I completely disagree with Aretha B's post above. Yes, the shop is expensive, and yes, there are a…read morelot of tourists there. But, it's on Martha's Vineyard - everything is expensive, and it's full of tourists. So you should expect to find that at Menemsha Blues just like you would anywhere else. It is similar to Black Dog, but not as big, and not as ubiquitous. I also disagree with characterizing it as a "chain." It's a local store that has several physical locations in the area. As far as their products: the quality of everything they sell is excellent. We bought several clothing items from them, and they were worth every penny. My husband seriously considers a trip back just to buy more of the polo and button-up shirts there because he loves them so much (and you can't get most of the items on their website, which is the only slight issue I have). He routinely gets stopped while wearing their items, because people like the small fish logo and it's so unusual, and they want to know where he got it. By all means, go to Menemsha Blues, and the original store in Menemsha is quite charming. If you dislike paying for quality items or buying from a store that has several locations in the area it was founded, I guess you can skip it, but you're doing yourself a disservice.

I like this shop. I still have a polo bought 100 years ago from them. They carry great quality…read moreclothes that I like. I have seen different prices. Some high some lower. In any case, quality aint free. Love The logo and the name. All the best , Ps in San Diego with great blue sweater

One of the best souvenir shops on the island. Great prices, friendly people. Found a "Beavis and…read moreButthead" Captains Club shirt and scooped that up. Yeah, I still have that immature side. Anyway, it's also one of the bigger stores and has a variety of items. Staff was great, and if/when I go back to the island, this will be one of my stops

I am the lady who said "thanks you too" when you asked if I wanted a receipt today, lol Thx for…read moremaking me LOL Great service and conversation

Have been shopping at black dog for decades. This location in particular has a super rude staff…read more What a bummer. I put all my stuff down and left.

Love the black dog. This one is conveniently in the heart of Edgartown. Great selection of clothing…read moreand other items.

I purchased some sweatpants. 2 for $40 which is a good deal. The employee was really nice and let…read moreus try on the pants to make sure they fit. He also tried to assist us with finding another size.

Very nice store. Fully stocked with cute designs. The young lady who was working was helpful and…read moremade thoughtful suggestions without being pushy. My only critique is that they add some 3x in men's as my husband is tall and with braid shoulders and needs a larger size. Prices are very reasonable.

A year later we went back. Celebrating my Mama's 90th birthday. This time there were 7 of us and I…read moreworked ahead of time with Mollie and our caterer on MV (Chef Caneika) to set up a sip 'n shop for the ladies. What a lovely treat to browse, try on, and shop while noshing on mini lobster rolls, charcuterie, champagne and other bites in a private setting just for us. I feel like these ladies are friends now.

I live mostly in Bryn Walker clothes and I'm so grateful to have a Bryn Walker store on our small…read moreisland. I always feel welcome there and never rushed. This store also has great sales at the end of the summer season. The clothes are comfortable, stylish and well made.

Grabbed a sweatshirt in my travels. Clerk was friendly and the prices were reasonable, and the…read morestore was clean. Nice selection of items and its close enough to the ferry to walk to and/or grab a souvenir on your way home.

A standard souvenirs / t-shirts shop on Martha's Vineyard, but they have a plentiful selection,…read morewith some fashions put on discount.

My favorite store in Edgartown. Cute and comfy clothes that sells other great brands as well. Also…read moremore affordable.

My ten year old daughter was saying the store was over priced and how much it changed. It isn't s…read morelie, they even changed the logo the new t shirts are just dumb. So the d bag who owns it approaches my child and says Ma'am, I'm the owner of this store and you can't talk that way in front of customers it's disrespectful" first of all genius she's 10, a child, not a ma'am, clearly his common sense is as crappy as his business sense. Second, WE were customers and maybe with his ridiculously over priced merchandise a $300-400 sale doesn't mean much but based on his absurd reaction a $40 sale is probably something. This used to be one of my favorite stores on the vineyard but it's now owned by some neurotic poser who even screwed up the logo that made the boneyard the boneyard. I'll be glad when he epicly fails after the season.

Expensive, preppy, spacious, and with a front entrance hidden behind a fake bookcase with a censor!…read more Need a $860 Moore and Giles leather duffel bag? This is your shop! A pair of yarn tassel earrings? They'll only cost you a measely $65! Dying to pay $195 for a Brackish bowtie? Look no further!! $425 for a Mignonne-Gavigan scarf? It's all here, baby!! And lest you worry they're leaving kids out, that is not so! Here you can buy your infant daughter a Petit Peony dress for $88 or an EZPZ dog bowl for $25! Is it a fun store to enter and wander into? Sure. And you might even decide some of these items are affordable for your budget. And best of all, the whole store is very WHEELCHAIR-ACCESSIBLE!! The gentleman working there was affable and helpful. But will I be doing a lot of shopping here? Nope. Nothing felt special enough to warrant those prices...but again, you may feel differently! Different strokes for different folks, you know?