looking for. It's simple, authentic, and utterly amazing. If you're passing through or are a local looking for a reliably delicious and quick bite, this is the spot. The Johns of Arthur is a great suggestion for any pizza lover who appreciates high-quality taste in a low-key setting. I highly recommend swinging by for one of their massive, delicious slices.

During a recent visit to the area, I was on the hunt for a genuine New York-style slice, and "The…read moreJohns of Arthur" came highly recommended--a suggestion that turned out to be an absolute delight! This is not a fancy, upscale establishment, and that's precisely its charm. The Johns of Arthur is the quintessential quaint, little local pizza joint. It embraces its neighborhood roots, offering a wonderfully casual and welcoming atmosphere perfect for a quick stop. The star of the show, however, is the pizza. They currently sell by the slice in two classic varieties--Cheese and Pepperoni--and these slices are truly huge. They are perfectly cooked, flavorful, and deliver that satisfying, authentic taste I was looking for. It's simple, authentic, and utterly amazing. If you're passing through or are a local looking for a reliably delicious and quick bite, this is the spot. The Johns of Arthur is a great suggestion for any pizza lover who appreciates high-quality taste in a low-key setting. I highly recommend swinging by for one of their massive, delicious slices.

Pleasantly surprised!! Stopped by on my lunch break and so glad I did!!! Bar area in front with…read moredining tables in the back. Bar environment seem nice and laid back . I'll definitely be stopping by again to have a cocktail. Sorry I ate the pizza so fast I forgot to take a picture of it's visual deliciousness

The food is incredible. It's a shame that the service is so bad. I ordered a pizza and drove to…read morepick it up from a neighboring town. I waited an extra 20 minutes later than the time that they told me it would be ready...just in case. It wasn't ready. The person behind the bar said 5-7 minutes more. It has been an additional 30 minutes. The order was 1 pizza.

Be prepared for some amazing food, drinks and great service. The atmosphere is always so friendly…read moreand invitin. One the best places in Rye, NY for a drink and food.

This is a great little place for a quick bite to eat. The pizza is a little different than most and…read morevery good.

After running a half marathon here in Rye I was a bit hangry for some carbs. While heading back to…read morethe train station I found Sunrise Pizzeria. Nice little locals pizza joint where you can grab a slice and soda before walking over to the train station. Two slices definitely hit the spot to refuel. Pretty tasty.

Chicken Francese Pizza was like cardboard. Horrible! It's almost like the crust was stale and they…read morejust threw the chicken on top. Won't be back.

Considering I received a small bowl of romaine lettuce chopped with 3 tiny slices of Parmesan it's…read moreawful that they charge $17.95 for this The pizza tasted like it was made this morning and heated up The crust was like cardboard Very disappointing

Ordered takeout - meat lovers and a grandma pie, we thought the meat combo was a bit salty but is…read moreto be expected when you're getting pepperoni and sausage. The grandma was good for that order. Second time ordered just grandma and the cheese had an odd smell and did not taste like mozzarella, tasted very old. The 4 adults tried it and then ended up throwing it out. We had to physically remove it from the house and put it into the trash it was that off-putting. Would not reorder.