Fantastic pizza, ghastly service. I went to place a to-go order and asked the cashier about the daily takeout specials. Right off the bat, she seemed unfriendly and mildly sarcastic like she was having a bad day or didn't want to be there. Whatever, we all have days like that-- I just wanted my pizza so I placed an order and when I was charged, I noticed that I was charged full price instead of the daily special price. I think it was something like BOGO toppings. When I asked the cashier why I was charged full price she simply shrugged and told me my card was already charged and there was nothing we could do about it now. No attempt at apology or suggestion on how to make it right. I really didn't want to have my food defiled in any way by this patent unprofessional, so I let it go. I used to drive 35 minutes one-way from my house to pick up this fabulous pizza when I needed a real treat. Something about the cheese combination they use is absolutely magical. I used to praise this pizza as my favorite NY-style pizza in Corpus and order boxes to-go when I dined in. Though the pizza is still wonderful and would highly recommend to anybody, I've got better things to do than drive over an hour round trip to be assailed by crap service and bait and switch pricing. Will not be back. read more

It seemed to be one of those meals that whatever could go wrong, did. Probably the biggest thing that happened was the waitress walking into the swinging doors and dropping my pizza on the floor. I felt sorry for her because I think she hurt her hand. I ran out of water for a long time and the men's room was out of paper towels. The food did taste good however. I wouldn't consider this New York style pizza but it still tasted good. I ordered some cheesy garlic bread as well as the 12" pepperoni pizza. If I am a local, I would not hesitate to order take out. It was reasonably priced and tasted good. read more

Authentic New York Pizza - Garlic cheese bread - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

See all

Not authentic NYC pizza! Stingie on sauce, the "real NYC Italian sausage was not even close in flavor the crust was soggy in the middle and the crust had burnt bottom. Bad service was a main disappointment also. read more

Vegan Pizza in Corpus?! Yes you heard me right! This adorable mom and pop shop knows how to get down. The NY scenery plus the friendly staff gives north meets south in the best way. The cheese is usually the downfall of most vegan pizza but not here! The vegan cheese is just right and the vegan meats, yes MEATS with an 'S' are delicious as well. Be sure to check them out! read more

Authentic New York Pizza - Vegan Meat Lovers - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

Food is really good just found out about this place and haven't stop coming by, meat lovers pizza is awesome didn't get to take a picture of it cause it was gone read more

Authentic New York Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

The best pizza and pasta I have ever had, absolutely delicious, awesome atmosphere, and great service! Definitely recommend

Best Pizza I ever put in my mouth. Me and my wife gets a Brooklyn bomber once a week. LOVE IT!!

First time at the establishment and I can say it is a pretty decent spot if your craving wings and pizza it's not a knock your socks off type of place but it gets the job done. The pizza was cheesy and hot to order but just super greasy for my liking and the wings were good. read more

Authentic New York Pizza - Hot honey wings and pizza - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

I'm disheartened that I have to leave this review but this is the second time I've ordered pizza and have been disappointed. Y'all used to be my favorite in town. I've been ordering from y'all for over a year now and this will be my last. I always order extra cheese and extra sauce .my pizza was always perfect. I just got your pizza tonight. My friend bought it for us. Just a scant amount of sauce. Barely even visible. Lack of sauce makes the pizza dry. read more

Authentic New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

My pepperoni pizza was above average, though not the best I ever had. The crust was a little overdone. My daughter thought it was excellent. The service was excellent. I picked up. It was waiting when I arrived. Woman at the counter was pleasant. She offered parmesian cheese and crushed red pepper, which I appreciated. All in all, a good experience. I will go back the next time I'm in Corpus Christi. I recommend it. read more

I love this pizza it's so good!!! I've only had the pizza but I've heard the other food is good too. Staff is also very friendly.

