I came to change a damaged rim with a new one I had bought online. As soon as I drove in, I was…read moregreeted and attended to right away. Without me asking they also checked the tire that was removed and found a nail in it and showed it to me. The tire had been losing air and I thought it was because of a bent rim. They patched my tire , changed my rims and did it within 10 minutes. Very fast service. And then I was shocked at how low I was being charged for all of that. They have a sign showing charges for their services and to me they are undercharging. Next time I have tire problems , I will go to this place and bring some cash with me so I can tip them for their excellent work and give them something more than what they charge. They deserve it.

Quick service as I was in an out in 10 minutes and they did great work! I had an annoying nail in…read morethe tire releasing air every 2 days but now I don't have this issue. Great price too!

I first came here because it was the most recommended and reliable place for me to get a photo…read moreinspection on a new car. It only took 5 minutes and the staff was so kind and helpful. When my local mechanic then tightened my oil filter so tight during an oil change that the oil had completely leaked out of car on the highway, I decided I needed a new place to rely on for regular maintenance. While All Tire's services are slightly more expensive, I know I'm getting the value for my money and I feel safe when I drive off the lot.

Had new pirelli tires from tirerack installed, balanced and aligned. Seamless experience,…read morereasonable price, easy parking and clean shop. My 20 yo car drives like new. They also do NY safety inspections which makes it really convenient.

We only come here for an occasional Nail in our tire. They…read moredo patch work from the inside of the tire which is what we love. So there is no plugs Friendly staff ..we were originally recommended to this place by another company which is also good. Depending on how crowded the waiting area gets you may have to wait a little while and that's part of life so keep calm. but they do good work for what we get done here.

Had a car accident in front of there - cop said they had a video of it - when I called They said…read morethe person who has the vid wasn't there - called again the person who had the vid said they sent it to the cop - could not get the video - showed up to this racist business and the guy says he send the vid and deleted it - which was a lie - kid who hit us worked there and of course they produced the vid for him as if my insurance and lawyers weren't going to get it lol so yea I got the vid but you can tell it was because I was Spanish and the kid who hit and almost killed us was white! they are nasty and rude as well all assholes dont give them your business - also kid was found liable for the accident so idk hat they thought they was doing

Tires overinflated by 15psi Lug nuts so over tightened I…read morecould not budge them with a 24" breaker bar. Seriously WTF is wrong with you guys? This is tire 101! Will never go back.

Brought car for inspection and was told multiple items wrong. Wanted $600 to fix and told me it was…read morea major safety concern not to drive it. I had to tow to my dealership to be told by them that nothing is wrong with the car and I wasted money on a bogus tow. Basically this place just wanted quick money and thought I was an idiot because I was a female. I was warned about this that they did it to another person wife and now I know the stories are true.

I've been there twice for flat tire fixes and both times I had a positive experience. I paid $20…read more(plus tips) which is a very reasonable price. They're open until 10pm which is a big plus and both times I was assisted right away and was in and out in less than 15 minutes. Staff is friendly and the manager seems to be a nice guy. Note that I haven't done any other more serious services besides flat tire fixed so I can't comment on that but for what I've done I definitely recommend this place.

don't ever go here i had the tire pressure light go on i go there they change a tire cost $75 had…read moreto go back the next morning they changed a tire that did not need to be changed the tire light was still on and the tire was flat on the opposite side went back today charged another $75 and with someone on disability that's a lot of money to spend two days in a row i'll never go here i'll put the donut on the car and go to another shop anywhere but here

Top notch place in the heart of SI. These guys care and take care of many issues with many…read moredifferent types of models

I recently needed new tires for my old Jeep, I checked out the Big Box Stores but I wasn't happy…read morethe prices. I talked to Sal the manager at Guys Tires on Hylan Blvd, He helped me select the right tires at a fair price. Plus a wheel alignment, inspection & oil change. Got all the work done the next day, I drove away ready for the winter storm coming this weekend. Jeff

I wish yelp have a negative review feature so I could give this place -5 stars. The guy that runs…read morethis place is an absolute joke , they had lost one of my wheel locks and I came back asking if they have it and the guy told me it's my fault for not asking for it back? Excuse you Now he wants to charge me to break the lock on the wheel. Save yourself your time and your money and go to a business that's going to appreciate you as a customer and save yourself the trouble from dealing with this meat head

Untrustworthy and unsafe! They sold me a twenty year old tire, and when I noticed, they refused to…read moreoffer a return. Not only are they greedy in their business practices, they are willing to put your safety at risk! Go elsewhere.

On March 13, 2026, this shop demonstrated dishonesty, dangerous incompetence and negligence that…read morenearly cost me my life. I came in for a simple two-tire installation, quoted 20 minutes. Over an hour later, Chris, one of the workers, informed me a lug nut was broken and other was lose. They promised to install it if the retrieved the parts myself from the nearby Auto Zone, I did. Then came a sudden $100 surcharge for work already included in the service had paid for infull, I refused to pay it. After that, they were very rude and disrectful. What followed was unconscionable. Driving home on the highway at 60 mph, my newly installed tire began wobbling violently. A nearby mechanic found that all lug nuts had been left loose, a fundamental sasfty step no licensed mecahnic should ever skip. This is not a customer service failure. This is a criminal negigence. Do not bring your car here. They will take your money, cut corners on life-critical safety checks, and send you onto the highway in a compromised vehicle. You have been warned.

Paid $105. To have 3 brand new tires mounted balanced,all 3 tires where leaking air 4th I did…read moresomewhere else was not, went back to fix problem , they refused to fix the problem unless I paid them again for the screwed up job!

I just wrote a review for the repair shop next door and it reminded me that I never got around to…read morepraising this tire spot right next door. I was driving around with a flat tire in the back for almost a year. I would add air to it and visit a tire shop every other month only to be told that there is no hole in the tire, yet the gauge would say the pressure is dropping daily. I thought maybe it's just the sensor, but my gas mileage for the car was abysmal, too. Anyway, after spending probably $200 in visits to tire shops to have them take the tire off, soap it up, and tell me there's no hole and charge me half price to air it up and put it back on, when I got a second flat on another tire I pulled up to this place. I'll be honest, the first guy said there's no hole either. Then, another guy came over, and it's been a few months now so I forgot the names and for that I am very sorry, but he spotted the hole in like, no exaggeration, in 1 SECOND. I'm talking about a tire hole that 15 other people couldn't find, looking for a combined hour or two. The guy saw it IMMEDIATELY. As fast as a blink of an eye. I can't convey the speed in a way that feels satisfying enough to me, that's how fast he saw it. Anyway, long story longer.. tires fixed, price super super reasonable especially for a change of a tire and 1 patch. I think it was something like $80. The whole thing took 10-15 minutes, plus they took me in just before closing time. Somehow I have a habit of showing up for auto repair right before the place is closing and the guys want to go home. Finally got the tire fixed, got a go to flat tire place on the island, didn't feel ripped off. Good stuff.

Genuinely amazing staff. Was having a tough day and got a flat about a mile from the shop. Was…read morehelped immediately when I arrived and the staff even went so far as to help me transport the tire back to my car as a courtesy. Extremely professional, reliable, and hard workers. Will be coming back for any needs in the future!!!

Brought over my car after getting a flat from driving on a screw they plugged it and fixed it in 15…read moreminutes cheap and easy highly recommend

Went for a nail in my tire, I was in and out of there in under 10 minutes. I should have figured…read moregiven the name. Good pricing, do recommend