Pizza is excellent!! We live on the island and this is one of our go to places for sure. Brooklyn will take good care of you at the bar. She's hilarious. read more

Brooklyn was awesome! We were staying close by and needed something to eat that was fast close and easy and here we are! Plus we got to hear some local gossip and have a laugh! Wine and beer and pizza plus more and plenty of parking! read more

Disaster in the kitchen, front side of restaurant is outstanding covering for a kitchen that pumps out one pizza every 40 minutes. So much potential but dogshit pizza and took over two hours for two pizzas.... Clowns... read more

Great tasting pizza! I'd highly recommend the Godley... it's delicious! Pleasant staff also.

We walked in for a table of four and were told by the hostess that it would be a short wait. We waited about 5 minutes and were seated which was super quick. Our server was friendly and made sure we were welcomed by taking our drink orders right away. We got a bottle of Chardonnay for the table and one of us ordered an Arnold Palmer instead. The four of us decided to split salad and pizza for our dinner. We started with the Caesar salad which was delicious and we could tell it was fresh! Then, we had the build your own pizza with carnelized onions, black olives, pepperoni, and sausage which was delicious as well! We would definitely come back again! The restaurant is cute inside and feels very cozy! read more

Another Slice - Build your own pizza: carmelized onions, black olives, pepperoni, and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Saint Helena Island, South Carolina

Yummy pizza, delicious wings, tasty cheesy bread sticks! Diane our server was phenomenal! Great spot to stop for lunch after a beach trip! 10/10 read more

May be the best pizza crust I've ever had. Staff friendly. Casual feel. Convenient to Harbor Island, Hunting Island State Park and Fripp Island. read more

Pizza and food is alway excellent and the staff super nice. My favorite pizza is the Italian lady so good! Definitely recommend you try this place read more

Very underwhelming. Pizza was undercooked (even after I asked for it to be cooked "well done"), floppy and toppings were sparse. Crust had no crunch and was spongy. The wings and Caesar salad were good enough and the service was attentive but for a pizza place I was disappointed. Probably wouldn't recommend. It's a cute place but the food could be better. read more

Another Slice - Pizza Near Me - Saint Helena Island, South Carolina

We waited as did most of the people in the restaurant for about an hour for our food. Like others, we got our food , when it finally came, in dribs and drabs. Appetizer after the pizza. The food is good but you could starve waiting for it.waiting for it. read more

We did Friday evening takeout, clean bathroom, food was ready on time, price was reasonable, the two ladies behind the counter were super nice and helpful. It was the best pizza I've had in the last 12 months. And maybe the best cheesy bread ever. Will be back soon! read more

Great service and pizza/salad combo. Neat vibe inside not a huge indoor seating area but overall great experience!

The staff here were some of the nicest I've ever encountered in a restaurant, not exaggerating. Absolutely everyone we spoke to was upbeat, full of helpful suggestions, and seemed genuinely happy to not only help us as customer but seemed ready to pitch in and help each other. They're definitely doing something right here with their staff! We got 2 large pizzas to go. I had previously read reviews that the pizzas come out a little slow so we knew that it would be a wait. We were headed back from a beach day at Hunting Island and came in and sat at the bar to place our order. They said it would be 40 minutes so we ran back to our rental to take showers and my husband went back to pick it up and it was coming out ready exactly on time. One to the food: These pizzas were exactly what I had hoped for. Unique, fresh, flavorful ingredients that went together perfectly on amazing homemade crust. The crust was truly magnificent. Soft, slightly chewy but with a thing crisp exterior and slightly sweet. I seriously wish there was a pizza place this good close to where I live. read more

It was a good place to eat, but the waiter were not that good or nice. Our food came out at two separate times which is not supposed to happen. I was done with my mail before my fiancé and child. but considering all that, the food was pretty buss. and I guess they let the waiter clock out during your meal. read more

This place is adorable!!! The pizza was delicious! The sauce was so flavorful and we really enjoyed the crust, too. Highly recommend! read more

Thanks for closing at 8 when Google and tropics and 2 signs outside the restaurant read 9. We family of 12 went to Beaufort and had the best pizza the the Hearth. We will NOT even try this place as the girl was so so rude to us and said " well tonight we close at 8" if that's the case at lease take down all the signs u have on the chalkboard .... From reading the reviews not even worth a retry! Hope the owner is aware. And we TIP fantastic read more

I am visiting from Florida and we found this hidden gem! Food was excellent, service was great (shout out to Diana who made us feel like family)! We will surely be back! Thank you! read more

Great pizza and wings!!! The service was perfect. We watched a lil football while we ate. Italian Lady Pizza Wings read more

Pizza is very good and the pulled pork is the best in this area. Service is outstanding

Excellent service. Delicious cheese sticks and pizzas. Highly recommend the Old Italian Lady & The Hottie specialty pizzas. Live music was a bonus on this Friday night. read more

See all

This might not be saying much, but this is the best pizza I've tried in the Beaufort area. Barely beating Upper Crust. Just sucks it's almost to hunting island. Kind of pricey, but for being the best in the area, I guess it's worth it. It's amazing that this town lacks a GREAT pizza place. Even my little hometown in WV has like 3 GREAT pizza places. If you're looking to open a pizza place, look up Evaronis pizza in Kenova W.V., copy they're ingredients and become famous in this area for pizza. "In all the world, there's only one Evaronis!" read more