Dear reader, I needed pizza . We've just left the beach and I had a hankering for pizza, a Jones even. My wife, looked up the usual suspects in the area , and when she said Authentic New York Pizza, the decision was made. We found this mom and pop establishment nestled off Staples and the Pizza did not disappoint . The waitstaff was courteous and friendly , and we expressed our enjoyment to find a local gem. It's clean , with Italian American decor. We left most happy, and ready to share the word . Until next time , gumshoes. Ciao read more

my mom liked it, it was the first time she didn't complain pizza. i'm writing this for her. she told me "i'd give them a 5 star" the woman who served us was very nice. it's calm in the restaurant, sometimes a clown shows up to give ballon's. read more

Authentic New York Pizza - it's been a while since i ate here. it's really good.. the wings are okay. and the drinks were perfect. - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

We found this restaurant by default, and I am so glad we did! They accommodated 28 of us. Let me start with the women who welcomed us was so nice and attentive to our party. All the staff worked hard to get our food and drinks out. Now the pizza, WOW, delicious. We had pasta, calamari, wings, mozzarella sticks and subs. Everything was so fresh and tasty. I highly recommend this pizza spot! read more

The pizza was fresh, hot, and super delicious! We ordered the margarita with pepperoni and it did not disappoint. Definitely try this place out! read more

Authentic New York Pizza - Margarita with pepperoni. Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

HANDS DOWN, BEST PIE YET IN SOUTH TEXAS! Like holy wow! From the deliciously soft crust to the undeniable fresh ingredients, this pizza pie was the highlight of our dining adventures while in Corpus. Their Large is def a LARGE and the price matches. Well worth it. Kind of pie a family of 4 has no worries sharing. Also had great curbside service. Thanks guys!!! read more

Authentic New York Pizza - Curbside Pie - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

See all

Our favorite local pizza spot!! Everyone there is so friendly and the food is fast and delicious. Go here

Had the 18 inch meat lovers and hot wings, wings were super good and the pizza was great. Would definitely eat here again. Staff is very friendly and accommodating. We will be back read more

It's been too long since I've been in New York to say "authentic" but it was a great pizza. Enough toppings without overpowering it (except some seedy jalapeños - so maybe just think about that before you order jalapeños). The crust is delicious and the sauce is good! The price surprised us because it didn't match what was advertised online, but we ended up with a pretty big pizza for the price so overall it was a good deal. The pizza was ready when they said it would be and everyone was pleasant during the experience. We'll definitely be going back! read more

Best vegan pizza I've had. Great service. Good price. We got the vegan cheese w black olives, vegan meat and onions. Was so good our four year old devoured it. Will be back again. The coke a cola was really sweet and mixed well too lol! Service took good care of us and were friendly to our kiddo! read more

Authentic New York Pizza - Vegan pizza - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

This pizza and bread sticks were amazing . Definitely would go back people are beyond friendly the pizza is way to big for two people we definitely know for next time best pizza very tasty read more

Authentic New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

See all

The only reason I gave it one star was for the service. The pizza was not even close to New York pizza. I have had better pizza at a gas station. The pizza was way too greasy and the toppings just slide right off. Save your money and go some place else. read more

This place is a hidden gem!! I'm so glad I gave this place a try. Their hot honey wings are SOO delicious literally the best wings I've ever had. I ordered togo and the cashier said the ranch was in the box but when we got home there was no ranch :( read more

Authentic New York Pizza - Hot Honey Wings - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

Omg!!!! You can't go wrong with this pizza place. I took my team of 15 girls and 3 coaches and the service was AWESOME! The food was even better. The pizzas, wings, garlic cheese bread, and plates were piping hot and sooooo tasty. Everyone ended up taking food home. The pricing is well worth the amount and quality of food you get here. (Pictures are Feb 2020) I then visited again during Covid and the curbside pick up was fast and friendly. The pizza we got was amazing. I can't wait to go back and visit. read more

See all

Food wise - it is Mediocre. Quite disappointed with the pizza. The margherita's basil would taste better if it was not burnt or added after the pizza was baked. Shrimp scampi was too sour & salty for my husband. But the taste was more appealing to my toddler. Their wings are good enough and can have 2 flavors for a 12 pcs wings. Customer service - The staff was amazing & welcoming. They made sure that you are well attended. Ambience - Outside it was simple but the parking space are ample. Inside, they created a homey new york style feels. It seems they have a band playing at night & somehow goes perfectly with their string lights. read more

