I am a Midwesterner, and one of the only things that the heartland does better than NYC is the thrift stores. Imagine this: a huge warehouse full of clothes and housewares that gets all the goods when granny croaks or when that fabulous gal with more money than you finally moves away. You can browse the racks in peace because the store is huge and the mass populace is at the mall spending all that extra money they accumulate from the ridiculously low price of living trying to find validation in some sick new threads, which will end up in the thrift store in a few months because we all know that doesn't work. Did I mention that every item is a couple dollars, or sometimes even just a few pennies? Suffice it to say that my thrifting itch has never been scratched in New York, which is why I ended up at this Amvets thrift store on a bargain hunting day trip to Long Island.
The moment I walked in, I forgot all about the cramped, expensive, and disappointing NYC thrift shops and tumbled down the rabbit hole of bargains galore. The store is huge, and while there was a nice hustle and bustle from other shoppers that supported my high spirits, browsing was easy and there was plenty of space to search the aisles without getting too close for comfort. There are two sale tags, one that is 50% off and one that is 25% off. I didn't see very many of the 50% off color but 2 of the 4 items I purchased were 25% off. The clothing is organized by SIZE, which always makes life so much easier, and featured a good mix of all eras including name brand current fashions. Most shirts were 4.98 and most dresses were 7.98, and while that may be on par with pricing I've dissed they run so many specials and discounts that I ended up with some true bargains. The housewares were very fun to browse and had some great antique/vintage items that were still in the price range of a dollar or two. There were several adorable hardshell vintage suitcases in the $3-$7, which I admired but left for someone else to find (maybe you?). The store was very clean and well organized and the staff was friendly.
I browsed for about an hour and a half and loved every minute of it. I ended up purchasing 3 shirts, one of which was a new-with-tags Eileen Fisher tunic that retailed at $98, and one pair of black Keds. The Keds were 2.98 and all 3 shirts were 4.98 each, but two of them were 25% off and combined with the check-in offer of $4 off a $15 purchase, my grand total came to $12.
They had a few signs up advertising a 50% off sale the following Wednesday, and had I known about that I would have postponed my trip! If you're a serious bargain hunter you may want to call ahead and see if they have any upcoming sales. Regardless, in an age of sketchy Goodwill operations and a homophobic Salvation Army, you can't beat the cause of helping veterans while you thrift! This store was the highlight of my expedition, which included 8 different Long Island thrift stores. read more