My favorite local pizza place. They cook on a stone and it's awesome! They also added a new dine in…read morearea that is beautiful.

Great pizza in a friendly hometown atmosphere. Always lots of toppings and I love the crust!!! I…read morelove that they are a small family owned business.

Waitress was preoccupied the whole time running around like a chicken with her head cut off. Didn't…read moreask more information about orders nor ask to fix the ones she messed up. Wasn't very polite or friendly. I wouldn't recommend eating here unless they get more waitresses. Food was eh.

I was visiting family, and everyone wanted to come here…read more Honestly, was not a fan. The pizza was good ,so I will start with the pro. But the chicken parm... no. My boyfriend and I ordered this dish. Both our meals were soggy wet at the bottom with water. The chicken felt like frozen chicken. It was so hard that the knife was having a hard time cutting. Only really edible item was the pasta. If I ever went back here, I would order the pizza.

I took a team of 5 athletes to Joe's the evening before the Nike Midwest Championship cross country…read moreraces. The food was pretty good and the restaurant is cozy and warm. I ordered two meatballs as an appetizer, which were really good, and then the chicken and broccoli bake for my entree. The bake wasn't exactly what I was expecting but it was good. I was expecting a whole chicken breast in the bake but it was bit sized chunks of chicken. My husband was also with us and he ordered the cheesesteak sandwich and the Greek salad. Neither were mind blowing, but they were good. The rest of the team had fettuccine Alfredo, garlic bread, and personal sized pizzas and they all seemed to be pretty happy.

The food is fantastic. The Rosa sauce is the best. The French bread with pesto is so good.read more

Food was great!! Service very fast…read more I had a Lemon pepper chicken harvest salad with poppyseed dressing, and it was one of the best salads I've had in Sullivan!! With pecans, apples, and dried cranberries. Lettuce was fresh. Delicious. My husband had a Rueben and seasoned fries - both were great! Iced tea was fantastic!! Definitely entering the rotation of regular places to eat in town!!!

I'm only giving four stars based off of our previous visits being so good, based solely on today's…read morevisit it would be at most two stars. We normally spend less than half of what I was charged today. We walked in and asked to claim a lane (see pricing on pic) but the gentleman working today who I've never seen or dealt with before insisted we give him a number of games to bowl instead of the hourly rate we normally pay when the younger guy is working. We also normally pay when we're finished but he had us pay before we began bowling. We played for 4 hours. At the hourly rate that would have been $70, instead I paid $90 for five games. Not sure why he insisted on a number of games instead of the hourly rate. The sign doesn't say that the hourly rate isn't available on Sundays. The lane we were at was missing a seat instead it was just the metal piece. Which was very inconvenient for four bowlers and only two usable seats. And this place was supposedly just remodeled. We went to order food. We asked what was in their fruit bowls, we were told strawberries, pineapple, peaches, and apple slices. We ordered two fruit bowls, a Philly cheesecake, pretzel sticks, and four drinks. They brought up the pretzel sticks almost immediately, then they only brought out three drinks and said I didn't order a fourth so we paid for another drink as I didn't have an itemized receipt, just the total. Then they brought out the Philly cheesesteak. We waited several more minutes and still no fruit bowls, so we went and asked and were told they forgot. They brought out two very small bowls of just canned sliced peaches. Nothing the way the fruit bowls were explained to us. The fruit bowls were $4. $4 for a small bowl that had maybe seven slices in it was ridiculous and they were slimy. We were told that they didn't realize they were out of the other fruits. No apologies, no offer to replace it with something else, no discounts, nothing. My daughters were disappointed so we ordered something else for them instead. They couldn't eat the peaches due to the sliminess. And who wants to pay $8 for less peaches you'd get in a whole can for less than $2 at the store? The Philly was dry and had very little onion. It was more peppers than anything. Normally they're really good. The lane kept messing up and not counting knocked down pins or getting stuck and we had to have the employees fix it. You can't manually change scores from the lane as it's restricted so we had to wait in line to get employees to correct the score from the counter. Most bowling alleys have the ability to adjust scores yourself, but not Maddog's. It was quite annoying and we just gave up having the scores corrected for accuracy. The arcade took my daughter's money but didn't give her an item. It was one of the machines that you pay for an item and get it not that you have to win one. She told an employee and they didn't care. After it slowed down, the employee started being nice and kind and even made a few jokes with us which was nice. So his attitude earlier on might have been just from being overwhelmed and stressed. If he hadn't, the amount of stars would be less. We also informed him that we were military but he either didn't hear me or something. Looking at the receipts and total he charged us for five games, we weren't given the military rate. We had our military ID's and paid with bank cards from a well known bank that only does business with military service members and their families. I think the guy who normally is working when we go is possibly named Brian? He's always incredibly friendly and accommodating. He's another reason why I'm giving more stars than I would after everything that happened today if I was solely basing the review off of today's visit. Overall it's not a bad place. And usually the employees are friendly and food is better. I'm hoping they'll fix the broken seats and issues with pins and balls constantly getting stuck. I'm also hoping today was just a very unusual off day and that future visits will be better, if it is anything like today again, we won't be back again.

For pub style food, this is a good place for lunch in the little town of Sullivan, IN. The decor is…read moretypical sports pub, but the place is roomy enough that you don't feel crowded. Service was a bit slow but still okay. In terms of the food itself, most of our group ordered steak or chicken Philly sandwiches. Both varieties were good. Rather than using a traditional hoagie, the rolls were more like baguettes. I really liked that as hoagies often get too soggy from the juices whereas here the rolls stayed nice and crispy on the outside while still being soft on the inside. The highlight of this place though was the sweet potato fries. I like sweet potato fries but at most places they are never as crispy as regular potato fries. Here they were perfectly crispy while still retaining a nice softness and bit of sweetness from the sweet potato inside.

I ordered the breaded tenderloin sandwich with a side of sweet potato fries. The food came out a…read morebit on the warm side not hot, like had been sitting awhile. The service was good at first but I haven't seen my server for a while so another waitress got my tea refill. The brewed was great. The decor and dining room atmosphere is very cozy and rustic. It's located on a perfect place on the corner of the square in downtown Sullivan. My first waitress left the building without telling me and another one finished the sale and got me a to go drink.

okay so.. ladies sit down.. this might overwhelm u. boys, dick down. so!!! basically i LOVEE the…read morefood !! so yummy and i love the hot guys touching my food but why everytime i go thru the drivethru CATS are in the back..?? they r meowing at the cars its weird and unsanitary anywho!! hmu fine shyts (snap:frankoceanlr)

The employees were very polite and the food was delirious I loved every second about it and the…read moreplace had a very nice cool breeze and it was very clean!!