See all

This place is a little, hidden gem on the Southside of town. It's not much to look at, inside or out, but it makes up for it in hospitality and the PIZZA! The service is top-rate! You're greeted the second you walk in and nothing but smiles and excellent service the whole time you're there. I was with a couple of friends and this was our first time here. We looked at the menu.... simple enough. We were struck, though, that they only make one size of pizza, 16-inch (aka LARGE, GRANDE, an Italian Sombrero!!). Yeah, it's not really 16 inches, it's around 20 inches! All their pizzas are hand-tossed so no two are going to be exactly the same size, but they're all going to be massive and very good. But, again, this was our first time so we naively ordered two pizzas, all "half-this-half-that" kind of thing. AND, we ordered some hot wings to try while we waited. I can see Julia Roberts in my head now, "BIG mistake, BIG, HUGE!" If you're expecting the typical fried wings with red hot Buffalo sauce, forget it. These are baked and just DROWNED in some kind of sauce that had more vinegar than heat. If we hadn't ordered the wings, this would easily have been a 5-star review. So, do yourself a favor, DON'T order the wings (unless you're really that curious). In fact, you shouldn't order ANY appetizer because you'll regret filling up on that when your bodacious pizza arrives. And so it did. My Lord, this tiny waitress is lugging a manhole cover! The pizzas are HUGE, steaming hot and LOADED with tasty toppings. One SLICE has got to be close to a pound! The first slice I tried was the "meat lovers." It had CHUNKS of fresh-made Italian sausage (no kidding, it's made right there), pepperoni, meatballs, ham and (we opted for) jalapenos. It was AMAZING good! The crust is thick, with a nice, crispy bottom and as fresh as can be. The ends are like breadsticks. Awesome! The other thing I like about their pizzas is, it's not dripping with sauce. It's got just enough to make a really good base for the toppings. Good sauce! I also tried a ricotta and sausage slice. Normally, I'm not a big fan of thick globs of ricotta, but this works. It's so fresh and creamy and just loaded with flavor. They import it from New York, along with the pepperoni. But, what made it work for me was that Italian sausage on it. The texture and flavor is really, really good. Another excellent slice but, as big a guy as I am, two slices was all I could muster. We had the equivalent of a whole pizza plus a couple slices left over. I'm talking HUGE pizzas but easily some of the best pizza I've ever had. I'd put it in the top 3 of places in the area to get a pizza. So, if you can put up with the construction woes on Staples St and you find this little jewel, go inside and be expected to have a good time and great pizza. .....PS: unless you've actually PERFORMED on one, please stay off the piano! read more

Authentic New York Pizza - MASSIVE pizzas - delicious!! - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

Authentic New York pizza is amazing. The pizza is perfect! Ingredients are absolutely as fresh as can be and they definitely pack on the toppings. Hot wings are magnificent. I am looking forward to trying lemon pepper wings next. One of the best parts is seeing the owners go from table to table to make sure everybody is happy. This is definitely a spot that I will be frequenting a lot more. read more

See all

Great pizza! The size, flavor, service...oh let me also add that you can byob too! One of the best pizza in town imy.

Who knew I'd have to travel to Corpus Christi to find the best pizza in Texas? Simply excellent, from presentation to flavor.

Loved our waitress. Super sweet Hubby got a sausage pizza. Loved the sausage they use. But the crust was a little too thick for his liking. I got a child's spaghetti with a marinara sauce. Nah, nothing special at all. No real flavor in the sauce. Pretty much out of a can. And something a little off.... it sounded like some employees were in the restaurant to dine and got into a heated discussion with another employee /manager.... not good for the dining room folks. read more

