I read about their cinnamon rolls online. I just had to try them. They were fabulous and I'm definitely coming back. read more

Baked on the Beach - Desserts Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

Was craving chocolate chip cookies and baked on the beach met my needs. Crispy on the outside slightly soft on the inside with just the right about of chocolate chips - not too many or too little. And yes I do feel there can be too many. Friendly service and it smelled delicious inside. read more

See all

In season, out of season, or somewhere in between, Baked on the Beach is always a must stop. When we rent over the summer, we probably go every two or three days. The muffins are the BEST, especially the fruit ones, and the crumb cake is nuts. It's like they bake it JUST to the point of not being raw and then top it with 60lbs of crumb. The building itself is tiny, so if there's a line outside, don't let that stop you. Things move quickly. If you're planning to pick up pies or other must-have items, definitely order ahead since you never know when they will be sold out--I've seen it happen. Nothing says summer on LBI like starting the day with a few bites of anything from here. Waking up to that pink box always puts a smile on my face. Oh, and the cold brew is like 110 octane so a little goes a long way... yet I always get a large. read more

Stopped in here back in March and bought their homemade Irish soda bread. So delicious! You can tell they put a lot of pride into their baked goods and it shows. The best in the area! We tried 3 other local bakeries and their soda bread was not even close to Baked on the Beach!! read more

See all

Delicious cinnamon rolls!! You can smell the freshly baked pastries before even walking in the door. read more

Baked on the Beach - Exterior - Desserts Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

See all

Terrible. Reached out to them via phone (phone number better worked and didn't have an answering machine) I also emailed them and did an online inquiry. they are so unprofessional as the girl that finally answered today told me they cannot make a simple cake and that they DONT HAVE TIME TO CHECK EMAILS. it's just an u professional business model. don't waste your time trying to email or call them, clearly they don't answer read more

If heaven had a scent, it would be the sticky buns from Baked on the Beac. These things are so good they might be illegal in some states. And the freshness? Let's just say the pastries are so fresh, they probably woke up at 5 AM to do yoga on the beach before being served!!!. Honestly, if you haven't tried this place yet, what are you doing with your life? Get there, grab a sticky bun, and prepare to have your taste buds thank you (sidenote remember that on vacation calories don't count) Yum read more

I love this bakery. The product is delicious . Every year I look forward to it while visiting Surf City. June 6, 2026 I went in the morning. The young lady behind the counter want friendly and didn't smile which is not normallly the service. Perhaps she was having a bad day ‍ read more

Best cinnamon rolls EVER! I hope they stay open in the off season so us locals can enjoy their delicacies. read more

Hands down one of the best muffins I've ever eaten!!!! Tried one of each muffin- pumpkin, banana chocolate chip, blueberry, mixed berry, & strawberry peach. Will be daydreaming about the strawberry peach for a long time. Also had a brownie bar all for $26. Not bad for beach pricing. read more

It's a wonderful bakery and everything is delicious. My friend and I made multiple trips to this bakery over the summer. Our favorites are the beach bum cookie and the raspberry bar read more

I generally try to stay away from bakeries because, well...let's just say as a guy of my size I can go overboard. Today, our first morning of vacation here in LBI, Wifey and I want for a walk and 'ended up' in front of Baked on the Beach. Ok, so maybe I planned it because I KNEW she'd want some treats, but what's a guy to do, NOT make his wife happy??? The aroma outside was fantastic, and the aroma inside was...heavenly. We walked out with an Orange-Strawberry muffin, blueberry muffin, chocolate croissant, blueberry scone and a Beach Bum cookie (not all for us for those already judging the fat guy, our kids are here too). As I'm writing this I'm wiping the last crumbs off my plate, because nothing should be left behind. The two muffins were absolutely amazing...not too sweet, but lots of fruit that really made the flavors pop. I also tried the Beach bum cookie and "Wow" is really the only word to describe it. So.Damn.Good!! Wifey and the kids LOVED the scone and croissant too. Thankfully, the walk may have offset some of the calories. Maybe a longer walk tomorrow, LOL. read more

Baked on the Beach - Desserts Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