We love the pizza. If you're a jerk or in a big damn hurry go somewhere else. This is a family owned Lowcountry pizza joint with bbq, cold beer, decent wines and sweet staff. Worth the drive out from Beaufort. read more

Another Slice - Pizza Near Me - Saint Helena Island, South Carolina

See all

Excellent food- the bbq sandwich is PHENOMENAL! And the music was great. Overall 10/10 experience and love supporting a local family business read more

Another Slice - The pulled pork sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Saint Helena Island, South Carolina

Decent pizza. But for the price I was expecting a lot more. We got a large half pepperoni, half Hawaiian pizza (8 slices) for takeout and it cost $28.67 with tax! Some of the slices didn't even have cheese all the way up to the crust! With all the good pizza options in Beaufort and beyond, it's hard to reconcile spending this much on a pizza unless you live close by and convenience is what you're looking for. read more

Another Slice - Half pepperoni, half Hawaiian - Pizza Near Me - Saint Helena Island, South Carolina

Super fun pizza, bbq, and beer restaurant right off of Hunting Island. Clean atmosphere with lots of indoor and outdoor seating. Likely great for wiped out beach families who want a casual place to feed sandy kids. OR for vacationers who want to lowkey enjoy beers. The owners are super kind and clearly take pride in their restaurant. We ordered hot wings, a cheese pizza, and bbq with mustard sauce. Tracy read more

See all

Food was very good (cheese breadsticks and pizza) but unless you are a "regular"you have to ask for everything. Once seated and order placed we never had any follow up from our server. Tried to order another beer twice. Had to ask for our check and ask for a box. The pregnant lady that brought the pizza to the table was kind enough to finally bring our beer. Never offered water refill even though glass was completely empty. read more

Another Slice - Old Italian Lady pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Helena Island, South Carolina

$#!+ show. waited 45 minutes for pizza. appetizers never arrived. overcharged. Skip it!

The My Favorite pizza was quite the hit in the house. I had ordered it for me while boys wanted pepperoni and cheese pizzas but ended up eating mine too. We also tried white pizza. Everything was good. They even sell wine by the bottle to go which was handy. Would return. read more

We sat down after we ordered at 7 pm, and we did not receive our pizza until 8:35. The three other people with us all received their pizzas along with everyone in line before us and everyone who walked in after us. We had to talk to three different people before they offered to give us a refund. The only person who was helpful was the person working the register. The pizza was good, but for the amount of time we had to wait, I'm not sure it was worth it. read more

After a long day in the car getting to Harbor Island we wanted something quick and easy to eat. We were told to give this place a try and we are glad we did! Great atmosphere and wonderful pizza. Definitely will be back! read more

I don't ever write reviews, but our food was so bad tonight 8/23/24, that I felt like I had to complain. We ordered wings and they were the worst we have ever eaten. The skin was soggy, fatty and the flavor was terrible. They tasted like they had been cooked a few days ago and then just warmed up in the microwave tonight. They were so bad we couldn't even eat them. We have been to your establishment many times in the past and the food has always been good. Also, the "no table service" was horrible. Having to go to the back corner of the restaurant to get your water, and then going to the bar each time you want to get food or a beer, was inconvenient and not something I want to do when I go out to eat. read more

Amazing food and service! Will go every time I am on the island. The food was fresh. A member of our party must eat gluten-free and they were quite accommodating. The gluten-free pizza crust was excellent! read more

Great pizza! We're staying at Hunting Island State Park on Super Bowl Sunday and ordered a Old Italian Lady pizza. They're only 5 minutes from the park and the pizza was ready in no time. It was fantastic! Meatballs, Italian Sausage, pepperoni. Perfect! Great crust, the meatballs were as good as I've had. I love this place! I wish we were staying longer, I'd get another pie. If you're deciding on where to go if your at the park, if you like pizza and a good wine and beer selection, you can't go wrong. read more

Possibly the best pizza I've ever had!!! The wait staff was so nice! So friendly! And so welcoming! The restaurant was so cool and fun and had real local flavor. But the pizza was absolutely delicious! I also got the Caesar Salad, which was also totally enjoyable. Highly recommend this place. It was fun and delicious! read more

Best Calzone ever!!!! Cool little placeHope to be back there one day, great service as well!!

This place is adorable. Wood fireplace, great atmosphere and the food is delicious. Everyone is so welcoming and hospitable. The owner may even pop out to say hello and she is a delight. 10/10 would recommend! read more

Another Slice - Pizza Near Me - Saint Helena Island, South Carolina

See all

When we arrived it wasn't that crowded but service was very slow, but very friendly. We each ordered a small 10" but on both the ingredients were all in a small center area - unlike those in the review pics. There was so much, too much crust! The saving grace is that they both tasted very good and were not greasy at all, like some in the review pics. We probably will try it again as we like to support local, family owned businesses. read more

Might just be our new favorite! Currently eating a slice from Another Slice for the first time and I have to say YUM!!! Definitely going back. read more

It's pizza is at best average and It's very expensive. Next time I would drive into Beaufort

Such a gem. Mom and pop eatery serving flaky crust pizzas plus delicious hoagies and salads. Order the cheese bread! Wine and beer was also great. Friendly staff and the cutest pizza mascot, Bella. A must try for anyone in the area. read more