This is hands down the BEST pizza I've had. Too often, when you get New York style pizza, the crust gets soggy from grease and you are left with a floppy piece of pizza. Not the case here. Thank toppings are fantastic, especially the house made Italian sausage. The crust maintains its form and doesn't become soggy from grease. Also, the flavor of the crust is GREAT . The sauce is flavorful and light- they put just the right amount on. If I didn't live 2 hours away, I'd be here all the time. San Antonio has good pizza, but I haven't found anything in this league. Out of this world. This is definitely a place my family will return to on future Corpus Christi visits!! Also, on top of be food, the service was super friendly. The wings were large and good. The bbq wings were great. The Siracha wings were good and as hot as you'd expect. read more

Authentic New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

See all

How have I lived here my entire life and not known about this unbelievably delicious pizza?!? We ordered one for take out. My son said the ambiance was family friendly and clean. The price for 18 inch pizza is very affordable. I requested a base Alfredo sauce, which to my surprise was a homemade! The crust was absolutely perfect and flavorful. The veggies were fresh, honestly the tomatoes almost tasted home grown. I have not had a pizza THIS delicious in 17 years! The pizza didn't arrive home as hot as I would have liked, but that may not have been their fault. It was nice to actually speak to a human when we placed our takeout order. The lady was pleasant and happy to customize our pizza to my picky liking. They were so proud of it, they asked to photograph it before my son left to bring it home. They beyond exceeded my expectations. Sorry chain pizza shops... you just lost our business to this locally owned gem!!! Thank you for awaking my taste buds with this culinary masterpiece. read more

Best pizza I've had since moving to Corpus Christi. They don't scrimp on their toppings. Every bite is a medley of all toppings, sauce and crust! read more

I got half supreme margharita half meat lover 18" very big slices enough for 5-6 people dough was perfect topping were nice overall very good spot and the service is amazing. I would definitely try their lava cake next time. read more

We came in for the first time in a while and weren't sure if we'd get pizza or (for the first time) try something else on the menu. We opted for something different and I got the Chef's Combo lunch special and my wife tried the Italian Herb Chicken over linguini. Again, fantastic service. The servings are easily good for two people. The Herb Chicken was done perfectly with the chicken falling off the bones. My dish was delicious and could have made 1 1/2 meals if I weren't so hungry at the moment. There weren't too many people in the place at lunch time. It might be the location not being at the front of the center and kinda back away from view. I hope they do something to bring more attention their way...they need to stay in business for a LONG time. We would miss a local treasure if we lost this pizza import. Go here. It's not just the pizza!! read more

Food was great and so was the service! The environment was great and it was easy to find. I'll definitely be coming back. read more

Authentic New York Pizza - Four cheese pizza with pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

See all

This is a wonderful place to bring your kids or a romantic dinner or lunch break. We had the delicious garlic bread, & meat pizza. The tea & the salad was delicious as well. The waitress was so sweet & she kept our tea filled & visited our table very often. The pizza & service are fantastic. The manager also came & asked if we were enjoying our meal. I will have to say that the pizza slices are delicious and huge. Buffalo Wings,Chicken Alfredo,Grimaldi,Italian Sausage,Meat Lovers Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza read more

Wow!, talk about some great tasting pizza. My family enjoyed a supreme and a pepperoni/sausage pizza. We also tried their fresh buffalo style wings. We were stuffed! We were greeted by at least 3 staff members upon entering and that attention stayed the entire visit. Great to hear some New York accents.. Place is nice and simple, just a relaxing atmosphere. We did not get to try their homemade cheese cake...gonna have to come back for that! A definite must try! read more

Authentic New York Pizza - Slice of heaven! - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

Had dinner at Authentic New York Pizza off Staples in Corpus Christi, the pizza is the best in town, amazing sauce, perfect crust and delicious sausage and mushrooms, the atmosphere of the place is relaxed and inviting with great wall decor of New York, the staff were friendly and quick to offer drink refills and without a doubt the pizza is the best in town. read more

Authentic New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Corpus Christi, Texas

Best pizza in all of TX! Great family friendly atmosphere and the customer service is fantastic!!! The wings are amazing and the pizza is mouth watering. You won't find pizza like this anywhere else. Our favorite is the meat lovers. read more