What a great birthday cake! Ordered a strawberry cake with whipped cream between the layers and a vanilla buttercream icing. Just fantastic! read more

Baked on the Beach - Strawberry cake with whipped cream between the layers wrapped in a vanilla buttercream! - Desserts Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

The bakery smells great when you walk in and the food looks great, but the taste was not there. Overall, not great and the prices were high. We went in the off season, so maybe they're better during the summer. read more

Absolute best bakery in LBI! As we only vacation for a week or two each year, our visits to Baked on the Beach are sadly limited to just a few a year. However, I spend the rest of the year thinking about it and looking forward to my next visit! The staff are so nice and everything is made fresh daily. My favorites are the beach bum cookies (if you have not tried these, go get one...right now, if possible!!). They are huge and amazing and just $2. I bring home a least a dozen every year and freeze them so I can enjoy throughout the year. Well, let's be honest, they only make it about a month or two! All of their other cookies are good as well. My husband usually picks out an assortment to bring home. Scones and muffins - yum!! Key lime pie - best ever!! I love when I'm lucky enough to score one of the mini pies. It stays fresh all week and I can enjoy a bite here and there. Key lime bars are also great. I'm not super crazy about the chocolate croissants as I found them to not have enough chocolate inside - I prefer consistent chocolate all the way through. But everything else I've had has been amazing. They are open year round, so if you're in the area, go in for some sweet treats. The best on the island! read more

Not recommending this place. Underwhelming. Crumb cake, very little flavor not leaving you wanting more n where is the powdered sugar. Also it was a bit dry n seems to be made too in advance, not fresh. Maybe make less than more daily n under bake. Muffins were moist fluffy n a lot of berries so that was good. Pies well let's just say a crust needs to be delicious n it was not. And at $25 a pie. That pie needs to be amazing. Re: prices, how about displaying them??! Yes they r too high, what should they be well if you cut the crumb cake in half $3. It's too big anyway. A couple things for a family of 4 should not cost $50. I can go get a full breakfast at Table for $80. Table I highly recommend instead. The boys r always on point. Lastly, it's uncomfortably small / tight when just a couple people r in there. Get rid of the furniture. Oh almost forgot, the counter help, is not appreciative not Kind, Helpful, so no tip for you girlies. Too immature n angry for young girls working at the shore steps from the beach. read more

love this bakery! Always delicious, always fresh! Keylime to die for! Don't get me started on the muffins and cupcakes!

Underwhelmed with chocolate cake. Won't purchase again. Disappointed because we like their other baked goods

Everything tastes homemade and has been always consistent ! Friendly and perfect! Baker is so sweet ! No pun intended! Gluten free options we love! Scones are stellar read more

My favorite bakery on the island. They make beautiful and delicious cakes. Love their muffins! read more

Baked on the Beach - Desserts Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

Best cinnamon roll I've ever had without exaggeration. Get one, you will not be disappointed! We also had blueberry muffins and a mini key lime pie. Both were just ok, not bad but not exceptional. Will be back for those cinnamon rolls though! read more

sweets and more sweets very good baked items and great service, cute place and nice staff. read more

I placed an order and paid in full on Thursday, August 29th for 6 tarts to be picked up at 11:00 am on Monday, September 2nd. I was having company on Labor Day. My guests asked if they could bring dessert and I said I had that taken care of, or so I thought. My husband went to Baked on the Beach in Surf City with receipt in hand ready to pick up the order. He was told that 4 of the 6 tarts were sold out. The person behind the county said they ran out of product that morning. How do you take an order 4 days in advance that was paid in full 4 days in advance and not put aside the ordered items? We had to scramble to find dessert items for my guests as I told them not to bring anything. My husband did get his money back, but that's not the point. Don't expect your ordered items to be waiting for you when you arrive. We won't be patronizing Baked On The Beach anymore. Very poor customer relations! read more

I guess we got there pretty late as many things were sold out. We ended up with the last 2 cinnamon buns (with cream cheese frosting). Quite delicious! read more

See all

This place is great. The Key Line pie was terrific. Their blueberry scones was very good. The oatmeal raisin cookies are great. I highly recommend this place. read more

This bakery is so cute! Very Instagram worthy, both on the outside as well as the inside. They recently introduced a "take out" window on the side of the house. Because of the pandemic, they are only allowing 1 person in the bakery at a time (which is perfect). I ordered a cake for my Birthday, they had a lot of options and I went with a red velvet cake with cream cheese icing. The smallest cake they had feeds between 12-15 people and it cost about $40. A little pricier than we were expecting, but it was absolutely delicious! They also sell candles (thank God!) so that is super convenient! read more

Happy to be back on LBI and have my morning muffin from Baked on the Beach - heaven.

