His practice came highly recommended from several folks that I know. Now - it's my turn to recommend him! First, let me say that the facility is VERY clean. If you are skeptical about cleanliness, it will be the least of your worries here. Everyone is super friendly and super informative. They are fast, effective and efficient. I had my wisdom teeth pulled yesterday, and he did remarkably well! My anxiety levels were through the roof (I have put this off for nearly a decade because of it), but they made sure to make me feel as comfortable as possible and communicated what they were doing/going to do, the entire time. I checked in @ 1pm and was out the door before 2pm. I was so confident in his practice (based on what I was told by others) that I chose to go to him, even though he is "out-of-network" for my dental insurance provider. Even though it increased my out-of-pocket, I DO NOT REGRET IT! He knows what he is doing and so do his staff, they are fantastic! read more

Anthony J Hornaday, DDS - Oral Surgeons Near Me - Muncie, Indiana

If I could give zero stars I would. Imagine getting teeth extracted just to have the sites to be reopened 5 times in a little over a week. Told you don't feel any pain, you don't have dry socket (in both) (which I did), rough handling to the point your crown on another tooth is popped off. Bruises on both sides of your face told and you don't need pain meds. Countless injections on both sides of your face for numbing and not even told you were going to be reopened again. Nerves hit repeatedly to the point a panic attack is induced and told "oh stop it... We don't do that here". Having to remain in the chair, quiet, bleeding and feeling it. Then a panic attack happens. You get HIS doctor notes approving the time you need off. But it when it comes to your paperwork for work- he fills it out completely wrong 5 times. It's only 8 questions. Changes his answers, doesn't respond to emails, doesn't pay for the crown he dislodged, and now your job is at stake. The staff argues with you about the time off letters and it's wording. Yeah never going back and telling everyone this story. read more

This was the worst dental experience I have ever had and I wasn't even the patient. My daughter went in for wisdom teeth extractions and ended up with dry socket, which could have been prevented had they given proper after care instructions and medications. She suffered needlessly. I have four kids and she was the third one needing their wisdom teeth extracted so I know a little bit about the process. Do not take your child here. read more

I had a very confusing experience in Dr Hornadays office. Hornaday partially numbed my mouth, claimed I was touching his arm, refused my surgery. With the sedatives & his quick manner I was confused. With the Drs bedside manner I began to have a panic attack. His tone & choice of wording was more than questionable. I walked into the lobby and grabbed my husband. My husband came back to the room to speak with the doctor and nurse. After a discussion we left. I had never had such an experience and was confused. Days later, my husband agreed with my feelings that something didn't feel right during my experience. I reached out to Hornadays team & asked for the Dr to reach out as I'm concerned about what medications I took, how they may have interacted with my usual meds, and why I had such an adverse reaction to cause an intense panic attack. Hornaday never reached out to check on me, offer an explanation, or even reply to my email. I wasn't even aware that was an option for doctors- refuse to reach out regarding questions about an operation. My feel .... Odd about this. I did research to find a lawsuit (public record), several negative reviews matching my experience in slight ways, and a general mistrust of the doctor while speaking with those I know in the community. I'm writing my experience to the Attorney Generals office because I don't want others in our community to feel the way I did while sitting in his office. I've never felt so belittled & violated by a doctor. His bedside manner is very abrasive & crude to say the least. read more

He is so good! I was nervous but Anthony and his staff made me feel great! I got a tooth extracted and it was so easy. Highly recommend- don't worry about the other weird reviews! read more

this is not a good dentist. my wife has had a lot of tooth work and never has she been in so much pain because of his lack of caring. with a 3.3 on reviews I see only negative remarks. I don't understand that. also he will charge you whatever he wants. and you pay before you get out of the chair. is he afraid someone will run out? anyhow, worst experience my wife has ever had. steer clear of this bozo. read more

ALLOW ME TO INFORM YOU OF THE WORST ORAL SURGEON IN THE MUNCIE AREA. Approximately 3 years ago I got all 4 wisdom teeth removed here. I actually had a decent experience during the operation before and post as well! However, about a week or so after the operation was feeling a tad uncomfortable and pulled out a shard of tooth still remaining in my gum. Honestly, I wasn't upset by that really or even concerned. Then we go to present 3 years later where I get an x ray done on my teeth because I was in a small amount of pain. TURNS OUT there's ANOTHER shard that had been left for my gums to cover up and now I have to have another surgery.. read more

We had a great experience with having both my boys wisdom teeth removed at the same time within a half hour. No complications, very clear instructions and friendly staff. read more

Dr. Hornaday did an amazing job pulling all my teeth in a single appointment. No swelling, no bruising, amd was done quickly. Minimal pain. I highly recommend anyone needing a dentist to give him a call! read more

I cannot say enough good things about Dr. Hornaday and his staff! I had an infected, impacted wisdom tooth and was terrified to have it taken care of. But when I came to the point where I knew I had to have it removed, I called Dr. Hornaday's office and got right in! He was very professional in every way and the whole experience was much less traumatic than what I had expected. His staff were kind and very helpful. I would highly recommend him! read more

I was told I would have to pay in full before the procedure for my son was done. They told me an amount, which was outrageous to begin with for a procedure that took maybe 10 minutes. I paid in full. Now I'm getting bills a few months later saying I owe them $400 more! read more

GF was referred here to have my wisdom teeth out - cool. Then she was told that, despite bomb insurance, the procedure would be over $700, and oh, no painkillers after, because she has to work (at a sit down desk job). What a joke. Save yourself some time, go elsewhere. read more

I just wanted to give a positive review because I've seen a few negative ones, and I don't want anyone to not go to Hornaday because of them. I was worried sick over this surgery for months... and it was an absolute breeze. I had four wisdom teeth that weren't able to grow in, removed all at once. If anyone is reading this, terrified of going, go to this place and it's over in minutes. The only pain I felt was the injections, but those were just little pinches that were over in seconds, and he does them quickly and gently. When I felt any discomfort at all during the surgery, he'd numb the area again, and I'd feel nothing. You also get some oral sedation and nitrous, which kept me feeling really calm, and the whole experience kind of feels like a dream looking back on it. I'm not sure why anyone gets this surgery done while asleep, cause it was so easy. The only part that was unpleasant for me was the recovery, but that's to be expected, and I healed perfectly with no complications. read more