Flabbergasted.
Their website says this: "...our hallmark has been our keen attention to detail in evaluating fine quality jewelry and appraising precious stones" That's not exactly true.
I called last week after finally finding my wedding ring which had been lost and I had never had a rider on our insurance to cover it properly. Bad mistake on my part as I am a certified diamontologist and worked in the industry preaching to others the need to get their appraisals updated every 3-5 years. So I came here, to yelp*, found and called Sandra. I told her upfront I had a lot of pieces and she told me to just bring them all and we would determine what was most important as she had a full schedule and we might have to make a few appointments based on our discussion. I was FINE with that. However, 5 minutes into our appointment she decided we weren't going to 'mesh' based solely on my reaction to her telling me that one of my rings was something which "could be picked up at Macy's for about $500" even though I had an appraisal, though 20 years old with an appraisal value of $1395. She barely even looked at the ring but told me there weren't any diamonds in it (which I pointed out there were) and then followed that up with that they weren't important enough to consider, they were just chips. When we had first talked on the phone, she made it clear that if I had pieces valued over $1000 per then that's how she considers them worth appraising for insurance purposes. To her, I had about 5 pieces worth appraising today which, AGAIN, I was okay by me.
Beyond shocked that a professional, who not only realizes the importance of sentimental value, and even I understand that THAT cannot compare to the actual value, would be that callus then turn a client away for THEIR insult. She even went further by telling me that I was qualified enough to appraise my own jewelry (huh?). Last I checked the GIA (the premier appraisers of gem stones & diamonds in the US) has a course one takes in order to be certified through THEM because insurance companies may not accept just anyone to appraise jewelry - which was WHY I was paying for someone 'qualified' to do it. She told me flat out she was just too busy for me. I apologized if I had offended her somehow, though I'm not really sure what I did except to disagree with her assessment but wasn't going to worry about that specific ring - basically a trinket to her. But the last I checked gem stones do not devalue and gold is at a fairly high price currently so how could that ONE ring possibly have devalued by $900??????
Bottom line, I'm probably glad she didn't appraise any of my jewelry and I would tell anyone to second guess using this woman for yours. I'd like to think she was just having a stressful day, but I'm still just shaking my head after this experience.
UPDATE: The next day...
I ended up calling Allen Park at Heart to Heart who also happens to be the current Director for the Hawaii Jewelers Association (HJA). After looking at everything I had, including what I have now dubbed my Macy's $500 Trinket, he told me that if Macy's truly had a ring like that, he'd go buy 10. Knowing Sandra, he, too, was absolutely shocked by her manner with me. Again, maybe it was an off day for her but it simply doesn't justify how she handled the situation. read more