Ordered a cake for our daughters 8th birthday just a couple days ahead and the folks at Baked were amazing. she loved the decorations and it tasted great. read more

Fresh and homemade pies, cookies, lemon bars, muffins. They are all excellent. The scones are most amazing! The best you'll find anywhere! And if you have a dog, try their doggy treats. My dog goes CRAZY over them! Sometimes I stop in just for those! read more

See all

The crumb cake was delish! The service was great. Decent variety of flavors. Busy little place.

My husband and I arrived around 3:30 on 7/2/19 to purchase a pie for my mother's 80th birthday. The girls working behind the counter looked half asleep and even less interested in assisting us with a purchase. We stated we were looking to purchase a pie and we were quickly offered the peanut butter mousse pie. We stated we have several family members with a nut allergy and requested an alternative. We were offered the chocolate mousse pie and assured there weren't any nuts in this pie. Thank god we realized as we were cutting the pie. Yes nuts in the pie crust. No trip to the ER on grandma's birthday Suggestions: Have allergies listed for your products and hire staff that actually care about your customers. I mentioned to my Mom later about Baked by the Beach. (She lives in LBI year round). Let's just say, she didn't recommend it. Stay away! read more

Baked on the Beach - Desserts Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

these are the best gluten free brownies in the world!!!! Don't miss this place I am obsessed with this bakery. It's has the best gf treats. I never miss it when visiting LBI. Always make sure to bring some goodies back with me to the city. The best! read more

Baked on the Beach - Gluten free brownies - Desserts Near Me - Surf City, New Jersey

A small, independent bakery with big tastes. Fresh-baked scones, cookies, muffins, cakes, & more. Decent prices, friendly staff, good coffee, & tasty treats. A perfect combination. Speaking of coffee, this is something most bakeries miss, & a nice surprise to see here. I mean, if you find a better combo than coffee & anything fresh baked...you won't, so forget about it. And, just like the beach, they're here all year, not just a tourist shop. Next time you're in Surf City, get Baked on the Beach. read more

Love this bakery! Have gotten treats for a couple of years here and they never disappoint. The girls behind the counter were quick, attentive and friendly. Highly recommend. read more

Wow!!! Amazing and we love coming here every year for the summer. The cookies are solid and the best on the island. We love the baked goods and the ladies are quick and responsive and super helpful. We love this place and we will continue coming every summer! read more

Baked on the Beach provided all the pastries and wedding cake at Parker's Garage on mid October, 2023...ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS! We are now full time Surf City residents and go there for all of our party needs and when we just need a couple things for our sweet tooth. Thanks so much! read more

Fresh and delicious A wide variety of homemade baked goods from muffins, cookies, pies and cakes. Their cinnamon buns frequently sell out so get there early! read more

Was so happy to find gluten free items. Cupcakes were moist and the right amount of sweet! Cookies were so soft. Can't wait to go back before leaving the island to stock up on my gluten free sweets read more

The best baked goods on the island! So delicious, and I love the amount of gluten free & vegan options available to choose from. The cookies are incredible - we had the chocolate chip, m&m, & the rainbow sprinkle cookie! Each cookie was more delicious than the next. The croissants, cinnamon buns, cupcakes, and brownies are a must try as well! We can't wait to come back year after year! read more

We celebrated our daughters 13th birthday at summer house in LBI and had her birthday cake and cupcakes made @ Baked on the Beach. Cake was gorgeous, delicious ~ red velvet filling with fresh cream, fruits & flowers... beyond perfect! Madison was great when ordering. Thank you so much for making such a beautiful and delicious cake! Everyone loved it! Place is adorable; our new favorite bakery on the island :). read more

See all