Really awesome coffee, gift, and bait shop by the Lighthouse! I was a little disappointed that their gift shop seemed to be out of a lot of the funky trinkets that are posted on Instagram but what can ya do at the end of the season. It's very relaxing to sit by the bay with your coffee and watch the boats and birds go by, we even saw a pod of dolphins! I will definitely be back next year! read more

See all

Just keeps improving! Love that they installed a fence and have plenty of tables to enjoy coffee/pastries outside. Had the blueberry pie latte and it was delicious. Loved watching the boats with my toddler. Great spot and making major improvements! read more

Andy's At the Light - Fashion Near Me - Barnegat Light, New Jersey

See all

Nice spot by the Lighthouse with a nice view of the water. Great place to grab the Best Chai Tea that you going to get outside of the Green Bean in Kuwait. It truly was that good. Chilli was perfect on the cold day we were visiting. Plenty of seating with a restroom, and a gift shop. Friendly young lady at the Counter. read more

Andy's At the Light - Veggi Chill- it actually works - Fashion Near Me - Barnegat Light, New Jersey

This is a cherished memory place for me. So many trinkets as well as well as a new coffee place in the back that used to be in the area where a dinette area was. That are hasn't been utilized in a long time and they've made it awesome!! Just go and enjoy!! read more

Went in to get 2 kids fishing rods and ran into Ross. Super helpful and kind. Helped us set up the rods and gave my 2 kids a lesson on how to cast. Was patient, went slow and the 5yr old picked it up right away. Highly recommend this shop - exactly what we needed for a great first time fishing experience. read more

I stopped in here the other day to see what products they had since I had never been inside. They had a lot of Knick knacks and ornaments and souvenirs. I was expecting it to be more of a vintage store so was disappointed in their products. It is probably a good store if you want Knick knacks that are modern though. read more

Beach-y gift shop at Barnegat light. Fun to poke around. Very old and it looks it. T-shirts, gift items, magnets, post cards. Shells. NO PUBLIC RESTROOM - so don't even ask. read more

Fantastic location and view! Excellent coffee prepared by a talented and friendly barista! Terrific addition to town. read more

Coffee Shop opened about 2 months ago here. Great coffee and pastries with the best views of lighthouse, inlet and bay. They are trying the stay open year round so please support this great local business read more

See all

Delicious, rich tasting coffee/tea, perfect view of the lighthouse, sea breeze blowing from the bay steps away, what a perfect experience! Andy's Coffee Shack and Andy's Bait, Tackle, Gift Shop is the perfect escape back in time while serving up a genuine, timeless, friendly LBI atmosphere. Bravo to the owner, Britt, for sharing her love for the island, Barnegat Light and bay no matter the weather. read more

Well I was very excited to come to the end of the island in order to see the lighthouse and I came across this nice little gift shop that had souvenirs of the island. I was able to see all the different kinds of postcards they had. Of course they had the photo style postcard but they also had some pretty little drawings/painting/sketches of the island and the lighthouse. Beautiful little images. I definitely like sending postcards so this is right up my alley. The wonderful shopkeeper let me know that the lighthouse was under construction for another month. So I look forward to coming back. In the meantime they had sweatshirts and T-shirts and I'll sorts of things for sale here. It's a pretty big store and it was nice to look around at everything. I also picked up some cold drinks here. read more

See all

Great coffee in a location with such good memories! Nice view of the inlet while you enjoy some crumb cake or a toasted bagel with your morning drink. read more

Went here with my family as part of our long beach vacation on Sunday June 9th 2024. This store is conveniently located near the Barnegat Lighthouse, since we were coming from there, we browsed here. We came sort of late, and the store was closing in 10 minutes. Stores around here seem to close early for some reason. It is a nice big shop with lots of souvenirs and t-shirts and many other things. My dad brought a bottle opener here. We then went shopping at other places such as schooner's wharf, on the other end, where we did find more souvenirs. read more

If you're an LBI old-timer like me (50+), you probably already appreciate Andy's for what it truly is: a local icon steeped in LBI lore and wonderful memories. It's been around longer than I have, and that's saying something. If you're looking for some kind of bougie poser "curated" island experience with culinary snobbery, then just keep walking; there are plenty of those popping up around the island every season. BUT, if you want a good cuppa, a fresh pastry, some friendly company and good service with simple, well-cooked fare - with unbeatable views of the bay/inlet/Old Barney, then Andy's is your only choice. Now you're in-the-know. read more

We have been going to Barnegat Light for over 40 yrs. renters at that time now own. We always went to Andy's to browse and get a hermit crab to bring home. It was so much fun for my kids and I always the tourist had to get a t shirt or something. I still have a navy blue sweatshirt thats probably 35 yrs old like new with a little light house on front that I cherish. At that time you could go in the back and get like a hot dog or something it was so much fun for us and the kids., My grandkids are not 6 and 9 and of course we got the picture in front of Andy's, they come down every year and visit their moms haunts and now they can experience Andys at its best. Please dont judge the building as being old (where are you from anyway) not everything has to be new. I cant wait to go down in a few days to get my Andy's shirt and send one to my son (now 43) . This is what its all about making memories with your kids. read more

Some fishing tackle, half empty refrigerators, loose shells, tchotchkes. Nothing wrong just a dated business with some nostalgia for some.

The people in the store were so personable! They took time to talk with me, and I felt like I was the most important visitor to come through that day. I kept finding one more thing to buy... They had to ring me out 4 times, and seemed excited to help me every time I found something! I will be back next ttimttime I'm atat the beach read more

Sad. Was a really vibrant store many years ago. Just not what it used to be and sad to walk in.

Nice person that runs it! Smiles, nice to talk too! Love going there to look around. You never know what you'll find

Carries Barnegat Light souvenirs, bait and tackle. Some t-shirts and gift items. While slightly overpriced, good for the bait and tackle you forgot before you went fishing in the state park next door. The souvenirs are run of the mill. None of the shells are local. Good stuff for kids. The back room has t-shirts and sweatshirts of the lighthouse, Barnegat Light, and LBI. Also carries cold drinks. read more

Nothing special, but if you're at LBI they have all the gitchy little trinkets you'd want. Prices are fair, but this is not a destination store or must see. read more

I have been coming here my entire life. When my parents would take me to the lighthouse as a child, we always stopped at Andy's so that I could get a shell to remember the experience. Now that I have daughters of my own, we have been keeping up with this tradition. Today we went into the store with our 3 year old and our 1 year old. My girls were so excited to pick out a shell. The baby dropped a shell that cost $.39. If it broke, we would have paid for it. The cashier snapped at my kids telling them to be careful right after my husband said, "Be careful girls." I understand that kids can be such a pain and can break things, but all my kids wanted were two $.39 shells. They were well behaved and so excited. I'm sure that things break all of the time because accidents happen. My husband was so annoyed, that he just grabbed the kids and left. I know that our less than $1 purchase won't make or break your business but we won't be back. Teach your employees not to be cruel to toddlers. They are people too. They were not running around or being loud. Just one little shell dropped one foot to the floor and was picked up. read more

I have been going to LBI for years and definitely disagree that Andy's is "overpriced." They do have a lot of "made in China" souvenirs but it's still a "must-stop" when you go to the lighthouse! For those of us who aren't millionaires and can't afford some of those pretentious (and truly overpriced) LBI art shops, Andy's is just fine. read more