Cute little store, found some good things here. Charming place. love that it was an old house. Very…read morenice employee. She was a big help. Prices vary, but I like what I got. I feel was very reasonable. They were willing to work with me with prices. I do wish they were open more though.

I hate to say this, but I am underwhelmed by this store. The prices on most of these items are way…read moreover their intrinsic value. I perused the store looking for inexpensive, clear glass containers for my shell collection. It took me all day to find a few items. It's a shame, that people, I can understand, want to get as much money as possible for their items, but because it costs so much to rent out a space, they are forced to up their prices, hoping not to lose money.

Lots of interesting, and even one-of-a-kind items! So much to look at. There is literally something…read morefor everyone here! Antique, Vintage, Handmade, and New items!

I can see that nobody gives a crap about this place with so few reviews but whatever…read more I returned here after being away for a while and my last visit here was many months ago - the placed seemed half empty (or half FULL if you like). I can tell vendors were "pulling out". But things kinda (?) changed here . They now are back to being FULL again however - but all the prices are very high now! The dealers here seem to do what ALL DOPEY ANTIQUE DEALERSHIPS do : They blindly look up prices on ebay or the internet . This is not a good practice because PRICES ARE FLUID on collectibles and antiques. Always were , always will be. Again, it's all about not caring / not wanting to "move things along" - this is what retired vendors & dealers do. They probably have a pension check coming in and don't REALLY need the extra money. The staff here was less than helpful, less than friendly , less than knowledgeable and now sit "Floyd's Baber Shop" style with a round kitchen table in the middle of the store -- and you can hear all their takes on recent current events and the news . Oh wonderful ! I did buy a few OK / lower priced things here but I hope the dealers involved can get their act together and lower some of the stupid old fashioned prices on junk like Flintstones jelly glasses and old magazines that are collecting dust . (Crazy Prices of note: One average fashion magazine from the 1960s -- it was Vogue or something- was marked $75.00 . So it clearly was somebody looking up internet prices - saw one rare issue of Italian Vogue - either sold or was merely asking for $75.00 - and bingo : he thinks his is ALSO worth $75.00 ). Stupid.

This is truly a hidden gem in the heart of Kings Park. You will be greeted with the sweetest hello…read moreand made to feel so welcomed! If you like thrifting , you will love this shop! Enjoy!

Finally stopped in after months if passing the balloons of the store…read more It's a small spot, very clean and organized. The owner is very pleasant and gladly answers questions. As is true of most thrift shops, you never know what there is to find. There are large selections of record albums, cds and DVDs. Not sure what kind of market there is for them these day. I took a quick look at the albums. One cover was stuck together and there was the pronounced smell of mildew overall. The back room is full of clothes. And in keeping with name of store, there are odds and ends all over. The owner told me business was good. So apparently there are buyers out there. I might stop back in someday, but this trip didn't really do much for me. I wish the owner the very best of luck.

Adorable stuff! Prices are not too high. Very friendly atmosphere. It always feels nice to shop…read morelocal.

Hidden gem in Sayville! This shop is right off Main St on Railroad. We have gotten many pieces for…read moreour house here and could not be happier. Really feels like rustic, Hamptons-esque furniture. Everything is done very tastefully and the prices are very reasonable. Highly recommend stopping here if ever you are in town, especially if you are looking for items for your home!

Such a pleasurable experience every time i go, always something new to see all the time. from my…read moreexperience this store has got to be the best antique store on LI. The owners or workers are so nice and so easy to talk to.

Very nice set up and have really cool things but seems extremely overly priced! Looked at a single…read moretea cup and saucer, not a set but just one, it was priced at $25! I can understand if I were interested in multiple tea cup/saucers but for just one? Kind of steep! The staff seemed nice but I didn't interact with any of them! Would check it out again if I were in the area

This hidden gem is full of amazing antique and vintage. It is a multi vendor store. Owner is…read morereally friendly and kind.

Kirk is THE MAN!! My husband and I purchased a beautiful Victrola Talking Machine from Oakdale…read moreAntiques. We had a million questions about the piece and Kirk was super patient and answered every inquiry. Store has an amazing and diverse collection of inventory- we can't wait to come back!! Thanks Kirk for an awesome experience and for our new favorite antique!!

Chaos with parking. There are always a bunch of locals in front chewing the fat (do they still even…read moreuse that phase anymore?). Some parts of the store are inaccessible, blocked by merch . A lot of it looks like curb finds , especially the soft goods .Unorganized, nothing priced, as for the clothing, the less said the better. But everyone is friendly . They have a good selection of books and records, and vintage furniture - if you can get to it. Don't attempt if you have mobility issues. Another reason why I love Mastic Beach.

Great thrift store, I felt right at home. Everyone was so friendly. And pleasant owners. Love the…read morereasonable pricing. I went in there for glasses for my dinner party and left with a table cloth, glasses, an ironing board, a brand new bed frame and some clothing for my grand daughter. I love this place will be back. Highly recommended!!!!

The House of Timeless Treasures is a fantastic secondhand and consignment store with numerous…read moresellers in a lovely old house. Every room features a separate vignette and a different vendors and styles.. Everything is tastefully exhibited throughout the store, which is divided into distinct sections. When in Huntington spend some time exploring artifacts from the past and present. There may be some memories to be made.