Cancel

Open app

Search

All Star Ice Cream

5.0 (1 review)
Open • 4:00 pm - 9:00 PM

ALL STAR ICE CREAM · YELP ASSISTANT

Ask Yelp Assistant

All Star Ice Cream Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - All Star Ice Cream

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of M W.
244
26
0

4 years ago

Delicious Ice Cream's. So much to chose from in this place. Too bad it was not open more then the summer.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - All Star Ice Cream

You might also consider

Pecora’s Creamery - The Pecora Dairy Farm

Pecora’s Creamery

5.0(5 reviews)
33.5 mi

As someone who relocated up from Lancaster/Harrisburg to this area for work, I've sorely missed Fox…read moreMeadows creamery. Nothing compared to its smooth, flavorful consistency...except Milkhouse's own flavors! I once enjoyed their cake batter three times in one week...I haven't done that since I was a child. And the milk is easy on my stomach too which can't handle most supermarket dairy. It's not cheap, but somewhat reasonable. Each glass jug requires $2 holding deposit which you get back or can put towards your next return. They're trying to go for an old fashioned general store aesthetic and I wish them well. Berwick's location is decorated the prettiest, but they often get sold out often (of milk), but Drums (this one) is the flagship location.

Okay, so it's a long story on how I found myself seeking out Pecora's Creamery, which is a tiny…read morestore at the end of Pecora Road across from the old dairy. Inside is clean and quaint, with tasty breads, meats and cheeses from local farms. And while those are darn good- let's talk about the ice cream. This is the creamiest, most flavorful ice cream I have ever had in my life. No like seriously. This ice cream is small batch and it's AMAZING. I had the chocolate peanut butter egg (their Easter flavor), my husband had coffee, and my son had chocolate. Each was phenomenal in its own way. I don't know when I will be back in this area of Pennsylvania but if I'm anywhere remotely near, I will drive out of my way to have some more. Seriously folks, this ice cream is special.

Photos
Pecora’s Creamery - Ice Cream quarts

Ice Cream quarts

Pecora’s Creamery - Vintage Pecora Dairy boxes

Vintage Pecora Dairy boxes

Pecora’s Creamery - Chocolate Peanut Butter Egg Ice Cream

See all

Chocolate Peanut Butter Egg Ice Cream

Brennan's Big Chill - Banana Split

Brennan's Big Chill

3.3(52 reviews)
24.4 mi
•$

You know, it takes a lot of moxie to berate an ice cream parlor but some people just really love to…read moreact miserable and love to bring down others joy. This has been a longtime running decadent decadent homemade ice cream shoppe with a variety of flavors. It gets crowded easily, as it would be nifty if they had a fun, upbeat soundtrack playing or a few arcade games for children but the general ambience is so cozy and inviting already. You can't beat it on a sultry, summer evening!

I was actually pleasantly surprised by the ice cream. I wasn't sure what to expect when getting the…read moreice cream for one thing they don't allow you to taste the different flavors so for that, I was very skeptical but when I actually got the ice cream, I thought it tasted very good. It tasted very fresh very creamy. Specifically the mint one was into minty. It was just the right amount of mint and the chocolate one wasn't too sweet. The cherries actually provided a nice darkness that balanced out the chocolate. The chocolate itself had a decent amount of sweetness, but it wasn't overpowering so I felt like that was a nice balance. It definitely felt like a homemade fresh sort of ice cream and the cool part is at this place that the flavors end up changing I think every week so they have new flavors that they come out with so it's always a new experience. The only reason why he gave it four choices instead of five stars again because they don't provide that tasting service so that's just one thing that I thought that was kind of a miss.

Photos
Brennan's Big Chill
Brennan's Big Chill - Pumpkin Marshmallow with Peanut Butter Cups

Pumpkin Marshmallow with Peanut Butter Cups

Brennan's Big Chill

See all

All Star Ice Cream - icecream - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...